MLB Rumors - MLB Trade Rumors
Subscribe to MLB Trade Rumors using RSS
Home     Contact     About     Advertise     Archives     Widget     Twitter      RSS Usage

« Astros Sign Clay Hensley | Main | Yankees Sign Mark Teixeira »

Mets Deep In Negotiations With Lowe

According to Yahoo's Gordon Edes, the Mets are deep in negotiations with free agent starter Derek Lowe.  However, the Mets have yet to make an offer.


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834515b9a69e20105368fa415970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Mets Deep In Negotiations With Lowe:

Comments

If they sign him, hope it takes them out of any running for Manny.

But in turn, it sucks for the red sox.

Thank goodness. I need some good news.

What's a "Mets"?

Manny and Lowe would do the trick.

The Yanks got their XMAS present, now we need ours!

Not sure if you're serious or not Michael Kei, but it's short for Metropolitans.

I don't think the Mets are serious bidders for Manny anyways NedCollettiClueless, the Wilpons would never allow a serious run at him.

As for Lowe, this would be good news. Get it done, Omar! Hopefully something like 3/45.

Mets stand for Metropolitans... I am extremely happy that this rumor has come about. i for one am very happy that the Yankees are sticking it to the Bo Sox but i would love it for the Mets to swoop in a just completely destroy them by taking their next offseason priority Derek Lowe. A rotation of Santana, Pelfry, Lowe, Maine, and Niese plus whoever is a great rotation considering the strength of our bullpen.

Derek Lowe does seem like a good addition to the Mets. Hopefully Scott Boras isn't asking for Barry Zito money still. Here's what the Mets rotation will look like if Lowe is signed:

Johan Santana
Derek Lowe
John Maine
Mike Pelfrey
Jonathon Niese

Looks like a solid rotation to me. Also, how come no one wants Daniel Murphy to play left field in 2009?

I wonder if the Sox will make a run for Lowe now despite what Tim's other post says.

Nick Swisher for MVP
I for one think Murphy will flourish in Left Field this year for the Mets and am a big supported of them keeping him out there long term or at least until Carlos Delgado leaves.

Thank god this is true i want the mets to get him very badly..Minaya is doing a good job and now he should get manny and o-dog

Agreed. It seems as if the Mets would rather have a young, inexpensive left fielder with talent instead of signing an older free agent to a long term deal. Omar Miniya did not want a big payroll for 2009.

Hurry up and sign him before the Red Sox change their minds about pursuing him.

i am a DIE HARD mets fan..die hard..but im a realist
Johan, Pelfrey, Maine, Lowe, Niese is NOT a "great" rotation at all...maine is good, but coming off surgery (not really pitching related but surgery nonethelss), pelfrey REALLY turned a corner last year and im a fan, but he hasnt proved himself to be penciled in to be a significant helper to this team, by any means. I see growing pains for him...lowe i like, i do, and of course Johan is God...Niese hasnt proved a DAMN THING..i like his potential, but we all know the number 5 starter never makes 30 starts...
bottom line is this, if you're a mets fan...if you DONT want them to sign TWO of Lowe, Ollie, Sheets, or Wolf, AND MANNY, then you're VERY delusional about this team...
does anyone think Delgado is REALLY gonn hit 37 Hrs again??? Does anyone think Tatis is gonna have the same year he did last year? Both are POSSIBLE, but u can't bank on it (see Omar's mistake of BANKING on Sanchez and Heilman returning to form)... We need a BIG TIME bat in this line up, preferably a righy..manny makes TOO much sense..and he'll take media pressure off guys like beltran and delgado that dont really like it. ALSO, if it aint manny, now that tex is a yank, i know its rare that it happens, but try to trade with the bronx bombers for Nady (right handed bat)

oh and for Maine, i forgot to mention he pitches about 5 innings or so a start too...we CANNOT go thru that again this year

and i DO LIKE Murphy a lot..but this team needs to prove something to its fan base..we need to win NOW..2 more SOLID starters and manny/nady is NECESSARY

i couldnt be happier with the bullpen...but now its time to realize there are still A LOT of holes in this team

I absolutely bigchart. I have been hoping the mets get Nady back right after the 06' season when we traded him. He carried us the beggining portion of that season.

