« Braves Rumors: David O'Brien Discusses |
Main
| Holliday, Angels A Good Fit? »
By Nat Boyle [June 21, 2009 at 11:37am CST]
A busy Sunday morning has made for some some discussable items from around the league:
- Rick Dempsey of MASN is excited by the Orioles future and says it is undoubtedly time for the team to trade, highlighting George Sherrill, Jeremy Guthrie, Brian Roberts, Aubrey Huff, and Melvin Mora.
- Carlos Frias of the Palm Beach Post notes A.J. Burnett has regrets over leaving the Marlins and burning his bridges in the process.
- After Josh Johnson beat the Yankees yesterday, Mike Feinsand of the New York Daily News says, "Hope you got a good look, Yankees fans. You may have been watching your future ace."
- River Ave. Blues thinks trading Xavier Nady makes sense despite Buster Olney having said, "The Yankees are unlikely to trade Nick Swisher of Xavier Nady after Nady returns."
- Not a trade rumor, but Manny Ramirez is set to begin a minor-league stint on Tuesday in Albuquerque, says The Tribune-Review.
- Amalie Benjamin of the Boston Globe says (via Twitter, of course) "Daisuke [Matsuzaka] to DL. [Catching prospect] Dusty Brown up with the team for the first time." She continues, "About to talk to Daisuke. Will get quotes to you shortly. [Sox manager Terry Francona] said he doesn't think this will be a two-week DL." While the Sox still have rotation depth, this surely effects any perceived sense of urgency to deal.
I agree with RAB. If we don't trade him now for whatever value he has, we won't get ANYTHING for him at the end of the season.
Posted by: Thee4stringking | June 21, 2009 at 11:48 AM
"After Josh Johnson beat the Yankees yesterday, Mike Feinsand of the New York Daily News says, 'Hope you got a good look, Yankees fans. You may have been watching your future ace.'"
I couldn't help but laugh hysterically at that sentiment.
Posted by: soxfan93 | June 21, 2009 at 11:50 AM
"
"After Josh Johnson beat the Yankees yesterday, Mike Feinsand of the New York Daily News says, 'Hope you got a good look, Yankees fans. You may have been watching your future ace.'"
I couldn't help but laugh hysterically at that sentiment."
My sentiments exactly. The Yankee sentiments of entitlement come bleeding through once again.
JJ got his game on center stage though vs the Yankees, I watched it and thoroughly enjoyed watching him out duel Burnett in a very well pitched pitchers duel. Pretty full stadium in Miami for a WELL BIASED Yankee crowd that was very pro Yankee.
Johnson hit 99mph on the Radar as late as the 6th inning when he struck out Jeter.The guy is a real talent.
Posted by: johns | June 21, 2009 at 11:57 AM
Dice-K is now officially on the 15 day DL. He should suck it up and rehab in AA, AAA until he gets his stuff back together.
I know trading Penny creates a depth issue but I don't think he is needed. Buchholz and Bowden (I know he stunk last time out in the minors) could step right in and pitch just as well if not better. With limited pitching available on the trade block the Sox could end up with a B+ prospect without becoming weaker at the MLB level. Buchholz's upside is becoming the 1AA pitcher by seasons end, Penny is a 4/5 guy on this team.
Posted by: Theo Epstein | June 21, 2009 at 11:58 AM
"
"After Josh Johnson beat the Yankees yesterday, Mike Feinsand of the New York Daily News says, 'Hope you got a good look, Yankees fans. You may have been watching your future ace.'"
I couldn't help but laugh hysterically at that sentiment."
Because even though it represents the Yankee mentality perfectly, you know its still going to happen?
Posted by: Thee4stringking | June 21, 2009 at 11:59 AM
Why would any pitcher want to pitch half their games in a park where most 18 year olds could put one in the bleachers?
If he signs with the Yanks his contract would probably end when he was 32-34. He would likely be looking for one last big deal. Young pitchers will not want to play for the Yankees.
Posted by: Theo Epstein | June 21, 2009 at 12:04 PM
"Young pitchers will not want to play for the Yankees."
