The White Sox’ long-awaited deal with Cuban slugger Oscar Colas became official earlier this month, when he agreed to a $2.7MM signing bonus as international free agency opened. Notably, while there’d been some talk of the 23-year-old Colas working as a two-way player, he’s made clear since his signing that he’ll be working as strictly an outfielder with the White Sox (link via Vinnie Duber of NBC Sports Chicago).
“Pitching is in the past for me,” Colas told reporters through the team’s interpreter. Colas adds that it was an “easy decision” and that the White Sox were far more interested in his potential as an outfielder than on the mound. Indeed, ChiSox special assistant Marco Paddy tells Duber and others that Colas is “not really a pitcher” and that his development on the mound would have taken considerably longer.
While it’d have been a fun story to see a highly touted young talent like Colas strive to become a two-way player, the “Cuban Ohtani” moniker that was placed upon him always seemed rather misguided and, frankly, unfair to Colas himself due to the expectations associated with the nickname. As we noted at the time Colas was declared a free agent by MLB, to liken a player with all of 3 1/3 professional innings pitched (during the 2018-19 Cuban National Series) to Ohtani never made much sense, catchy and marketable as the narrative might’ve been. Colas is reportedly able to reach 95 mph with his fastball, and perhaps there’s some raw pitching talent that could have been refined. However, by the time Ohtani was this age, he’d amassed 543 innings of 2.52 ERA ball in Nippon Professional Baseball and was on the cusp of jumping directly to the Majors.
None of that is to downplay Colas’ potential for big league success with the bat. By all accounts, the 6’1″, 220-pound slugger has huge raw power from the left side of the dish and could eventually settle in as a productive big league hitter. Baseball America’s Ben Badler noted recently that even though he’s improved his conditioning since leaving his native Cuba, Colas is likely to settle in as a left fielder or first baseman due in part to questions about his outfield range.
Given his age and prior professional experience in Cuba and in Japan, Colas is more advanced than your typical amateur who’d sign during the international period in MLB. That said, he also hasn’t played a game in the CNS or in NPB since 2019, so there’s surely some rust to shake off as he reacclimates.
It’s possible he’ll be a quick mover, although the White Sox already have a fairly crowded collection of players in the mix in the outfield corners, at first base and at designated hitter. Jose Abreu is locked in at first base, leaving the outfield corners and DH work to fall to Eloy Jimenez, Andrew Vaughn and Gavin Sheets. Chicago also has fleet-footed Adam Engel as an option at all three outfield positions, and corner outfield prospect Micker Adolfo is out of minor league options, meaning he cannot be sent to the minors without first clearing waivers. It’s not an immediate issue anyway, as Colas will need some time in the upper minors before he’s an option in the big leagues, but some eventual turnover among that group of corner bats/DH options is inevitable.
Please, Hammer. Don't hurt 'em.
That’s a shame. MLB needs more 2-way players. I think they help increase fan base and make things more interesting and fun to watch.
Dorothy_Mantooth
With pitchers being asked to throw harder than ever, it’s really difficult to develop two-way players these days. Pitchers have a completely different work out routine than position players do as well. Pitchers focus on a ton of arm strengthening exercises and core exercises, while position players tend to have more ‘normal’ work out regimens, focusing on overall strength and flexibility. That alone makes it hard to find the time to stay in the proper shape to do both, let alone all of the work someone like Colas would need to do on the mound just to be competitive. Ohtani is really the proverbial ‘needle in a haystack’. The next predefined two-way player most likely comes out of a college program where he was a Top 10 pitcher and a Top 20 batter in the nation. That’s the level of skill these guys need to have in order for teams to consider them for a two-way career. The injury risk doubles with two-way players as well, so most teams don’t want to take that chance since they have invested so much money to acquire them (someone like this would be drafted #1 or #2 overall and get a $7M+ signing bonus). All this extra work even took a toll on Ohtani as he had TJS himself.
With that said, there’s always a chance a team drafts a superb athlete who surprises everyone and gets a chance at doing both, but I highly doubt we see another talent like Ohtani anytime over the next 10-15 years. He’s that rare of a talent.