With that being said I would much rather see Minaya sign Manny then make a deal with those absolutley atrocious Hankees.

I also concur that Niese is horrible as a 5th starter. He hasnt proved a single thing. I would much rather see a rotation of Santana, Lowe, Pelfrey, Maine and Wolf or Marquis then a rotation that includes Niese.

We do have a lot of holes i agree with that. I also think that Minaya has to dump Castillo for a bucket of balls and sign O-Hudson. He would be a perfect number 2 hitter or we could drop him to the 8th hole and have him prosper there.

I love what Minaya has done so far but there is so much more that needs to be done.

NIck Swisher for MVP? ahahah Yu must be a true fan to think thats even close to realistic

Johnnyfly11

I actually made this account a year ago when Nick Swisher was on the A's. But now that he is on the Yankees I want to change it. Does anyone know how to change your user name on Type Key?

Just leave the username the same. It makes it funny.

YES!!! Deep negotiations seem to be the flavor of the day. Lock down Lowe, move on to Manny...good.

Santana
Lowe
Pelfrey
Maine
Redding/Uehara/Marquis

To me, this season is a success if the Mets win the division. I don't give a rat's behind what they do in the playoffs; as long as they upset the Phillies and win the NL East, I'll be chugging victory brew.

How come the Braves will not go after Lowe? This continues to make me mad that they will just sit by and watch teams improve themselves while we get steadily worse.

After we sign Lowe, sign Redding for 2 yrs 6 million. Our rotiation would be:

Santana
Lowe
Maine
Pelfrey
Redding

And for you chinese food fans, how about some Lowe-Maine for dinner tonight!

A rotation headed by Santana, Pelfrey, and Lowe would be very solid.
Plus, Maine giving you 5 or 6 strong innings will have a different feel with K-Rod & Putz since the game is pretty much shortened to 7 innings. That means if Maine goes five, all the Mets would need would be a strong bullpen for 2 innings.
As for Niese, he'll be fine in the five spot. I mean, he'll be average or slightly above average. However, I think it would be a good idea for Omar to sign a veteran pitcher to a one-year deal (like El-Duque) who could at least start the season in the rotation until he fails or (in the case of El Duque) gets injured.
As for the lineup, the Mets do need a right-handed bat to balance out the order. Nady; however, would cost prospects that the Mets can't afford to lose without a first round pick this year and a weak draft class to boot. So, either the Mets try to buy low on someone like Eric Byrnes or Jose Guillen, or sign a somewhat cheap free agent like Ty Wigginton (2yrs 15 MM).

The Mets need at least two starters. This move for Derek Lowe, if (and when?) it happens, will stabilize the rotation and hand it three healthy starters. Pelfrey could have growing pains, or he could pull a Webb (heck, he even pitches like him) and build to the ace-like heights Mets fans expected when he was drafted. St. Johan is, well, St. Johan. And Lowe is solid. John Maine is the wildcard; I believe that if he comes back and returns to '07 form, the Mets have the firepower to win the division. Of course, to be safe, I'm still picking the Phillies.

Lowe would be a good addition to the Mets. He's a durable and dependable pitcher behind Santana.

If Lowe signs for 15 MM and Manny signs for 20MM, we have effectivley added only 40 MM in payroll (K-Rod included), and thats how much we had coming off the books. We can afford both Lowe and Manny!

"and i DO LIKE Murphy a lot..but this team needs to prove something to its fan base..we need to win NOW..2 more SOLID starters and manny/nady is NECESSARY"

So either a fringe league average corner outfielder, or if not him, the best hitting outfielder of this generation are a necessity? That is like me saying..... CC Sabathia or Jon Garland are a necessity!

Ty Wiggington? Do me a favor....

Yeah wtf Nady? He's not much better than Murphy.

As a braves fan, a word of advice to the Mets: DONT SEND AN OFFER SHEET TO LOWE! The fa*got skankees will triple the offer and take him from you.

