The Diamondbacks announced on Tuesday that they’ve traded outfielder Peter O’Brien, who had recently been designated for assignment, to the Royals in exchange for minor league right-hander Sam Lewis.
The 26-yer-old O’Brien has drawn his fair share of attention over the years due to his gaudy power numbers in Triple-A. In 968 plate appearances at that level — split between the Yankees and Diamondbacks — O’Brien has compiled a career .270/.315/.530 batting line. Originally acquired by the D-backs in the 2014 trade that sent Martin Prado to the Yankees, O’Brien has slugged a total of 50 home runs in parts of two seasons in Triple-A.
While O’Brien began his career as a catcher, few scouts gave him much of a chance to stay behind the plate due to defensive concerns. Many scouting reports have suggested that O’Brien lacks any real position on the defensive spectrum, and he’s struggled in his brief taste of the Major Leagues to date (.176/.228/.446 with six homers but 32 strikeouts in 79 plate appearances). Still, he’ll give the Royals a potential power bat with multiple years of club control remaining. Unlike the D-backs, the Royals can simply elect to play O’Brien at DH in the event that he does eventually see his big league production more closely mirror the work he’s put in at the Triple-A level.
Lewis, meanwhile, turned 25 this offseason and returned from a 2015 injury to log 44 1/3 innings of 1.62 ERA ball across three minor league levels. However, impressive as that number seems, it should be noted that he topped out at Class-A Advanced, so he was working against considerably younger and less experienced competition. Lewis averaged 7.9 K/9 against 1.4 BB/9 in his 2016 campaign while also posting a 47.5 percent ground-ball rate, per MLBfarm.com. Their notes on Lewis have his fastball in the upper 80s to low 90s. Lewis only totaled nine innings at High-A last season, and that was his first exposure to the level, so he could return there to open the 2017 season or be pushed to Double-A if the D-backs take a bit more aggressive approach. He’s made just nine minor league starts, so he’s likely viewed strictly as a reliever by his new organization.
crazysull
Eventual replacement for Hosmer at first?
jwood
Doesn’t get rave reviews on his defense as a catcher or OF.
jwood
Doesn’t get rave reviews on his defense as a catcher or OF .
Mike_Davis
Nope. DH or LF in a pinch. He really has no position.
SupremeZeus
Nice guy, light tower power, but he is a AAAA Player or 4K per dayer.
jwood
Doesn’t get rave reviews on his defense as a catcher or OF .
TheAdrianBeltre
So nice, had to say it thrice!
Whyamihere
What kind of reviews does he get on his defense as a catcher or OF?
pinkerton
not rave.
statmaster96
Legitimately made me lol
kmh878s
Haha same here
davidcoonce74
I’ve read somewhere that they aren’t raving about his defense.
lesterdnightfly
Raveless.
Notable for the absence of rave factor.
Ravelorn.
Bereft of rave.
As barren of rave as the bleak winter of Newfoundland is barren of bikinis.
pinkerton
that was just beautiful.
bigcubsfan
Doesn’t get rave reviews from the MLBTR reader with the username jwood on his defense at catcher or OF.
pinkerton
he doesn’t? I thought jwood was keen on giving rave reviews on his defense at catcher or OF. But on second reading, and after thinking about it over a drink and a cigarette, it does appear that indeed, the ballplayer in question that jwood is referencing does not get rave reviews on his defense at catcher or OF.
(I can’t help it. I’m bored.)
schellis 2
He does get rave reviews on the lack of defensive ability he has at SS/2B/CF.
dbacksrs
Lol
IloveMACfootball
LOL
bosox90
Sometimes I just come back to this article to chuckle at these comments. They are still here, and still chuckle-worthy
gallenofbeer
Still chuckling
El Duderino
Years later, I still look it up at times to giggle.
Solaris611
A cautionary tale for any team considering home grown NYY prospects. As with O’Brien, Aaron Judge’s name keeps coming up in trade rumors for a reason.
MB923
The only time Judges name has came up in a rumor is for Quintana (and no, obviously not as the centerpiece)
jdgoat
You could say this about every team
lesterdnightfly
Another Calvin Pickering….
dodgerfan711
Another failure of the disfunction dbacks
Binnster
Another idiot from Cali…
MJ 3
So the Dbacks sold high on O’Brian.
nailz#4life
Isn’t he Petes son , ex catcher for the Braves??
BravesCanada
I think you mean Charlie, and no lol
bigcubsfan
Doesn’t get rave reviews from the MLBTR reader with the username jwood on his defense at catcher or OF.
cardinalfanforever
Sometimes a change of scenery can do wonders for a young player. I hope that’s the case for him. I like to support both Missouri teams
mcdusty31
Yes but will his rave reviews get better in Missouri?
cardinalfanforever
Only time will tell
cardinalfanforever
I think he’s actually Conan O’Brien’s son lol
pinkerton
are the Royals aware of the rave/not rave reviews?
dutch91701
The word’s getting around. It’s everywhere. I’m sure they’re vaguely aware
mcdusty31
Now that he’s off my minor league keeper roster he’ll probably come up and hit 40 homers
angelsinthetroutfield
Hope he finds success in KC. Always felt he could become a Russell Branyan type…
baseball10
If u tell me all i have to give up is a 25 yr old AA reliever then sign me up for this deal
strostro
Source Confirms: Peter O’Brien doesn’t get rave reviews at catcher or outfield
lesterdnightfly
CAFARDO’S LATEST
Among Nick Cafardo’s latest MLB scoops:
Newly acquired Royals farmhand Peter O’Brien is “absolutely getting rave reviews for his defense as a catcher and OF”, according to Cafardo’s high-ranking sources.
JoeyPankake
Cafardo is a raving lunatic.
pinkerton
what does Olney think? Then we’ll have a story!
alexgordonbeckham
I love how about half (if not more) of the comments are poking fun at the guy who posted the same thing multiple times lol
schellis 2
That poster is obviously not getting rave reviews for his posting ability.
Cave
Anyone leaving rave reviews in 2019?
gallenofbeer
2020 here. If you knew what was good for you, you’d stay in 2019.
Srechter35
This thread still kicks