Please, Hammer. Don't hurt 'em.
All true. It being so hard to accomplish is what makes it so fun to watch, though. Now that I think about it, I wonder how Adam LaRoche would have turned out as a 2-way player. His dad was an MLB pitcher and teams actually wanted to draft him higher than he went but as a pitcher. LaRoche fell in the draft because he said he wanted to go to a team that would draft him as a hitter. His bat was good enough to make him a good regular starting everyday position player with some power. Most teams thought that he would become a better pitcher than he would a hitter. I wonder if, after the Ohtani revelation, Adam LaRoche wishes he has just tried to do both. If he had made it as a pitcher I think his hitting would have been there regardless.
Dogbone
The heck with Adam LaRoche – the real two way star in the LaRoche family from what I hear – is gonna be Drake LaRoche. Plus Drake is a leader, so he might manage the team once LaRussa moves on.
Rsox
A Pitcher who can DH is not a two-way player. When Ohtani actually lines up in the OF grass then he’s a two-way player. Carlos Zambrano and Mike Hampton could have done the same thing if they played in the AL and a manager was willing to let them
tstats
You’re just full of bad takes today arent you
realsox
I think you make an important, and valid, point. “Two-way” players have to play defense as well as hit.
GareBear
So David Ortiz’s Hall of Fame plaque represents a non-player? He played over 80% of his games out of the DH spot. Ohtani is a two way player, deal with it.
Please, Hammer. Don't hurt 'em.
@RSox: Ohtani does typically DH but he has “lined up in the outfield grass.” Last season he spent some time playing right field in games where he didn’t pitch.
Rsox
8.1 innings in the field
rjh
your point about playing in the field is well-taken, rsox. however, your equating zambrano and hampton with ohtani is a huge stretch. neither could hold ohtani’s jock strap when it comes to hitting. here are their respective triple slash statistics projected out to 162 games:
zambrano………238/.248/.636
hampton…………246/.294/.650
ohtani………………..264/.353/.890
those zambrano and/or hampton stats would have every gm searching for a new dh. but those ohtani stats are good to go!!! and, if recent results are over-weighted (as they should be), it’s hard to overlook the 46 home runs and 100 rbi’s that ohtani put up in 2021.
JeffreyChungus
Unsurprising to say the least. He’s a guy who could be up this year, if not 2023, given his age and track record. Chicago will want him up ASAP if he could contribute while the team is in its window of contention
Bob Sacamano 310
He hasn’t played a game in over 2 years at this point. Unless he completely destroys minor league pitching this year, I’m not sure he will be up. He does look a lot trimmer than when we first started hearing about him about 2 years ago. Hopefully he can keep the weight off.
DarkSide830
given he had, like, one pro game at pitcher this is far from shocking
Bob Sacamano 310
Whenever I read “Cuban Ohtani,” I cringed. Dude has thrown about as many innings as Matt Davidson.
rjh
i always shudder at the idea that some, supposedly knowledgeable people still call micker adolfo a prospect!
Bob Sacamano 310
Injuries really derailed him. He’s out of options. I’m sure some team will claim him off waivers towards the end of spring training when he doesn’t make the team.
louwhitakerisahofer
Understand what you’re saying, but literally everyone in the minors is a prospect. It’s not like he called him a top prospect or anything.
maximumvelocity
I would not be shocked if he makes the roster, especially if they do nothing significant in the outfield.
They could have given him a shot last season with all the injuries.
Dorothy_Mantooth
This guy hasn’t played pro-ball since 2019 and the White Sox have plenty of options for the corner OF positions for 2022. Unless he absolutely rakes in AA & AAA, I really don’t see Colas contributing to the big league club until 2023 at the earliest. Maybe he gets a September call up this year, but that’s not guaranteed since the league limited the amount of players to be called up to 2 (26 man roster can expand to 28 in September). Most teams opt to bring up extra pitchers in September now.
