Headlines

  • Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony
  • Craig Kimbrel Elects Free Agency
  • Marlins Place Ryan Weathers On 60-Day IL With Lat Strain
  • White Sox To Promote Grant Taylor
  • Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence
  • Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

6 Teams Have Made Offers To Edwin Encarnacion

By charliewilmoth | December 21, 2016 at 6:57pm CDT

6:56pm: Cleveland, Texas, and Oakland appear to be the three most likely destinations at present, Bowden adds. On the N.L. side, the Rockies are said still to be “monitoring” the developments while the Marlins aren’t involved.

6:13pm: In addition to the Indians and Blue Jays, the Rangers, Astros, and Athletics have all made offers to Encarnacion, according to ESPN.com’s Jim Bowden (who cites team sources for each organization). As noted below, there’s apparently at least one other organization that has dangled a proposal as well.

Each of those five clubs have put multiple years on the table, per Bowden, who notes that some of the offers include opt-outs following the 2017 campaign. Two suitors, in particular, are said to be engaged in negotiations “at a rapid pace” with Encarnacion’s reps. It’s not known which of the five organizations are pushing hardest at present.

2:35pm: The Indians are “pulling out all the stops” to land Encarnacion, although they might ultimately not be able to afford him, a source tells Fan Rag’s Jon Heyman. Kinzer tells Heyman that two teams have been especially enthusiastic in their pursuit of Encarnacion, although he doesn’t say who.

11:14am: Here’s the latest from Edwin Encarnacion’s agent Paul Kinzer, via an interview with Jeff Blair of Sportsnet590:

  • Kinzer says he is surprised Encarnacion isn’t yet signed. He acknowledges the “glut” of power hitters remaining on the free agent market (presumably including players like Mark Trumbo, Mike Napoli, Jose Bautista and Chris Carter) but says he felt Encarnacion and Yoenis Cespedes stood above that group.
  • Encarnacion has gotten three- to four-year offers from six teams, Kinzer says. Most of those offers were for three years. National League teams have been involved in Encarnacion’s market as well as American League teams.
  • Encarnacion’s priority, though, has been to return to the Blue Jays. The Jays, of course, made a significant offer to Encarnacion, but that offer came right around the opening of free agency, and Kinzer says the timing wasn’t quite right for Encarnacion, who wanted to assess other teams’ interest. After the Jays signed Kendrys Morales and then Steve Pearce, Kinzer and Encarnacion felt it wasn’t likely Encarnacion would return to Toronto. “We never had any idea that the Blue Jays were going to move that fast,” Kinzer says. He acknowledges the two sides have spoken recently, but says Encarnacion is coming to grips with the fact that he probably won’t be a Blue Jay next season.
  • Kinzer says he expected significant offers from teams like the Red Sox and Yankees early in free agency. Those apparently didn’t materialize, and Kinzer says he believes the threat of a lost draft pick had an impact on Encarnacion’s market. The absence of a new CBA early in the offseason was a factor as well, he adds.
  • Kinzer feels it wasn’t a mistake that Encarnacion didn’t discuss an extension with the Jays once the 2016 season started. He says that when he negotiated Starlin Castro’s extension with the Cubs, it was a significant distraction for Castro, affecting his eating and sleeping habits. Encarnacion, meanwhile, was very productive in his final year before free agency.
Share 0 Retweet 16 Send via email0

Cleveland Guardians Colorado Rockies Houston Astros Miami Marlins Oakland Athletics Texas Rangers Toronto Blue Jays Edwin Encarnacion

MLBTR Chat Transcript
Main
MLBTR Poll: Where Will Edwin Encarnacion End Up?
View Comments (134)
Post a Comment

134 Comments

  1. CardsBaseball6

    8 years ago

    i know it’s probably not likely but you have to at least mention the Cardinals since they have “showed interest” in Edwin

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      8 years ago

      The way you guys act on here I don’t blame them for trying to leave you out – STL fans show up in almost every thread for a name player regardless of whether STL has actually shown interest or not, its so annoying (see below for further evidence of what I’m talking about).

