Headlines

  • Red Sox Likely To Activate Alex Bregman Tomorrow
  • Astros To Promote Brice Matthews
  • Phillies Reportedly Targeting Controllable Relievers
  • Yankees Prioritizing Pitching, Also Searching For Infield Help
  • Orioles Trade Bryan Baker To Rays
  • Yankees Release DJ LeMahieu
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2025 Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Indians Showing Interest In Justin Smoak, Nicholas Castellanos

By Jeff Todd | July 30, 2019 at 10:20am CDT

10:19am: Tigers outfielder Nicholas Castellanos is also a possible target for the Indians, per MLB.com’s Jon Morosi (via Twitter). It is not clear from the report whether the teams are engaged in talks.

9:38am: The Indians are “among [the] teams looking at” Blue Jays first baseman Justin Smoak, according to Jon Heyman of MLB Network (via Twitter). Smoak, a switch-hitter, is earning $8MM this year before reaching free agency at season’s end.

It’s not surprising to see the Cleveland organization exploring possible offensive-oriented additions. The club has received a big contribution from Carlos Santana at first base, but hasn’t settled on a steady designated hitter.

Plugging in the 32-year-old Smoak would make for a nice lineup boost for the Indians. Smoak is slashing .215/.357/.427 this year with 18 long balls in 359 plate appearances. That’s shy of his output in the preceding two seasons, but still handily above-average production.

No doubt the Indians also see a bit of an opportunity to buy low on a player that may not draw much demand elsewhere, due in no small part to the lack of American League buyers and his defensive limitations. Smoak is drawing walks at a hefty rate (16.7%) and seems rather unfortunate to carry only a .220 batting average on balls in play. Statcast credits him with a big .388 xwOBA based upon the quality of contact he has made, which is much higher than his .342 wOBA.

Even as the Indians consider scenarios in which they’d part with starter Trevor Bauer, they’re hardly looking at a sell-off. The club weathered a tough start to the season and presently sits just two games back of the Twins.

Share 0 Retweet 13 Send via email0

Cleveland Guardians Detroit Tigers Toronto Blue Jays Justin Smoak Nick Castellanos

Trey Mancini Drawing Interest
Main
Closer Market Rumors: Diaz, Vazquez
View Comments (83)
Post a Comment

83 Comments

  1. Indiansjoe

    6 years ago

    NOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!

    Reply
    • deweybelongsinthehall

      6 years ago

      This game has sadly changed. Smoak kills the Red Sox but when a .215 hitter at a power position is considered “handily above average production” something needs to be done to address how to improve the game. 18 home runs in a day when everyone’s grandmother seems to be able to pop an opposite field homer should not be sufficient to consider his 2019; production good.

      3
      Reply
      • jrickel96

        6 years ago

        The average is not good, but that OBP differential is elite. I think there is also an idea that the average could improve with better protection as Smoak would see better pitches.

        He’s a career .230 hitter. There are other guys I’d rather have (Puig and Castellanos come to mind as rentals), but Smoak would not be a bad add if the price is cheap.

        2
        Reply
        • deweybelongsinthehall

          6 years ago

          I don’t know his splits but perhaps solely against righties, he’s good to have on the bench. Again he kills Boston and it’s usually against the pen. My beef is the game is getting unwatchable. I often now look at highlights because I start my work day at 6 AM and can’t watch four hour games.

          1
          Reply
      • baji kimran

        6 years ago

        The “new” metrics they use in baseball that they try to pass off as statistics, are to me a system made up by player agents to try to convince teams that certain players are better than they really are so they will get hefty pay raises in salary arbitration and on the free agent market..

        Reply
        • sufferforsnakes

          6 years ago

          Exactly, and many of those goofy “stats” are either ‘projected’ or ‘weighted’ or some other kind of formula that amounts to nothing more than guessing.

          Reply
        • Down with OBP

          6 years ago

          Can I borrow your tin hats for a little bit?

          Reply
        • macstruts

          6 years ago

          What’s a goofy stat? The best “real” stat in baseball is OBP. And even that in isolation doesn’t paint a complete picture. No stat paints a complete picture. WAR paints a pretty good picture, but it’s still incomplete.

