Headlines

  • Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.
  • Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment
  • Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
  • Braves Select Craig Kimbrel
  • Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox
  • White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Cubs, Diamondbacks No Longer In Mix For Shelby Miller

By Mark Polishuk | December 8, 2015 at 12:15pm CDT

Shelby Miller is still an Atlanta Brave as of this morning, though trade winds are swirling around the right-hander.  Here’s the latest…

  • While the Orioles have inquired on Miller, per Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports (Twitter links), there does not appear to be a match since Atlanta obviously seems to be angling for bats.
  • The Cubs are also “not currently in [the] mix” for Miller, Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports tweets, joining Arizona in that regard. While the Dodgers have had conversations with the Braves, it’s “unclear” where they stand, per Rosenthal.
  • The Diamondbacks appear to have “moved their attention away” from Miller, Mark Bowman of MLB.com tweets. There are still multiple clubs involved on the righty, however, Bowman adds.

Earlier Updates

  • The Braves reportedly made progress on a Miller deal and a trade could happen as soon as today, CBS Sports’ Jon Heyman tweets (and expands upon further in a report today).  Braves management met “late into [the] night” discussing Miller.
  • The Diamondbacks are still hopeful they’ll be the team to obtain Miller today, USA Today’s Bob Nightengale reports (Twitter link).  Atlanta and Arizona have had several talks about Miller, though the D’Backs have turned down at least two offers that would’ve sent A.J. Pollock to the Braves.
Share 47 Retweet 10 Send via email0

Arizona Diamondbacks Atlanta Braves Los Angeles Dodgers Shelby Miller

Infield Notes: Zobrist, Davis, Lind, Moreland, Walker, Angels, Flowers, Reynolds, Matsuda
Main
Diamondbacks Designate A.J. Schugel
View Comments (130)
Post a Comment

130 Comments

  1. ScottySmalls25

    10 years ago

    The Braves are ridiculous. They just acquired Miller last season! He deserves to be their ace! How can anyone root for this team? They’re turning into the Marlins! Immediately dishing any talent. Appalling.

    Reply
    • Jordan R.

      10 years ago

      I think it’s going to be another year before we can make that call. I’ll admit I am a little disappointed as well being a Braves fan, but their strategy (so they say) has been to be a contender in 2017. They’ve acquired exactly 30 pitchers I believe since last off-season, so if 5 of those guys couldn’t theoretically rise to the top and be viable options in an MLB Rotation, the Braves brass has fallen far short of expectations.

      Reply
      • thebare54

        10 years ago

        Hey the Cubs Astros A’s

        Reply
    • Mike Query

      10 years ago

      If you dont understand whats happening, by all means, go root for someone else.

      Reply
      • Ragin' Cajun Brave 2

        10 years ago

        THANK YOU!!!!!!

        Reply
    • RunDMC

      10 years ago

      Jordan, with all due respect, you don’t understand what’s going on. I think they’d be insane to sit on Miller, who I really like, with how much starting pitching is being valued at. Ridiculous? It’s ingenious. Think about it. They acquired Miller (and 4 years of control, now 3) and one of their top pitching prospects in Tyrell Jenkins for 1 year of Heyward, whom they knew was not going to re-sign. Now, ATL can possibly flip Miller for offensive help? Great deal. If they don’t get the deal they want they can sit on him and try and re-sign him when resources great increase in ”2017. This is how you build a winning ball team. Take note, AJ Preller.

      Reply
      • Jordan R.

        10 years ago

        I think you misunderstood what I was saying. I am for them flipping pitching for hitting. I guess I failed to make my argument clear. I was trying to say that Miller is essentially disposable to the Braves because of all the talent they’ve acquired for Pitching of late. I was also a little misleading on my 30 pitchers comment. What I was trying to say is it will be hard for me to believe we can’t find 5 guys in that crop of talent that could rise to the top and be viable starting pitching guys. If there ARE NOT 5 guys out of that group, than the Braves Brass has fallen short of expectations. (I’m sure we easily have 5 future studs for rotation opps).

        Reply
    • christian18cutshaw

      10 years ago

      Harts clearly said he’s getting calls and he’s listening he’s said what it would take to get the job done. An impact bat and an MLB ready pitcher and they’re sticking to it obviously seeing how it’s the braves and Shelby’s not gone yet. They have a ton of pitching and no position players. I don’t think Shelby is near the pitcher he’s put out to be after one good year not even that. Half a year. And some can blame it on the bull pen and he was left in too long but an elite pitcher as he’s put out to be should be able to go 8 innings without a problem. I don’t want Baez if the braves could get Soler, Panik, Duffy it would be great. But if they do go for Baez, Inciarte, Peralta I think they could get that potential impact bat and the mlb ready pitcher they’re looking for.