      Reply
      • RedFeather

        8 years ago

        Dude get over yourself. I just took a look below and the only whining little troll I saw was you with your “shut up cardinals fans, no one cares about what you have to say” comment. For starters the Cardinals have been linked the entire offseason to EE and they have every right to get excited about it because this happens every year. Jon MO claims he is going to spend money and/or change the look of the team and all thats happened is a new reliever and the Fowler signing. The Cardinals fans all know that team is lacking a #3 hitter and EE would be a great fit at 1B. So please quit crying over others excitement.

        Reply
        • lesterdnightfly

          8 years ago

          Somebody’s missing the Christmas Spirit.
          Cheer up, maybe Mo will get rid of some the Cards’ spare/overpriced parts (Wong, Pham, Adams, Peralta, Leake, Mayers, Broxton, Rosenthal…) for some guys who can produce or play multiple positions. But there’s not a lot of demand for those St. Louis fellers.

          Reply
        • liamsfg

          8 years ago

          You recited a quote, but that wasn’t at all what the person had said…

          Maybe it’s you who should reflect on what you’re posting online and correct yourself.

          I agree that STL is barely, but probably NOT in the running to land him.

          Reply
        • Doorman550

          8 years ago

          They’d never bat EE 3rd. Fowler, Diaz, Carpenter then EE.

          Reply
      • birenstl

        8 years ago

        What a dummy. Stop embarrassing yourself.

        Reply
    • mickeyposkonski

      8 years ago

      Mo’s not looking for any deals with opt outs. He’s too conservative and always looking for an angle..

      Yes, I’m a Cards fan but it is what it is. 10 to 1 he ends up in the junior circuit.

      Reply
  2. Eacino21

    8 years ago

    He should sign with the Indians

    Reply
    • BillGiles

      8 years ago

      I agree

      Reply
    • raykraft88

      8 years ago

      They just signed Collabelo so probably unlikely.

      Reply
      • norcalguardiansfan

        8 years ago

        Collabelo probably won’t make the team out of spring training, so I doubt he will be a block for Encarnacion.

        Reply
  3. alexgordonbeckham

    8 years ago

    I hope he signs with the Rockies and in a “go for it” move, deal a package consisting of Rodgers and Dahl plus one other for Quintana. And then the Rockies also sign Wieters. It’s hard for Rockies to bring starters in via free agency so going after 4 years of Quintana who also is signed very cheap would be a good move.
    Lineup:
    Blackmon CF
    LeMahieu 2B
    Arenado 3B
    Gonzalez RF
    Encarnacion 1B
    Desmond LF
    Story SS
    Wieters C
    Pitcher’s Spot

    Reply
    • BillGiles

      8 years ago

      Too much for Q

      Reply
      • alexgordonbeckham

        8 years ago

        As an alternative, I was thinking maybe Rodgers or Dahl, Tapia, plus two more prospects. But I could see them pulling the trigger on Q if they add another bat.

        Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          8 years ago

          No, you were right the first time, that’s about what Quintana’s value is – especially if you add in how team-favorable his contract is, and that’s a big part of what’s being acquired here, not only are you getting arguably an ace, but a cheap one.

          Reply
        • jakem59

          8 years ago

          Quintana’s value to team X is wildly different than it is to the Rockies. Quintana’s a flyball pitcher who has a tendency to give up some pretty hard contact. That could set him up for a very rough transition to Colorado. That would be a drastic overpay for the Rockies, especially when you look at what they got for Sale, a much better pitcher.

          1
          Reply
        • rocky7

          8 years ago

          Wow, I keep hearing you say how Quintana is an ACE.
          Does that mean that Chicago actually had 2 ACE’s???
          I know you’re going to say how bad the Sox defense
          was behind him but wasn’t that the same defense behind Sale.
          No matter how you look at metrics, Quintana has NEVER pitched in pressure and you simply don’t know how he will handle this.
          Calling Quintana an ACE is an overstatement. A good solid innings eater that provides his team with a chance to win…YES but an Ace. That title has to be earned on the field in actual battle not in the blogs.

          Reply
    • Joe Kerr

      8 years ago

      Damn that would be a nightmare of a lineup to pitch against, especially at Coors Field.

      Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      8 years ago

      Rb: Quintana for Rodgers Dahl and tapia who says no?
      9:06
      Paul Swydan: Rockies
      9:06
      Paul Swydan: Quintana for Rodgers would be an overpay by the Rockies, nevermind adding the other two guys.

      Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        8 years ago

        What a dumbass – that’s laughable. Rodgers is absolutely not in the same universe as Q.

        Reply
        • bonquisha

          8 years ago

          Rodgers isnt more valuable than moncada.

          Reply
        • lesterdnightfly

          8 years ago

          Andre Rodgers was better than both of them.

          Reply
      • theo2016

        8 years ago

        Paul’s a fantasy guy, wouldn’t hold his opinion on that too high.

        Reply
    • dag

      8 years ago

      Scary lineup

      Reply
    • Dock_Elvis

      8 years ago

      I keep waiting on the Rockies to sign a major bat and also deal for a starter. If that doesn’t happen…I think it’s because they couldn’t get it done. They’ll pay someone. I look at the arm as the James Shields type move that KC managed when they traded Wil Myers to Tampa. Sure, Quintana is great…but they have serious competition for him IF the Sox wanna deal him at this point. I’d also imagine they’ve talked to the Rays about starters. Personally, I like Chris Archers K rate for Coors and in those big western division parks.

      Its cold out and fun to speculate…but Id be surprised if Desmond was it. I think ownership is trying to build franchise value.

      Reply
    • Enarxis

      8 years ago

      1.Blackmon RF
      2.LeMahieu 2B
      3.Arenado 3B
      4.Edwin 1B
      5.Gonzalez LF
      6.Story SS
      7.Desmond CF
      8.Wieters C
      9.Pitcher Spot.

      Reply
    • james_schicker

      8 years ago

      Interesting post…..that’s quite a lineup. Hard for me to see them trading either Dahl or Rodgers …… those guys are potential future perennial All stars.

      Reply
      • Dock_Elvis

        8 years ago

        Same was said about Wil Myers in KC and they flipped him for James Shields

        Reply
        • SuperSinker

          8 years ago

          And Wil Myers might yet be a perennial all star.

          Reply
    • brewcrewontherise

      8 years ago

      What Colorado has going for them is quite nice. I’m not a fan of them cutting the rebuild short tho. They have such high end prospects, not to mention the best player in the NL (sorry Harper and Bryant). The Desmond contract wasn’t to good. If they were to invest, why not in the stud at the hot corner. They should not act irrationally because would they be better than the giants or dodgers or even possibly the dbacks if they gave up the farm for Quintana and signed wieters? I don’t think so. Keep developing talent and getting draft picks, trade cargo, and in 5 years or so, they could be a run away in the west. But apparently they are convinced that they can be good now.

      Reply
      • SuperSinker

        8 years ago

        Arenado is not better than Kris Bryant, unless you aren’t accounting for park factors.

        Reply
      • astros_fan_84

        8 years ago

        In five years or so, their nucleus will be gone. I’m not high on the Rockies, but I understand why they would go for it.

        Personally, I think they should try to add Chris Carter. He’d be a cheap addition.

        Reply
        • SuperSinker

          8 years ago

          In five years, almost no nucleus will be together. Rosters are far too fluid to be forecasting that far ahead.

          Reply
    • jlv3gem

      8 years ago

      Hell of a lineup. Your pitchers would still suck ass though lol

      Reply
  4. cardfan2011

    8 years ago

    Don’t know, but I have a feeling once another slugger signs, that’s when we’ll see more signings

    Reply
  5. Bald Vinny

    8 years ago

    You don’t have a 4 year offer, if the team pulled it.

    Reply
  6. Bald Vinny

    8 years ago

    Was Castro working on another extension last year?

    Reply
    • cubsfan2489

      8 years ago

      No

      Reply
      • theo2016

        8 years ago

        joke goes over your head. he is saying castro sucked last year.

        Reply
  7. greg 14

    8 years ago

    let’s assume that the reports are right and he was offered 4/80M by the Jays which he turned down because he wanted $100M plus. Let’s see if he beats the 80M now.

    Reply
    • stormie

      8 years ago

      It’s unfair to say he turned it down because he wanted X amount. He turned it down because it was before/early in free agency and he wanted to see what was out there.