Bob Sacamano 310
Plus, I feel like they will be in the market for a regular RF. Sheets has minor league options left so let him go play every day in AAA as depth, Vaughn/Eloy split LF/DH, Engel 4th OF, and regular RF’r. Abreu is a free agent after this year so there can still be room in 23, although I think Jerry will bring him back.
Bottom line: don’t count on Colas as the answer or even to play in the MLB this year.
rjh
if you check the 2021 platoon splits, it seems as though sheets/vaughn is the perfect dh solution. and it works out well for reinsdorf’s “:spending” habits.
second base can be a competition between yolbert sanchez, romy gonzalez, jake burger and leuri. the results could be surprising (to the upside), again working out well for jerry’s “spending” inclinations.
which means that the perennial promise of “we will spend” should be a maximum offer to get seiya suzuki for right field. however, unless there’s a super stealth effort in that regard, it’s not going to happen…as the sox haven’t so much as been mentioned as one of the 8 teams in on suzuki, even though the cubs have been!!!!!!!!! what kind of fit is suzuki for the cubs??? isn’t it too soon in their rebuild???
15Step
When did they promise ‘we will spend’?
Augusto Barojas
Sox fans can only hope Jerry changes his Gollum like hoarding of money. His net worth is up like 200M since 2020, I mean how much does the guy need to get a real 2b and RF rather than waste the whole rebuild dumpster diving. They aren’t going to win anything other than a weak AL Central with Grandal as the highest paid free agent of the whole rebuild. Schwarber is the guy I think they should get. The guy kills righties, which is exactly what they need. They would have tons of lefty/righty platoon options that way, I don’t think Sheets will hit lefties well enough (sub-.300 OPS last year) or Vaughn will hit righties well enough (.600 or so OPS vs RHP last year) to play full time against same handed pitching. Split RF/LF between Vaughn, Eloy, Sheets, Engel, with Schwarber the primary DH. They won’t suck at scoring runs against righties (or good teams) if they add Schwarber.
rjh
hello agusto. i always enjoy reading your posts. i agree with you about jerry’s reluctance to spend. i always hope against hope that posts such as yours and others will shame him into going big to acquire one of the top free agents. however, i’m trying to face the reality that jerry’s spending will be limited. this could be the one off-season when that works out okay! as you correctly observe, neither vaughn nor sheets can hit well enough against “same handed” pitching to play every day. but they were both promising enough to earn their keep, particularly if you check their platoon splits!! vaugn had a .938 ops versus lefties, and sheets was .900 versus righties!! there’s our dh!! there’s not a gm in baseball who wouldn’t take that production over the course of a full season. and since neither is exactly a gazelle in the outfield, dh is the perfect ZERO COST SOLUTION!! so, we still have that “schwarber money” to spend on a guy who can actually play the outfield and BASH!! that guy is seiya suzuki, the best player in japan, a basher who’s also earned a gold glove…and at 27 years old, IS A LONG-TERM SOLUTION!
what do you think?
Augusto Barojas
Hey RJH, nice to hear from you and thanks for the props. I highly doubt anybody in the Sox front office bothers to read this stuff, I don’t think they care about what fans think at all really. I like Suzuki, if only his first name was Ichiro! He sounds like he has a very bright future, but is also a bit less of a certainty given that he has never played in the US. His numbers are excellent though. I could not find left/right splits, only negative is he is right handed hitter. I think he will be expensive and want a longer term deal. Schwarber would not be cheap either but they might be able to get him on a much shorter deal, which is also part of Reinsdorf’s pattern. Certainly neither Vaughn nor Sheets projects to be as good defensively as Seiya, but at the same time either or both are probably adequate enough for RF, which I assume is what their plan for RF is.
I’d be pretty happy with either Seiya or Schwarber, but we have of course heard no rumors tying the Sox to either. So both are probably long shots, along with the Sox chances of doing anything in the postseason. Seiya linked to Padres, Giants, Cubs, Redsox, Mariners. I think Seattle might be a likely place because of Ichiro, I’m sure Ichiro as a countryman would speak very highly of their organization and how that city treated him. I wonder if the Angels would want to add him with Otani. I just hope the Sox do SOMETHING, their efforts the last two winters were pathetic, and Eaton being the best they could do for RF last year was unforgivable.