They will if offered enough money.
Posted by: start_wearing_purple | June 21, 2009 at 12:07 PM
Affects. A-F-F-E-C-T-S. Affects.
Posted by: skyharbor215 | June 21, 2009 at 12:09 PM
This is a statement from a beat writer not the representation of the the Yankee fanbase. So maybe we should calm down with this sense of entitlement stuff. If/when Johnson hits the market im sure if the rotation needs an upgrade the yankees will do there research and see if he'd be a good fit with the club. Just like EVERY good franchise will.
Posted by: CosaOneNYC | June 21, 2009 at 12:22 PM
"I couldn't help but laugh hysterically at that sentiment."
Exactly what I thought.
'Hey, a good pitcher. Remember his face because he's good and therefore he'll be a Yankee soon!!'
As if that is remotely logical thinking.
Is that what Yankee fans say every time they play against Lincecum, Kershaw or any of the other top young pitchers in the game?
"This is a statement from a beat writer not the representation of the the Yankee fanbase. So maybe we should calm down with this sense of entitlement stuff."
I think that everyone knows that.
It's just odd, and in my opinion, poor journalism.
Posted by: scribbletone | June 21, 2009 at 12:26 PM
"Young pitchers will not want to play for the Yankees."
"They will if offered enough money."
You missed the point, why would a young pitcher want to go inflate their ERA if they are going to be looking for their next deal at 32-34 years old.
The Yankees paying them an extra 10-15M could lose them a year or two plus $ off their next contract...unless they move the fence back.
Posted by: Theo Epstein | June 21, 2009 at 12:27 PM
"I couldn't help but laugh hysterically at that sentiment."
Exactly what I thought.
'Hey, a good pitcher. Remember his face because he's good and therefore he'll be a Yankee soon!!'
As if that is remotely logical thinking.
Is that what Yankee fans say every time they play against Lincecum, Kershaw or any of the other top young pitchers in the game?
"This is a statement from a beat writer not the representation of the the Yankee fanbase. So maybe we should calm down with this sense of entitlement stuff."
I think that everyone knows that.
It's just odd, and in my opinion, poor journalism.
Posted by: scribbletone | June 21, 2009 at 12:26 PM
========
I agree its foolish and odd. You say everyone knows its just the opinion of a beat write but a sentence before you ask if this is what Yankee fans say when they see a young stud pitcher. Let me answer NO when i see a young talented pitcher i DO NOT think to myself, "cant wait to see him in pinstripes". I dont bother entertaining delusions of Lincecum, Price, Kershaw, Volquez, Hernandez being in my rotation because the chances that any of these guys ever plays for the yankees is small. Their current clubs would be best served pulling out every stop to sign them.
Posted by: CosaOneNYC | June 21, 2009 at 12:45 PM
i hope JJ doesn't go anywhere and the marlins sign him long term but JJ is the type of pitcher the Yanks need at that stadium one that gets groundballs
Posted by: bronzeagle | June 21, 2009 at 01:07 PM
Does anyone else find it strange that Manny can start a rehab assignment before his suspension ends? I'm not some big steroid hater/basher. I don't really care. It just seems odd to me that you are suspended 50 games and you get to use 10 days of that time to get yourself ready to come back to the majors. Also, if he is able to play in the minors, why not play the whole 50 games to keep yourself sharp? Stupid rule in my opinion.
Posted by: DustyP15 | June 21, 2009 at 01:28 PM
You know Scribbs and Cosa I was saying the same thing. It's obviously a journalism with nothing better to report on a Sunday. JJ MAY become a FA and the Yanks will have just as much of a shot at him if he does. However, there's ZERO certainty that he will ever be a Yankee. I just all who post on this subject realize that it's not a "Yankee fan" righting that.