          Reply
      • driftcat28 2

        6 years ago

        Couldn’t agree more. .215 is a terrible avg but some will tell you this stat no longer means anything

        Reply
        • macstruts

          6 years ago

          110 OPS+ tells me more than his batting average. A WAR of .8 tells me more than his batting average. An OBP of 357 tells me more than his batting average.

          There are lots of things to look at that tell you more than batting average, No one is ever telling you that you should ignore batting average.

          1
          Reply
        • its_happening

          6 years ago

          Two out, nobody on, Smoak walks. Next guy gets out.

          Two out, runner on second, Smoak walks. Next guy gets out.

          Strikeout, fly out. 0 for 4.

          That OBP looks good. No runs to show for. No hits can be found. I’ll take a better batting average. Thanks.

          Reply
    • jak949806

      6 years ago

      Just send them (2) A players and I’m fine with this.

      Reply
      • Waz1

        6 years ago

        The all love our A players. That’s where the talent is other than Jones and 1-2 others.

        Reply
      • Indiansjoe

        6 years ago

        He is a cash consideration player at best

        Reply
        • The Ghost of Bobby Bonilla

          6 years ago

          Cash considerations going both ways with the bigger amount from Toronto.

          Reply
  2. lfrient1

    6 years ago

    I hope that the Tribe doesn’t overpay for this rental. After all, with the trade deadline so near, the temptation is to do anything, just anything. It can distort your vision.

    All told, Smoak can get in your eyes…

    Reply
    • macstruts

      6 years ago

      You think they are going to overpay? Detroit is not going to get anyone for N.C. and the Blue Jays are not going to get anyone for Smoke.

      Overpay?

      Reply
  3. sherlock_

    6 years ago

    That’s who the A’s should’ve traded for instead of Morales when Olson was out…

    3
    Reply
  4. ThePriceWasRight

    6 years ago

    better than bauers

    1
    Reply
    • hockeyjohn

      6 years ago

      Bauers is 23 years old. Give the kid a chance. With that said, if the cost is minimal, bring on Smoak.

      Reply
      • Ketch

        6 years ago

        They’re not giving up on Bauer’s. Smoak would be for 2 months

        Reply
      • jdgoat

        6 years ago

        Yep. Bauer’s helps you win in the future. Smoak helps you win games this year.

        Reply
    • Indiansjoe

      6 years ago

      The difference between him and Bauers isn’t worth anything. Soler, Mancini, Castellanos all are better options that could have a real impact.

      Reply
      • ThePriceWasRight

        6 years ago

        switch hitters are useless

        Reply
  5. RedKing22

    6 years ago

    .215/.357/.427 is “handily above average production”?

    2
    Reply
    • damascusj

      6 years ago

      I was thinking the same thing.

      1
      Reply
    • BigTicket

      6 years ago

      Jeff Todd must have have Smoaked something to make that comment…

      Reply
    • CanadianJay

      6 years ago

      The batting average isn’t. But the on base percentage and slugging is. OPS of almost .800 is good

      2
      Reply
      • damascusj

        6 years ago

        That slugging is average at best

        Reply
    • flippinbats79

      6 years ago

      OPS+ of 131, 122 and 110 last 3 years. Yeah I would say so

      1
      Reply
    • TheFixIsIn

      6 years ago

      I was thinking the same thing!! The writers on this page always skew their information — if a team is picking up a player and they have Smoake-like numbers…it’s a great “get.” If a team is getting rid of a player, those same numbers suddenly stink. The numbers stink. Why do they have to pretend they don’t?

      Reply
    • Twinsfan333

      6 years ago

      That’s a 784 ops and a 110 ops+ literally well above the league average. Stop the fixation with BA. It’s about reaching base and damage young fella.

      3
      Reply
      • stymeedone

        6 years ago

        .784 ops is disappointing for a 1B. Maybe a lot of 1B are disappointing this year. It would be good for 2b and C and passable in the OF.