      Reply
    • dalealvingribble

      10 years ago

      Shelby Miller did have a great season in Atlanta, but judging by his win / loss record. You see how many holes that The Braves have currently. Shelby pitched great but we did not have enough offense and the bullpen was bad. The fact that The Braves are shooting for someone like an A.J. Pollock in trade discussions even though they won’t get him. Shows the type of return that it would take to pry Miller away. The Braves are working to get prospects with as many years of control as possible and / or MLB ready players who have good value. As many of these cheaper controllable players you get to graduate to your roster from the minors. The more money you have to spend when you are closer to contention.

      The Braves have totally rebuilt the farm system through shrewd moves. Acquiring extra draft picks, preparing to spend huge in the international market, and acquiring extremely high upside players albeit some with risks. The only deal that I can’t wrap my mind around is The Hector Olivera / Alex Wood trade. Other than that I personally trust the Braves front office.

      People complain about The Braves becoming cheap and being like the Marlins. When the truth is The Braves are still rebuilding, and with Rebuilding you move your most valuable and typically most expensive assets. I mean anyway you slice it. The Braves at present are a non-playoff team with or without Shelby Miller. The absolute high water mark for this team in wins in 2016 is 75 and that is if everything goes perfectly. So if you can deal Miller now before his arbitration numbers start to get more expensive and he has that extra year of control that teams will pay handsomely for. You pull the trigger on it. The Braves will have to receive enough high end prospects / or a solid regular MLB who will be with the club for several years to come to pull the trigger though.

      Reply
      • braves25

        10 years ago

        The Olivera/Wood trade is not done yet. Like you said they are collecting draft picks, which they also got in this trade. That pick will not be made until July and that is where the Braves good possibly make or break this trade. Maybe someone like Daz Cameron drops in the draft due to the amount of money he wants and Atlanta is able to snag him and pay him there, like the Astros were able to. Just a thought.

        Reply
    • williamg

      10 years ago

      I think they are trying to put similar team Astros have cheap young talent.

      Reply
  2. Joe Covert

    10 years ago

    Atlanta can have Blaire/Shipley with O’Brien.

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      10 years ago

      Laughable return for an elite arm like Miller.

      Reply
      • David 8

        10 years ago

        Miller is not an “elite arm.” He had a very fine first half and was slightly above average in the second half. All things considered (not taking 2015 by itself), Julio is currently ATL’s #1 starter.

        Reply
      • tom brunanskys black sock

        10 years ago

        Elite? Uhhh

        Reply
    • wb89

      10 years ago

      Include Lamb, and I would pull the trigger

      Reply
  3. prestigeworldwide

    10 years ago

    I think AZ is where he is going unless Baez is being offered by the cubs

    Reply
    • tim815

      10 years ago

      I;m a Cubs fan. I chased Javy across the Midwest League at various stadia in the League.

      I would have thought Atlanta shot it down.

      Reply
      • Jordan R.

        10 years ago

        I’m pretty confident the Cubs won’t get Miller without Soler. That seems most practical from a Braves Fans POV

        Reply
  4. bravesfan22 3

    10 years ago

    Glad Baez deal didn’t happen. Would much rather see a package with Soler or a package from dbacks for pollock.

    Interested to see if bethancourt will be involved in these talks and if we trade for Soler does that mean Markakis would be made available or would Soler play center?

    Reply
    • williamg

      10 years ago

      Lucky as seems to be out

      Reply
  5. mmlotto0707

    10 years ago

    Baez and Hendricks

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      10 years ago

      This will get it done, IMO.

      Reply
      • Mike Query

        10 years ago

        Braves want no part of Baez, he goes completely against the philosophy new management has imposed since taking over.

        Reply
        • HalosFan

          10 years ago

          You have no proof of this. Baez was a different player after he came up last year. He has an unreal upside. The power for a mid infielder is ridiculous. If I’m the Cubs, no way do I include Baez for just Miller. And what’s their new philosophy? Guys with no power like Markakis?

          Reply
          • Jordan R.

            10 years ago

            Their philosophy is contact hitters with high OBP. I agree with Mike, the Braves just got done tearing down a team filled with guys like Baez.. As far as your “unreal upside”, that might be true, however he is still considered a prospect by most peoples evaluations. And a sample size of <100 AB's does not allude to him being a different player. He's a gamble

            Reply
          • Mike Query

            10 years ago

            You have no proof im wrong. What was the point of that comment? They’re trying to build the team around pitching and getting on base, like the old Braves, like the Royals that have been the best team in baseball the last two years.

