Sabean: Belt Staying Put

At times it's not clear where Brandon Belt fits on the Giants' roster. The 24-year-old gets regular plate appearances, but he shares the first base job with Brett Pill, Aubrey Huff and Buster Posey. However, GM Brian Sabean says Belt’s not trade bait. 

"He's going nowhere," Sabean told Scott Ostler of the San Francisco Chronicle. "The kid's earned his way onto the team … and we all want him to take over as the first baseman, and help this lineup, and I think it'll turn out that way.”

Sabean cautioned that Belt will have to earn his playing time and noted that some of his at bats have been disappointing. Belt, a top prospect entering the 2011 season, has a .234/.317/.407 line in 259 plate appearances as a Major Leaguer. He appeared in left and right field last year, but has played exclusively at first so far in 2012.


Leave a Reply

23 Comments on "Sabean: Belt Staying Put"


chico65
3 years 4 months ago

Giving the kid consistent playing time at one position may help him start Belting the ball in the majors.

formerdraftpick
3 years 4 months ago

With a combination of the players mentioned in the article, it gives the Giants some nice flexibility.  Buster can play C and 1b; Pill a little 2b, 1b, 3b and OF; Aubrey the corner positions in the infield and outfield and Belt a 1b…well he can stand in LF, but wouldn’t suggest it.  I wouldn’t trade any of them, just make sure they get their AB’s in.     

ramjamrock
3 years 3 months ago

You have got to be joking. You say that Pill can play 2B, 3B (which he never has), and the OF, and that Huff can play both corner positions in the IF (nevermind that he hasn’t played 3B in five years)…But Belt “can stand in LF, but wouldn’t suggest it.” Belt is by far the superior defender in the OF over those two.

Pill at 2B is the epitome of “he can stand there, but I wouldn’t suggest it.” Hell, why not say that Huff can play 2B? He “played” there for an inning, right?

vtadave
3 years 4 months ago

I’m pretty sure Belt “earned” playing time with what he did in AAA last year and spring training this year.  If the Giants are going to go anywhere, he needs to be playing most every day.

3 years 4 months ago

Belt needs ABs but with the ABs he’s had he hasn’t exactly been driving the ball hard.  It’s a very weak .278.  He earned the time but does need to hit like a #5 hitter

corey23
3 years 4 months ago

I was talking to my sf fan friends about this, they didnt agree with me… I say stick him at first for 2 years, then move posey there and trade belt for prospects.  Posey is too good to risk behind the plate.

Tony DiQuattro
3 years 4 months ago

It would help if the rest of the offense wasn’t scuffling right now, but they should at least give him a month of regular time before getting reactionary.  Not every prospect starts raking immediately like Posey. He hasn’t found the power stroke but he’s hitting .273 and getting on base at .360 and has an OPS of .746, not bad for a guy who hasn’t found his legs quite yet.

3 years 4 months ago

 That’s the tough part — NO power, no hard line drives.  The Giants need someone to hit 5th

Tony DiQuattro
3 years 4 months ago

Well that’s the dilemma; try to run Huff or Pill out there or give Belt some time to develop. Don’t forget that he hit 9 homers in 209 plate appearances  scattered throughout last year, which extrapolates to 30 over 700 PAs.

3 years 4 months ago

Yep yep, except Sanchez will be the one taking playing time away.  Sabean said if/when Huff returns, it will be in the OF.  Pill rarely makes a dent, plays as much as any backup does.  So if Hector outhits Belt with Posey at 1B I’m 100% okay with that.  As long as any of the young guy’s start producing

Lunchbox45
3 years 4 months ago

Trade him to the Jays please.  I can’t take another day of watching Adam Lind.

Giants need some bullpen help and could use an upgrade in the outfield

Eric Thames + Joel Carreno + Staring Pitching prospect = Brandon Belt

Steelslayer
3 years 4 months ago

I would like to see it…and I don’t necessarily disagree with the offer.  But Belt is somewhat unproven.  Who would you consider as the “starting pitching prospect”? 

Lunchbox45
3 years 4 months ago

someone in the 10-15 on the jays prospect list. 

or David Cooper might be a better fit as insurance for 1B

55saveslives
3 years 4 months ago

Bonds didn’t hit very well his rookie year either.  Kid needs his ABs.  Let him start the remainder of the season.  

melonis_rex
3 years 4 months ago

…until a must have on the other side of 30 comes along. 

FrnchDp
3 years 4 months ago

no?  so you don’t want him to be part of the Giants squad?

Casey
3 years 4 months ago

I don’t want them to keep jerking him around. Let him play, somewhere, even on a different team.

FrnchDp
3 years 4 months ago

he needs to earn it.. how many inconsistent players do you know that get consistent playing time? Sabean just came out and said that they weren’t going to be doing the up and down deal. He’s in the dugout. That’s better than the vast majority of minor leaguers ever get. If he wants more PT, it’s up to him to show he deserves it.

Grab some pine, meat.
3 years 4 months ago

or we can do the logical thing and trade him for prospects before he shows that he cant perform at this level. We have so much talent at first, its not even funny. Even if you disregard the talent at that position, it should be noted that we are flush when it comes to reliable catching as well. With the injury to Posey last year, I think the majority of true Giants fans probably want to see their franchise player in a position that will allow him to play for a long time. 

Honestly, it should be Buster Posey at first on the days that Hector Sanchez catches, and it should be Brett Pill at first on the days Buster Posey catches.Notice how I didn’t mention Huff or Belt, there is no room for them on the roster. Trade high while Belt still has value. (huff is a lost cause, only really worth the 1 year/3mil we gave him during our world series season)

jb226
3 years 4 months ago

Which sounds great in theory, but may well be setting him up for failure.

The reality is that not everybody is cut out to be a bench player, the same as not everybody is cut out to be a pinch hitter or a DH.  259 PAs is barely a third of a season and for him it has taken place over a time span of a year plus.

If Brandon Belt turns out to be one of those players who needs consistent at-bats to keep hitting, all “earn your playing time” does is ensure he won’t get there — probably leading to the organization giving up, trading him for pennies on the dollar and watching him take off with an organization with more patience.

I don’t approve of the up-and-down nonsense some teams do with players, but if the Giants can’t find ABs at the Major League level they should find them in the minors.  Top prospects sitting on the bench rarely ends well for the prospect OR the organization.

3 years 4 months ago

The kid is hitting .273 so far this season. Small sample size. But its the same sample that Huff has. Huff is hitting .182

Chris Faina
3 years 4 months ago

Brandon Crawford?

FrnchDp
3 years 4 months ago

he was supposed to be all about his D.. I think if he doesn’t shape up soon, he’s going to start losing P/T as well.