Extension Candidates: Sophomore Starters

Wade Davis signed a multiyear extension with the Rays last week, though he's just one season into his MLB career. The deal is not without risk for Davis, since he could pitch like Ubaldo Jimenez and become a bargain for Tampa Bay, or for the Rays since Davis could get hurt, depriving them of a pitcher they need.

Here's a list of pitchers who could sign deals like the four-year, $12.6MM contract Tampa Bay completed with Davis. Like the Rays righty, these pitchers are on track to hit arbitration after 2012 and free agency after 2015 unless otherwise noted (age in parentheses):

  • Mat Latos, Padres (23) – Latos was flat-out phenomenal last year and would be positioned to ask for more than Davis obtained with his record deal. The skill is there, so if the Padres believe in his health (he's now on the DL) and maturity, Latos would be an extension candidate.
  • Wade LeBlanc, Padres (26) – LeBlanc, now in the minor leagues, is older than Latos and without the same front-of-the-rotation potential. His numbers, though comparable to the ones Davis has, don't scream 'lock me up,' so a deal seems unlikely.
  • Jhoulys Chacin, Rockies (23) – The Rockies were aggressive with extensions this offseason, locking up Carlos Gonzalez, Troy Tulowitzki, and others. Chacin, who struck out a batter per inning in 2010, wouldn't cost nearly as much as his more experienced teammates.
  • Mike Leake, Reds (23) – If one organization was as extension happy as the Rockies this offseason it was the Reds. Leake struggled down the stretch last year and just barely made Cincinnati's rotation. They'll likely let the 2009 first rounder prove himself before committing eight figures to him.
  • Jon Niese, Mets (24) – Niese has comparable numbers to Davis, with slightly more strikeouts per inning (7.4 K/9) and a higher ERA (4.33).
  • Brian Matusz, Orioles (24) – Matusz compares to Davis statistically, but he could establish himself as a front-of-the-rotation starter with a breakout 2011 season, so he may be reluctant to lock himself in to pre-set salaries.
  • Mitch Talbot, Indians (27) - Talbot has poor walk (4.3 BB/9) and strikeout (5.0 K/9) numbers so far in his career, so he doesn't seem like a likely extension candidate. The Indians did extend Fausto Carmona, who doesn't get many strikeouts, but they may prefer to let Talbot prove himself further before committing to him.
  • Brett Cecil, Blue Jays (24) and Madison Bumgarner, Giants (21) both impressed in 2010. They're possible super two players, which means they may go to arbitration four times, once more than the starters above. If either Cecil or Bumgarner signed an extension, it wouldn't be completely parallel to the Davis deal.

It's possible that none of these pitchers will sign extensions, since long-term contracts for starters with fewer than two years of service time are uncommon. Some players don't mind going year to year in anticipation of big arbitration paydays and many teams prefer not to commit eight-figure deals to relatively unproven pitchers.

But some small market clubs, like the Athletics, Indians and Rays, have successfully completed a number of multiyear contracts for emerging pitchers. Teams looking to spend now and save later could take note and approach their best sophomore arms about long-term deals.


Leave a Reply

17 Comments on "Extension Candidates: Sophomore Starters"


Brian
4 years 4 months ago

No mention of Jaime Garcia?

$1519287
4 years 4 months ago

He’s in a different service class. He has 2.047 years now and the others are all one-plus.

Dermick
4 years 4 months ago

1.047*

TophersReds
4 years 4 months ago

Leake was our best pitcher at the beginning of the Season last year, i believe he started the season out 5-0.

kräftig. entschieden
4 years 4 months ago

Citing wins means you’re doing it wrong.

Bucs
4 years 4 months ago

How is citing wins doing it wrong?

Lunchbox45
4 years 4 months ago

Casey Janssen started last year 4-0 . thats how

briankoke
4 years 4 months ago

LeBlanc is starting the year in AAA. He doesn’t belong on this list.

$1519287
4 years 4 months ago

Added a line about where LeBlanc is now. He belongs based on his service time and stats.

briankoke
4 years 4 months ago

He doesn’t belong because there is zero chance of him getting an extension. You might as well list every player in baseball with the same amount of service time.

orneryfish
4 years 4 months ago

LeBlanc couldn’t break a window with his fastball.

LeBlanc would make more money selling health insurance.

He’s garbage.

$1519287
4 years 4 months ago

But I appreciate the note!

– BNS

orneryfish
4 years 4 months ago

The Padres will extend Stauffer and Richard long before they think
about extending Latos.
Both are horses

Latos has maturity and injury issues that both play upon each other…
…if you follow my train of thought.
Latos forgets he has a defense behind him.
He tries to strike everyone out.
That will cost him his arm…..just like Peavy.

4 years 4 months ago

Not a sophomore season, but I really hope the Braves can lock Hanson up within the year or offseason. They don’t have a strong track record with Boras clients, but Hanson is probably the best right-handed starter who’s come up through their system since Smoltz……

Btw, how about Beachy dismantling one of the best offenses in the NL today? ‘Tradebait’ is probably the most underrated rookie pitcher in baseball……

brucefan5
4 years 4 months ago

At this point travis wood is more likely than leake to get an extension from the reds

YankeePhan1234
4 years 4 months ago

Wheres Phil Hughes?

Lunchbox45
4 years 4 months ago

do people not know what sophmore means?