Headlines

  • Rockies Fire Bud Black
  • Cubs Promote Cade Horton
  • Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base
  • Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton
  • Mariners Claim Leody Taveras
  • Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Astros, Blue Jays Swap Anthony Gose & Brett Wallace

By Tim Dierkes | July 29, 2010 at 3:41pm CDT

Just minutes after the Astros officially acquired Anthony Gose, they sent him to the Blue Jays for Brett Wallace. The Blue Jays obtained Wallace for Michael Taylor last winter right after the Roy Halladay trade. Now, the first baseman could become the heir to Lance Berkman in Houston. 

The Blue Jays believe Gose, 19, is an "athletic, Gold Glove caliber center fielder," Jays GM Alex Anthopoulos told the FAN 590. They tried to acquire him in the Halladay deal and again this spring. Meanwhile, Astros GM Ed Wade says Wallace is a "hitting machine," according to Alyson Footer of the Astros (via Twitter).

ESPN's Jayson Stark first reported that the Astros were sending Gose to Toronto and Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports reported on Twitter that the Astros were getting Wallace in return. The Blue Jays confirmed the trade.

Share 9 Retweet 21 Send via email0

Houston Astros Toronto Blue Jays Transactions Anthony Gose Brett Wallace

Orioles Hire Buck Showalter
Main
Padres Acquire Miguel Tejada
View Comments (439)
Post a Comment

439 Comments

  1. BeenThereDoneIt

    15 years ago

    hmmm… I wonder for what? I guess AA is just purging through the Phillies minor league system. He did mention that he was out there trying to get in on a couple of three ways.

    Reply
    • PujolsHollidayWestbrook

      15 years ago

      Lucky Canadien! 😉

      Reply
  2. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    wow didn’t see this coming

    Reply
  3. Dave_Gershman

    15 years ago

    YES! Go Jays!!! They really wanted him back in the Roy Halladay talks. This is awesome. I think that maybe the Jays could send someone like Trystan Magnuson or Carlos Perez to the Astros. Go Jays!!!! We got Gose!!!!

    Reply
    • Nicholas

      15 years ago

      Better not be C. Perez. AA may be the best GM in the game.

      Real talk.

      Reply
      • Ferrariman

        15 years ago

        idk about best…most aggressive probably.

        Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Jays fans would turn against AA if it was Perez.

      Reply
    • vick_jaswal

      15 years ago

      u dont know anything about baseball
      JAYS loose this trade biiiiiiigggggggggggggg timeee
      worst trade evenn
      this gm is a moron giving up brett walace

      Reply
    • JRM Sports

      15 years ago

      DOn’t get too excited. Gose hasn’t really hit a lick and there is always somebody stealing 70 bases a year in the minors, but you’ve never heard of any of them. That being said, Anthony is as cool as they come and I hope he succeeds.

      Reply
  4. Corey Bishop

    15 years ago

    There he “Gose” again….

    Reply
  5. Rahul

    15 years ago

    for what?

    Reply
  6. Marxkip

    15 years ago

    Please say. Jose Bautista, who will then be sent to Philadelphia, because Houston hasn’t gotten fleeced enough.

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      lol.

      Probably a prospect for prospect trade. Kind of surprising.

      Reply
  7. Nycalex00

    15 years ago

    Astros fans what going on with ed wade.

    Reply
    • frank_costanza

      15 years ago

      Yeah this is curious… Gose was the better of the 2 prospects in the Oswalt deal. I wonder who they got for him

      Reply
    • MadmanTX

      15 years ago

      Not an Astros fan anymore, but I can tell you Wade is liked as much as Uncle Drayton in Houston…which means…not at all.

      Reply
      • tmengd

        15 years ago

        Liking Wade more now since the Astros just stole a top prospect from the Jays?

        Reply
  8. Linutor

    15 years ago

    This seems like a Taylor for Wallace-esque move. I wonder what’s going the other way?

    Reply
    • zonis

      15 years ago

      thinkin the same thing

      Reply
    • zeroes

      15 years ago

      Moreso than anyone expected. Wow.

      Reply
  9. Andrew S

    15 years ago

    i’m gonna go ahead and guess that this isn’t actually happening, just a typo/mistake

    Reply
    • ejr

      15 years ago

      ruben amaro announced that Gose would be “going to another organization” in his press conference a few moments ago. it will be interesting to see who the Blue Jays send to Houston. I assume Ed Wade will get someone that seems worthless to everyone!

      Reply
  10. Dave_Gershman

    15 years ago

    If can improve his base stealing abilities (not speed) but learn how to be a good baserunner, he could be a great player. The player that the Jays love to have and use as a weapon.

    Reply
  11. illnath

    15 years ago

    Astros getting a pitcher?

    Reply
  12. dopefein

    15 years ago

    At this moment, the Astros are the worst run organization in baseball. Very sorry for Astros fans out there. Very sorry.

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Nobody knows what the return is…

      Reply
      • dopefein

        15 years ago

        That’s correct, but there is nothing likely to come back in return that balances the absolute smack-down that Philly has placed on the Stros. This was a terrible deal for the Astros — eating salary, getting fairly weak prospects and a pitcher who remains an enigma. Hey, I’m a White Sox fan, but good deals mean a balance, not thievery.

        Reply
        • dopefein

          15 years ago

          OK, I stand corrected: the pulled off a good deal here. The Astros brought themselves up quite a bit with this part of the deal. I have egg on my face.

          Reply
    • PujolsHollidayWestbrook

      15 years ago

      I think the Royals and Astros are pretty much in the same boat there. Pirates come in a distant 3rd.

      Reply
    • tmengd

      15 years ago

      Think the Oswalt trade turned out better now? After they stole Wallace?

      Reply
    • Justin Nye

      14 years ago

      m sorry too. wallace is hitting .400 in the mlb and gose is on pace to ko 100+ time in AA. sorry for the jays!

      Reply
  13. andhicks

    15 years ago

    Kevin Gregg?

    Reply
    • Linutor

      15 years ago

      That would be a dream come true…for a Jays fan.

      Reply
      • Nicholas

        15 years ago

        Hyperbole, although Gose is very intriguing. Sexxxy tools with his hose and wheels.

        Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      if its for Kevin Gregg I will personally fly to Houston and kick Drayton in the shins!

      Reply
      • Will

        15 years ago

        I wouldn’t worry about it, dude. Even Ed Wade has to know that there’s absolutely no point in Houston acquiring Kevin Gregg.

        Reply
        • Joseph C

          15 years ago

          We are talking about Ed Wade and Drayton McLayne, I have no faith that either of them know the weather outside, forget baseball.

          Reply
        • Joseph C

          15 years ago

          We are talking about Ed Wade and Drayton McLayne, I have no faith that either of them know the weather outside, forget baseball.

          Reply
  14. Shoeless_Joe

    15 years ago

    With the Jays just taking Gonzalez off the 40-man roster, it probably means the Astro’s are probably getting somebody who’s not on the Jays 40-man. Tolisano? McDade? Thames?…hopefully not Jimenez or Perez.

    Reply
  15. TheBunk

    15 years ago

    Maybe Litsch?

    Reply
  16. S8P7W

    15 years ago

    He’ll turn out to be Joey Gathright or Michael Bourn. Please be the latter.

    Reply
    • Wilson

      15 years ago

      i’ve followed gose since we drafted him and the dude is 6’1″ bordering on 6’2″ the bourn comparisons are not apt and gathright is just insulting, lol. he has way more power than those guys while maintaining high end defensive skills and range. and he’s only 19. despite me defending him I am glad the phils included him in the oswalt deal and were able to land an ace with him as part of the package. We kept all of our great young arms and potential stud in singleton.

      Reply
      • S8P7W

        15 years ago

        I’ll take your word for it. I just looked at his numbers and scouting report and came to that conclusion.

        Reply
  17. Alex Grady

    15 years ago

    $20 to a donut says that it’s not for a prospect. AA isn’t unloading prospects, he’s getting rid of old guys.

    Reply
    • foxtown

      15 years ago

      Why would the Astros want old guys though?

      Reply
    • moonraker45

      15 years ago

      guess you owe me 20 bucks and a donut.

      Reply
  18. FPN

    15 years ago

    BJ’s wanted Gose from the Phils last year, I think.

    Reply
  19. illnath

    15 years ago

    Astros getting a pitcher?

    Reply
  20. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    Zep, mills, litch, purcey???

    Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      I’d take Ryzypcynski *SP?

      Reply
  21. BeenThereDoneIt

    15 years ago

    LOL… Litsch? Is that a joke?

    Reply
    • TheBunk

      15 years ago

      The chances that Gose turns into ANYTHING is very low, it’s not ridiculous that he would be traded for a young cost controlled starter who has had success in the AL East, We aren’t talking about a Dominic Brown here, it’s Anthony friggin Gose

      Reply
      • Sniderlover

        15 years ago

        It could be Mills who could be back-end starter and is MLB ready.

        Reply
        • TheBunk

          15 years ago

          Definitely, I think Litsch or Mills make sense, I doubt it’ll be Rzep, IMO Houston would have to sweeten the pot to make that work.

          Reply
          • Sniderlover

            15 years ago

            Even Litsch. Litsch is a young pitcher who has 2 very successful season putting up ERA below 4 and is a good #4-5 starter who eats innings. It would have to be Gose + for Litsch. He is not really a highly touted prospect and is just speedy.

            Not a chance it’s for Zep unless there is another prospect coming with Gose. People forget but Zep was better than Cecil last year.

            Reply
          • rzepczynski

            15 years ago

            litsch? does everyone forget he had a 3.50 era in the al east as a 23 year old?……

            Reply
          • Joseph C

            15 years ago

            I’d take Rzep in a second… don’t want another M. Bourn… been there, next!

            Reply
      • melonis_rex

        15 years ago

        Ding ding ding. Getting two league-average cost controlled starters for Oswalt is smart.

        Reply
      • Steve Smith

        15 years ago

        How does the shoe taste in your mouth?

        Reply
    • blizzah

      15 years ago

      Uh. Litsch in the NL would be a #2-3 quality pitcher provided he is healthy now

      Reply
  22. MadmanTX

    15 years ago

    Yeah…you gotta think there is another part to the story…unless the Phillies and Astros just felt like tossing a player to the Blue Jays for laughs.

    Reply
  23. blizzah

    15 years ago

    I like the prospect of AA dealing with Houston.

    For all we know, Jonny Mac and Dwayne Wise might be the package going back

    Reply
    • Ian_Smell

      15 years ago

      I had a dream last night that Dwayne Wise was traded for Justin Smoak. Anything’s possible.

      Reply
  24. S8P7W

    15 years ago

    Anthopoulos wanted the Jays to be more athletic.

    Reply
  25. Brian Henry

    15 years ago

    Its not a typo. Ruben Amaro Jr. just said Gose is heading to a different organization [besides Houston]

    Reply
  26. Astrosfan9145

    15 years ago

    For who???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????. Gosh darn it. :/. This better be a good prospect.

    Reply
  27. meanguygary

    15 years ago

    Better not be Perez!

    Reply
  28. bonestock94

    15 years ago

    …for the ball boy.

    Reply
  29. MattXner

    15 years ago

    I love it, I’m a Phillies fan, so i’m really excited with the robbery that was the Roy Oswalt deal. I love the Blue Jays too, and I’m really excited that so many phillies prospects are headed to Toronto it gives me another reason to root for the Jays. I can’t wait for Drabek and Gose to start making an impact for you guys

    Reply
  30. renegade

    15 years ago

    I’d love it to be for Mills. Two Brad Mills in Houston? Boom.

