Giants Release Calvin Mitchell

The Giants have released outfielder Calvin Mitchell, according to his transaction log on MLB.com. He had joined the organization on a minor league contract after he was released by the White Sox in April.

The Pirates took Mitchell, now 26, with the 50th overall pick in the 2017 draft. He played in the organization from 2017-23, and he ranked among the team’s top 25 prospects according to both Baseball America and FanGraphs each year from 2018-21. He was even considered a top-100 prospect in the sport by Baseball Prospectus back in 2019. Mitchell’s big league debut arrived during the 2022 season, and there was plenty of reason for optimism after he slashed .339/.391/.547.

Unfortunately, he wasn’t able to come close to those numbers in the majors. While he got into 69 games for the Pirates with fairly regular playing time, Mitchell hit just .226/.286/.349 with a wRC+ of 77. While his 10-to-15 homer power played as expected in the majors and he walked at a solid 7.8% clip, his strikeout rate jumped to 22.4% during his time in the big leagues. For a player whose profile was built around his ability to make contact, that uptick in strikeouts proved disastrous. A lackluster .276 BABIP certainly didn’t help things either, but whatever the culprit was behind Mitchell’s lackluster offense in that first opportunity in the majors, it has held him back from getting another substantial run in the big leagues ever since.

While Mitchell did return to the majors with the Pirates in 2023, he appeared in just two games and went 0-for-4 with a walk and a strikeout. His Triple-A numbers also took a step back that season, as he hit just .261/.333/.414 across 78 games with Pittsburgh’s Indianapolis affiliate. He was designated for assignment and outrighted off the club’s roster in late September, and since then has bounced between the Padres, White Sox, and Giants organizations without finding a big league opportunity in any organization. While he slashed a respectable .277/.359/.512 in 2024 with Triple-A El Paso last year, this year his numbers at Triple-A have taken a massive nosedive. He’s batting .160/.224/.249 across 50 games between the Giants and White Sox organizations.

Now that Mitchell is on the open market again, he could look for another minor league deal with another organization. On the other hand, at just 26 years old it’s possible he could look to follow in the footsteps of many other players who struggled to establish themselves in the majors and try to forge a career outside of affiliated ball, either overseas in a league like the KBO or NPB, or even in a stateside independent league like the Atlantic League. Given Mitchell’s youth, it’s not hard to imagine him reinventing himself in a new environment and perhaps even returning to the majors at some point in the future as players like Eric Thames and Merrill Kelly have in the past.