      Reply
  8. 24TheKid

    8 years ago

    Well it won’t happen but it makes a ton of sense to me, the Mariners have Cruz for 17 and 18 which means that is probally going to be there only window unless they have someone else ready to step in. Signing EE to a 4 year deal with and opt out after the 3rd to play first for the first 2 years and then DH the last year. Mariners trade Vogelbach and Peterson for another starter and then you have a slightly above average pitching staff and if not the best, one of the best lineups in the American League.

    Reply
    • terry g

      8 years ago

      EE won’t make the Mariner’s one of the best lineups in the American League while running an outfield of Smith, Martin and Gemel. Jerry’s made improvements, no doubt, but his team is more than two players away. I think he knows that.

      Reply
    • davbee

      8 years ago

      The Mariners had another starter for Vogelbach. His name is Mike Montgomery. One of the stupidest trades of 2016.

      Reply
    • jrwhite21

      8 years ago

      What about Peterson and/or Vogelbach as being a replacement for Cruz?

      Reply
  9. luvbeisbol

    8 years ago

    Candor from a chastened agent. Refreshing….the field is overflowing with poseurs.

    Reply
  10. VICTOR DEDOVIC

    8 years ago

    Between Ortiz coming off the books, Uehara’s 9M coming off the books, and trading away Buchholz’ entire 13.5M salary, I am hoping Boston is trying to find room for Edwin.

    Reply
    • dan-9

      8 years ago

      Sounds like they genuinely want to get under the luxury tax threshold for at least one year (which will reset the penalty rate). So probably not.

      Reply
    • mcase7187

      8 years ago

      Most of that money was eaten up by sale and all the arbitration players they have and plus they really have no need for him

      Reply
    • Ry.the.Stunner

      8 years ago

      The Red Sox already signed Moreland, who will play 1B. Since Hanley can’t play any other position but 1B and DH, that kind of handcuffs them from signing EE.

      Reply
    • terrymesmer

      8 years ago

      If Boston signs Encarnacion, where do Panda and Hanley play? Don’t say 3B and DH/1B. You have to have at least on decent glove at those positions.

      Reply
      • alexgordonbeckham

        8 years ago

        Well, that’s where they would play lol

        Reply
      • BoSoxs4life

        8 years ago

        They cold move Hanley to make room.

        Reply
      • hojostache

        8 years ago

        They are both dead weight. Maybe Hanley bounces back a bit, but Panda has been reeeeeally bad. I still think the Sox want to stay under the cap,Mao they pass.

        Reply
        • SuperSinker

          8 years ago

          Hanley crushed last year.

          Reply
  11. bucknerforhall

    8 years ago

    title of the article should be

    Agent Fuc_ed up

    Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      8 years ago

      +1

      Reply
    • GrandSlammy

      8 years ago

      Yup. I’m surprised agents haven’t caught up to teams’ strategy with the draft pick compensation tied to these FA’s.

      Reply
    • canadianblue

      8 years ago

      If he doesn’t beat Toronto’s offer especially considering he wanted to come back the first thing on his agenda should be to fire his agent

      Reply
  12. ThePriceWasRight

    8 years ago

    love how this agent is basically saying why he should be fired. lol

    I didn’t expect people not to want to part with picks and the lack of a cba surprisingly meant teams weren’t jumping on my guy.

    I’m more surprised Edwin is still with this clown.

    Reply
  13. Solaris611

    8 years ago

    Who needs EE the most? Clearly it’s the Indians, but it’s almost impossible for a team accustomed to shopping at Dollar Tree to make a Nordstroms purchase.

    Reply
    • jmace2710

      8 years ago

      hahahaha…also the price will eventually come down to maybe jc penney’s or dillards so the Indians might be able to shop for EE!

      Reply
    • jpdutton

      8 years ago

      I think we saw enough of Santana playing left field in the World Series.. Bring EE in would require more of Santana in left field and no one wants to see that.

      Reply
      • Ry.the.Stunner

        8 years ago

        Why? They don’t have Napoli anymore, so one of EE or Santana gets 1B and the other gets DH.

        Reply
        • jpdutton

          8 years ago

          If your serious contenders, a team needs one of either their 1st baseman or DH to be able to play OF.

          Reply
        • CubsFanForLife

          8 years ago

          See: 2016 Red Sox (Hanley and Ortiz)

          Reply
        • SandyAlomar

          8 years ago

          Not true If you looked how Francona deployed his team last year. They have a 3b that can play OF if needed and defensive specialists in the minors that can pick up for a game or two. There is no need with how Francona platoons CF and RF.