        Reply
      • Avory

        6 years ago

        Can’t believe anyone still thinks batting average as worthwhile indicator of value in isolation. Besides, reading comprehension will tell you that Todd is looking more deeply into Smoak, like for instance his .220 BABIP–averaged.290 over the last three years, and well below his historical norm–indicates a ton of bad luck, especially since his hard-hit rate hasn’t dropped. That makes Smoak a nice buy-low candidate, a guy who, whatever he is, makes 2/3 of our lineups immediately better (c’mon, Kipnis clean-up vs. Smoak?) You want to bat Luplow 4th against southpaws fine, but Smoak at DH definitely lengthens our lineup and I love that he’s another switch-hitter. I prefer him to Castellanos or Domingo Santana, although the Jays are sage traders….it still hurts to see lefty Pannone developing into a solid rotation piece over the long haul and Merryweather could develop after elbow surgery as well, all for a month or two of Joe Smith and Josh Donaldson. These types of trades can really haunt you. But maybe we get lucky and get Jay Bruce-like production for little or no cost.

        Reply
  6. BigTicket

    6 years ago

    Tough next couple weeks for the Tribe… we will see how they fair against some tougher opponents…The 10 games against the Twinkies will determine the winner. Good luck!

    Reply
    • ColossusOfClout

      6 years ago

      Indians have been getting fat on cupcakes for so long when they try to chow down on some twinkies, it’s gonna feel like chewing concrete.

      1
      Reply
      • Polish Hammer

        6 years ago

        Split with the ‘stros in Houston, took 2 of 3 in Boston, two of 3 from the Yankees, Twins have the season edge but also played 6 of 9 in Minny

        1
        Reply
        • Nam

          6 years ago

          The first 2 months the twins have played the the White Sox, Orioles, and Seattle. They play a easy schedule every year because they’re one of the worst team year in, year out. A 13 gm lead a little over a month ago now you’re probably not going to even make the post season.

          Reply
        • Avory

          6 years ago

          A team’s current schedule has nothing whatsoever to do with the previous year’s record. You’re thinking NFL, bud.

          Reply
  7. cmanson

    6 years ago

    the Indians can have Joc Pederson….please please anyone take him away

    Reply
    • jak949806

      6 years ago

      We have some shovel handles and a $3 steak. Will that do?

      Reply
    • E munchy

      6 years ago

      On today’s episode of it could be worse. Joc Pederson, sure! Bring him on!

      Joc Pederson for Chris Davis and his money. Deal?! Haha

      Reply
      • OCTraveler

        6 years ago

        Dodgers say “NFW”

        Reply
  8. iplay_in_traffic

    6 years ago

    Why not somebody like Dom Smith from the Mets? Kid has swung a nice bat this year, is cheap, and won’t take much in prospect capital to obtain.

    Reply
    • Freddie Morales

      6 years ago

      Because the Mets want a SS, CF, or MLB ready arms for Smith and justifiably so. Indians don’t have any to offer.

      perhaps Mets make an aggressive offer for Lindor in off-season

      Reply
      • Nam

        6 years ago

        Lol Lindor isn’t going to the a 3rd tier team in New York. They need to learn to develope players and stop being the Yankees step child. Unless you’re giving up Alonso and Wheeler.

        Reply
  9. bobtillman

    6 years ago

    All the Tribe should be looking at is whether player X is better than player Y (with all the finances figured in). Smoak > Bauers (tho there’s hope for Bauers still) for 2019, and the money shouldn’t be an issue.

    A couple of low-level prospects should get it done….at the end of the year, you kick Smoak down the stairs….he won’t mind; his numbers look better in a pennant race than in the obscurity of Toronto….

    Reply
    • Indiansjoe

      6 years ago

      Cash considerations would get it done….not sure Smoak is better fit than anything they have. Castellanos is a different story, would love a Castellanos/Green package.

      Reply
  10. tuner49

    6 years ago

    To win the WS the Indians will have to go through several LHP(Yankees and Dodgers). Smoke vs. LHP: .204/.328/.286/.613 while Castellanos is hitting .347/.415/.611/1.026.

    2
    Reply
    • deweybelongsinthehall

      6 years ago

      Not to mention a possible wild card game against Boston (Sale, Price and/or Rodriguez).

