Email a copy of 'Mark Appel Out For Season Following Elbow Surgery' to a friend
Loading ...
By Steve Adams | at
Email a copy of 'Mark Appel Out For Season Following Elbow Surgery' to a friend
MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com
hide arrows scroll to top
sflomenb
Wow. Bad luck just keeps coming.
johncena2016
I’ve started to feel like the Philles didn’t get a package for Giles. Just feels like a lot of subpar players and guys with injury concerns.
Brixton
That was always the feeling. They got five guys, 3 who hoped to be back of the rotation types, then VV who has a long injury history, and Appel, who’s Mark Appel.
All upside, little certainty. Hard to love, but not hard to like the return for Giles. But then again, if VV turns into a middle of the rotation guy, Eshelman into a backend guy and 1 of the other 3 into a middle reliever, can we really complain?
johncena2016
No we can’t at all. I just think Giles wasn’t a guy who had to be traded. It’s kinda like Tehran on the Braves, still young enough to go through a rebuild but kind of a veteran, enough team control, and a great player to have.
osoblanco
As a Braves fan, I hated the trade, which means I thought it was pretty nice for the Phillies. VV looked sharp this year, and if he gets healthy, he should only improve. Appel has the potential to essentially replace Giles as an effective closer or set up man if he maintains his health and makes some adjustments. I realize that the trade was based on a lot of potential and not much of a track record, but you can’t blame Klentak for going for it. If the Braves could get a similar haul for Viz, I’d take it.
Ruben_Tomorrow 2
Remember after one month, and everyone was clamoring about what a fleecing this was? Trades take time to evaluate who really benefited from the trade. I think the Phillies did very well for themselves at the time they made it. They traded a closer (who may have peaked at his value, time will tell) and got several top prospects from an organization with a deep farm system. Let’s see how it turns out, but imagine if Giles was struggling as much as he is this year and still with the Phillies? Their fans would be all up in arms that they didn’t trade Giles while he was coming off a very strong season.
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
VV will be a #1 if he can stay healthy
AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres
I said at the time of the trade that it’s likely that everyone the Phillies got in that trade would be a bust except Velasquez, but I love that trade for the Phillies because of him.
baseballfan 3
Not signing was the best thing Appel could’ve done for the Pirates (they got Meadows with the comp pick).
Robertowannabe
I was just about to post the same thing… Great minds!!!
st1300b 2
Ha ha from the Pirates organization.
hanks1hammer
Wow. Maybe the guy should just start over again and learn to be a left handed pitcher. This is a joke, in case someone takes me serious.
brood550
Appel has to be off the top 100 prospects list after this set-back. He was already falling this has to be the final nail.
notagain27
Hate to see anyone get hurt but this guy has been way overrated in my opinion. What has he done?? Did he throw 100 with a nasty breaking pitch?? PR move of the decade by his advisors. This is guy has always been too big of a projection to ever warrant being a top 10 pick.
Niekro
high 90s fastball with a + slider has always been why he was rated high, never developed much of another pitch still can be a solid bullpen guy as people have said.
notagain27
You can throw it hard and make it break but if you can’t locate those two factors don’t equate.
Niekro
Control was never a problem until the injuries started
formerjuicer
So glad Houston took him #1, Bryant was #2 and he’s an MVP candidate
Niekro
Still not nearly as impressive as getting the best player in baseball at #25. Everyone is a draft expert in hindsight though.
formerjuicer
That’s true but the two I mentioned were going 1/2 that year. The Cubs lucked out.
Niekro
This guy also had a lot of substance at Stanford far from just hype not sure why you dislike him so much. Hes far from as overrated as some guys are.
htxstunna
Remember this name Jonathan Arauz. could be a steal for the Astros