As for Nady, why would anyone think that Nady will be a desired commodity coming off of a major elbow injury that was rehabbed as opposed to surgically repaired? The elbow problem eliminates half of the teams in baseball as almost none of the NL teams would want to to take a chance on his healthy and ability to play the field and throw. The Yanks obviously wouldn't trade him to an AL East team, so that leaves the AL West and AL Central. Because he's a FA next year that would mean he's only going to a contender who needs a bat. That narrows it down to either the Tigers, Twins, Angels or Rangers. None of those teams are a good match. Furthermore, even if Nady were traded for a relief pitcher is it at all realistic to expect anyone decent in return? What team would be dumb enough to trade an effective relief pitcher.
Nady's greatest value would be as a right-handed platoon DH'er or bat off the bench. Matsui is hitting .228/.323 vs lefties (despite hitting 6 of his 10 hrs against them) and .262/.360 vs lefties. Nady can prodide a power bat to complement Matsui against tough power lefties in the AL like Lester, Lee, Downs, Price, Okajima, etc.
Posted by: YanksFanSince78 | June 21, 2009 at 01:30 PM
I would trade anyone if it made the team better long and short term, but I'm not sure what they could get for Nady at this point.
Posted by: Rich | June 21, 2009 at 01:36 PM
"I would trade anyone if it made the team better long and short term, but I'm not sure what they could get for Nady at this point."
So what you are saying, is that you would make any trade that you would clearly win? Because that is some awfully insane thinking there.
Posted by: scribbletone | June 21, 2009 at 01:40 PM
No one is going to give the Yankees anything of value to the Yanks, not even a half way decent relief pitcher. Might as well keep him? Best case scenario is he becomes a power bat off the bench (as opposed to Berroa, Pena or Gardner) and DH's part time w/ Matsui. Worse case scenario, he's insurance against Matsui going down because of his knees.
Posted by: YanksFanSince78 | June 21, 2009 at 01:51 PM
Why would the Orioles trade Brian Robert's after resigning him to a team friendly 4 year contract and making a point of rewarding a home grown player.
They have no 2B prospects and Robert's figures to age pretty well over the contract.
Would they trade him simply because some teams want him?
If they can get some good prospects for Huff, Baez & Mora then I would go for it(I'd keep Sherril) and only trade Guthrie if they're blown away.
It doesn't really make sense as a trading partner but maybe they should try and get Ricky Nolasco?
If they can get a decent prospect for Baez and then two close to MLB position player prospects for Huff and Mora then that would be good business.
I would say Boston could use Huff especially but the problem is trading within the AL East & Andersen is maybe too much to ask for even if they do pay the full amount of Huff's contract for the year.
JJ throwing 99 in the 6th, daymn didn't he just come back from surgery too? Thats impressive stuff.
Orioles probably only need a 3B, 1B & SS along with an ace for the staff and they'd be set as soon as their pitching comes through.
I say Guthrie and Baez to Milwaukee for JJ Hardy and/or Gamel.
Posted by: OhPityMe | June 21, 2009 at 02:35 PM
"I say Guthrie and Baez to Milwaukee for JJ Hardy and/or Gamel."
You would not get Gamel for Guthrie and Baez. Hardy maybe.
Posted by: Indiana Bob | June 21, 2009 at 02:44 PM
I don't think Guthrie & Baez for Gamel is unfair, in hindsight the Hardy & Gamel comment was.
Posted by: OhPityMe | June 21, 2009 at 02:59 PM
Why would the Orioles trade Brian Roberts. They just signed him to a four year deal to be a face of their franchise.
Posted by: metfan57 | June 21, 2009 at 03:47 PM
How will Dice-K's DL stint not be 2 weeks? The 15-day DL is 2 weeks. Unless they mean it won't take more than the 15 days.
Posted by: icedrake523 | June 21, 2009 at 04:15 PM
"Why would the Orioles trade Brian Roberts. They just signed him to a four year deal to be a face of their franchise."
They wouldn't, that's just Dempsey. He was a great catcher, but most of the stuff that comes out of his mouth as a broadcaster doesn't make sense.
Posted by: Daphne | June 21, 2009 at 04:17 PM
"How will Dice-K's DL stint not be 2 weeks? The 15-day DL is 2 weeks. Unless they mean it won't take more than the 15 days."