As for Lowe, good pitcher. But for whoever said "Santana, Lowe, Maine, Pelfrey and some other guy is a good rotation" has to be kidding me. The Phillies won the world series. You guys gotta have better then that.

Im saying this cause Atlanta doesnt know how to make a deal anymore. Jake Peavy? No. Burnett? No. Jermaine Dye? No.
JAVIER VAZQUEZ? Yes! ha

nrmax88,

Xavier Nady is better than an average corner outfielder. .305 AVG, 25 HR, 97 RBI in 148 games is better than average. He is a better hitter now than when he was on the Mets. He also has a good throwing arm.

Would not shock me if the Yankees put a 5 year/90 mil offer for Lowe to be a fifth starter. haha

Santana, Lowe, Pelfrey, Maine, and "some other guy" (Tim Redding? Koji Uehara? Pedro?) is a very good rotation, probably the second or third best in the NL, behind the Cubs and maybe Arizona. Look, the Mets have more individual talent than the Phillies. No one is gonna argue with that. But the Sillies, believe it or not, have much more team chemistry and a better bullpen, which won them a championship. As I said before, if the Mets win the division and lose 3-1 in the NLDS, the season is a success. But they're under no circumstances the favorites until they prove it.

I'm SO glad he's no longer a Dodger.

What's a reasonable contract ceiling for Lowe? He's 35 (will turn 36 this June) and it helps anybody to pitch in the Dodgers' home park (the stats. agree with the opinion).

3/48?
4/60?

Also, I wonder what "deep into talks" means. Are they sitting cross-legged in a circle? Drinking beers and watching Cheech and Chong movies? In a stall next to Canseco? Is everybody in the room smoking cigars and wearing those poker visors?

"If Lowe signs for 15 MM and Manny signs for 20MM, we have effectivley added only 40 MM in payroll (K-Rod included), and thats how much we had coming off the books. We can afford both Lowe and Manny!

Posted by: johan=cy | December 23, 2008 at 05:39 PM"

Problem #1 with that theory is that there is no possible way Manny is signing for $20MM per year. He had 2/40 in options with the Red Sox, hired Boras and engineered his trade to the Dodgers to make more than $20MM AAV in the next couple years. I don't think anything less than $22-25MM AAV gets you Manny at this point.

Peterherman, Manny has no market. I'm not even sure the Dodgers are too keen on bringing him back. If the Mets want him, they'll get him, and on their terms.

Lowe would make the Mets' rotation pretty solid. Signing "5-run" Redding, however, would neutralize some of the advantage.

My guess: The Dodgers re-sign Manny.

Lowe CAN help take the pressure off your bullpen by going very late into games with his sinker. He just simply WON'T go into the late innings often, as he told Torre and previous managers that he's done, usually after the sixth. Not a slam on DLowe, just fact.

"Peterherman, Manny has no market. I'm not even sure the Dodgers are too keen on bringing him back. If the Mets want him, they'll get him, and on their terms."

I think Bernie Madoff's terms send him back to LA...

"5-run" Redding, eh?

While I realize he doesn't deserve the respect of a Santana or a Sabathia, he had as many or more quality starts last season as World Champions Joe Blanton and Kyle Kendrick, Daisuke Matsuzaka, Johnny Cueto, Ian Snell, Justin Verlander, Jonathan Sanchez, Andy Sonnanstine and every Met fans' favorite guy to hear about, Scott Kazmir. If his toe is healthy he'd make a fine #5.

GravediggerHebner,

I'm seeing a career 4.92 ERA and someone who's never pitched more than 176 innings before 2008, when he pitched 182 (with a 4.95 ERA).

I'm also not a fan of Blanton, Kendrick or Sonnanstine. Several of those other guys had bad years.

Redding's had a mediocre (at best) career. Maybe he's No. 5 starter, and I'm sure he'd be cheap, but I wouldn't want to count on him and plan to win.

We're not counting on Tim Redding to win. We have Jon Niese to step in if Redding is that bad (and he shouldn't be; he was 7-3 with a 3.58 ERA in the first half last season), and we'll probably sign yet another retread, maybe Freddy Garcia. It's all about depth. Heck, we could end up with Koji Uehara.