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Mills helped his value yesterday with that amazing start… but then again, it was against the Orioles.

      Reply
  31. Nicholas

    15 years ago

    Mike Newman from Scouting the Sally has raved about Gose’s defense in CF:

    In watching Gose in centerfield, I could not help but think of “The Bad News Bears” and “Kelly” catching everything from foul pole to foul pole. In making spectacular sliding catches in both outfield gaps, he showed gold glove caliber range. As impressive as those catches were, however, his routes can definitely improve, as well as his overall body control. He was borderline reckless in the outfield and could leave himself open to serious injury. In seeing him twice, he was not in a situation where he needed to show off his arm strength.

    Reply
    • wbruyea

      15 years ago

      I’m guessing Jays will trade a similarly rated prospect at a similar level in the minors with a similar upside. Henderson Alvarez comes to mind.

      Reply
  32. wbruyea

    15 years ago

    I’m sure it will be for a pitcher………the Jays strength and something the Astros need more than ever with Oswalt gone

    Reply
  33. BHam2421

    15 years ago

    I think its Brett Wallace headed to Houston for Gose.

    Reply
    • Ted

      15 years ago

      Riiiiight.

      Reply
      • Steve Smith

        15 years ago

        Cooorrrreeccttt

        Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      lolwut?

      Reply
    • Troy_k

      15 years ago

      AHahahahahha

      Reply
    • renegade

      15 years ago

      I think you’re clueless.

      Reply
      • BHam2421

        15 years ago

        Do you still think I’m clueless?

        Reply
      • BHam2421

        15 years ago

        Do you still think I’m clueless?

        Reply
      • bonestock94

        15 years ago

        You just got shat on

        Reply
      • bonestock94

        15 years ago

        You just got shat on

        Reply
      • Joey Doughnuts

        15 years ago

        lol, eat crow.

        Reply
        • Mike P

          15 years ago

          ohay joecoolman

          Reply
          • Joey Doughnuts

            15 years ago

            Oh hey, whoever you are…?

            Reply
      • Joey Doughnuts

        15 years ago

        lol, eat crow.

        Reply
      • Steve Smith

        15 years ago

        HAhah I think you’re cluless

        Reply
  34. astros44

    15 years ago

    Andrew- I couldn’t agree more. I wanted Singleton and Cosart- anything else I really don’t mind. Happ is nice, no doubt- but he’s 27 going on 28 years old. He’s not a “kid” anymore, especially when you compare to the 19 year old Miller they were going after from St. Louis… Wade just likes dealing with Philly.. Can he seriously make a move when another freaking team???

    Reply
  35. wpgjaysfan

    15 years ago

    Do the Astro’s need a first baseman? Throw in one more prospect and give them Overbay. Time for Wallace to come up anyways.

    Reply
    • astros44

      15 years ago

      No thanks.. We don’t want a 33+ year old first baseman struggling to hit .250. We pretty much have that now..

      Reply
      • Ty

        15 years ago

        Not struggling… Overbay had a terrible April but he’s been getting better and better ever since. Perfect type of guy for a team looking to make a stretch run… the Astros, not so much.

        Reply
      • Karman

        15 years ago

        lol

        Reply
    • Steve Smith

      15 years ago

      I think that we’ll take Wallace instead…

      Reply
  36. BeenThereDoneIt

    15 years ago

    It wont be for Litsch, Mills, Zep or any of the young pitchers the Jays have. Litsch was a sub 4 era pitcher in the friggen AL east and is starting to show very well after a bad couple of starts coming back from injury. Mills is the low end of those guys, but you don’t trade young pitching for even younger hitting. It just doesnt happen. Zep, you can forget about. None of these guys go for any less than an impact player. Unless there is more to this and another player comes the Jays way, this will probably be a guy no one has ever heard of…

    Reply
  37. PhillyPhan11

    15 years ago

    wonder who their going to get for him

    Reply
  38. meanguygary

    15 years ago

    With Brad Arnsberg in Houston, I bet it’s for a pitcher.

    Reply
  39. Joshua

    15 years ago

    AA is going to be on The Fan 590 (you can listen online) just after 5pm EST, so maybe he’ll mention it then. Bob McCown even said he was going to ask him about the Oswalt trade.

    Reply
  40. Joseph C

    15 years ago

    Ugh why are my Astros such a punchline? I miss the days of Gerry Hunsicker!!!

    Reply
  41. MattXner

    15 years ago

    The Blue Jays and Phillies have such a special connection because of Pat Gillick, its as if he is building the Phillies to win now and the Blue Jays to win later. Gillick is a genious and he has a hand in all of this. The fact that Ed Wade is in Houston opens the Astros up to help Philadelphia and Toronto because of the connection. Just look over the past three or four years of the trades involving these teams. All connected. But, I hope Gillick convinces AA to let Bautista go to the Phillies on the cheap…. (wishful thinking on my part haha)

    Reply
    • Karman

      15 years ago

      sure, very cheap, just one prospect, nothing massive like 3 or 4 prospects. Can you guess who the one prospect I’m thinking of? lol

      Reply
      • Jim

        15 years ago

        gose haha

        Reply
  42. Josh

    15 years ago

    Brett Wallace is correct…

    Reply
    • Joshua

      15 years ago

      Oops, didn’t mean to “like” that. If AA actually did that, he’d get absolutely torn to shreds in the media.

      Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      That would be SWEEEEEET!

      Reply
    • melonis_rex

      15 years ago

      I would laugh so hard if that were correct. I don’t believe you though.

      Reply
      • Josh

        15 years ago

        Just wait…I have had it confirmed by two different sources. I work in baseball.

        Reply
        • Joshua

          15 years ago

          Have you had it confirmed that AA is either on some heavy drugs or is somehow flipping Gose and Downs for Montero?

          Reply
          • Josh

            15 years ago

            No this is where my sources end…haha…sorry.

            Reply
          • Josh

            15 years ago

            No this is where my sources end…haha…sorry.

            Reply
        • Joshua

          15 years ago

          Have you had it confirmed that AA is either on some heavy drugs or is somehow flipping Gose and Downs for Montero?

          Reply
      • Josh

        15 years ago

        Just wait…I have had it confirmed by two different sources. I work in baseball.

        Reply
  43. Josh

    15 years ago

    I have sources in this deal…

    Reply
    • Joshua

      15 years ago

      Right. Because teams always trade guys hitting .301/.359/.509 in AAA for guys hitting .263/.325/.385 in low A. Especially when the AAA guy is the only in house replacement for your current, expiring contract 1B.

      Reply
      • Ferrariman

        15 years ago

        can’t hoffpauir play firstbase?

        Reply
      • Josh

        15 years ago

        I agree with you, it’s puzzling. I have seen Anthony Gose play about 100 games, he is very very raw with high upside. He has been hitting full time for only about two years, he used to be a highly rated lefty pitcher with a 96 mph fastball. Great defensively, and despite his numbers this season, is a great base stealer…Has the upside of a Michael Bourn. Take it for what it’s worth.

        Reply
      • Josh

        15 years ago

        I agree with you, it’s puzzling. I have seen Anthony Gose play about 100 games, he is very very raw with high upside. He has been hitting full time for only about two years, he used to be a highly rated lefty pitcher with a 96 mph fastball. Great defensively, and despite his numbers this season, is a great base stealer…Has the upside of a Michael Bourn. Take it for what it’s worth.

        Reply
      • Joshua

        15 years ago

        Well, now I feel stupid. There must be something else going on.

        Reply
      • Joshua

        15 years ago

        Well, now I feel stupid. There must be something else going on.

        Reply
  44. 14 Rocks

    15 years ago

    Wow. The Jays fleeced the Braves in the Escobar trade. And now Philly fleeces Houston in the Oswalt trade. Looks like Philly will be repeating as NL East champs unless Frank Wren pulls a rabbit out of his hat in the form of a power hitting outfielder.

    Reply
    • johnsmith4

      15 years ago

      The icing on the cake will be if the Jays send Jo Jo Reyes (acquired from Atlanta in the Escobar trade) for Gose

      Reply
    • johnsmith4

      15 years ago

      The icing on the cake will be if the Jays send Jo Jo Reyes (acquired from Atlanta in the Escobar trade) for Gose

      Reply
  45. meanguygary

    15 years ago

    WWHHHHHAAATTtttt!!!!!!!?????

    Reply
  46. Shane Kelly

    15 years ago

    Yep…It’s for Wallace according to Rosenthal on Twitter

    Reply
  47. Shane Kelly

    15 years ago

    Yep…It’s for Wallace according to Rosenthal on Twitter

    Reply
  48. renegade

    15 years ago

    FOR WALLACE? ARE YOU KIDDING ME?

    Reply
  49. Sniderlover

    15 years ago

    WHAT THE HELL IS THIS!?!?!

    Reply
  50. Sniderlover

    15 years ago

    WHAT THE HELL IS THIS!?!?!

    Reply
  51. Zebradune

    15 years ago

    Wow, Gose for Wallace??? I guess Ed Wade isn’t THAT dumb.

    Reply
    • Abraham Zapruder

      15 years ago

      Wallace, Happ and Villar isn’t THAT bad for Oswalt. Nice deal Houston.

      Reply
    • Abraham Zapruder

      15 years ago

      Wallace, Happ and Villar isn’t THAT bad for Oswalt. Nice deal Houston.

      Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      If that is true, kudos to Ed Wade, but he is still a moron

      Reply
  52. Zebradune

    15 years ago

    Wow, Gose for Wallace??? I guess Ed Wade isn’t THAT dumb.

    Reply
  53. ryanfea

    15 years ago

    Wow, poor deal for the Jays

    Reply
  54. ryanfea

    15 years ago

    Wow, poor deal for the Jays

    Reply
  55. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    If they trade wallace i’ll stop watching jays for 20 years…………….

    Reply
    • Yoni Pollak

      15 years ago

      stop watching!

      Reply
    • Yoni Pollak

      15 years ago

      stop watching!

      Reply
    • ryanfea

      15 years ago

      Don’t be so melodramatic. Good God…

      Reply
    • ryanfea

      15 years ago

      Don’t be so melodramatic. Good God…

      Reply
  56. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    If they trade wallace i’ll stop watching jays for 20 years…………….

    Reply
  57. Ian_Smell

    15 years ago

    Why didn’t they just keep Taylor? Gose doesn’t seem to be as good as Taylor. The Cardinals might regret ever dealing Wallace if he turns out to be as good as he’s hyped up to be.

    Reply
    • melonis_rex

      15 years ago

      Except that Albert Pujols plays 1B for the Cardinals, and its kinda clear that Wallace is not a 3B.

      Gose has more upside than Taylor. Taylor’s more likely to actually be a good MLB player, but Gose’s got a way higher ceiling.

      Reply
    • melonis_rex

      15 years ago

      Except that Albert Pujols plays 1B for the Cardinals, and its kinda clear that Wallace is not a 3B.

      Gose has more upside than Taylor. Taylor’s more likely to actually be a good MLB player, but Gose’s got a way higher ceiling.

      Reply
    • Triteon

      15 years ago

      But how often are these “can’t-miss” prospects traded three times in a year? I’m starting to think he may be all hype.