The implication is that it won't be JUST two weeks. I wouldn't look for him again before the trading deadline.
Posted by: Little Bear | June 21, 2009 at 05:05 PM
the red sox could use a guy like George Sherill. Their is not a really good bullpen pitcher for the nation . He could be a set up man for papelbon .
Posted by: frank bob | June 21, 2009 at 05:12 PM
"Their is not a really good bullpen pitcher for the nation"
I assume you're not counting Ramirez, Okajima, Saito, Delcarmen, Bard, or Masterson? Seriously, that's just a silly statement.
Most people agree the Sox have the best bullpen in the league this year, every member of the pen could easily be a set up man anywhere else. The Sox don't need another reliever.
Posted by: start_wearing_purple | June 21, 2009 at 05:19 PM
What would it take for the Braves to get Luke Scott? He seems to be a fan favorite after watching the series last week, they all chant LUUUUUUUKKKKKKKEEEEEEEE everytime he bats. Don't know if they want to move him but I heard his name on this sight a few times. We desperately need another bat in the outfield, he seems like a very good fit if he costs us about what Nate McLouth did.
Posted by: siskel_god | June 21, 2009 at 06:13 PM
Easy guys.....no Yankee fans said anything about Josh Johnson. Its was a moronic writer from the daily news. The media today in general is a joke which is why I check this site and not ESPN's. Sports writing today is about as classy as celebrity tabloids these days.
Please Tim you have a great site. Don't give in and a great following...don't give in and become the next ESPN!!
Posted by: yanks09 | June 21, 2009 at 07:11 PM
"This is a statement from a beat writer not the representation of the the Yankee fanbase."
Yeah, you are right CosaOneNYC. NYY and Boston both have their fair share of do-do heads that post here with ludicrous things like expecting every thing good should just happen to both Boston and NYY, but I realize that many of the level headed posters here don't expect all the good players to sign in NYY every year they are available.
Some of the NY media are not as level headed on the other hand and they cut both ways, possibly from having 2 MLB teams.
Posted by: johns | June 22, 2009 at 07:24 AM
BRob isn't going anywhere. Scott, on the other hand...
I like how Andy is handling the situation. He'll talk and if he's blown away, he'll deal, but he's not going to trade anyone just for the sake of it (according to what he said in The Sun). We ain't the Marlins, so there's no need to dump salary, esp. with cheap players under long term control like Guts, Scott, and Sherrill. Huff could net two premium draft picks as a FA. If nothing else, Baez provides valuable innings out of the 'pen; protecting our valuable young arms. I'm all for shopping these guys (BRob excluded), but I'd only make a move if the price is right.
Posted by: milehigh78 | June 22, 2009 at 10:17 AM
Agree with milehigh78. I think Mora should be mostly off-limits, too, but strictly because he's such a great team guy and wants to retire as an Oriole.
I say keep Roberts and Mora, but Sherrill must be traded, I'll take either a second-tier prospect or two top picks for Huff, and would want decent value for Guthrie, though I suspect we can't get enough for him to make a trade make sense.
Posted by: The Globalizer | June 22, 2009 at 10:37 AM
OhPityMe: We wouldn't get Gamel for Guthrie + Baez. Sure, I'd love it, but it's simply not happening.
Personally, I'd rather us move those two to pick up a pair of second-tier position players, one at 3B and one at 2B. Young, raw, fast. One to replace B-Rob in a few years, and one to replace the Mora/Huff/Wigginton committee at 3B.
Posted by: The Globalizer | June 22, 2009 at 10:45 AM
"Young pitchers will not want to play for the Yankees."
"They will if offered enough money."
You missed the point, why would a young pitcher want to go inflate their ERA if they are going to be looking for their next deal at 32-34 years old.
----
First of all Yankee Stadium is not the only hitter friendly park in baseball. Great American, Coors, Rangers Ballpark. and even Fenway are all hitters ballparks
Posted by: mike923 | June 22, 2009 at 12:48 PM