Players Win Six Of 14 Arbitration Hearings

The Mariners’ defeat of reliever Tom Wilhelmsen today ended this offseason’s arbitration season. This year, 14 players went to arbitration hearings, with the players winning six times and teams winning eight. Via MLBTR’s Arbitration Tracker, here are the results.

Player	Team	Player Amt.	Team Amt.	Player won?
Pedro Alvarez	Pirates	$5.750MM	$5.250MM	Yes
Jerry Blevins	Nationals	$2.400MM	$2.200MM	Yes
Alejandro De Aza	Orioles	$5.650MM	$5.000MM	No
Josh Donaldson	Blue Jays	$5.750MM	$4.300MM	No
Mat Latos	Marlins	$10.400MM	$9.400MM	No
Mike Minor	Braves	$5.600MM	$5.100MM	Yes
Jarrod Parker	Athletics	$1.700MM	$0.850MM	No
David Phelps	Marlins	$1.875MM	$1.400MM	No
Wilin Rosario	Rockies	$3.300MM	$2.800MM	No
Mark Trumbo	Diamondbacks	$6.900MM	$5.300MM	Yes
Danny Valencia	Blue Jays	$1.675MM	$1.250MM	Yes
Neil Walker	Pirates	$9.000MM	$8.000MM	No
Tom Wilhelmsen	Mariners	$2.200MM	$1.400MM	No
Vance Worley	Pirates	$2.450MM	$2.000MM	Yes

A few notes:

• Via MLBTR’s 2014 Arbitration Tracker, only three players (Andrew Cashner, Vinnie Pestano and Josh Tomlin) had hearings last year, so 14 hearings this year marks a dramatic spike. No players had hearings in the 2012-2013 offseason, and seven players did in 2011-2012. The number of hearings this offseason was the most since 2001, although not everyone is convinced this is the start of a trend, according to the Associated Press. ”Just as I didn’t think [2012-2013] was the start of a trend when we had no hearings, I do not think any conclusions can be drawn at this point from the increased number of hearings this year,” says MLB chief legal officer Don Halem.
• The Pirates alone took three players to arbitration, as many as all teams combined in the previous two offseasons.
• Teams will pay the 14 players who went to arbitration $57.925MM next season, saving a total of about $1.5MM versus the midpoints between those 14 players’ proposed figures and those of their teams.
• There appears to be no obvious pattern in which players won and which lost (which isn’t necessarily surprising, since the terms of each arbitration hearing are set ahead of time by the teams and agents who determine the figures, and not by the arbitrators). As CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman notes (via Twitter), better established players (like Josh Donaldson, Neil Walker and Mat Latos) mostly lost their hearings, while players coming off mediocre or poor seasons, like Pedro Alvarez, Mark Trumbo and Mike Minor, won theirs.
• In terms of overall dollar value, Donaldson might be the player most affected by the result of his hearing, which he lost. There was a fairly large gap (over $1.4MM) between his proposed figure and that of the Blue Jays. Donaldson is also a Super Two player in the midst of his first year of arbitration eligibility, and his salary for 2015 could impact his salary in the next three seasons after that.