      Reply
      • sacu

        15 years ago

        I was thinking the same thing. Maybe he has a poor attitude. I don’t recall someone as good as Wallace being traded three times in year, before reaching the majors!

        Reply
  58. Ian_Smell

    15 years ago

    Why didn’t they just keep Taylor? Gose doesn’t seem to be as good as Taylor. The Cardinals might regret ever dealing Wallace if he turns out to be as good as he’s hyped up to be.

    Reply
  59. meanguygary

    15 years ago

    I am so unbelievably furious.

    Reply
  60. gs01

    15 years ago

    OMG, Brett Wallace, I hope this doesn’t mean Overpay is going to be getting another contract extension, who’s the 1st baseman of the future now?

    Reply
    • melonis_rex

      15 years ago

      With all his pitching depth in line, AA goes out and signs Prince Fielder/Adrian Gonzalez to a massive FA contract after the 2011 season, to throttle the Yankees and Red Sox.

      Reply
  61. rynonocerus

    15 years ago

    rosenthals just tweeted:
    Ken_Rosenthal

    #Astros sending Gose to #BlueJays for IF Brett Wallace. #MLB
    5 minutes ago via web

    Reply
  62. TheBunk

    15 years ago

    I assume this means Adam Lind is going to be the full time 1B for the Jays come next year. I don’t really like this deal on first look but I don’t think it’s a disaster either.

    Reply
  63. TheBunk

    15 years ago

    I assume this means Adam Lind is going to be the full time 1B for the Jays come next year. I don’t really like this deal on first look but I don’t think it’s a disaster either.

    Reply
  64. astros44

    15 years ago

    YEAHHH! LET’S GO HOUSTON! WHAT UP BABY IF THIS IS TRUE, ED WADE ISN’T AN IDIOT (well, a complete idiot- I mean, he did assemble that winning Phillies squad…) AFTER ALL! WALLACE FOR GOSE!!!!!

    Reply
  65. astros44

    15 years ago

    YEAHHH! LET’S GO HOUSTON! WHAT UP BABY IF THIS IS TRUE, ED WADE ISN’T AN IDIOT (well, a complete idiot- I mean, he did assemble that winning Phillies squad…) AFTER ALL! WALLACE FOR GOSE!!!!!

    Reply
  66. Will

    15 years ago

    Gotta agree with the comments here–Ed Wade seems to have actually done himself a nice little piece of business here.

    Reply
  67. Will

    15 years ago

    Gotta agree with the comments here–Ed Wade seems to have actually done himself a nice little piece of business here.

    Reply
  68. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    i hope Ken Rosenthal is bsing i dont think AA is mentally retarded

    Reply
  69. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    i hope Ken Rosenthal is bsing i dont think AA is mentally retarded

    Reply
  70. Sniderlover

    15 years ago

    There has to be more to this deal right? Because this is unfeaking believable.

    Reply
  71. Sniderlover

    15 years ago

    There has to be more to this deal right? Because this is unfeaking believable.

    Reply
  72. ukJaysfan

    15 years ago

    Breathe guys, there’s probably something more to this. Remember ‘How to Cook Forty Humans’

    Reply
  73. andhicks

    15 years ago

    How does this happen?
    AA?

    Can’t say I like this one bit as a Jays fan.

    Reply
  74. Nicholas

    15 years ago

    WTF AA?!?!?!?!

    Wallace??!?!?!?

    I’m gonna go hang myself nao.

    Reply
  75. renegade

    15 years ago

    OUR FIRST BASEMEN OF THE FUTURE for a ****ING 4TH OUTFIELDER AT BEST?
    I TRUSTED AA…

    Reply
    • johnsmith4

      15 years ago

      Hey….here is your proof AA has Montero lined up

      Reply
      • CosaOne

        15 years ago

        No chance

        Reply
      • CosaOne

        15 years ago

        No chance

        Reply
    • johnsmith4

      15 years ago

      Hey….here is your proof AA has Montero lined up

      Reply
    • Dave_Gershman

      15 years ago

      Actually everybody, people just look at Brett Wallace’s hitting stats, but he is one of the most overrated players in MILB according to Baseball Prospects. From my point of view, I was upset to see Wallace go, but he isn’t sold on succeeding on the defensive side in the NL. We’ll see what happens.

      Reply
      • The Jesus

        15 years ago

        I’m not high on Gose -or- Wallace. There is a lot not to like so far about both. Either way, we just need to stay calm and see what happens. I truly think it makes more sense to have Lind as a 1B and Snider ending up as a DH long-term.

        Reply
        • jeffdg

          15 years ago

          (1) Anyone who thinks Lind can be a good 1B is crazy. Look at his lack of mobility and lateral quickness. Not chance he plays at 1B. He would be below replacement level i suspect.
          (2) Snider is a very good athlete is a much better defender than you think. Not sure why he gets the “lind treatment” for this, but he is a much better defender.

          Reply
          • kldhca

            15 years ago

            Anyone who thinks Lind can be a good 1B is crazy. Look at his lack of mobility and lateral quickness. Not chance he plays at 1B. He would be below replacement level i suspect.

            The same can be said for Wallace

            Reply
        • Dave_Gershman

          15 years ago

          Agree. Your a smart guy.

          Reply
    • Ty L

      15 years ago

      4th outfielder at best? At best Gose is a gold-glove CF with a great arm, can steal 50+ bags a year and hit 10-15 HR’s…maybe more.

      I would never trade Wallace for him because he comes with more risk, but Gose is more than a 4th OF if he does indeed work out.

      Reply
      • Nicholas

        15 years ago

        Gose has an immensely high ceiling but no way he is worthy of being traded straight-up for Wallace.

        Reply
      • Nicholas

        15 years ago

        Gose has an immensely high ceiling but no way he is worthy of being traded straight-up for Wallace.

        Reply
    • Ty L

      15 years ago

      4th outfielder at best? At best Gose is a gold-glove CF with a great arm, can steal 50+ bags a year and hit 10-15 HR’s…maybe more.

      I would never trade Wallace for him because he comes with more risk, but Gose is more than a 4th OF if he does indeed work out.

      Reply
  76. renegade

    15 years ago

    OUR FIRST BASEMEN OF THE FUTURE for a ****ING 4TH OUTFIELDER AT BEST?
    I TRUSTED AA…

    Reply
  77. ITALIAN IN NEW ZEALAND

    15 years ago

    A.A MADE THIS DEAL WHILE BEING POSSESSED BY J.P

    Reply
  78. wbruyea

    15 years ago

    if this is true………….I don’t get it! AA must have a pretty high opinion of Anthony Gose after spending so much effort acquiring and promoting Brett Wallace

    Reply
  79. wbruyea

    15 years ago

    if this is true………….I don’t get it! AA must have a pretty high opinion of Anthony Gose after spending so much effort acquiring and promoting Brett Wallace

    Reply
  80. Guest

    15 years ago

    Brett Wallace will play for every AAA team before he makes it to the majors.

    Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      Dont the Astros qualify as a AAA team at this point? :-/

      Reply
    • Joseph C

      15 years ago

      Dont the Astros qualify as a AAA team at this point? :-/

      Reply
  81. J D

    15 years ago

    How did Houston get a major league ready 1st/3rd baseman for a 4th OF prospect with no plate discipline and no idea how to steal (70% success rate)?

    Reply
    • Dave_Gershman

      15 years ago

      Brett Wallace can’t play 1st or 3rd. Future DH. Anthony Gose has tremendous upside and potential. Young but is the next Michael Bourn. Jays also have a logjam at 1B which Lind will eventually fill which will let the Jays have a ton of AB’s for a future DH.

      Reply
      • J D

        15 years ago

        Ok you say he cant play the field, so why trade their future DH for nothing?

        Reply
        • Dave_Gershman

          15 years ago

          gose is far from nothing

          Reply
  82. J D

    15 years ago

    How did Houston get a major league ready 1st/3rd baseman for a 4th OF prospect with no plate discipline and no idea how to steal (70% success rate)?

    Reply
  83. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    now some carefully thinking Ken Rosenthal is a moron probably just saying random crap to get people to check his twitter.

    Ken Rosenthal = Sparkling Vampire from GAY twilight?

    Reply
  84. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    now some carefully thinking Ken Rosenthal is a moron probably just saying random crap to get people to check his twitter.

    Ken Rosenthal = Sparkling Vampire from GAY twilight?

    Reply
  85. renegade

    15 years ago

    EVEN JP RETARDI wouldnt have made a deal this bad.

    Reply
  86. renegade

    15 years ago

    EVEN JP RETARDI wouldnt have made a deal this bad.

    Reply
  87. adameb

    15 years ago

    WTF. As a Jays fan I couldn’t be more unhappy with this deal.

    I can only assume that someone found AA’s cell phone, found Wade’s phone number, and made this trade as a prank. Hopefully Selig can step in before the guy trades Drabek for a fast pitch machine.

    Reply
  88. adameb

    15 years ago

    WTF. As a Jays fan I couldn’t be more unhappy with this deal.

    I can only assume that someone found AA’s cell phone, found Wade’s phone number, and made this trade as a prank. Hopefully Selig can step in before the guy trades Drabek for a fast pitch machine.

    Reply
  89. ITALIAN IN NEW ZEALAND

    15 years ago

    HOW THE HELL DO YOU TRADE A POTENTIALLY INJURY PRONE OUTFIELDER FOR A MIDDLE OF THE ORDER BAT LIKE WALLACE??

    Reply
  90. ITALIAN IN NEW ZEALAND

    15 years ago

    HOW THE HELL DO YOU TRADE A POTENTIALLY INJURY PRONE OUTFIELDER FOR A MIDDLE OF THE ORDER BAT LIKE WALLACE??

    Reply
  91. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    Brett wallace for gose.. omg awful move. Does this mean we are getting montero

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      omg ur right down for montero ok make sense now

      Reply
      • Sleepykarl

        15 years ago

        Yes, you are getting a top 5 prospect in baseball for two months of a 35 year old reliever.

        Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      omg ur right down for montero ok make sense now

      Reply
    • CosaOne

      15 years ago

      Who would you be getting Montero for? Please dont say Downs

      Reply
      • Yankees420

        15 years ago

        What are you talking about? Downs is worth Montero+ easily, I mean the guy is a stud LH 8th inning pitcher and HE GETS YOU DRAFT PICKS!! Cashman would be a fool to hold on to Montero instead of getting Downs.

        /ends overzealous sarcasm. =P

        Reply
  92. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    Brett wallace for gose.. omg awful move. Does this mean we are getting montero

    Reply
  93. Ian_Smell

    15 years ago

    Hopefully this will shut up the AA fanboys.

    Reply
    • CosaOne

      15 years ago

      That wont ever happen. They are convinced that he will be getting every teams best prospects or young cost controlled players in exchange for soon to be free agent reliever(albeit a good one) or guys having career years. That Escobar trade has made these people think hes some sort of evil genius or wizard

      Reply
      • Ian_Smell

        15 years ago

        Sadly you’re right, but I’m glad that someone is just as annoyed with them as I am.

        Reply
  94. Ian_Smell

    15 years ago

    Hopefully this will shut up the AA fanboys.

    Reply
  95. JPB705

    15 years ago

    A lot of you on here on a smaller amount of you on here an apology. They called Wallace before it happened and were laughed at.

