The Blue Jays and designated hitter Eloy Jimenez have reached an agreement on a new minor league contract, per Mitch Bannon and Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. The Klutch Sports client was with Toronto earlier this season but elected free agency in early May after being designated for assignment and clearing waivers.
It appears no other club was willing to plug Jimenez right onto its big league roster, so he’ll head back to the Jays and hope for another opportunity. Jimenez, 29, appeared in a dozen games with the Jays prior to his DFA and hit .290 with a .343 on-base percentage in 35 trips to the plate. That .290 average is obviously strong but lacked any teeth; Jimenez didn’t have an extra-base hit (and thus also slugged .290), and he continued to show a ground-ball approach at the plate, undercutting the plus power he once showed.
Early in his career, Jimenez was a top prospect who looked like a potential star. He blasted 31 homers in only 504 plate appearances as a rookie, and while that came in the juiced-ball 2019 season, it still appeared to set the stage for a run as a middle-of-the-order bat on Chicago’s south side.
Instead, injuries regularly hobbled Jimenez over the course of his White Sox tenure. He’s never reached 500 plate appearances in a season since that 2019 debut, nor has he put together even a 20-homer campaign (let alone another 30-homer season). He was still plenty productive when healthy in 2020-22, hitting a combined .281/.334/.499, but his bat has tanked since.
Dating back to 2023, Jimenez has taken 873 major league plate appearances and posted a below-average .259/.307/.393 line. If he were able to provide value with his glove and/or on the basepaths, that could still be a passable line, but Jimenez is a poor defensive outfielder whose sprint speed sat in the 21st percentile of big leaguers earlier this season, per Statcast. Defensive Runs Saved has dinged him for -14 runs in his career, and Statcast has graded him at -19 Outs Above Average. He’s played all of 117 innings in the outfield since Opening Day 2023 — and none since 2024.
Jimenez is still only 29, so it’s not out of the realm of possibility that he reinvents himself and enjoys a nice second act in his career. He’s taken 258 minor league plate appearances across the past two seasons, however, and slugged well under .400 in that span. He’s got a ways to go, but the Blue Jays aren’t risking anything by seeing if they can get him back on track with a non-roster deal that’ll send him to Triple-A Buffalo.
Ah well. Sad state for a fun clubhouse guy and fan favorite. Was never a pure power hitter, more of a Frank Thomas with line drive power and good batting eye. His ability to make contact hasn’t gone away, but the power has cratered. Not really an opportunity for a situational pinch hitter, maybe back in the 70s-80s when rosters had 13-15 position players but not in today’s game. Still hoping he gets a few select moments in the show. Always though team like Tampa would know how to use him. Maybe a similar situation for a team comprised of multi positional Swiss army knives just needing an occasional Big bat. Actually, could that be the White Sox in say 27-28? They just signed Grichuk for that role to promising initial results.