            Why am I discussing anything with someone who puts stock in 76 at bats though, and yeah compltely different player in those 76 at bats, he only struck out 33% of the time instead of 50%, how exciting.

            Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          10 years ago

          Right, and Baez has improved his game to where he’s striking out much less. Might want to pay attention to baseball more closely, as things like that change quite often. As it stands now Baez is a plus 2B/SS defender with a top of the order bat. Only problem, the Cubs have two of those already, ergo a trade of Baez for Miller makes a ton of sense for both sides.

          Reply
          • Mike Query

            10 years ago

            Yeah, were arguing about a baseball trade in December at 10am regarding a prospect, a poor attempt at insulting the other person for not knowing about baseball is a pretty dumb move, no?

            Im not in the business of putting a ton of stock in 76 at bats, or thinking that a strikeout rate of 33 percent, or 25 in the minors is some huge feat that should be celebrated. This is the nature of prospects, sometimes people/teams dont like a certain prospect that everyone else loves.

            Reply
    • Joe McMahon

      10 years ago

      Hendrick and Miller are very similar.Both solid #3 starters who had extremely similar years last year. In that situation,there is absolutely no reason to add Baez, Hendrick for Miller would be far enough by itself. Maybe a small prospect going to the Braves as well.

      Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        10 years ago

        Miller had a 3.5 bWAR last year, Hendricks had a 1.8. so no, they are not “very” similar.

        Reply
        • Joe McMahon

          10 years ago

          Miller had a 3.4 fWAR last year, Hendricks had a 3.4, so ye, they are “very”similar.

          Reply
          • bhambravesfan

            10 years ago

            I’ve seen this brought up multiple times. Hendricks threw 20 less innings, had an era almost a full run above Miller and projects to do the same again. fWAR is not everything when evaluating pitchers.

            Reply
          • chesteraarthur

            10 years ago

            It’s easy to have a good era when you have simmons at ss. Look at their fip and xfip. Hendricks also projects (steamer) to be better than miller next year.

            Reply
  6. WisBrave 2

    10 years ago

    Braves should target Almora or Happ instead as a center peace to a deal and get C.Villanueva tossed in with the deal.

    Reply
    • mmlotto0707

      10 years ago

      Baez can play the whole infield. That’s who the braves want

      Reply
      • tim815

        10 years ago

        He’s playing CF in Winter Ball.

        Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          10 years ago

          He’s playing CF for the first time just in case he gels there the Cubs won’t have to trade him, but playing a plus 2B/SS defender in CF is a real waste. Miller is a better fit in Chicago and Baez is better in Atlanta.

          Reply
          • chesteraarthur

            10 years ago

            He played cf a lot in hs and claims he likes it, color me curious. Is Mookie Betts playing CF a real waste? The cubs have tons of MIF prospects and no cf. There also aren’t a ton of cfs available via trade or free agency, so if Baez can hold his own there, it’d be helpful to the team, at least for this year.

            Reply
      • WisBrave 2

        10 years ago

        Then they shouldn’t have dumped Peraza.

        Reply
        • bhambravesfan

          10 years ago

          I’m not sure Peraza will ever be more than a backup infielder/4th OF type with great speed.

          Reply
          • WisBrave 2

            10 years ago

            I see him as as a younger version of O.Infante with better arm and plus speed. But we’ll see, just my opinion.

            Reply
        • braves25

          10 years ago

          The Dodgers have Peraza now and they don’ want to play him either.

          Reply
    • tim815

      10 years ago

      I’m fine with the framework there, as well.

      Reply
  7. southi

    10 years ago

    Even though the braves have insisted supposedly on getting Pollock or proven major league hitters, if the D-backs overwhelmed them with an offer of Blair, Shipley, O’Brien and Lamb it would be a no brainer for them to pull the trigger. That type scenario would be extremely unlikely though. I do believe that Hart/Coppy is looking to get overwhelmed however.

    Now personally if I was offered Baez and Hendricks I’d agree quickly even with Baez high K history.

    Reply
    • pronk19

      10 years ago

      Lmao! That’s a package you offer for a guy like gray not 3/4 starter like Shelby. Inciarte and Anderson/godley is a more reasonable offer

      Reply
      • Admiral Rusty T. Shackleford

        10 years ago

        I want some of what you’re smoking

        Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        10 years ago

        lol none of those guys are even that good, AZ doesn’t have a good farm system. O’Brien is a DH at best.