          Reply
    • tigers1968

      8 years ago

      Brantley is unlikely to come back to anywhere near what he was and that is a big contract for Cleveland. They may have to keep DH open for Brantley.

      They do not need EE. They did pretty good without him in 2016 and who is going to challenge the Indians in the Central division next year ? The only reason I want to see Cleveland sign EE is that it would be amusing to find out what they actually offered.

      Cleveland should wait to see who the last 1B/DH is left and grab him on the cheap.

      Reply
      • SandyAlomar

        8 years ago

        We don’t know what Brantley can and can’t do. Has there been other major leaguers who have had this issue and how have they fared on their return?

        Reply
        • tigers1968

          8 years ago

          it’s two years going on three for Michael… I am not optimistic…

          Reply
    • slider32

      8 years ago

      Cotts only has the Indians at 68 right now, they were at 89 last year, that;s 21 for EE and he might sign for 3/65 with an club option for a fourth year.

      Reply
  14. CardinalsNation1

    8 years ago

    The Cardinals need to sign him now!!! Like right now! Lol

    Reply
    • cards fan 1963

      8 years ago

      Go Cards. Get him, his bat in the middle, makes line so much more dangerous. Carp to second or third and make a move for strong bullpen guy.

      Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        8 years ago

        shut up cardinals fans, no one cares about what you have to say

        Reply
        • themed

          8 years ago

          The Cardinals have the most post season wins this century son.

          Reply
  15. mike156

    8 years ago

    This is refreshing. An agent being fairly open and realistic. Boils down to a lot of assumptions that might have been reasonable at the time they were made, but, as the market has gone in a different direction, now look less sound. This is likely EE’s last contract of significance. If you were negotiating it, wouldn’t you try for a 5th year and a higher aggregate than Toronto’s offer, which was thought somewhat skimpy at the time it was made, and you thought was a floor?

    Reply
    • Dock_Elvis

      8 years ago

      Take the Yankees, Red Sox, Cubs, and Dodgers out of the free agent market and there’s some squeeze. Call it collusion of sanity if you will. The major markets that have historically paid out like rigged slot machines are focusing on team control. EE is looking at the Rockies, Indians, and Cardinals maybe…those arent teams that are going to ice the cake.

      Reply
    • lesterdnightfly

      8 years ago

      Mike156:
      Your take is more reasonable and logical than those whose contribution is to call his agent a clown. Thank you.

      Reply
      • mike156

        8 years ago

        Hey, thanks.

        Reply
        • astros_fan_84

          8 years ago

          Agreed.

          Reply
  16. bonquisha

    8 years ago

    He should go the jason hammels route.
    He clearly needs a new agent.

    Reply
  17. madmanTX

    8 years ago

    Now I see why the Rangers (or other teams) haven’t signed him if EE plans on taking their offer and circling back to Toronto to see if they will match it. It sure sounds like he wants to stay with the Jays based on the above.

    Reply
    • TheBoatmen

      8 years ago

      I don’t think this is the case based on last week where somebody was bad mouthing Atkins and Shapiro for being cheap and Edwin liked the comment. I think he knows his time in TO has run out which is unfortunate. Couldn’t make it to the WS last year and it seems there is a whole lot more subtraction from last year than addition.

      Reply
      • jaysfan77

        8 years ago

        Some moves coming yet, hang on…

        Reply
  18. kiwimlbfan

    8 years ago

    The Yankees have been saying for two years now that they don’t want to take on older, declining players on big contracts because they want to get under the luxury tax threshold. Boston are now saying it as are the Dodgers. They are also valuing their draft picks, another change from the past. I’m really surprised that his agent isn’t in tune with what’s happening with these teams and held out for a big contract from them.
    Unless a team does a stupid overpay, he may have to take a one year deal around the QO and hope to re-enter the market next year.

    Reply
    • jaysfan77

      8 years ago

      You’d think he’d know his client as well, if EE’s desire was to stay in Toronto, then he should of signed. Blaming Jays management just seems really weak to me.

      Reply
      • johnnywalker

        8 years ago

        If EE wanted to “really” stay in Toronto he could have started contract extension discussions one year ago.

