They both kind of seem like popularity contests. Obviously the All-Star fan voting is, but it just seems to me like Elias ranks players based more on their reputation than their actual stats at any given time.
dwarfcatt
If Bold means “Free Agent with Option”, what option is this list referencing for Carl Pavano?
He accepted the Twins arbitration offer and is on a 1-year deal, no?
so you mean to tell me Jason Kubel is a type A free agent but Justin Morneau isnt?? WTF
ronny9
it’s b/c its based only on two years performance. morneau missed a big chunk of time at the end of last year, therefore while he is a great player, his last two years (in total) are suspect due to that injury.
Comments for this post have been closed by the site administrator.
BravesRed
I don’t know what is worse, the elias rankings or allowing fans to vote for the all-star game players. Neither of them are obviously about talent.
venn177
They both kind of seem like popularity contests. Obviously the All-Star fan voting is, but it just seems to me like Elias ranks players based more on their reputation than their actual stats at any given time.
dwarfcatt
If Bold means “Free Agent with Option”, what option is this list referencing for Carl Pavano?
He accepted the Twins arbitration offer and is on a 1-year deal, no?
venn177
Bold means free agent, bold + italics means free agent with option.
dwarfcatt
touche
venn177
I can’t believe the Angels got another K-Rod.
Jonas
so you mean to tell me Jason Kubel is a type A free agent but Justin Morneau isnt?? WTF
ronny9
it’s b/c its based only on two years performance. morneau missed a big chunk of time at the end of last year, therefore while he is a great player, his last two years (in total) are suspect due to that injury.