    Reply
  96. JPB705

    15 years ago

    A lot of you on here on a smaller amount of you on here an apology. They called Wallace before it happened and were laughed at.

    Reply
  97. Ferrariman

    15 years ago

    so they traded oswalt for Wallace and Happ….not bad.

    Reply
    • Astrosfan9145

      15 years ago

      Dont forget Jonathan Villar. Who is still a couple years away from the big leagues.

      Reply
  98. Ferrariman

    15 years ago

    so they traded oswalt for Wallace and Happ….not bad.

    Reply
  99. kornut11

    15 years ago

    Bravo Easy Eddie, bravo.

    Reply
  100. kornut11

    15 years ago

    Bravo Easy Eddie, bravo.

    Reply
  101. renegade

    15 years ago

    why would AA flip Taylor for Wallace if all he wanted was an outfielder? This move makes zero sense.

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Not to mention Taylor is in AAA while Gose is in A+.

      Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Not to mention Taylor is in AAA while Gose is in A+.

      Reply
    • nepp

      15 years ago

      Things change in 8 months? Who knows. Maybe they’re less impressed by Wallace than everyone here. His bat is good, not great for a 1B/DH.

      Reply
      • Sniderlover

        15 years ago

        He is hitting .300+, .350+ OBP with 15+ HR and 61 RBI. That’s a pretty good bat if you ask me.

        Reply
        • explodet

          15 years ago

          Pretty average bat for a first baseman. Adam LaRoche could give you that. A lot of Wallace’s value as a prospect is tied to whether he can stick at 3rd.

          Reply
          • Sniderlover

            15 years ago

            He could be a 30 HR/100 RBI with .300 batting avg. That’s average? While I do agree he has more value as 3rd but he still has good value at 1st.

            Reply
            • adlenon

              15 years ago

              Maybe not in all of baseball, but that just might be below average in the NL Central which is loaded with first baseman. Albert Pujols, Joey Votto, and Prince Fielder. That puts 3 guys in front of him, and therefore below average in his division, even if he could put up those numbers.

              Reply
            • explodet

              15 years ago

              Wallace is hitting .301/.359/.509 right now in the ridiculous hitting environment of Las Vegas. Last year the average first baseman hit .277/.363/.483 and this year they’re hitting .271/.356/.462. Even if you assume he hits EXACTLY as well in the majors (unrealistic given his track record and scouting reports in regards to his power), it’s a better than average bat, but not MUCH better.

              Reply
  102. renegade

    15 years ago

    why would AA flip Taylor for Wallace if all he wanted was an outfielder? This move makes zero sense.

    Reply
  103. chucktb

    15 years ago

    Wow!!! What a great trade for the Astros. That’s not something you can say very often either! It’s going to keep Lee in LF next year rather than moving to 1B but Wallace has got to have a lot of value to the Astros.

    Reply
  104. chucktb

    15 years ago

    Wow!!! What a great trade for the Astros. That’s not something you can say very often either! It’s going to keep Lee in LF next year rather than moving to 1B but Wallace has got to have a lot of value to the Astros.

    Reply
  105. Ferrariman

    15 years ago

    Wallace is gonna absolutely rake at minutemade park.

    man..its gonna feel weird when he plays the cardinals.

    Reply
  106. Ferrariman

    15 years ago

    Wallace is gonna absolutely rake at minutemade park.

    man..its gonna feel weird when he plays the cardinals.

    Reply
  107. Brandon E.M. Savage

    15 years ago

    There is no way there is any deal that’s Gose for Wallace straight up. Unless Wallace just lost an arm in a chainsaw accident…

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      like i said only way it could happen if AA lost his brain and JP took over as intern

      Reply
  108. Brandon E.M. Savage

    15 years ago

    There is no way there is any deal that’s Gose for Wallace straight up. Unless Wallace just lost an arm in a chainsaw accident…

    Reply
  109. renegade

    15 years ago

    Seriously, given AA’s track record so far this move makes zero sense whatsoever.

    Reply
  110. Will

    15 years ago

    I am shocked…

    Reply
  111. Will

    15 years ago

    I am shocked…

    Reply
  112. IndyNate

    15 years ago

    Wow, really surprised it’s Wallace. As a Cards fan, I just want to see him finally play in the majors so we can see how good he really is. Sad to see him continually traded. Surprised they didn’t keep him for next year though.

    Reply
  113. IndyNate

    15 years ago

    Wow, really surprised it’s Wallace. As a Cards fan, I just want to see him finally play in the majors so we can see how good he really is. Sad to see him continually traded. Surprised they didn’t keep him for next year though.

    Reply
  114. philliesfan27

    15 years ago

    is AA dropping acid?

    Reply
  115. philliesfan27

    15 years ago

    is AA dropping acid?

    Reply
  116. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    i bet it’s wallace for gose + Jason Castro-C

    DREAM ON

    Reply
  117. Joshua

    15 years ago

    Well, the Fan590 must be happy. This might be the most popular interview they’ve ever had in 10 minutes. Everyone is going to tune in to see what the hell is going on.

    Reply
  118. Joshua

    15 years ago

    Well, the Fan590 must be happy. This might be the most popular interview they’ve ever had in 10 minutes. Everyone is going to tune in to see what the hell is going on.

    Reply
  119. Will

    15 years ago

    I feel like our tiwtter and messagboard are going to explode with angry Jays fans any second now.

    Reply
  120. Will

    15 years ago

    I feel like our tiwtter and messagboard are going to explode with angry Jays fans any second now.

    Reply
  121. davengmusic

    15 years ago

    sets up a berkman trade?

    Reply
    • booyahtastic

      15 years ago

      That is exactly what i was thinking. My guess is the ChiSox since the Dunn talks dont seem to be going anywhere

      Reply
  122. davengmusic

    15 years ago

    sets up a berkman trade?

    Reply
  123. HerbertAnchovy

    15 years ago

    This is insane. Who is the 1b of the future now?!

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      Lind? or Arencibia.

      Reply
      • HerbertAnchovy

        15 years ago

        Possibly, but it’s still a horrendous trade. I hope something is missing here. Good call on Lind, I forgot that they tried him out a while back.

        Reply
        • Sniderlover

          15 years ago

          Very horrendous trade. If it really is straight up… then I would have just lost all my faith in AA. Up until now, I trusted him well because he has made very good moves but this would just be dumb straight up.

          There has to be more pieces involved which may explain why it’s not official yet.

          Reply
          • HerbertAnchovy

            15 years ago

            I still have trust in AA, for now. He’s done so much good in his short tenure, but hopefully he does something smart soon to redeem our trust (the fans) in him.

            Reply
  124. HerbertAnchovy

    15 years ago

    This is insane. Who is the 1b of the future now?!

    Reply
  125. Guest

    15 years ago

    This is unbelievable. 30 minutes ago the entire city of Houston was ready to march on MMP, and then they spin Gose around for Wallace. Unbelievable

    I take back the previous comments I made about the Roy Oswalt deal. Well played Ed Wade, well played

    Reply
  126. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    AA smoking some good sht i seriously wanna join the pot party

    Reply
  127. LarryZ

    15 years ago

    AA smoking some good sht i seriously wanna join the pot party

    Reply
  128. Table

    15 years ago

    WTF. This is a horrible trade, Wallace is a far better prospect than Gose. Or at least a far more sure thing. Wallace is a 23 year old 1st baseman that is ready for the bigs. Gose is 19 in the low minors, is said to have good d, but has not shown anything else as of yet.

    Reply
    • Ferrariman

      15 years ago

      not true.

      he has shown he can get thrown out stealing.

      Reply
      • Mick_In_Ithaca

        15 years ago

        He’s 19 years old in advanced A ball. All the Toronto scouts love him. He covers a huge amount of ground in CF. He is raw. They had their player development guy on him many times through this season and they are certain they can develop him. He’s fast as stink. He gets on base, and will improve his strikeout ratio. The only thing he lacks is plus power, but he’s only 19.

        Reply
        • Table

          15 years ago

          He has not gotten on base yet. I know he is young so that COULD change, but he has a long way to go before you could project better than a 320 obp in the majors.

          Reply
          • jeffdg

            15 years ago

            Devon White had a 320 OBP year after year, and was the starting CF for a WS winning team.

            Reply
      • Table

        15 years ago

        +1

        Reply
  129. ClarenceGaston

    15 years ago

    AA will be on the FAN590 in 5 mins. We’ll see what he has to say!
    fan590.com/listen/

    Reply
  130. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    OMG AA ARE YOU SERIOUS??? IF YOUR WANTED AN OUTFIELDER YOU COULD HAVE KEPT MICHAEL TAYLOR

    Reply
    • Ferrariman

      15 years ago

      taylor is sucking it up right now. Just saying.

      Reply
      • Nicholas

        15 years ago

        and he can’t play CF like Gose.

        Reply
      • Kevin

        15 years ago

        Well to be fair, Taylor was playing through some injuries in May, where he had a .552 OPS. If you take out that month (assuming it was because of the injury) his OPS was .754 in April, .741 in June, and .838 in July. That is much more respectable.

        Reply
  131. ClarenceGaston

    15 years ago

    AA likes Springsteen..

    Reply
  132. bevothephenom

    15 years ago

    this is stunning…..ed wade dug his own grave and dug right back out of it in a matter of 5 hours….amazing

    Reply
  133. jeffdg

    15 years ago

    AA confirmed. Shocking. Straight up Wallace for Gose.

    Reply
  134. Jared M.

    15 years ago

    ok ok ok, the SECOND i heard wallace for gose I lost it….BUT, and I might be alone on this, initially when we acquired Wallace he was supposed to be a 3B, and we ended up converting him at the EASY position to fill of 1B/DH…a lot harder to fill a CF speedy guy where we lack in depth…a 19 year old in HiA already? That’s very, very, rare…come on 76 steals last year in A ball. He can work on the caught stealing….BUT i agree why didn’t we keep taylor? unless they feel higher on Gose?

    Reply
    • Sniderlover

      15 years ago

      No, he was acquired to become our future 1B. Everyone knew he wouldn’t stick to 3B.

      What a fail trade.

      Reply
      • Jared M.

        15 years ago

        agreed, Wallace a lot closer to MLB for sure…maybe they thought his defence was a bit of a problem? We won’t know for sure until Wallace succeeds Berkman and Gose matures and we see what he can do…

        On the bright side, a lot easier to replace a 1B/DH prospect than a CF prospect, but still. Shocking.

        Reply
        • LarryZ

          15 years ago

          wasn’t Wallace ranked in the top 20 prospects… and u trade for some unproven dude in A ball…………………….

          Reply
        • HillbillyHomeboy

          15 years ago

          Jeff Bagwell is the Stros hitting coach I am sure they could have him teach Wallace to play the position as a 3b to 1b convert himself….

          Reply
      • Mick_In_Ithaca

        15 years ago

        Wallace isn’t a very good 1st baseman either. Gose is a guy they wanted in the Halladay deal, and couldn’t get him. He projects as a leadoff batter and a top class gold glove type center fielder, and Jays don’t have anybody like that in the system. What happens now is Lind plays first (and won’t be any worse than Wallace defensively), and it means your boy Snider has a place to play everyday, which is a definite positive I’d say.

        Reply
        • Sniderlover

          15 years ago

          I am not against trading Wallace. They should traded him for someone better or better yet, give a pitcher for Gose like Alvarez since we plethora of freaking pitching but nooooo… we should trade our 2nd best prospect for a guy who can’t even crack our top 5 prospects. Yeah, smart trade.