        Reply
        • Doc Halladay

          8 years ago

          The Jays and EE did have extension talks last off-season. They lasted well into Spring but EE out an opening day deadline to get a deal done.

          Reply
        • astros_fan_84

          8 years ago

          Encarnacion is surely in the loop. It’s not like his agent is holding information from.

          Reply
    • AddisonStreet

      8 years ago

      Didn’t they just give an old guy like 13 million for one season?

      Reply
      • SuperSinker

        8 years ago

        That’s hardly a big contract. It’s hard to get beat on a 1-year deal.

        Reply
  19. Indyjuster

    8 years ago

    Translation: Your agent is a dumbass that overvalued you initially. You rejected a fair deal offered by the team you wanted to play for. Now that deal is gone and you wont get anything that is close to it. Sorry if I don’t feel sorry for you. Next time realize that 80 million dollars is a lot of money….

    Reply
    • terrymesmer

      8 years ago

      Yep.

      Reply
    • jaysfan77

      8 years ago

      Straight up

      Reply
      • hersch

        8 years ago

        You three are definitely not the three wise men!

        Reply
  20. Baseballholic

    8 years ago

    Another article in the endless chain about EE ( and JB ). Do these writers have nothing else to write about? These players are gone.

    The admin hopefully wants to change this team’s slugfest approach to winning games, especially , trying to turn aboot those heaps of demoralizing one-run losses into wins. Let the endless gossip be cut out, shredded over the editor’s floor.

    I like how the lineup is being under-estimated by many observers. Place most of that money offered to these aging sluggers in the bullpen-slots, for effective pitchers who have closer experience …. even if the admin were to wait until the beginning of the season , when teams will want to address their needs through a two, three way trade.

    Merry Christmas

    Reply
    • SuperSinker

      8 years ago

      The Blue Jays crushed their way to the ALCS the last two years (2015 more than 2016, but still). Scoring runs is something teams should be trying to do, and Edwin/Bautista are exceptional at doing that.

      Reply
  21. Deke

    8 years ago

    We see this every year with the draft pick forfeiture. There is always some agent who is blowing wind up his players behind saying “Dude, you’re a superstar, I’m going to get you a crap load of money” and it doesn’t happen. I’m torn by it, there’s a part of me that feels bad for the player and then there’s a part of me that loves to see arrogance taken down a notch.

    It just amazes me that having seen it happen every year, that we keep seeing people overplay their hands.

    Reply
    • BooJays33

      8 years ago

      Sure maybe fringy guys like Desmond after his terrible FA year in Washington or Drew or Morales a few years back over played their hands and the market wasn’t kind. Edwin is not 1 of those guys. Blue chip middle of the order studs like Edwin Encarnacion have always gotten paid on the open market… it’s not arrogance …somebody will pony up. Maybe not the 5/110M he thought he would see but he’ll get his. I can see 3/65 sounding about right.

      The market for Bautista looks as though it’s cratered but again I wouldn’t call it arrogance. Not sure why a guy who jumps through a million hoops and defies the odds by actually making it to free agency while still productive is arrogant when they finally get a chance to be paid market value.

      Reply
      • lesterdnightfly

        8 years ago

        Sensible post. You are an exception.

        Reply
      • Deke

        8 years ago

        @BooJays33, thanks for the thoughtful response. You certainly got me thinking and softening my stance on that a little. Also I didn’t mean to slight EE, I actually haven’t seen him play enough to form an opinion on what he is or isn’t worth. I think of players like JD Drew who I don’t think are worth what THEY think they are worth even if they didn’t have a draft pick holding their value down.

        Now having said that I don’t think a player’s earning potential should be affected by attaching a draft pick to them, to your point when they do get to Free Agency they should be paid what they can get.

        Reply
      • astros_fan_84

        8 years ago

        Prince Fielder signed in Feb for $200 million. It’s still early.

        Reply
    • Dock_Elvis

      8 years ago

      You’d think guys like Bautista would look at themselves from other orgs standpoint….the age…the demand…the draft pick attached. But then again quite a few players want the stability of 3 years or more….guys with families etc. Theyve been held hostage by that draft pick or taking a one year deal.

