Red Sox lefty David Price announced today that he will not opt out of the remainder of his contract with the Red Sox, as Chris Cotillo of MassLive.com was among those to report on Twitter. The 33-year-old starter, who is fresh off of a redemptive run through the postseason for the World Series victors, will earn $31MM for the 2019 season and $32MM annually for the three campaigns that follow.
It’s no surprise, certainly, that Price has elected to stay in the deal that he inked in advance of the 2016 season. Though he has certainly had plenty of success during his first three campaigns in Boston, there have also been plenty of low points along the way.
At 33 years of age, it’s tough to imagine Price doing better than the four years and $127MM he already has in hand. That said, he would still have been a major part of the postseason picture had he elected to return to the open market.
In the just-completed campaign, Price threw 176 innings of 3.58 ERA ball, registering just over a strikeout per nine while allowing 2.6 BB/9. That represented a bounceback from an injury-marred 2017 campaign and an improvement on his bottom-line results (3.99 ERA) from 2016.
Of course, Price had also logged 230 frames in his first season with the Sox, a number he won’t likely approach again. And his peripherals have eroded since that time as well. Estimators valued his 2018 output well below his actual ERA, with FIP (4.02), xFIP (3.95), and SIERA (3.82) suggesting Price is now more a solid rotation presence than frontline starter.
Price’s postseason performance — which featured four excellent starts in the ALCS and World Series after a rough divisional outing — certainly showed that he can still get the job done when needed … and that he can do it on the big stage. That reversed a long run of difficulties in the postseason though it won’t turn back father time. Over the course of the 2018 campaign, Price’s average fastball (of both the four and two-seam varieties) clocked in at a personal-low 93.1 mph, while his swinging-strike rate dipped to 9.6% after sitting over 11% for the prior three seasons.
In any event, Price’s decision to opt in to the remainder of his deal at one point seemed likely to be met by widespread complaints from the Boston faithful. Instead, he’ll be lauded along with his teammates today in the club’s World Series parade. And while the expectations for the remainder of the contract will necessarily be tempered, the Red Sox have good cause to anticipate that Price will continue to be a worthwhile member of their rotation for some time to come.
I Believe We Can Win
In related news, water is wet.
tylerall5
Beat me to it
mark0817
Water isn’t wet. Water is a liquid that wets things. Once you come into contact with water you become wet. Until then water is a liquid and you are dry.
bobtillman
Scotch is a liquid that, when mixed with water, will make you feel dry when you are wet…..
Cat Mando
and sometimes wet your dry pants
Moonlight Grahamcracker
I bet you’re real fun at parties…
trident
We are solids that are dry. Water is a liquid that is wet.
xabial
Humans about 60% water, does that make us 60% dry?
xabial
*40% dry lol
mikeyank55
Price, “Are you kidding? There’s no other team that will screw up and make such a stupid money contract. I’m not letting the Red Sox off the hook. Everyone knows that I will be injured during the first half and then admit that I need TJ surgery. So I’m good to go and will collect around $65 million for ‘19 and ‘20 while I hang near home.
It’s all good.
Bruin1012
World Series go crawl back under your bridge or better yet go troll Mets articles World Series champions enough said.
mikeyank55
Oh Bruin…you are so cute skating around the rink, however now that you are 18 don’t you think that it’s time for mommy to get you big boy skates that don’t have the training blades?
I wasn’t commenting on the team, rather that there was no way that price would be stupid to let the team off the hook with the WORST free agent contract in their history.
Bruin1012
Mikey, Mikey, Mikey, worst contract in Red Sox history not. I think you would be hard pressed to find many in Red Sox nation that think he hasn’t earned every dollar of that contract. Anything the Red Sox get from Price from here on out is just gravy. DD bright Price in to be big part of winning a championship and guess what the Red Sox did and Price was a big reason why. Calling Prices contract as the worse in Boston history is asinine even for you. The Price is low right in Boston.
Bruin1012
“ the Price is right”
Frank Barrett
Price has hardly been the worst red sox free agent. Did you forgot carl c, hanley, pablo……..sure there have been many worse lesser signing far worse than price who even though was limited to 11 starts 1 year is still averaging13 wins a year not including playoffs. Which now in Boston is 1 playoff win a yearon average far more than alot of other players. And thus far price has been borderline better than sale in playoffs. In red sox uniforms
batty
Shocking!
377194
No reason for him to opt out. Good $$$ for a 33 year old on a WS winner.
lowtalker1
Right? Even though this post season was the best he has ever thrown, no one will at minimum match that annual offer.
stug14
You do know about the Mets, right? They would’ve offered 14 years @ $65 mil per…
RunDMC
That sounds like the deGrom extension that inevitably will happen if Van Wagenen is the only one at the table for talks arguing with himself.
xabial
“You do know about the Mets, right? They would’ve offered 14 years @ $65 mil per…”
Know this post is made in jest, but you give the Wilpons far too much credit, my friend.