Lowe would be/is a great signing for the Mets. Do grab a cheap gloveman to hold 2B when Lowe pitches though; Castillo at 2B when Lowe pitches is an absolute disaster.

Why aren't the Braves in on him though again?

With Lowe, the Mets are definitely the team to beat in the East...

NL East:
1. NYM
2. Phi
3. Fla
4. Wash
5. Atl

"Lowe CAN help take the pressure off your bullpen by going very late into games with his sinker. He just simply WON'T go into the late innings often, as he told Torre and previous managers that he's done, usually after the sixth. Not a slam on DLowe, just fact.

Posted by: abcrazy4dodgers | December 23, 2008 at 06:34 PM"

You do realize he pitched the 9th MOST amount of innings in the NL last season, right?

"nrmax88,

Xavier Nady is better than an average corner outfielder. .305 AVG, 25 HR, 97 RBI in 148 games is better than average. He is a better hitter now than when he was on the Mets. He also has a good throwing arm.

Posted by: viteminj | December 23, 2008 at 05:51 PM"

Can you say Career Year?

His 162 game average is .280/.335/.458 with 21 Home Runs and 78 RBI's. He's a slightly above-average player and nothing more. I think Murphy is more then capable of replicating the production, although yes he is Left-Handed.

The Mets are in no way, shape or form anything remotely resembling the team to beat in the NL East. Even though none of our players have said "we're the team to beat" yet, contrary to biased reports, Mets fans are still going to get overexcited, leading to disappointment. If the Mets win the NL East in 2009, it will be as big of an upset as it was when the Sillies shocked us in 2007.

oh tru tru my b Nick_Swisher_For_MVP

^ You're kidding right??? The Phillies are the team to beat, but don't make it like they're some sort of demi-gods, and can't be touched...

I'm a yankee Fan and i really hope the mets get lowe insteed of the yankees.......

lowe is one of my fave pitchers but come on we spent so much money already now we just need to trade matsui/damon and sign Baldelli o be our back up out fielder

I would much enjoy some Koji Uehara.

Just because I haven't heard anyone mention this possibility yet... Is it beyond the realm of possibility that the Mets could acquire Lowe (3/48?) and then turn around and make an offer for Perez, too - (3/36)? That's a total of $28 million/year. High, and the Mets don't have money to throw around... but not impossible?

Wouldn't we all rather have Perez as a 4 (if Maine gets injured or Pelfrey has trouble) or 5 than Redding/Wolf/Garland/Neise/Marquis/etc.?

Peterherman, Manny has no market. I'm not even sure the Dodgers are too keen on bringing him back. If the Mets want him, they'll get him, and on their terms.

I SECOND THIS BECAUSE MANNY HAS NO OFFERS BUT FROM THE YANKEES AND THERE DONE THEY WASTED MONEY ALREADY.

I don't know why all the love for Redding. Marquis would be a far superior option. Dependable inning-eater with an era in the mid 4s. With a solid #5 such as Marquis, and Lowe, I don't see how the Phils can touch that rotation. Plus with the bullpen adds (which why we blew it the last few years), the Mets are defintely the team to beat. The Braves are now the favorite for the cellar for the next 12 or so years...a team in a steep decline, and by far the most disappointing offseason (Peavy, Furcal...)

I think the Mets can do that, but I don't see it happening. The Madoff scandal has to affect the team in some capacity, and I just don't think the Mets are gonna shell out that kind of cash unless they absolutely have to. Lowe and a Redding-type seems like the direction they're headed. I personally would like to see Lowe and Manny Ramirez, but that's just not gonna happen.

Art, once again, I made the mistake of picking the Mets last year, and look what happened. The Mets are not the team to beat until they beat the Phillies. They are the World Champs. We are the "Choke Artists". It hurts, but it's true.

Art,

haha. Ya right. Team to beat. Actually since we are, as you say, The WORLD Champs, we are the team that NO ONE beat.

Oh and exactly how do you get "deep in negotiations" but have yet to make an offer. Isn't that a tad oxy-moronic?