      Im not going to feel too bad though for anyone in society that can turn down 15m and will eventually be paid millions….not with the general economy some people deal with.

      Reply
  22. jimmertee

    8 years ago

    EE will get some large money. I think it would be crazy to give him 4 years. I like him at 3 years 20-25 M aav/yr. He can play a decent but not all star first base too so the National is a valid option. He outplayed his Jays contract and is looking to cash in. Since he is one of the premier right handed sluggers available, I am sure he will do well. He might as well be patient at this point, some team will eventually cave and give him big dough.

    Reply
  23. Enarxis

    8 years ago

    Tim Diekers your app stinks !!!

    It keeps on crashing/freezing all the time !

    Fix this or I’m uninstalling. Too bad because I’m a big fan but this issue needs to be fixed !!!!

    Reply
    • lesterdnightfly

      8 years ago

      Careful, you may need to save some exclamation points for the future.
      p.s. There is a way to email Tim Dierkes and the rest of the staff. But that would be subtle and respectful.

      Reply
  24. Enarxis

    8 years ago

    Bautista returns in a RF-1B/DH capacity, Edwin share duties with Morales as 1B/DH, Pearce is use in a UT role/PH against LHP, Smoak gets traded for anything that we can get or starts at AAA !!!!

    1.Travis 2B
    2.Donaldson 3B
    3.Bautista RF
    4.Edwin 1B
    5.Morales DH
    6.Tulowitzki SS
    7.Martin C
    8.Pillar CF
    9.Upton LF

    NavarroC, Carrera OF, Pearce UT, Goins IF.

    Carrera become the platoon partner with Upton in LF and takes over in RF when Bautista DH/or plays 1B !!!

    Would also love to see Revere in LF and have both of Upton and Carrera of the bench while Pearce is exclusively used as a IF !!

    Reply
    • jimmertee

      8 years ago

      Great Jays lineup but it won’t happen unless the Jays brass go back to Rogers and ask for a boatload of cash. Sad.

      Reply
    • rocky7

      8 years ago

      Wow…possible but only if EE takes less to come back.
      Probably not a good bet given the fact that he seems to be committed to the biggest payday he can get and currently that doesn’t include the Jays!

      Reply
    • kc38

      8 years ago

      Sir just stop. EE is gone. That train has left. Just stop

      Reply
  25. BoSoxs4life

    8 years ago

    Don’t count the Red Sox out of EE signing

    Reply
    • SandyAlomar

      8 years ago

      I thought they wanted to stay under the salary cap?

      Reply
    • start_wearing_purple

      8 years ago

      Too late, the logic suggests they’re already out.

      Reply
    • rocky7

      8 years ago

      Right on Bowsox4life
      The Sox are all in these days.

      Reply
    • kiwimlbfan

      8 years ago

      Please Red Sox sign him for 10 years/250mm. Then trade away more prospects.
      Love,
      The rest of the division.

      Reply
  26. JoeyPankake

    8 years ago

    The A’s made an offer? MLB must be putting pressure on them to spend some of that revenue sharing cash they have been hoarding.

    Reply
  27. kc38

    8 years ago

    I don’t care how good the athletics offer is no way EE chooses them. But man if the Astros could add him nobody is gonna touch that offense. I think Colorado may have an offer in as well but I wouldn’t doubt the Indians trying the hardest

    Reply
    • Chefno2

      8 years ago

      there is no reasonable logic behind Oakland going after him. Probably even less than when they signed Billy Butler. Don’t know what they are thinking. But if they do offer more money I’m sure he’d consider it.

      Reply
      • arborwolf19

        8 years ago

        Only logic that plays is a 3 year deal with a year one opt-out whereby EE is his normally high-performing self and the Athletics flip him at the deadline to a contender. Then EE goes on a playoff tear, opts out, and we do this dance again, sans any draft pick hullabaloo.

        Reply
    • JoeyPankake

      8 years ago

      MLB must be putting pressure on them to at least make it look like they are willing to spend money in order to field a team that has a shot at winning.

      Reply
    • astros_fan_84

      8 years ago

      I’m warming to the idea of the Astros signing him. I was afraid of an overpay, but for a reasonable amount, why not?