        Reply
  8. Voice of Reason

    10 years ago

    Miller will end up with the Cubs.
    Baez for miller.

    Reply
    • seamaholic 2

      10 years ago

      Braves have already rejected this … and for good reason. They have little interest in Baez. Cubs fans are really and truly delusional about his value.

      Reply
  9. braves833

    10 years ago

    I don’t see where Baez alone is enough for Miller. With Coppy’s & Hart’s love for pitching and small ball I doubt they value him and his strikeouts as being enough for Miller.

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      10 years ago

      Baez & Kendrick for Miller and a teenage prospect is a fair deal for both.

      Reply
      • tryptamine

        10 years ago

        In what world is that fair? Kyle Hendricks himself may be as valuable as Shelby Miller.

        Shelby 2015: 3.45FIP 4.07xFIP 3.4fWAR 4.16SIERA 7.5K/9 3.2BB/9

        Hendricks 2015: 3.36FIP 3.25xFIP 3.4fWAR 3.37SIERA 8.35K/9 2.15BB/9

        Baez and Hendricks? You’re absolutely kidding yourself.

        Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          10 years ago

          Nope, not kidding myself. Just aware that trades are not 100% dependent on stats.

          Reply
          • prestigeworldwide

            10 years ago

            yeah, screw objectivity,

            Reply
          • Joe McMahon

            10 years ago

            Well, Hendricks has a better hair cut than Miller and he also has a nicer car, so he wins there too.

            Reply
    • keepthecore

      10 years ago

      From Bret Taylor: Consider this: how many big-time, young, controllable positional players are you hearing about on the rumor mill besides Baez (and Soler)? Virtually none. For all the talk of controllable pitching being valuable because of the pricey free agent market, at least those arms are plentiful and available. The same does not appear to be true on the positional side, especially when you’re talking about guys who are controllable for as long as Baez and Soler are.

      Reply
    • Mike Query

      10 years ago

      Yup, certain people keep completely ignoring the Braves direction towards an OBP based team, they dont want a guy thats going to strike out 250 times, Frank Wren isnt our GM anymore. I dont care how highly ranked Baez was/is, he doesnt fit this team.

      Reply
      • Admiral Rusty T. Shackleford

        10 years ago

        Hart & Co. have been saying they want to acquire a young power bat for over a year now. You really think they’d let a high K rate for a 22-year old stand in the way of that?

        Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        10 years ago

        Baez doesn’t K as much anymore though, he fixed his approach. Did you know players are allowed to improve? Crazy right???

        Reply
        • braves25

          10 years ago

          A K rate of 31% in 76 at bats is considered “fixing” his approach? Well that is bette then 44%. He also showed a lot less power, only 1 hr, in those 76 at bats. Give him 500 at bats at the MLB level I bet he has 175-200 k’s and 15-18 hrs.

          Reply
  10. kevb201336

    10 years ago

    I saw where Cubs/Rays were in discussions centered around Baez. Braves were focused on Soler. I’d be okay if Cubs could get Odorizzi and Miller and use their FA money on Heyward and maybe Parra.

    Reply
    • braves25

      10 years ago

      Rays are talking to Odorizzi about an extension. I don’t believe he is being traded.

      Reply
    • superman 2

      10 years ago

      There is no guarantee the Cubs are getting Heyward. You want to trade Baez/Soler and get Odorizzi and Miller? You’re stupid. Bats are better than arms.

      Reply
  11. Mikel Grady

    10 years ago

    Arrieta Lester odorizzi Miller lackey (Hendricks)

    Heyward
    Schwarber
    Rizzo
    Bryant
    Castro
    Russell
    Coughlan
    Montero

    I’m liking it a lot

    Reply
  12. Backatitagain

    10 years ago

    Braves should just Add Heyward(10/220, back loaded some to average 20 mil for first five years), Add Flowers(3/10), Trade Markakis for a prospect or draft choice or Third Base upgrade(Lawrie, Plouff, etc.) This adds 12-15 Million to the payroll within the budget. Keep Miller and Teheran. Far better approach than all of the trade proposals for Miller or Teheran. If we can’t get Heyward for 220 million then there are others just as good that we can get.

    If a trade is inevitable do a simple deal with Boston Red Sox. Shelby Miller plus a pitching prospect(Prospect 9-15, ie. Ellis, Jenkins, Bird) for Jackie Bradley(impact bat?) and a Left handed 3-5 starter such as Owens, Rodriguez, Johnson(#3).

    Other than that, do nothing keep the roster and save the money until halftime.