Astrobabg93
No I think the sox gotta play sheets. He showed some real pop last year. I like him a lot. .260/25-30/95 I could see in the future
nrd1138
Agreed, I think the stats on Sheets Vs lefties is incomplete (to say the least), considering he came up in the middle of the season. The times they did have him in critical situations vs a Lefty he came out well, getting hits when needed the most. I think Sheets is the guy you want to really work against lefties in spring training (if they have one this season anyway) and see what you have. I find it funny talking about woeful at bats and bringing in a guy like Schwarber to somehow fix that, Stats may say otherwise, but I have seen Schwarber too much to think that he is much better IMO.
Augusto Barojas
@nrd Schwarber has had a season OPS over .800 3 of the last 4 years, 2020 being the exception. His OPS vs righties was over .900 in 2021 and 2019. I don’t know what you are seeing in Schwarber that you don’t like, the dude is pretty damn good, with a much longer track record than Sheets. No need to get rid of Sheets either, I say get Schwarber and have both of them play against righties. I mean it’s not like they were neck and neck with the Astros last year, they got creamed in the playoffs and regular season against them, and need all the help they can get. Especially against right handed pitching. They’re not going to win in the playoffs with the same roster that did a face plant the past two Octobers, hoping for improvements in Sheets and Vaughn. They need a 2b and a big time lefty bat, which Schwarber absolutely is.
nrd1138
I dunno. Adam Dunn’s OPS was gargantuan when the Sox brought him in as well. I have seen Schwarber hit and yeah he can hit homers, but I just have a feeling he would whiff a lot and a lot when needed most (RISP and RISP with 2 outs), but that’s just a feeling on him, and from what I saw when he was on the north side. Never mind he is a huge liability in the field, which the Sox already have plenty of (and I doubt he wants to be a full time DH). I just know that the Sox need hitters a lot better than Schwarber.
DarkSide830
and he didnt exactly kill it by Serie standards
Ogie Oglethorpe
Dumpster Diving Rick
Old York
Oh, no! No mare Cuban Ohtani…
whyhayzee
They’re taking the fizz out of Colas. Oh dear.
junkyard
His first sip in the majors has already gone flat
Darryl Rhubarb
He still has a lot of pop in his bat though
IronBallsMcGinty
Also in White Sox news, minor league pitcher Alec Hansen retired and they signed New Zealand native and USC infielder Jason Matthews to a minor league deal.
ctyank7
Too bad the Yankees didn’t make a pitch for this guy: a near MLB ready lefty hitting 1st baseman/LF …
Instead they got for a long-shot shortstop, when they have two home grown ones ready from their own system for ‘23 and’24.
I guess that’s why Cashman holds the Mr Teflon Award. No pennants for a dozen years. Just spending millions in error.
Dorothy_Mantooth
It seems like a lot of teams spend most of their International money on shortstops. I’m guessing shortstops prove to be the most versatile athletes who can be moved to other positions of need as part of their development. Second seems to be pitchers followed closely by catchers. Every once in a while a Jasson Dominguez comes up (strictly OF) who is too good to pass up on. I believe the Red Sox signed 6 shortstops in one of their last 2 IFA spending sprees. I highly doubt they all stick to that position.
rocky7
From what I’ve read, this guy Colas is a real wildcard…potential but who knows……hasn’t played in 2 years and needs at least 1 season in the minors if not more to get his eye and timing back…Why would Cashman make a move on a player like this when all we read about all day long is that the Yankees will make a move on one of 3 if possible; Freeman, Olson, or Rizzo…..how do you characterize not going after an either Boom or Bust…Might be kid ( is he really 23) as a foolish immersion and spending error on Cashmans part?
mrmackey
I think Colas is overrated and has a much lower ceiling than Rod-A.
nrd1138
Well I’m sure if he gets some ‘vitamins’ he’ll be right up there with A Roid… Even if you take the ‘vitamins’ out of it, its easy to plug any prospect in against any former MLB with HoF numbers and say they are over rated, isn’t it?