          Reply
        • Joshua

          15 years ago

          Snider had a place to play every day anyway, and burying him at DH is a horrible idea. You don’t DH a 22 year old unless his defensive abilities are at Lind levels (and even that was a bad idea). Either way, right now Anthony Gose looks like DeWayne Wise. A guy who can run, field and can’t hit a lick. I’m sure they expect that to improve, but there’s been no evidence of it so far.

          Reply
          • Sniderlover

            15 years ago

            I think Lewis may DH now. He’s not really great in the outfield anyways and it would be pointless to put Snider at DH.

            Reply
  135. Kory

    15 years ago

    I just can’t believe this….AA just got knocked down several pegs…..this is a JP trade….I’m stunned.
    We were supposed to compete in 2 years….unless AA makes some killer deals (which I am now worried about him doing) the Jays just took a MAJOR step backwards.
    People are saying that we have a logjam at 1st – THAT DOESN’T MEAN WE GIVE AWAY TALENT
    @#$%@#$%

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      Yep JP phoned up AA and told him about how magically awesome Gose is… and he listened i bet he was gonna gave away JPA along with Wallace

      Reply
  136. renegade

    15 years ago

    Fire AA.

    Reply
    • Jon Stark

      15 years ago

      Now that’s a gut reaction.

      Reply
    • HerbertAnchovy

      15 years ago

      Oops, I didn’t mean to “like” that. Are you for real? Because of one deal?

      Reply
  137. richmond20657

    15 years ago

    Blue Jays got hosed!

    Reply
  138. Mick_In_Ithaca

    15 years ago

    AA wanted Gose in the Halladay deal. Phillies wouldn’t let him go. They’ve been on him massively for 2 years. All the scouts saw him extensively, and they had consensus on him as a guy they wanted. Evidently more than Wallace. Now Lind plays first, and maybe they’re on Montero as DH. I’m willing to trust this GM and his huge team of scouts.

    Reply
    • Jared M.

      15 years ago

      Exactly. The entire Phillies scouting department and the all new gigantic Jays scouting system lose their mind about this guy…

      Reply
      • jeffdg

        15 years ago

        Something that i think has been overlooked: After listening to AA on the Fan today, clearly he offered Wallace to the Phillies for Gose and the Phillies have declined. Sure it isn’t a positional need for the Phillies, but if the talent weren’t close to equal, the Phillies would have made a trade just to acquire value.

        Reply
    • moonraker45

      15 years ago

      but the jays went back after wallace, made him switch positions to groom him for the start of next season. Fine they wanted gose badly, but their had to be a better way.. would it not have been easier to trade downs or buck to acquire gose? players who won’t be a part of next season regardless? You traded a 2011 starter. It makes zero sense, even if we do acquire montero, Wallace was worth a hell of a lot more

      Reply
  139. pirateswillwinin2013

    15 years ago

    Damn how many times is Brett Wallace going to get traded lol

    Reply
  140. ukJaysfan

    15 years ago

    Not that this could have been predicted, but Michael Taylor is .269/.345/.398 in AAA PCL, with only 5 HR. So the flip worked in terms of raw numbers… (Taylor for Wallace)

    Reply
    • Jared M.

      15 years ago

      yeah the flip did work out well, apparently the A’s aren’t as thrilled with Taylor as they initially thought

      Reply
    • Kevin

      15 years ago

      Taylor’s overall numbers look terrible because of a miserable May (.204/.237/.315), but he was playing through an injury at the time. If you take out that month his stats don’t look nearly as bad.

      Reply
  141. Chris

    15 years ago

    Brett Wallace must be like “again”

    Drafted by St. Louis
    Traded Oakland in Holliday trade
    Traded 4 team to Toronto in Halladay
    trade
    Now traded to Houston in a minor league trade
    4th team before reaching the majors lol

    Reply
    • sacu

      15 years ago

      Wallace was never traded for Halladay. From Oakland he went to Toronto for Michael Taylor, straight up.

      Reply
  142. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    WOW…… I’m lost

    Reply
  143. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    Bigger trade only thing i can think of… Montero???

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      better be Montero.. or else or else

      Reply
      • adameb

        15 years ago

        In his phone interview AA didn’t seem to suggest there was any other shoe about to drop as a result. He even said he’d be open to signing Overbay again.

        Reply
        • blurnandez

          15 years ago

          OF COURSE he said that. He’s a crafty dude, and is no way going to show all of his cards.

          Reply
          • Jared M.

            15 years ago

            exactly man. especially because it’s AA and that’s his policy…listen to how vague he was about Bautista too.

            Reply
      • Jared M.

        15 years ago

        indeed, rumour that the Yanks are willing to pay premium prospects for something they need (i.e. lefty bullpen help…Downs), they wouldn’t pay premium prospects for Dunn since he was more of a luxury…should be interesting to see.

        Reply
    • moonraker45

      15 years ago

      right i thought of that too, but then i thought to myself.. even if your about to acquire montero who would move wallace down a tick on the 1b/dh depth list.. wouldn’t you try to get more for Wallace then a glorified track runner? Or trade lind and keep wallace and montero?? i can’t wrap my head around this deal whatsoever

      Reply
  144. mozelpuffski

    15 years ago

    if we get gose in the doc trade then we don’t flip him for taylor – this is the player the jays wanted and could not get. all it took was two thirds of a season for the cookie to fall in place. not bad AA not bad at all – btw Lind has been practicing now all year for 1b and apparently feeling good there. lind can and will hit 25+ hr till he is done with baseball. cant have a young guy stuck at dh…

    Reply
  145. mozelpuffski

    15 years ago

    right on AA we get the player we wanted in the end of it all. phillies would not give us gose but after a couple of flips he ends up right where he belongs. lansing lugnuts here he comes

    Reply
  146. mozelpuffski

    15 years ago

    btw wallace is suppose to be a power hitter, he is being outhit from arencibia in a hitters ball park.

    Reply
    • moonraker45

      15 years ago

      Arencibia is outhitting everyone, wallace has displayed more the adequate power. your post makes no sense

      Reply
  147. averykelly

    15 years ago

    wow , initially , i was upset w/ what we got from oswalt and missing out on singleton , but this is much better .
    blue jays , i like your team , but your GM must be an idiot , like mine , ed wade .

    Reply
  148. SpecialEd

    15 years ago

    I think this is the first time as a Jays fan thinking about GM AA where I’m thinking.. WTF ARE YOU DOING!!?!?!?!!

    I’m not against trading Wallace. he plays a position in 1B that can be played by someone else. the Jays could just as easily put Adam Lind at 1B going into the future and use someone else at DH. the loss of Wallace isn’t what bothers me. what bothers me is that all they got was this Goose.
    what makes Goose so special? he is in AA right now with these numbers..
    .263/.325/.385/.710/
    this is his best season yet, as his previous 2 seasons he had..
    .259/.323/.353/.676
    .256/.293/.359/.652
    he must have A LOT of speed. this season he has 36 SB but 27 CS. last season he had 76 SB with 20 CS.

    Wallace is MUCH better prospect than Goose.
    this is what Wallace is doing this season- .301/.359/.509/.868/ 18 HR/ 61 RBI.

    the Jays could have gotten Goose AND ANOTHER similar level prospect for Wallace.
    the Jays could really regret this trade. Goose could end up being a Joey Gathright type player.

    I admit I don’t know anything about Goose other than what stats I’m looking at, but I don’t see some cant miss prospect like Wallace who is going to be a hitting machine in the majors.

    this is F’n ridiculous!!

    Reply
    • briantalletsmoustache

      15 years ago

      The Jays got Gose AND a player named Goose? And the Jays’ return gets bigger . . .

      Reply
      • LarryZ

        15 years ago

        after doing some random reading apparently gose is drafted as a pitcher than can throw 97 but he wanted to play position.so now it’s not that bad of trade if you think about it wish AA gets like 1 more prospect out of it.

        Reply
    • Jared M.

      15 years ago

      Gose has a lot of speed, but also you have to get on base in order TO steal…so you can’t just look at the average…look at the walks. The kid is four years younger than Wallace man! and walked more than Wallace this year in less games…sounds like the kind of future top of the order player I want on my team thanks.

      that being said, I do agree that giving up Wallace is a tough pill to swallow, considering our other options. But, time will tell.

      Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      That’s why they have scouts actually watch the player. You can know nothing about a 19 by looking at minor league stats, or at least not enough to judge this deal. Wallace is by no means a “can’t miss” prospect; he’ll probably be a good hitter, mostly doubles, medium power, decent OPS — much like Overbay — but below average defensively — unlike Overbay.

      Reply
    • adameb

      15 years ago

      I’m betting he ends up more like Taveras, a except with a way lower steal %. At least by the time he flames out of the league, AA will have moved on.

      Reply
  149. P.J. Lowry

    15 years ago

    As much as I am sad to see Wallace go, it looks like AA wanted Gose for his glove. Wells isn’t going to be gold in center forever, and that is a harder position to find gold for than 1B which is usually a position anyone can play.

    No one will be complaining when Gose is diving for balls other fielders wouldn’t even get close to. I can see why this is a good deal, for both parties.

    Reply
    • vick_jaswal

      15 years ago

      noooo mann
      jays lost this trade big timee
      brett walace is a middle of the lineup type of guy who was going to be ready next year unlike gose
      and plus jays have needed a first baseman for soo long
      worst trade sice the micheal young trade
      AA is a moron

      Reply
      • Mick_In_Ithaca

        15 years ago

        Wallace is Overbay with a higher average, slightly more power, lower OBP, and poorer defense. He’s not the answer in the AL East. Whereas, Lind at 1st could be the answer.

        Reply
        • vick_jaswal

          15 years ago

          we’ll that’s where I disagree I think wallace is a better version of morales(of the angels) and he was ready to play nest year
          and plus this gose kid all he has is speed, yea he is young but wallace is a highly toughted prospect than gosee
          this is a horriable trade for the jays

          Reply
          • Jon Stark

            15 years ago

            Clearly it would not have been just AA evaluating this kids skill set. Obviously a whole host of people decided that they liked the bag that this kid was bringing, a bag that will certainly involve more than just speed.

            Reply
    • jeffdg

      15 years ago

      Wells looks worse and worse every month. He doesnt get to many of the balls he used to, especially those in front of him..

      Reply
  150. damnitsderek

    15 years ago

    AA must be drinking on the job. Gose for Wallace?

    This is a mind-numbingly idiotic trade.

    Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      You don’t know the player. Gose has way more upside than Wallace. They obviously have a plan for Lind at first base, and no doubt other trades are coming. This opens the DH slot either for a variety of players (keeps Lewis, Lind, Snider, Wells, Bautista in the lineup everyday) or for somebody they’re about to acquire (Montero?).

      Reply
      • damnitsderek

        15 years ago

        I know about Gose. I also know about Wallace. While Wallace is a question mark defensively, there is no doubt about his bat. Toronto has no other significant power prospects in the upper minors and are ready to unload Overbay. Basically, it was a perfect set-up to get Wallace into their lineup.Also, don’t forget that they got Wallace in exchange for Taylor, another player who should be considered superior to Gose. So essentially, what Toronto has done is turn Taylor into Wallace into Gose. Gose has his share of upside, but it’s all projection and he isn’t nearly ready to help the club.I just don’t like the trade. Toronto has the potential to compete within the next year, they only need to add a few more pieces. Taking Wallace out of the equation just adds to their shopping list.