    Reply
    • RunDMC

      10 years ago

      Braves fan here, I’d rather the $220M than Heyward. No thanks. Odd that your plan is to reacquire 2 former Braves (JHey, Flowers). A 3-year contract for him would be a head-scratcher. And Dombrowski will want more for Bradley than that, guaranteed. I like Bradley, but we have Mallex Smith waiting in the wings.

      Reply
    • JT19

      10 years ago

      So a #2 prospect, a mid level prospect for an elite defensive glove (and still young and promising bat) and a top pitching prospect? Oh man Braves fans are great.

      Reply
  13. degrominance

    10 years ago

    Trout
    Stanton
    pollok
    Donaldson
    harper
    Rizzo
    Heyward
    Cespedes
    Altuve

    I’m likkng this as a revamped mets lineup

    Reply
    • Joe McMahon

      10 years ago

      I love it. Might I suggest trading Cespedes for Buster Posey though? Your team needs a catcher and Posey is better anyway. The lineyp could look like this:

      Pollock: CF
      Stanton: DH
      Harper: LF
      Trout: SS
      Donaldson: 3B
      Posey: C
      Rizzo: 1B
      Heyward:: RF
      Altuve: 2B

      Nice lineup right there…….

      Reply
      • A'sfaninUK

        10 years ago

        No decaying corpse of Mordecai 3 Finger Brown, no World Series. Sorry.

        Reply
      • bhambravesfan

        10 years ago

        In 5 years it will look more like
        Reyes: SS
        Hamilton: LF
        Kemp: CF
        Braun: LF
        Beltre: 3B
        Vmart: C
        Fielder:1B
        Reyes: SS
        Uggle: 2B

        Reply
    • Nick Lastname

      10 years ago

      I never knew Altuve could pitch as well. Just boosts his value, I guess. 😉

      Reply
    • firstbleed

      10 years ago

      lol.

      Reply
  14. littleauditorium

    10 years ago

    If the Dimondbacks trade Pollock for Miller their offseason is ruined

    Reply
  15. yeage004

    10 years ago

    I hate to see Shelby go. However what kind of package would it take to get Todd Frazier

    Reply
  16. Los Calcetines Rojos

    10 years ago

    I really don’t see a trade where Baez by himself becomes Shelby Miller or as some are saying on other threads Baez/Soler for Miller+. Braves did that their fans would kill them for letting Heyward go for, in reality, nothing. It’s not realistic to trade for talent without giving up talent that’s how trades work. A relative unknown that’s built on potential v. a proven starter that is arguably an ace but typically one of the best #2’s in the league looks like a trade out of a video game.

    Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      10 years ago

      The only people arguing that he is an ace or one of the best #2’s are Braves fans.

      Reply
  17. ray1

    10 years ago

    Makes you wonder why both the Cardinals and Braves would give up on Miller so soon.

    Reply
  18. cjh815

    10 years ago

    For all you people who think miller and Tehran are worth to prospects well I have show you all . For all you fans of other team
    Here is list of 25 year pitchers

    Player. W–L— era—-g—Ings.—so—-whip
    A. 6. 17. 3.02. 33 205.1. 171. 1.247
    B. 10. 8. 5.05. 22 118.1. 93. 1.458
    C. 14 12. 3.70. 32. 202. 136. 1.396
    D. 8. 11. 3.18. 26. 161. 134. 1.147
    E. 12 13. 3.48. 34. 224.1. 218. 1.137
    F. 12. 11. 3.22. 28. 192.2. 172. 1.173
    G. 11. 17. 4.84. 33. 201.1. 163. 1.403
    H. 14 14. 3.47. 33. 233. 222. 1.220
    I. 14. 5. 5.43. 33. 179. 161. 1.503
    J. 10. 11. 4.32. 32. 193. 168. 1.268
    K. 12. 8. 3.85. 31. 215. 184. 1.107
    L. 15. 8. 3.41. 32. 203. 225. 1.230

    If lol at they stats you see how close they are . So you tell me miller or Tehran who is a year young . And has close they are to same players

    Reply
  19. yeage004

    10 years ago

    What kind of deal are the Reds looking for Todd Frazier

    Reply
  20. cjh815

    10 years ago

    Ow I left off this 25 player

    M. 11-10. 4.33. 30. 176. 152. 1.285

    Reply
  21. cjh815

    10 years ago

    Just so all know who these 25 old player

    Play names
    A Shelby miller
    B jake arrieta
    C Adam wainwright
    D Jordan Zimmerman
    E David price
    F. CC Sabathia
    G. Justin verlander
    H. Felix Hernandez
    I Cliff lee
    J. Cole hamels
    K. James shields
    L. John Lester
    M. Jared weaver
    All at age 25 tell know all you fans of other team that Braves should get top prospect for them