"The Braves are now the favorite for the cellar for the next 12 or so years...a team in a steep decline, and by far the most disappointing offseason (Peavy, Furcal...)"

What..the...hell. They may be the favorites for the cellar NEXT year, but do Jason Heyward, Tommy Hanson, Freddie Freeman, Cole Rohrborough, and Jordan Schafer not ring a bell? Oh, and they have cash to spend, and good young players in McCann, Jurrjens, Escobar, Kotchman, and Johnson on the big league club. Oh. Chipper Jones is good as well. 2009 is not their year IMO, but 2010 and the future is looking bright.

melonis,

I would agree with all except that I don't expect Chipper to be there much longer. At some point his age HAS to catch up to him. Ya i realize that he had one of his best years ever this year but he was injured a lot. I would say he's maybe got 1-2 more years in him and then the HOF calls 5 years later.

oh and i'm not all that impressed with Kotchman. They do have some very good young kids.

Beckett
Dice K
Lowe
Lester
Wakefeild

Seems good :)

Look, the Mets have more individual talent than the Phillies. No one is gonna argue with that. But the Sillies, believe it or not, have much more team chemistry and a better bullpen, which won them a championship. As I said before, if the Mets win the division and lose 3-1 in the NLDS, the season is a success. But they're under no circumstances the favorites until they prove it.

Posted by: metsobsessed | December 23, 2008 at 05:54 PM


The Mets have more individual talent??? I'd like to argue that point.. let's go position by position shall we???

Howard over Delgado
Utley over Castillo
Ibanez over Murphy
Werth over Church

Wright over Feliz/Dobbs
Beltran over Victorino

Rollins / Reyes tie
Ruiz/Paulino - Schoeder/Castro tie

Phillies bench over Mets bench
Phillies pen over Mets Pen
Phiilies starting 5 over Mets starting Five (as of today) - No Lowe yet, and right now, Niese as #5 starter.

Hasn't Christina Karl been insisting that Lowe will be the best value pitcher signed? She is pretty right on. It would be a great add for the Mets.

As a braves fan, a word of advice to the Mets: DONT SEND AN OFFER SHEET TO LOWE! The fa*got skankees will triple the offer and take him from you.

As for Lowe, good pitcher. But for whoever said "Santana, Lowe, Maine, Pelfrey and some other guy is a good rotation" has to be kidding me. The Phillies won the world series. You guys gotta have better then that.

Im saying this cause Atlanta doesnt know how to make a deal anymore. Jake Peavy? No. Burnett? No. Jermaine Dye? No.
JAVIER VAZQUEZ? Yes! ha

Posted by: bravesfansc | December 23, 2008 at 05:49 PM

Its one thing to say the mets arnt the team to beat... Thats fine, the phils won the past two years and are WS champs. But to say that a rotation of Santana, Lowe, Pelfrey, Maine and someone else isnt a good rotation because the phils are the team to beat is moronic.


The Braves have as bright a future as any team in the NL East, for sure. I thought if they brought in Peavy and Furcal they were the team to beat, in all seriousness. Frank Wren has been doing work, and the Javy Vazquez pickup will end up being one of those underrated moves that turns out outstanding when we look back in a year. The Braves core of McCann, Jurrjens, Kelly, Yunel and Frenchie is very good, and they have guys coming. Freeman, Heyward, Schafer should all be studs. Watch out for the tomahawks.

Fyreknight.... just go away, go wackoff to your BJ handbook. Nobody takes you seriously over here.

truth hurts max, doesn't it???

Phillies Eastern Division Champs in 2007 and 2008 - World Phucking Champions in 2008!!

Who's the team to beat???

The Phillies are the team to beat. You are still a dipshit. Anything else?

Sign lowe, sign redding, trade for nady. Any suggestions who we could trade For nady?

knight, how exactly is the phillies starting five better than the mets'? johan > hamels, pelfrey >/= myers, maine= moyer, blanton >(UNKNOWN), niese=?(could be stud, who knows?). Also, k-rod/putz >> lidge/madson. And dont forget sean green. The mets pen might not only be better, if lidge isnt anywhere near lights out... it could be far superior.