        Reply
    • moonraker45

      15 years ago

      i cant wrap my head around it either. I’m guessing this means jays will be acquiring montero to play 1b of the future.. but basically he traded michael taylor for brett wallace for anthony gose? make zero sense whatsoever. Especially when the jays have wanted and tracked brett wallace for so long. i just dont get it.

      Reply
      • damnitsderek

        15 years ago

        As much as I’d love to see the Yankees trade Montero, I can’t possibly imagine that Cashman would deal one of the best prospects in the game within the division. If Montero really develops into the hitter that scouts believe he will, it’s a decision the Yankees would regret for at least half a decade.

        Reply
  151. Chad Brown

    15 years ago

    Vernon Wells is on the jays forever basically. This move shows me AA has no intention of competing anytime soon. Throwing the “this isn’t a re-build, it’s a build” out the window.

    I still don’t understand this move. I think it’s easy to say that Overbay has overstayed his welcome in Toronto. If Overbay is re-signed I will cry for a week straight.

    You gotta feel bad for Wallace too, AA probably promised him a future with Toronto. After being traded so many times, he’s got to be doubting his skills by now.

    Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      Wallace is Overbay without defense. If you were counting on Cabrera or Tex, you don’t know the player. He’ll hit well (as Overbay has) but he’s not going to be a superstar. Snider will be a MUCH better hitter. Lind is and will continue to be a MUCH better hitter. And if they get Montero, he will be a MUCH better hitter, at DH, and if it’s him, he’ll be in the lineup this season.

      Reply
      • HerbertAnchovy

        15 years ago

        I would agree that Wallace isn’t a huge power threat, he had hit 18 home runs in very hitter-friendly Cashman Field.

        Reply
    • HerbertAnchovy

      15 years ago

      I don’t like the trade, but Arencibia or Lind can play 1b. Overbay won’t be re-signed, and I doubt Wallace really cares where he plays. To say that AA has no intention of competing because of one trade is stupid.

      Reply
    • jeffdg

      15 years ago

      Wells for Zambrano?

      Reply
  152. SpecialEd

    15 years ago

    I saw someone else say Goose with 2 o’s and just assumed that was his name, but I see it’s Gose with 1 o.

    still don’t like it.

    Gose looks to have a high ceiling, but I would also say he is a big risk. high risk/high reward.
    while he may walk, it doesn’t look like he is hitting all that much. evne with the walks his OBP..
    10- .325
    09- .323
    08- .293

    I also think the Jays could have gotten more along with Gose.

    I do think Wallace is a cant miss prospect. IMO in the majors he is 300+ AVG with 25+ HR power and he would be ready to produce that next season.

    Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      Translating Wallace’s numbers from PCL as if they aren’t inflated isn’t going to work. He might hit 280-300, but with few walks and a ton of Ks. He’ll hit plenty of doubles and perhaps 20-25 HRs. His defense is suspect.

      Lind is going to hit 20-25 HRs in a bad year. He needs to play 1st. The kid, according to AA and scouting staff, will be a gold glove CF in 2-3 years, at which time he’ll be 22. He’ll get on base, hit 300, hit a ton of doubles AND triples (he has 11 this year), steal bases and catch everything anywhere near him. And he’ll be there for 6 years after that, or longer.

      You probably hated the Escobar trade too.

      Reply
      • LarryZ

        15 years ago

        but prospects are prospects Gose might bust consider he has 2 more levels to go while Wallace is ready for majors i think. But according to AA on FAN590 he said top CF, C and SS prospects are hard to find and almost always unavailable.

        Reply
      • moonraker45

        15 years ago

        Everything you said makes sense. .. but one big hole comes to mind.. why trade for wallace in the first place? wasn’t like he suddenly stopped getting walks or striking out. He put up numbers that most expected.. So why trade for wallace if you didn’t think he was a legitimate starter for years to come. Especially when the player in question, although this year has not performed, was a highly touted prospect in a position that you sorely lack. makes no sense

        Reply
        • Jon Stark

          15 years ago

          Because obviously they liked the skillset they saw in Wallace better than they saw in Taylor. Taylor was never projected to play CF. They flipped prospects for what they thought was the better of the two. Now they are flipping for what AA sees is a bigger need (a future CF that can run down balls…which VW is having a hard time doing). In trades, you can only ever take the best that is available to you at the moment.

          Reply
          • Jared M.

            15 years ago

            bang on stark.

            Reply
            • moonraker45

              15 years ago

              i’ve seen your posts. coming from you, that means nothing

              Reply
          • moonraker45

            15 years ago

            You’re right i won’t argue. but if the goal is to replace Vernon here, which as i agree defensively needs to be done sooner rather then later. Letting Wallace play for a year and then flipping him probably would have increased his value. Gose is still so raw that you could have drafted a player who was close to his development stage at this point. they could have drafted an heir to cf, no need to go and trade for one for anything less then excess depth, which at this point wallace was not

            Reply
        • nother

          15 years ago

          Because a GM would have to be brain damaged to try to please the fanbase with minor-league trades.

          Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      ppl are saying wallace should light up PCL but he is not compare him to JPA. JPA > X2000 than wallace’s number lol. if Wallace was putting up big # like JPA than management might hold on to him, also heard his defense is junk.

      Reply
    • mkl_nyn

      15 years ago

      Well said. Personally, I didn’t like the trade either, but a 19 year old already in High A ball with a higher ceiling at a premium position is something that a team like the Jays need in their system. They will never be able to lure an All Star CF through free agency, but 1st basemen/DH types are a dime a dozen. Toronto has been spoiled with players like Wells patrolling CF for years (Beltran and Soriano signed to simliar deals within those few years… who would you rather have now.) One of those wait and see trades. Relax folks.

      Reply
  153. Triteon

    15 years ago

    Remember when Brett Wallace was “too much” for the Cards to give up for Matt Holliday? Wallace has now been traded 3 times in the last 12 months.

    Reply
  154. moonraker45

    15 years ago

    WHY DIDNT WE JUST KEEP JOEY GATHRIGHT!?? AHH AA everyone is allowed mistakes but trading wallace… really?

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      cuz Joey failed? and he is old?

      Reply
      • moonraker45

        15 years ago

        because at this point Gose has only shown himself to be a track and field star not a baseball player. . a minor leaguer with a career obp of .323 is not someone you trade a player ready to play everyday and be an impact bat.. I don’t mind the acquisition i don’t think we got fair return

        Reply
        • LarryZ

          15 years ago

          cuz he just started hitting 2 years ago? maybe that is why

          Reply
          • moonraker45

            15 years ago

            exactly. so at this point you don’t know what you are going to get from him. He could be a ellsbury or crawford type, or just an expendable pinch runner type. . Do you trade a player who is a lock to be a fulltime 1b? i’m not saying don’t go and get gose, i’m saying at this point Wallace > Gose.

            Reply
    • Jon Stark

      15 years ago

      because Gose has a much higher ceiling than Joey Gathright. (emphatic period).

      Reply
      • moonraker45

        15 years ago

        At this point, many people know what to expect from wallace. Where as gose could be a carl crawford or a joey gathright.. you traded a small IF for a huge IF straight up, makes no sense to me. Wallace could have gotten so much more, or been a part of a package that brought back a player much better then gose. and more mlb ready.

        Reply
  155. nico

    15 years ago

    As much as this appears to be a terrible trade for the Jays, I’m going to have to trust AA on this one. Every move he has made has been money so far, why not let this one play out alittle bit before we all act like he traded away the franchise.

    Reply
  156. Liban Yousef

    15 years ago

    I trust AA with all the scout we have he did his research so come down people. i was angry tooo but i came back to earth. Gose potential higher than wallace from what AA was saying. WE DON’T NEED AVERAGE PLAYERS how the hell are we gonna compete with average players

    Reply
    • Chad Brown

      15 years ago

      By being in any other AL Division.

      Reply
    • vick_jaswal

      15 years ago

      AVERAGEE? i would say he was above average with high potential and BASEBALL AMERICA ranked him no.17 ahead of drabek
      and if u think wallace was going to be averge so why dont we trade OVERBAY, WELLS, ESCOBAR, HILL, LIND, BUCK, MORROW, LEWIS, DOWNS, GREGG, FRASOR, JANSEEN, CAMP and whoever is left

      Reply
      • Jon Stark

        15 years ago

        pretty sure most people would consider Escobar, Hill, Lind, and Downs as above average. Wells was an all-star this year and Morrow clearly has front of the rotation material.

        Reply
        • vick_jaswal

          15 years ago

          yea and wallace had the potential to be better than all those names above MAYBE and that is MAYBE except morrowand wallace was ready next year and his power was just comming into its own as a 21 year old with 18 home runsthis GOSE kid can run and maybe he has alot of potential YESSS that would be right but that is a huge risk on a for sure thing

          Reply
          • Jon Stark

            15 years ago

            disagree. poor seasons aside, I’m pretty sure that any team, and I mean any, would gladly trade Wallace for Hill. Anyday. Hell, I will go as far as to say that 95% of teams would take Lind instead of Wallace as well.

            Reply
          • Jon Stark

            15 years ago

            oh, and Brett Wallace is turning 24 this August. He’s not 21.

            Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      Yea to compete in AL East u need Allstars players not avg players, gamble is a must to be competitivein AL EAST since yanks and sox just buy players.

      Reply
  157. ButWhatDoesMineSay

    15 years ago

    what’s with all this montero chat earlier in the thread? anything more than just rumours? seems quite farfetched to me.

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      Down + stuff for Montero plz ^^

      i like to dream?

      Reply
    • Joshua

      15 years ago

      It was merely people trying to think of a way that this was actually real. That way was that the Jays were getting Montero in some other deal

      Reply
  158. SpecialEd

    15 years ago

    I loved the Escobar trade. Escobar is going to contribute right away.
    how far away is 19 year old Gose? in AA right now and not exactly tearing it up, 3 to 4 years at least?
    Wallace could have been an impact next season. I could understand if the Jays were nowhere near contending right now and your building the team to contend in 3+ years, but they could contend even next season.
    the Jays were set with a majority of their team going into next season. OF of Lewis/Wells/Snider with Lind at DH and Wallace at 1B.
    the Jays now have to replace what Wallace could have contributed with next season in order to contend.
    both Overbay and Bautista should go this season and should not be counted on for 2011.
    even if you can move Lind to 1B you still then have a hole at DH, which is going to likely have to be filled by signing for or trading for someone else who is more likely going to cost a lot more than what Wallace would have cost.
    I really hope the Jays are not counting on returning with either Overbay or Bautista.

    Reply
    • Jon Stark

      15 years ago

      Why not Jose Bautista? You don’t like high OBP, great personality, HR power, and outfield assist?

      Reply
      • SpecialEd

        15 years ago

        Bautista is having a fluke season. he has been a bench player for years and prior to this season his career high in HR was 16. he has almost doubled his career high. I don’t think he all of a sudden found power at 29 years old(30 in October).
        factor in that and that Bautista is arbitration eligible after the season he is going to be getting a significant raise through arbitration. next season Bautista is going to be overpriced and when he comes back down to his normal type numbers he is going to be really overpriced. his value is never going to be higher than it is right now and the Jays should cash in on that to get a prospect while they can.