    Reply
    • nikogarcia

      10 years ago

      Coming from a Cubs fan, Arrieta was not worth top prospects at age 25. We paid a back up catcher and fifth rotation arm for him at age 27

      Reply
      • cjh815

        10 years ago

        But look what he became two years later

        Reply
  22. bravesfan13

    10 years ago

    Why can’t the braves realize that in order to contend they need to keep young talent instead of trading them away. Shelby could anchor our rotation for a long time. Make the trades stop already and spend the money to get great franchise changing players

    Reply
    • cjh815

      10 years ago

      To all Braves fans the real reason for Braves trading all are players or that they could resign Heyward or Upton . It wasn’t because they had bad farm system (because that could be fixed bye drafting and developing better player. It not because they didn’t have the money or bad TV deal. Braves fan front office has been trying to put red carpet over brave nation eyes. The real reason is liberty media is trying to set up a sale for the Braves . There try to prove prospective buyers . They had one trim the fat. Take it down the bare minimum . To let other future buy what there potential earnings that why they building the new stadium so that chance to show more future earning to the future buyer . So fellow brave fan we are going to have to what tell we get new owner ship for brave to win again . Because when library media bout the brave they did it as a favor to mlb . So sad as it is this what really going on . Company like library media have stock holders that they have to answer to. And these stock holder want best for there buck. This kind of stuff happen all the time in stock market . Company will take there stock down so they can sell it low . In hope that can find someone buy it knowing that stock will go up and they make more money . So it win both party’s . The old own can sell it because there goon to make initial earning and buy is banking on long term investment. So I hope his answer every body question why this is going on with the Braves.

      Reply
  23. cjh815

    10 years ago

    Bye the way I’m not new age number cruncher who live bye the number I’m old school guy

    Reply
  24. Joe McMahon

    10 years ago

    The Cubs and Dbacks are both out. Slowly teams are realizing that the Braves don’t actually want to move him and that the price tag is insane. The Braves are basically like “He’s not available but if you want to blow us away with a huge offer, go ahead.” Miller will be in Atlanta on Opening Day.

    Reply
    • braves25

      10 years ago

      As a Braves fan I am 100% ok with this. It is how it should be!! Keep Miller unless blown away with more then what he is actually worth.

      Reply
      • williamg

        10 years ago

        You never know they might be convinced to take more on the lower end talent than the kind they want

        Reply
    • prestigeworldwide

      10 years ago

      just wasting teams time. If they really wanted a young controllable bat with good defense and a near ready top pitching prospect….its already been offered by the Dbacks. Peralta./Inciarte along with Bradley/Blair/Shipley. time to move on..

      Reply
      • Acuña Matata

        10 years ago

        How is that wasting teams time? Just because you like the deal means jack all… Offer what the Hart and Co. wants or step off. Its that simple. Its business. The only person wasting time is the Dbacks. They know exactly who the Braves want. Either cough it up or move on like they have.

        Reply
        • prestigeworldwide

          10 years ago

          calm down lol. Atl is the one shopping Miller and calling on every team to whip up interest. Asking for Severino, Pollock, Baez/Soler, etc is a bit much and few (other than braves fans) would disagree. Millers advanced metrics are that of a back of the rotation starter than an Ace or number 2 some braves fans are proclaiming. 2013-2015 stats 3.25 walks per 9. 3.87 Fip xFip 4.10. The stats dont lie. That being said he is young, could improve and does eat some innings.
          BTW, the Dbacks are the ones rejecting the multiple offers from ATL and Miller not the other way around.

          Reply
          • Acuña Matata

            10 years ago

            Not true at all. Braves didn’t call anyone. They called BACK to make a counter offer to the Dbacks original inquiry.

            Stats dont lie eh? Sure as hell lied to the dbacks then. I’ll take it. kthx

            Reply
    • Acuña Matata

      10 years ago

      No the Cubs are said to be “not currently in the mix”. Thats not “THE CUBS ARE OUT”. The Winter Meetings have barely started and you’ve already declared that hes staying put. Based on what? A rumor from a rumor site? Thats a bang up job detective

      Reply
  25. dj227

    10 years ago

    So is anyone else hearing that the Cubs are actually getting serious about sending Baez, Soler, and Hammels to Atlanta for Miller, Williams Perez, and a currently unknown player? I just read it on another site and was wondering if it could be legit.