Why not also say: “Colas is overrated, and has a much lower ceiling than Hank Aaron”… Or “Ken Griffey Jr”.. Or…’Mike Trout’ Or ‘Babe Ruth’…..
racosun
Signs contract. “Welcome!” Immediately gets locked out.
Steve Adams
Minor league deal. He can head straight to their spring complex to work out with staff if they want. Only 40-man players are locked out.
racosun
Quit stomping my jokes, Steve! 😉
roob
IF, Colas ever becomes an impact player for the Sox, it will be at least 2 years from now.
Gwynning's Anal Lover
Coke should really sign him on an endorsement deal.
ChiSoxCity
The Sox don’t need anymore LFs or 1B/DH type guys. They need a RF who can slug a 2B who can field and hit a little bit.
Being a White Sox is damn frustrating. The Sox don’t usually suck as much as other teams, but they suck at getting timely trades and FA acquisitions done. No other team is worse when it comes to making moves to address roster needs when they actually want to.
nrd1138
Yeah, the Sox have a habit of saying they want to be competitive, but then go and spend the least they can for talent that was a ‘has been’ or ‘never was’. I thought they were done with that when KW was bumped upstairs, but apparently not after seeing the ‘blockbuster’ trades of Hernandez and Kimbrel. this past season when they really needed much much more from both spots.. I mean Kimbrel I could kind of understand (even though Kimbrel really only had about 1 good season collectively with the Cubs) but not what they gave up for him in Madrigal, but Hernandez was a joke. I could not get past the BA, but apparently the Sox org could not get past the homer total… The Sox have plenty of home run hitters, they need hitters that do not wilt against great pitching. To my count they have two guys that have done this: Anderson and Robert.. Even Abreu disappears in some big situations… Everyone else? Jury is out, to say the absolute least. Heck I would be happy if the Sox went out and got another proven (in the playoffs that is) SP. I mean Lynn was great.. until he faced tough competition, Same with their other..ahem.. ‘Ace’ in Giolito. Not too impressed with the pitching coach either, not have that disastrous playoff performance by pretty much the entire pitching staff last season. Sox just have the same problem they have had for some time now. Not heart, and to paraphase ‘Hawk’ no “Will to win”.
rjh
that’s a great post, csc. if colas can play right field…then okay, but if he’s another lf/1b/dh…not so great, given the current makeup of the team.
that’s why the sox need to win the seiya suzuki “sweepstakes.” and, yolbert sanchez (who’s supposed to be a major league ready 2nd baseman), should be given a shot to play 2nd base. he doesn’t strike out, and has hit everywhere he’s been. he could easily become a little bit better than madrigal. however, he’s not getting the kind of hype that selected flops such as collins, hawkins, and cespedes have gotten prior to their colossal flops.
Augusto Barojas
I hope they enter the Seiya sweepstakes. Or the Schwarber sweepstakes. Just do something meaningful to fix the roster issues that would be obvious to a 10 year old. Not complicated!
nrd1138
Schwarber is not going to help the Sox, they have plenty of homerun hitters that refuse to DH and that disappear against good pitching
Southsider
Adam Engle will be the Sox Right Fielder to start the 2022. He has a lot to prove and will be the player of the MLB month in April.. Yolbert Sanchez will be up within a month.
rjh
engel complicates things. he’s always been a stud in the outfield, and he’s markedly improved his hitting…so having him as the 4th outfielder is a “no-brainer.”
the reason he complicates things is that in 2021 he had monstrously reverse splits in a significant number of at bats, tattooing right handed pitchers to an ops far in excess of .900!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! there are some major league hitters (not too many) who have reverse splits, but what makes engel’s 2021 so odd is that he NEVER hit righties AT ALL, in his previous 4 years on the team!!!!!!!!!!! what this means going forward is a strange conundrum.