"I'm also not a fan of Blanton, Kendrick or Sonnanstine. Several of those other guys had bad years."

Kendrick may have had a bad year, but not Blanton or Sonnanstine. Blanton may have had an ERA of 4.69 through-out the year and had a down year from 2007, but when he came to the Phillies he didn't lose a single game and had an ERA of 4.20. Not a great ERA, but you could do a lot worse than that. Also, Sonnanstine had an ERA of 4.38 throughout the year while having 13 wins on the season. I know that a win-loss record is over-rated [good example is Matt Cain who had 8 wins and 14 losses despite having a 3.76 ERA.]
But Blanton and Sonnanstine were far from bad years and just because they are not ace like pitchers such as Johan Santana or Brandon Webb, they still were valuable to their clubs as a middle of the rotaion, innings eater starter that lead their teams to the world series. For example, Sonnanstine had an ERA of 3.43 in two playoff starts facing well hitting lineups of the Chicago White Sox and the Boston Red Sox before getting a loss against the Philles. While Joe Blanton had an ERA of 3.18 in three playoff starts against the lineups of the Brewers, Dodgers, and Rays and was a valuable pitcher in the Phillies world series run. Blanton and Sonnanstine may have not had a great year, but they were far from having a bad year and were both valuable to their teams in the playoffs.

Hamels is an Ace, as is Santana... Face them off, neither has an edge, both can shut out the other team.

Myers was as good as any pitcher in the NL after his stint in the minors to get straightened out.

Blanton isn't an unknown, he wins every year.. and was very very good for the Phillies, a full year he should be a 13-15 game winner.

Moyer was a 16 game winner in 08, a 14 game winner in 07. Age has nothing on him... if anything, he is improving...

Kendrick had 10 wins in 07 and 11 on 08 as our #5. He'll compete with Happ and Park for the #5.

We have a lot of depth for starters, with 4 fighting just to be our #5 pitcher.

Putz is your question mark.. how will he take the DEMOTION from being a closer to being the set-up man? Unknown.. and he wasn't healthy either.

Maine has health issues... Pelfrey is unknown still... Niese? Don't see him as being ready yet. You have 1 lefty in the Pen... Wagner put fear in the Phillies hitters... I welcome seeing K-Rod and Putz over Schoenwis and wagner....

Yeah "IF" Lidge isn't lights out... think you can say that about ANY Pitcher... player.

"The Phillies are the team to beat."

Maybe so. But it doesn't exactly mean that the Phillies for sure are going to again win the NL East. The Mets just added Francisco Rodriguez and J.J. Putz as their 8th/9th innings pitchers while they might sign Derek Lowe. Pretty tough combo to face right there. I'm not saying that these moves make the Mets a lot better. But it does strengthen them. I like both the Mets and Phillies a lot and can't decide for who to root for in this rivalry. But all I know is that its going to be fun to watch who wins the NL East and that the Mets and Phillies are creating a rivalry that could match up to the Red Sox-Yankees and Giants-Dodgers. This rivalry may not be as classic as those, but this rivalry has a chance to be big for years to come.

Look, the Mets have more individual talent than the Phillies. No one is gonna argue with that. But the Sillies, believe it or not, have much more team chemistry and a better bullpen, which won them a championship. As I said before, if the Mets win the division and lose 3-1 in the NLDS, the season is a success. But they're under no circumstances the favorites until they prove it.

Posted by: metsobsessed | December 23, 2008 at 05:54 PM


The Mets have more individual talent??? I'd like to argue that point.. let's go position by position shall we???

Howard over Delgado
Utley over Castillo
Ibanez over Murphy
Werth over Church

Wright over Feliz/Dobbs
Beltran over Victorino

Rollins / Reyes tie
Ruiz/Paulino - Schoeder/Castro tie

Phillies bench over Mets bench
Phillies pen over Mets Pen
Phiilies starting 5 over Mets starting Five (as of today) - No Lowe yet, and right now, Niese as #5 starter.

Posted by: FyreKnight | December 23, 2008 at 09:49 PM

Ignorant...


While i will agree that Howard is an upgrade over Delgado, it is a small one. Delgado is certainly a better fielder and comparable with the bat. Much less Ks, but also much less power.