    Reply
    • nikogarcia

      10 years ago

      No chance that the Cubs move soler and baez in the same trade for less than an ace much less Miller. One of those two alone are arguably enough to bring Miller back

      Reply
    • MLB4LIFE

      10 years ago

      You probably read it on the Braves Weekly….No chance

      Reply
  26. 2016aAintSoBad

    10 years ago

    #KeepShelbyMiller!

    Reply
  27. azbravesfan

    10 years ago

    I’d like to see Miller and some prospects for cargo

    Reply
    • bhambravesfan

      10 years ago

      Cargo is expensive and not great away from Coors. Wouldn’t fit the idea of unloading to spend big internationally. I love cargo though. I wanted him for Heyward + prospect when I thought we were still holding everyone else

      Reply
      • seamaholic 2

        10 years ago

        I’ll look forward to the first time I see someone comment that Pitcher A, who’ s leaving Seattle or San Francisco or Tampa, should really only be judged on their road numbers as they pitched in an extreme pitcher friendly park.

        And I’ll be waiting a long, long time.

        Reply
        • chesteraarthur

          10 years ago

          There are stats that look at a pitcher in a neutral environment, so that kind of helps, but I’ve definitely heard this. How many people have talked about the effect of petco on a pitcher and revitalizing their careers.

          Reply
    • seamaholic 2

      10 years ago

      Cargo doesn’t make sense, as he’s only got 2 years left. But other Rockies outfielders might, starting with Corey Dickerson.

      Reply
  28. williamg

    10 years ago

    Lookes like cubs and az are probably out on miller. Dodgers are sorta in. Wonder if their is going to be a mystery team to go after him

    Reply
  29. cjh815

    10 years ago

    Once again to every body who think Braves asking to much for Shelby miller and Julio Tehran read my post above you will see how Shelby 25 compared to other great pitcher at the same age then tell me he not worth kings ransom

    Reply
    • MLB4LIFE

      10 years ago

      Kings ransom for a # 3 lol

      Reply
      • prestigeworldwide

        10 years ago

        Braves fans are funny.

        Reply
      • cjh815

        10 years ago

        Hate to tell you no Braves just because guy can hit 95 to 100 doesn’t make a ace . The easer gun is over rated . Are you tell me that kuechel or cole hamels are not ace . Because they throw 93 to 92 are you tell me that Tom glavine , Greg maddux , jimmy key , Andy petititte or Barry zito or mark buehler where not aces really .

        Reply
    • JT19

      10 years ago

      So your idiotic post, which compares the age 25 seasons of established aces and Shelby Miller. Your theory is that because these guys are aces now, Miller is an ace because his numbers are slightly similar and should in theory require a top prospect haul. You claimed to be an old school numbers guy. Nothing more old school than wins-losses which Miller has the worst record, which in your crazy theory, would make Miller the least valuable at the time (and probably only more valuable than Lee and Sabathia currently).

      Reply
  30. cjh815

    10 years ago

    Bye the way the post that Arizona and Cubs are out is joke .you know how many time team a said there out then few days later they come make make the trade . I can’t count how many times that happen . It’s call posturing . They trying get brave comes down on there price but when they don’t and they realize that if they want a play they finally give in . So I give no thought that Cubs and dbacks are out. Please child

    Reply
  31. cjh815

    10 years ago

    The post that Arizona and Cubs are out of the Shelby miller sweep stakes . I can’t count the many time that teams have said there out on player x . To only give in few days later . When they realize that the other team is not bugging on there cost . So this called pondering. They hoping Braves will get nervous and come back with less price. Which braves won’t because they don’t need to trade either Shelby or Julio . And dback and Cubs want to win know and they both need pitching to win. Because at end of the day pitching wins games not slugging or ops. And end of day dbacks are going against dodger and Giants and Cubs are going against cards and pirates and they both know they need great pitching to beat there rivals plane and simple

    Reply
    • Niekro

      10 years ago

      100 percent correct his value can get much higher at the trade deadline Braves have no reason to take a light offer. Phillies ended up getting a better package for Hamels by waiting until the deadline, they ended up with a huge haul.

      Reply
      • Niekro

        10 years ago

        To clarify not expecting a Hamels package just that not settling for what the Red Sox were offering was one of the smartest thing Amaro ever did as a GM.

        Reply
      • bravos4evr

        10 years ago

        more risk there too tho, if Miller gets hurt or has a slow start, POOF! value gone

        Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      10 years ago

      Or teams come back if the team drops its price. The cubs don’t need pitching right now and even if they did there are still many options available, I think this is more just the reactions by teams who feel the braves are asking for a ridiculous return on Miller. I don’t understand why braves fans seem to think it’s everything other than that.