      Reply
      • Nam

        6 years ago

        Lol you must mean the twins that can’t hold a 13 gm lead.

        Reply
    • hockeyjohn

      6 years ago

      I am fine with Castellanos too. Will help in 2019 with minimal cost and keeps the Tribe’s future intact.

      Reply
  11. sufferforsnakes

    6 years ago

    smh……….

    Reply
  12. ClevelandGuardians2021

    6 years ago

    Sucks being an Indians fan.

    Reply
    • sufferforsnakes

      6 years ago

      No, it doesn’t. If you think it sucks, then root for a different team.

      2
      Reply
      • ClevelandGuardians2021

        6 years ago

        Off my balls dude.

        Reply
        • sufferforsnakes

          6 years ago

          By the sound of it you don’t have any.

          Reply
      • Polish Hammer

        6 years ago

        Exactly!

        Reply
  13. terry g

    6 years ago

    Smoak is more on the level of players that I think will be moved by the deadline. He’s not a headliner that will excite fans. However, he can get on base and has some power and can be had without losing ang any upper level prospects.

    Reply
  14. CJ81

    6 years ago

    jose martinez from the cardinals would look good as a dh in Cleveland. maybe Martinez plus montero (#4 prospect, 3b) and juinor fernandez (#10, sp) for trevor bauer. maybe one more prospect around #15-20. im sure indians want a top 50 prospect, but 3 good prospects plus a very good dh is way more than mets gave up for stroman.

    Reply
    • ClevelandGuardians2021

      6 years ago

      Now castellanos I’d be happy with

      Reply
    • Avory

      6 years ago

      CJ, that’s a fair offer, one I think the Tribe would look at very closely. And Trevor would love the atmosphere in St. Louis. For all of Bauer’s quirkiness, he’s the only starter on our team who, when coming off the mound to an ovation when leaving the game, will actually tip his cap to the crowd. I like to see that in a professional athlete. It’s a little thing, but a telling thing. Why so many guys in major league baseball think it,s bush to acknowledge the crowd is beyond me.

      Reply
  15. GB85

    6 years ago

    Atkins will be (rightfully) giving this guy away for a low-level lottery prospect to the first team that comes in with an offer.

    Reply
  16. dfranks

    6 years ago

    Absolutely not

    Reply
  17. dfranks

    6 years ago

    As long as Castellanos doesn’t bring his iron glove with him, I like him against left handed pitching.

    Reply
    • jirogers72

      6 years ago

      Indians should add more netting to protect the fans when he’s in the field!

      Reply
      • hockeyjohn

        6 years ago

        He will be at DH the majority of the time in Cleveland.

        Reply
    • stymeedone

      6 years ago

      How does one target a player like Castellanos without engaging in Talks? ESP?

      Reply
  18. TennVol

    6 years ago

    I think Smoak can be acquired for someone 25-30 prospect and the Jays will even pay his salary for the year if they up it to a 20th rank prospect. Good buy for a contending team. Gives you a professional at bat, great in the club house and above average defense.

    Reply
    • Indiansjoe

      6 years ago

      No way they get an top 30 prospect….from any organization…..for Smoak.

      Reply
      • JaysForDays

        6 years ago

        Wrong.

        Reply
    • Polish Hammer

      6 years ago

      Really? Considering what they got for Stroman they can send a bucket of BP balls for him and not a rated prospect.

      Reply
  19. sportsnut969

    6 years ago

    I would much rather see the Indians pony up prospects for a better all around answer with a way better batting average who is signed for 2 more years in Starling Marte

    with his contract you should not have to include any of you top 10 prospects if you pick up the rest of the contract about 2.5 mil this year 11.5 2020 & 12.5 in 2021

    just a thought

    Reply
    • Monkey’s Uncle

      6 years ago

      The problem from the Pirates’ perspective is that if they trade Marte they would have to acquire an everyday center fielder to replace him. Bryan Reynolds currently moves to center when Marte needs a day off but Reynolds is not going to be a long-term answer in center, he’s a corner outfielder.