Utley is head and shoulders better than any met 2nd baseman. just do me the favor of leaving castillo out of the equation.

SS is a different story. Equal is homeristic yes i said homeristic.

Going into last year all we heard was how much better Rollins was then reyes. However, three years ago reyes was superior, before last year rollins, then last year, clearly reyes. Reyes is also 25 while rollins is now 30. Combine age with numbers and clearly reyes is the better player... Last years stats:
Rollins- .277 avg 11 HRs 59 RBIs 47 SBs and a .786 OPS
Reyes- .297 avg 16 HRs 68 RBIs 56 SBs and a .833 OPS

Wright is obviously better than whoever you consider your 3rd Baseman. equivalently to Utley's advantage over our 2nd basemen.

In the outfield,
LF- Ibanez is more proven than murphy. He is also 12 years older. Murphy was in the league a lot shorter amount of time. so the only way to compare the bats is OPS and AVG, both of which Murphy is better.
Murphy .870 OPS .313 AVG
Ibanez .837 OPS .293 AVG

That being said, they are Equal in reality

Beltran, quite possibly the best CFer in the game, certainly better than Victorino

Church vs. Werth
Both Plus defenders lets call that a wash without actually looking at stats.. if you would like bring them in and ill concede if necessary

Because of injury, Church only played in 90 games. Which hurts his numbers.... My personal opinion is that he is a stronger Offensive player, although the numbers tend lean the other direction... although very slightly... I will agree to call them even.

At catcher no one has a stud, castro is the best hitting catcher out of the group, schneider maybe the best defensive out of the group.. its hard to compare 4 players in two groups. I am going to say there is no decernable difference. between the group of catchers.

Starting pitching... sure its easy to say that your 5 pitchers are better than 3.. but that just doesnt make sense to say.
That being said I will also agree that its not fair to consider Lowe a Met, or Ollie/Sheets/Redding/Garcia/? a met. So we will do it this way.
Johan > Hamels- I dont think this needs explanation, although I could see someone from philly disagreeing. We can go there if necessary.

The rest of the rotation is a ? so we will have to leave it like that until the mets have decided who is their 2-5


Bullpen I think is hard to say. Last year obviously phils over mets. This year is a different story. We now have 2 of the top 10 closers. I am not going to make a claim that we have a better pen, for me its like claiming we are the team to beat. Cant do it until it happens. I am claiming that no one should be talking smack about their pen. therefore making them equal. in my mind anyway, I am sure you will have a different say.

Overall...
Lineup- Mets
SP- Mets
BP- Tie


Mets- better on paper
Phils- team to beat


Why would you say the Mets have the better rotation?? The Phils have 1 stud and 1 above average SP and 3 average behind that. While the Mets have 1 stud, and 1 above average (Pelfrey). Other than that nobody knows hows its going to shake out so how can you give the mets the edge?? And Lidge is better than K-Rod/Putz. However I do agree its about a push. Except the Mets still dont have anyone to get a lefty out.

Fish&Mets,

did you really say Schnider was a better defensive catcher than Ruiz? I doubt that a whole lot. No one blocks the plate better than Ruiz (especially on Lidge's sliders), and go back and look at the swipe tag on Barrett on Utley's WS Game 5 play. Ruiz had perfect positioning and made a perfect tag. Schnider doesn't do that. While his offense leaves a lot to be desired his defense is fantastic. He outplayed Dionnar Navarro who is widely considered one of the best in the league.

I would trade Delgado to the Angels and have Daniel Murphy play first base. Then i would sign a left fielder or have Fernado Martinez play.

I would trade Delgado to the Angels and have Daniel Murphy play first base. Then i would sign a left fielder or have Fernado Martinez play.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Top Stories



Search MLBTR

Lijit Search

MLBTR Features



Recent Posts


MLBTR Mailing List

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner


Rumors By Team



Monthly Archives


Live Chats


Tuesdays at 2 p.m. CST



Site Map     Contact     About     Advertise     Privacy Policy     Widget     Twitter     Rss Feed


MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com.