        Reply
        • TheodoreRoosevelt

          15 years ago

          Why are you so convinced that it is a fluke season as opposed to a late blossoming from a man who, as you said in your post, never really had a crack at being a regular?

          The cannon arm is legitimate. The laser-aim is legitimate. The versatility is legitimate. The power is legitimate. Maybe he won’t hit 30+ home runs next season, but do you really think he’ll sink below 20 – 25? Anybody who has been watching the Jays for the past year would not bet a cent ont hat.

          Reply
        • Mick_In_Ithaca

          15 years ago

          Again, you don’t know the player. Or you listen to Keith Law, who also doesn’t know the player very well. Bautista has made 2 significant changes to his swing since getting sizable playing time last August: Murphy and Gaston have taught him to load up slightly earlier, and you can see it if you look at plate appearances from early last season, or even now when he isn’t going good; also, he’s aiming to hit the bottom half of the ball, thus putting it into the air more often than not, particularly against right-handers, against whom he was heretofore unsuccessful. Those two changes have lead to more deep fly balls, and thus HRs. He leads the majors in “barely over the fence” homers, but also in “no doubt about it” homers, so I think he will continue to hit for decent power for the next few years.

          As for the price, I have no doubt that AA, if he doesn’t trade Bautista, will sign him to a team friendly contract, and Bautista has said he’d like to stay with the Jays. He’s a good player, with versatility, several offensive pluses, and I hope he stays.

          I watch every Blue Jays game, and have done for the past several years. Bautista is an impressive and useful player, and his hitting is far from a fluke. They have hitting coaches for a reason; unfortunately, not every player can learn something.

          Reply
        • johnsmith4

          15 years ago

          Bautista is on pace to clear well over 40 HRs….plus he has hit 40 HRs in the past 365 days…

          Other players did not hit 40+ HRs until their 30s…Willie Stargell at age 31 hit over 40 HRs (48) and was the HR leader for the first time in his career at age 31 in 1971…same happened for Frank Howard (44 HRs) three years earlier…they both went on to hit 40+ HRs after their “fluke” year.

          Reply
        • paorta2

          15 years ago

          “I don’t think he all of a sudden found power at 29 years old.”

          I hate it when people say this. He did, somehow. He’s not flying the baseball over the wall with kites.

          Reply
    • eviola1

      15 years ago

      Try A+

      Reply
  159. SpecialEd

    15 years ago

    Jays writer MLBastian on twitter..
    “ays tried to get Gose from the Phillies but talks broke down a few days ago and Anthopoulos began working with the Astros.”
    “The Astros asked for Wallace. “We tried to find ways to make this trade without including Brett Wallace,” Anthopoulos said.”

    because the Jays GM had such a hard on for Gose he stupidly was willing to give up Wallace.

    Reply
    • vick_jaswal

      15 years ago

      I think AA had a thumb stuck up his ass and apperently GOSE was the only one that could help him with that
      worst trade since micheal young trade

      Reply
      • TheodoreRoosevelt

        15 years ago

        What are you basing this on?

        Reply
        • vick_jaswal

          15 years ago

          hmm lets seee shall we
          wallace (even though you might not think that much of him) was suppose to be the 1st baseman of the future who was ready next year.
          I makes me soo angry is that wallace was finally becomming the player that he was though to be when he got drafted in the first round
          I mean the power was comming along so nicely and the average was there as well
          i mean its just a horriable trade as it looks right now

          Reply
          • TheodoreRoosevelt

            15 years ago

            A few years ago Overbay was brought in to be the 1B of the future. He’s done pretty well over that time, but not blown anyone away. I honestly don’t think we’re losing out on much more than that with Wallace.

            If we were trading out a young Carlos Delgado or a Jesus Montero, then I’d understand the anger. We’d be throwing away generational bats. But instead, we are upgrading at CF, Lind can slot in at 1B creating space for a legit power bat at DH, or we could go out and get a Montero-type at 1B perhaps…

            Reply
            • johnsmith4

              15 years ago

              I wouldn’t downplay Wallace….he has hit well in AAA at ages 22 and 23…..which is significant…Also of significance….Philly thought Gose was more valuable than Taylor…in fact….they did not want to trade Gose for Halladay.

              Reply
              • TheodoreRoosevelt

                15 years ago

                I don’t mean to downplay Wallace. The guy will be a regular 1B in MLB, and that achievement speaks for itself.

                The point I’m trying to make is that there are the Vottos, Pujols, Delgados, and Teixeiras of this world…then there are the Overbays and Wallaces…and then there are the third-raters. He is not irreplaceable.

                To be honest, I’d have been far more annoyed if we’d traded Bautista instead of Wallace.

                Reply
                • johnsmith4

                  15 years ago

                  Got your point…Big difference between Wallace and Votto

                  By the way….who is Teixeira?….Is that Italian or Portugueese?

                  Reply
                • vick_jaswal

                  15 years ago

                  i guess time will tell who won this trade but there are going to be alot of angry jays fans including me if wallace has a 25 homer season with 280 average or above next year with the astros.

                  Reply
                  • TheodoreRoosevelt

                    15 years ago

                    Yep, time is everything.

                    That said, considering it will be anyone *but* Overbay at 1B next season, I can’t see a serviceable MLB 1B’s statistics being too far off the ones you mention. Certainly not enough to matter a great deal.

                    It’s all about how Gose turns out, and that will take time.

                    Reply
                • jeffdg

                  15 years ago

                  And Votto’s, Pujols, Delgado’s and Teixeiras are readily available some place?

                  Reply
                  • TheodoreRoosevelt

                    15 years ago

                    No, of course not. That’s my point: the Jays know that it’s a lot easier to get somebody the equivalent of Wallace at 1B than it is to get players with elite ceilings/talent like Gose and Escobar, which is why they take the opportunities when they arise.

                    Reply
                • moonraker45

                  15 years ago

                  Teddy, heres the issue i have with your post. You’re naming allstar first baseman and comparing them to what a star minor leaguer may or may not become. Basically insinuating that at this point Wallace is fully developed and has no room to grow and become a all star, similar to votto or tex.. Lets play a game shall we.. The following are the AAA stats of Wallace, Overbay, Fielder, and Votto.. keep in mind that Wallace’s stats are still growing…1/.294/.381/.478 ops.859 22 hr2..301/.359/.509 ops.868 18 hr3..291/.388/.569 ops.957 28 hr 4..343/.396/.528 ops.923 19 hrBesides the 3rd one which is leap and bounds more powerful (fielder) the rest are pretty comparable.. Yet you clearly suggest, Wallace will be nothing more then a lyle overbay, never a joey votto. 1.Votto2.Wallace3.Fielder4.OverbayYet Votto had worse AAA stats then Wallace, and substantially worse stats then overbay, yet he has grown in to a player you list among pujols, tex and fielder..So for you to suggest that his limit is a lyle overbay is completely inaccurate, because the very same could have been said for Joey Votto who has grown to be an elite 1b..

                  Reply
                  • TheodoreRoosevelt

                    15 years ago

                    You only need to look at Jose Bautista to see how a player can defy their career statistics and projections, whether in the majors or the minors.

                    So I do not dispute that it is possible for Wallace to exceed expectations, but like the vast majority of prospects, it is highly unlikely. What do you think a snap poll of users would think about the chances of Wallace becoming an elite 1B tell us?

                    I’m not beating up on the guy. I’m sure he’ll have a long, fine career. And it would have been cool to see him in the Jays uniform, to see how he would have done. But I don’t think we’ll be taking a significant decline if Lind (or a trade/FA) plays there, and the long-term talent ceiling of this team continues to increase.

                    Reply
            • vick_jaswal

              15 years ago

              first of all i dont think the yanks are going to give up a MONTERO type of a guy for a 2 month rental even if they get 2 high draft picks and if that happens it would be a major steal for the jays
              but back to the wallace trade i understant what u are trying to say but wallace is much different than overbay… i mean he is much bigger and stronger in size therefore there is more potential for power especially that he is only 21 just like J.P. Arencibia (sometimes it just takes time)
              and what i just dont like is who they got. this GOSE guy hasnt been doing much either and has no power potential

              Reply
            • R_y_a_n

              15 years ago

              Wallace hasn’t been compared to Overbay in anyway, just because they were both pronounced the “1B of the future” doesn’t make them alike. Wallace projects to be a middle of the order bat…Overbay always projected to be an average-above average 1B.

              Reply
              • TheodoreRoosevelt

                15 years ago

                Considering that a lot of people are going ape over the trade, it’s only right to evaluate what we’re losing – and comparing him to our 1B of the last few years is fair game, especially considering that Overbay hasn’t exactly overwhelmed the fanbase.

                Ripped from Drunk Jays fans:

                “Following up in a comment on his post, Smith explains that “Wallace could be a 25 home run hitter in 2011 and [still] not be worth three wins above replacement. And the math isn’t even hard. Say he gets 600 at-bats (+20 replacement), all at first base (-12.5 position adjustment), where he is bad defensively (-5 UZR) and hits like Juan Rivera did last season (.287/.332/.478 with 25 homers), which is only +10 with the bat. We add it all up, and Wallace is only worth 1.3 WAR.”

                To compare, Lyle Overbay was worth 2.0 WAR in 2008 and 2.7 WAR in 2009.”

                There seems to be a common consensus that Brett will make a fine 1B at the major league level, but come on, some perspective is needed here. There is nothing in the statistics or current performance to suggest that we’ve traded out a truly exceptional first baseman.

                Reply
        • Mick_In_Ithaca

          15 years ago

          Nothing. Absolutely nothing. Talk about thumbs up asses.

          Reply
          • TheodoreRoosevelt

            15 years ago

            Huh?

            Reply
            • Mick_In_Ithaca

              15 years ago

              What are you (ie Vick) basing this on? I’m suggesting Vick’s answer.

              Reply
    • TheodoreRoosevelt

      15 years ago

      In fairness, he was hardly going to say “Wallace was expendable. We didn’t value him as much as Gose. So off he went.”

      Reply
  160. TheodoreRoosevelt

    15 years ago

    I’m liking this trade. A lot.

    Wallace is good, but let’s not pretend he is the next coming of Carlos Delgado. I’d be surprised if he surpassed the accomplishments of Lyle Overbay…a very decent 1B, but no more than that.

    Gose, on the other hand, could be a legitimate CF stud. And he should be developed nicely by the time that Wells is on the way out.

    We can slot Lind in at 1B or trade for a genuine high upsider like Montero, or even pick up a free agent (doubtful). Wallace was a fair sacrifice. I think this makes the long-term look stronger and better for the Jays.

    Reply
    • LarryZ

      15 years ago

      3 teams have traded Wallace that has to say something about him, since we dont have the reports the management has we can only speculate what is wrong with him.

      Reply
      • vick_jaswal

        15 years ago

        he has been traded in some big deals though as a highly thought prospect that being MATT HOLLIDAY and the halladay trade
        he is ranked no.17 as a top prospect in the country and was a big part in both those trades obove and that is until noww.
        the third time is was traded apperantly as a total steal bacause the jays GM won’t stay off the bong pipe

        Reply
        • LarryZ

          15 years ago

          that is what i was saying before AA is smoking some good stuff i want some !!!