      Reply
  28. slider32

    8 years ago

    EE is a perfect fit in Cleveland and Texas, they both would be the favorites in the AL with him. It looks like EE will sign soon and then the rest of the DH types will sign. I’m thinking he goes to Cleveland due to the bad blood between the Jays and Texas last year.

    Reply
  29. 66TheNumberOfTheBest

    8 years ago

    What makes Paul Kinzer qualified for his job? It’s just now dawning on him that the loss of a first round pick and/or a glut at his position might affect his client’s market?

    Seems like Encarnacion could have thrown a dart at an open phone book and found equally skilled representation.

    Reply
  30. Enarxis

    8 years ago

    Not !!!!!

    His Preference is to stay in TO and with the addition of a high BA/contact first/high pop bat like Morales; bringing back guys like Edwin and Bautista who’s said that it wants to remain a Jay as well will only make last yrs line up better and you can add Pearce to that as well vs LHP !!!!

    Let’s go Jays; make it happen; bring back the duo and Revere-Navarro and we a w good to go !!!!

    The bullpen can be solve with in house options and great RL can always be acquire at the dead line!!!

    Reply
    • SuperSinker

      8 years ago

      Ew what is the fascination with Revere. He’s not good.

      Reply
    • stormie

      8 years ago

      Doesn’t really matter what his preference is, if the Jays don’t come close to matching the best offer, then he’s gone, and more than likely they won’t come close to matching the best offer. Too many holes that still need to be filled for them to stomach paying $20mm/year to another 1B/DH. Besides, I think Bautista will end up coming back on more of a bargain than what Edwin’s deal would’ve been and he may also need to play some 1B (and maybe make a move to LF), so there just isn’t room for everyone.

      Reply
  31. dematteo42282

    8 years ago

    Mets trade Bruce to the Jays for Loup and a prospect….then Granderson and Duda to the O’s for Brach and a prospect….
    Sign EE for 1B….
    3yr/$75mil…same opt out as Cespedes last yr…then..
    1.Reyes. 3B
    2.Cabrera SS
    3.Cespedes LF
    4.Encarnacion 1B
    5.Walker 2B
    6.Conforto RF
    7.d’Arnaud C
    8.Lagares CF
    Defense is improved…..good balance top to bottom….bullpen fortified and if SP stays healthy 1-5
    I see a team that can de-throne the Cubs…..as 2015 showed…..Mets can def play with the Cubbies
    This is nuts and has no shot…..but hey…..why not??

    Reply
    • SuperSinker

      8 years ago

      Why would the Blue Jays want Jay Bruce’s overpaid corpse.

      Reply
  32. SandyAlomar

    8 years ago

    If Cleveland lands him, would they be the AL favorites over the Red Sox?

    Reply
    • siliconmessiah

      8 years ago

      I am but a Jays fan but I think them signing him would probably tie up too much payroll. I’m just not sure it’s worth tying up so much payroll, the save amount of money could be used on two or three players.

      Reply
    • scott1965

      8 years ago

      Sandy,

      I think the Indians would be the best fit (rumor has it he is in Cleveland right now) for him With the Indians starting pitching healthy Cleveland is the team to beat. AL favorites whether the media wants to admit it or not.

      Reply
  33. toby312

    8 years ago

    I like how agent mentioned he thought Red Sox and yanks would be offering contract earlier? Should be he HOPED …….:)!

    Reply
  34. Polish Hammer

    8 years ago

    Cleveland only shops in the scratch and dent clearance section. If his price drops enough for them somebody else will snatch him up.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony

    Craig Kimbrel Elects Free Agency

    Marlins Place Ryan Weathers On 60-Day IL With Lat Strain

    White Sox To Promote Grant Taylor

    Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence

    Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Evan Phillips To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Recent

    Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony

    The Astros Are (Again) Not Getting Much From A Pricey First Base Signing

    Latest On Dodgers’ Rotation

    Royals Outright Thomas Hatch

    Diamondbacks Place Kendall Graveman On 15-Day IL

    Craig Kimbrel Elects Free Agency

    Guardians’ Will Brennan, Andrew Walters Undergo Season-Ending Surgeries

    Marlins Place Ryan Weathers On 60-Day IL With Lat Strain

    White Sox To Promote Grant Taylor

    Nats Notes: Nuñez, Chapparo, Williams

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version