      Reply
  32. greatd

    10 years ago

    Astros could swoop in and make this happen.

    Reply
  33. gojira15

    10 years ago

    I think teams are wising up to reality and backing off this overpay situation. Miller is a really nice pitcher but he’s no ace yet.

    Reply
  34. HibbardsHustler

    10 years ago

    To the Jays for Saunders dicky and Thole !!! Come on Shipiro

    Reply
    • bjf625

      10 years ago

      No thanks! Now a package of miller for max Pentecost I’m intrigued I’d like to get one of yalls of prospects too

      Reply
  35. chicubbies1

    10 years ago

    Good. Cubs came tot heir senses like I was hoping they would yesterday. Miller….. overrated.

    Reply
    • Jon429

      10 years ago

      “Shelby Miller’s past 40 starts: 2.86 ERA and .230 opponents’ average with 203 strikeouts and 82 walks in 248 2/3 innings” (Quoted from DOB, AJC Braves beat writer)

      Yeah, with those numbers, how dare Atlanta ever think they could get anything of value! They’d be lucky to even get pennies on the dollar!

      Seriously good luck getting any pitcher with those numbers without giving up top players in return.

      Reply
      • chesteraarthur

        10 years ago

        Why is he using 40 games? That K:BB ratio is also less than stellar.

        Reply
  36. cjh815

    10 years ago

    That where you all don’t get it team are don’t made trade for what player have down they trade for what play can be. They what play with up side that going to help them win . And like said above Shelby miller and Julio Tehran have 25 24 both and still on the same path a other great pitches like post I showed above talk time to look at it . Bye way for any one think Cubs don’t need starting pitch don’t understand where the do have two great pitcher .The reason they lost was they went against a team in met had 4 great pitches and pitching wins World Series And Cubs only had 2 and 2 4 starter

    Reply
    • prestigeworldwide

      10 years ago

      wtf?! engrish prease

      Reply
      • cjh815

        10 years ago

        First off think you speak English second for every body don’t think I make any since . I hate to tell you I have iq of 148 so before we talk about how smart someone is you need to know who you are talk about . I probably have under ware that older then you are

        Reply
        • prestigeworldwide

          10 years ago

          “I probably have under ware that older then you are” Best line ever!
          But honestly, I still don’t understand you. Do you mean English is your second language?

          Reply
    • chesteraarthur

      10 years ago

      The mets had better pitching and lost to the Royals. Boom, your argument fails. Regardless, even if whatever you are saying wasn’t ridiculous, Miller doesn’t add a torp. Finally, your posts are a garbled mess. Are you using an online translator or something?

      Reply
  37. cjh815

    10 years ago

    No it didn’t the reason royal bet the mets was that royal where total team . Met had better starters but royal had better bull pen/ defiance and timely hitting .Which what win in the play off and especially in World Series . So no argument didn’t fell . I was talk about why the mets beat the Cubs . And no I’m not using a translator I was born in Alexandra Virginia in 1973 . And second just because you don’t like what I have to say doesn’t mean that what I say doesn’t make since . Bye you need to know who you talk about. I have IQ of 148 and I’m old enough to remember last time the dodger won a World Series . You most like just kid that just about the number and radar gun right . Some kid that never play the game . There a reason why antic people don’t run front offices bye them self . Because sports are not just about the stats . The player are not a robots or a computer . There human beings . With minds and feelings . And if would understand this you understand better what make a player. If ever watched a Braves game not your team you realize that Shelby miller got the least run support in all of baseball . And when he didn’t get many run to play with he way trying to aim his pitches where to go not let them move . So his fast ball was strait and more hittable and when he gave up a run he would try harder and he gave up more hits that lead to more runs it was snow ball effect . And with ever lose it just got bigger. So before you speak know what your talking about

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.

    Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Evan Phillips To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    AJ Smith-Shawver Diagnosed With Torn UCL

    Reds Trade Alexis Díaz To Dodgers

    Rockies Sign Orlando Arcia

    Ronel Blanco To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Recent

    The Opener: Phillies, Wade, Perez, Dodgers, Padres

    Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.

    Blue Jays Notes: Scherzer, Varsho, Francis

    Pirates Reportedly Receiving Interest In Isiah Kiner-Falefa

    Angels Sign Ben Gamel To Minor League Deal

    Blue Jays Recall Spencer Turnbull For Season Debut

    Orioles Notes: Westburg, Mullins, O’Neill

    Tigers Notes: Vierling, Olson, Urquidy, Boyd

    Twins Place Zebby Matthews On 15-Day IL, Reinstate Danny Coulombe

    Yankees Claim CJ Alexander

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version