          Reply
          • vick_jaswal

            15 years ago

            loll
            MAN i really hope this GOSE kid is as good as AA thinks he is because they defenatly gave up on a sure thing as a middle of the lineup type of guy

            Reply
        • Jon Stark

          15 years ago

          Actually, he was only an auxiliary part in the Halladay deal. I am pretty sure that Drabek was really the centerpiece of that deal.

          Reply
      • moonraker45

        15 years ago

        to the other side of that, 3 teams have scouted and acquired wallace.

        Reply
      • TheodoreRoosevelt

        15 years ago

        It may not be that there’s anything *wrong* with him, but perhaps there is nothing *special* about him, and that’s what encourages GMs to flip him for positional players with higher ceilings.

        He’s a hit-for-average 1B with a glove that doesn’t even match Overbay’s. That’s it, or am I undervaluing him? He certainly didn’t “tear it up” in the minors.

        Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      Yes, I agree. Wallace has so inflamed the desires of the Overbay haters that he’s viewed as a player far better than he actually is. He is an Overbay type, perhaps with a tad more power, but not much more. Unlike Overbay, he doesn’t get on base much. And unlike Overbay, he doesn’t play first base well.

      Overbay last year was the third best player on the team, and he’s been good this year once he got over his early slump.

      Not that I would advocate resigning him. Much rather have Lind at first, even though he’s not as good defensively. Opens up the DH for resting players, or for somebody like Montero, who isn’t much of a defensive player either, but is a very good hitter with very good power. Much better than Wallace.

      Reply
    • R_y_a_n

      15 years ago

      Sure, Gose “could” be a stud, but he hasn’t shown any real brilliance in the minors – let’s not act like Wallace has no room for growth, as he has plenty.

      Reply
  161. Sleepykarl

    15 years ago

    Why does everyone think the Blue Jays can get a 20 year old, top 5 prospect in baseball for a 35 year old RP under contract for two months? AA asking for Montero does not mean in anyway that the Yankees would give up Montero.

    (sidenote, Downs has nearly identical FIP and xFIP as Joba)/

    Reply
    • SpecialEd

      15 years ago

      Downs will be type A free agent. whatever team signs him as a free agent, the previous team Downs was with will get two 1st round draft picks.
      it’s not just Downs for whoever, it’s Downs and potential draft pick compensation.

      Reply
      • Jared M.

        15 years ago

        And the yankees are in need of bullpen help, specifically lefty bullpen help. Add the fact Downs is the best available RP right now. You can go off about FIP and xFIP, but look at the real stats of ER, BB, H/9, BB/9…no comparison.

        That being said, obviously there’s no definitive way this will net the Jays Montero.

        Reply
        • LarryZ

          15 years ago

          Joba sucks ^^ i said it

          Reply
      • LarryZ

        15 years ago

        but i doubt yankee will trade him

        Reply
      • Mick_In_Ithaca

        15 years ago

        Downs will sign a contract with whatever team he’s traded to. Or else he’ll be offered arbitration, which he would likely take since there aren’t many teams willing to give up — not two first rounders, Ed — a supplemental and another 2nd or 3rd round pick for a set-up guy.If, say, the Yankees traded for Downs, and gave up something decent, they’d likely sign him to a 2 or 3 year deal with options, and Downs would likely take it. He’d be crazy not to. Because otherwise he’d have to accept arbitration.

        Reply
    • johnsmith4

      15 years ago

      All Yankees have to do is name their price for Montero…and…AA will most likely pay it….as he has proven with Gose….he wanted Gose as part of the Halliday trade…but…Philly wouldn’t include him…so he settled for Michael Taylor…turned Michael Taylor into Brett Wallace…and…when Houston named Wallace as their price for Gose….AA paid it.So…for Montero…you can get Downs and whatever prospect you name….what is wrong with this deal?

      If you only want to offer marginal prospects for Downs….you want get much interest from AA

      Reply
      • eviola1

        15 years ago

        Halladay

        Reply
        • johnsmith4

          15 years ago

          You must be related to Wilner

          Reply
      • Sleepykarl

        15 years ago

        Downs + any Jays prospect still makes zero sense. It’s just not in the cards to move Montero to the Jays.

        Reply
    • Mick_In_Ithaca

      15 years ago

      Nobody’s saying Downs for Montero. You’re right, the Yankees wouldn’t do it. But Montero was available for Lee, right? Along with Joba, I think. So Montero’s available. Yanks want Downs. What else do they want.

      AA is pretty close to the vest as to what he’s doing, and that’s as it should be. But it has been noted by various sources that AA has been the most aggressive GM out there, going to clubs and saying: “Here’s the guy we’d like. What does it take to get him.” In the case of Gose, it was Wallace. If the Halladay deal had gone AA’s way in the first place, they’d have gotten Gose, Drabek, and D’Arnauld, and never would’ve had Wallace. There are usually good reasons why teams want the guy they want, and aggressive GMs make it happen, even if it takes a while.

      Montero? Who knows? But I’d bet that Buck and Downs get traded, if not prior to the deadline, then afterwards, and that there may be other players (minor leaguers) involved, and Jays will get solid returns. Next year’s lineup will be different, and better (including “better than it would’ve been with Wallace”).

      Reply
      • Sleepykarl

        15 years ago

        Yes, Montero was available for 2 of the top 5 pitchers in the game. The Blue Jays have nothing worth giving Montero up for outside of RR, whom I’m sure they wouldn’t move. Buck has little to no value btw.

        Reply
  162. jeffdg

    15 years ago

    Something that i think has been overlooked: After listening to AA on the Fan today, clearly he offered Wallace to the Phillies for Gose and the Phillies have declined. Sure it isn’t a positional need for the Phillies, but if the talent weren’t close to equal, the Phillies would have made a trade just to acquire value.

    Reply
  163. Adil

    15 years ago

    i would have liked to have gose without giving up wallace, but its not the end of the world. wallace would be an average firstbaseman, it isnt like he is tearing up the minors, AA believes the team is 2-3 years away, why waste wallace’s clock on those years when gose can contribute during the prime jays years.

    Reply
  164. Lanidrac

    15 years ago

    Somehow I don’t like the idea of my team’s (Cardinals) former top prospect now being the first baseman of the future for a division rival.

    Reply
    • Matt

      15 years ago

      You have Pujols. What are you worried about?

      Reply
  165. La A

    15 years ago

    Trade to the Reds for Alonso because Joey Votto is blocking him and NL has no DH

    Reply
    • ButWhatDoesMineSay

      15 years ago

      this. yonder alonso was (falsely) rumoured to be in the rolen trade last year. instead it was encarnacion, stewart and roenicke. perhaps you’re on to something here.

      Reply
      • La A

        15 years ago

        AA has a lot of options

        Reply
  166. La A

    15 years ago

    Trade to the Reds for Alonso because Joey Votto is blocking him and NL has no DH

    Reply
  167. scrapi999

    15 years ago

    So who’s gonna play first base next year, Wallace played 3b in the minors but doesnt have major league defense, so he was projected to play first base then gradually move to DH. Overbay is gone, so who is gonna play first??? Like to see Bautista stay with the jays and sign something similar to Adam Lind’s contract!

    Reply
    • jeffdg

      15 years ago

      Dunn and his brutal defence?

      Reply
    • ClarenceGaston

      15 years ago

      Adam Lind will play 1st. At this point I would say that Bautista is not deserving of a Lind type contract. The Jays might as well pay him the 7M next season and find out if he is for real befoe they hand him an extension

      Reply
  168. scrapi999

    15 years ago

    So who’s gonna play first base next year, Wallace played 3b in the minors but doesnt have major league defense, so he was projected to play first base then gradually move to DH. Overbay is gone, so who is gonna play first??? Like to see Bautista stay with the jays and sign something similar to Adam Lind’s contract!

    Reply
  169. jeffdg

    15 years ago

    If Jays are going to be active in Free Agency, seems like a team that might overpay a Carlos Pena.

    Reply
    • mhunke

      15 years ago

      Given how the Jays are making due, production-wise, without a slugging 1B like Pena, I highly doubt they will sign ANYONE to more than a one-year deal this offseason. Unless there’s nobody else available, the Jays aren’t likely to overpay any FA’s anytime soon.

      Reply
    • mhunke

      15 years ago

      Given how the Jays are making due, production-wise, without a slugging 1B like Pena, I highly doubt they will sign ANYONE to more than a one-year deal this offseason. Unless there’s nobody else available, the Jays aren’t likely to overpay any FA’s anytime soon.

      Reply
  170. TimmyFranchise

    15 years ago

    Kinda funny reading all the speculation about who got fleeced and what type of major league player these prospects project to be. Bottom line is nobody will know who won this trade or by how much for another 4 or 5 years at least.

    Reply
  171. mhunke

    15 years ago

    How easy is it, in today’s market, to find a cheap, productive veteran 1B, similar to Brett Wallace, compared to finding a cheap, productive veteran CF, similar to, say, Austin Jackson? That is what AA is thinking.

    If you’re going to fill a certain position with stopgap FA’s every year, there is no better position to do it than at 1B. For years the Jays have been doing this at and 3B and SS, but every year there is bound to be loads of Ty Wiggington, Adam LaRoche, Carlos Delgado or Russel Branyon types waiting for a bargain deal. Great move.

    Reply
    • vick_jaswal

      15 years ago

      u are talking about brett walace –the former 13th overall pick just a couple of years who is starting todaayyy
      wayy to go AA u stupid bumm

      Reply
  172. mhunke

    15 years ago

    How easy is it, in today’s market, to find a cheap, productive veteran 1B, similar to Brett Wallace, compared to finding a cheap, productive veteran CF, similar to, say, Austin Jackson? That is what AA is thinking.

    If you’re going to fill a certain position with stopgap FA’s every year, there is no better position to do it than at 1B. For years the Jays have been doing this at and 3B and SS, but every year there is bound to be loads of Ty Wiggington, Adam LaRoche, Carlos Delgado or Russel Branyon types waiting for a bargain deal. Great move.

    Reply
  173. InLeylandWeTrust

    15 years ago

    Nice haul for the Stros. What is this, Wallace’s 4th team now???

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Rockies Fire Bud Black

    Cubs Promote Cade Horton

    Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base

    Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton

    Mariners Claim Leody Taveras

    Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach

    A.J. Minter To Undergo Season-Ending Lat Surgery

    Blue Jays Sign Spencer Turnbull

    Blue Jays Sign José Ureña

    Ross Stripling Retires

    Rangers Place Leody Taveras On Outright Waivers

    Triston Casas Likely To Miss Entire 2025 Season Due To Knee Surgery

    Orioles Recall Coby Mayo

    Dodgers Recall Hyeseong Kim

    Triston Casas Suffers “Significant Knee Injury”

    Angels Place Mike Trout On 10-Day Injured List

    Rangers Option Jake Burger

    Tigers Designate Kenta Maeda For Assignment

    Reds Option Alexis Diaz

    Orioles Move Charlie Morton To Bullpen

    Recent

    Rockies Fire Bud Black

    Nationals Notes: Susana, Cavalli, Law

    Marcus Stroman Has Setback In Rehab From Knee Inflammation

    MLBTR Chat Transcript

    Latest On Blake Snell

    Cubs Sign Tommy Romero To Minor League Deal

    Orioles Activate Zach Eflin

    Jose Altuve Exits Due To Hamstring Tightness

    Rockies Select Ryan Rolison, Transfer Kris Bryant To 60-Day IL

    Giants Notes: Hicks, Encarnacion, First Base

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version