      Reply
      • Grand Salami

        6 years ago

        Agreed. Marte is not a rental, he offers a permanent solution and while he may not have the pop of Puig or Nick C, he has speed and defense with a solid bat. With all of that comes a cost. I could see the Pirates asking for Lindor and trying to sell some prospects to open the talks. Not a realistic starting point to get to an actual trade though. Indians should probably stick with a cheaper rental deal

        Reply
        • Indiansjoe

          6 years ago

          Did you seriously just say they would ask for Lindor?

          1
          Reply
      • The Ghost of Bobby Bonilla

        6 years ago

        Greg Allen and/or Tyler Naquin can achieve that.

        Reply
  20. Tribe75

    6 years ago

    Lindor to the Pirates?If the Indians aren’t willing to pay Lindor,Nutting sure as hell won’t!

    Reply
  21. terrymesmer

    6 years ago

    Smoak’s slash line looks weak, but I agree with those who say it would improve with a little protection. Right now he’s in a lineup full of free swingers with lots of K’s.

    Smoak sees only 38.2% of pitches in the strike zone,. Of 162 qualified batters in MLB, that’s 13th worst. All the fellows at the bottom with him are elite sluggers.

    Smoak swings at only 22.7% of pitches out of the zone. That is elite too — the 12th best in MLB.

    His plate discipline is nearly identical to Carlos Santana. That’s a good thing if he can get on a good team. And Smoak will not cost much, so…

    And Smoak is a switch hitter. He would be the fifth one in Cleveland’s lineup. Gotta like that.

    Reply
  22. firegibby

    6 years ago

    Smoak is an excellent defensive 1B. He gets on base can hit a hr. Jay’s can cover his salary.

    Reply
  23. its_happening

    6 years ago

    Expect a hometown discount for the Indians courtesy of Atkins. Cleveland would be receiving a solid defender with a power bat that suits both Yankee Stadium and Fenway Park. Although his career numbers aren’t good in New York. He’s shown flashes in that ballpark.

    Reply
    • baseballsavvy

      6 years ago

      Oh is there any doubt? Smoak ideally should have been dealt last year. These dealings with the Indians and Shapiro kill me. Shapiro will give anything and everything to the Indians for a bag of balls. Please fire this schmuck and the rest of his cronies.

      Reply
      • its_happening

        6 years ago

        No doubts over here. I know they should have traded Smoak a year ago. It was all about opening a spot for Rowdy Tellez in 2019.

        Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

    Top Stories

    Red Sox Likely To Activate Alex Bregman Tomorrow

    Astros To Promote Brice Matthews

    Phillies Reportedly Targeting Controllable Relievers

    Yankees Prioritizing Pitching, Also Searching For Infield Help

    Orioles Trade Bryan Baker To Rays

    Yankees Release DJ LeMahieu

    Trevor Williams To Undergo UCL Surgery

    Nationals Fire PBO Mike Rizzo, Manager Dave Martinez

    Brewers Activate Brandon Woodruff

    Clarke Schmidt Expected To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Bobby Jenks Passes Away

    Braves Release Alex Verdugo

    Top 40 Trade Candidates For The 2025 Deadline

    Rays Reinstate Ha-Seong Kim

    Yankees Have Shown Interest In Ryan McMahon

    Royals Interested In Bryan Reynolds

    Rangers Option Josh Jung

    Kevin Pillar Announces Retirement

    Braves Place Spencer Schwellenbach On IL With Elbow Fracture

    Giants Exercise 2026 Option On Manager Bob Melvin

    Recent

    Trade Deadline Outlook: New York Yankees

    Trade Deadline Outlook: Atlanta Braves

    Which Other Relievers Might The Orioles Shop?

    Lee Elia Passes Away

    Red Sox Likely To Activate Alex Bregman Tomorrow

    Poll: Which Teams Should Make The Biggest Push For Jarren Duran?

    MLB Finalizes Home Run Derby Field

    Astros To Promote Brice Matthews

    Giants Outright Sergio Alcántara

    Joe Coleman Passes Away

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Sandy Alcantara Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Alex Bregman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android App Store Google Play

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version