Mets don’t spend on top FA; if they do, it’ll more or less likely be Tier-B-C FAs (Vargas, Bruce, Frazier..etc) only Tier-A at time, was their own FA. (Cespedes) and took a WS run
mikeyank55
If that’s the case then Abbott and Costello need to worry about the new GM gaming both ends.
bigalcathey
Over a strikeout per inning, not per 9
ac106
ugh
xabial
Fun fact: His 7 year 207M deal contains NO deferred money.
If Price does nothing from here on out, I’d say his deal more than paid for itself winning the clinching games of the 2018 ALCS and WS.
Meow Meow
Agreed, tbh. Price was even by far the most-valuable pitcher in Boston’s ill-fated ALDS last year, pitching out of the bullpen. His regular season numbers have been iffy, but he’s been showing up plenty in the postseason, which is what he’s really getting paid for.
Adam6710
I agree with you, but you can bet fans will not see it that way if he stinks for the rest of the deal and soaks up payroll. Fans (of all franchises) seem to forget the point of a deal, which is to win a World Series.
They got one, and he played a key role in getting it, so the deal is already worth it, even if he never wins another game.
Frank Barrett
I predict he will average 1t wins a season over next 4 yrs. And will have at least 1 by worthy year. Also think sox will repeat next year. Fyi not a sox fan (Rays). I have a feeling red sox may try to slip into harper race….nothing else to keep him away from nyy
MetsYankeesRedSox
I’d be interested to see his stats 162 games from when he announced he’s laying off all the video games he plays. I don’t remember when that announcement was made.
I’d like to think as he ages that he also matures as a pitcher and learn pitching versus throwing. Be nice to see them go back to back like the Dodgers did.
mikeyank55
And when you calculate the luxury tax for the next several years it’s a veritable bargain, right?
Bruin1012
And the troll comes out World Series Champs enough said.
mikeyank55
Not if you are John Henry though;)
yukongold
Should’ve been world series mvp. Lets see how he does next year vs the Yankees now that he knows how they know the first base coach was relaying signs on what was coming.
Ironman_4life
Good idea because the other 29 teams would never think of doing anything like that
mikeyank55
Speaking of Apple Watch—where was Peedie during the post season? He must have had a hand (pun intended) in the 2018 larceny.
dugdog83
He should not have been mvp. Pearce was the best player by far.
Meow Meow
Price was definitely the most valuable pitcher in the World Series, but Pearce pretty much single-handedly won two of the games. WPA is an estimation, of course, but Pearce’s (0.64) is so much higher than the next best (Price, at 0.46) that it seems outside of most reasonable error bounds.
MB923
Like all stats, WPA can be skewed.
It has Nathan Eovaldi witih a -0.018 WPA in his historic Game 3 performance of 6 IP, 1 ER (obviously being the decisive run which makes the WPA take the big hit). In Game 2, he only threw 1 inning and had a 0.078 WPA
I do agree about Pearce being MVP, though having co-MVP’s could have made sense too.
fasbal1
And starring David Price as Mr. Obvious
Foreveryankees
32mill a year for that!!
Cat Mando
Beats $21M+ a year for Ellbury
MetsYankeesRedSox
You win the MYR post of the day award.
driftcat28 2
At least Ells is gone in 2 years
Adam6710
What does it matter? He is paid to win, he helped win a World Series. End of story. With the money the Red Sox have, he was worth every penny.
jmi1950
Beats the NYYs who spent over 2 BILLION the last 9 years for ZERO trips to the WS.
bobtillman
Watching the Red Sox victory parade….knowing that somewhere in heaven Tom Yawkey is looking down at Price and Betts and JBJ……and screaming “What the f****k are they doing there??????”……
yukongold
And that is why Yawkey way is no longer.
HalosHeavenJJ
Have to give the new owners credit for distancing themselves from the Sox disgusting past. Paid settlements to the child rape victims, petitioned the city to change the street name, signed talent regardless of color (and look at the dividends that talent has paid)..
Eventually, players and fans of colors will be able to visit Fenway without being subject to the N bomb. Hopefully very soon.
Flapjax55
Sounds good! Great post.
Judge Judy
Sweet. 3WAR for the Yankees each year paid by the Sox.
kodion
lol
Watch him no-hit the Bronx Bomblers next season! … now that you’ve given him such a vote of confidence
MB923
Yes I’m sure he will read this comment and get a huge boost of confidence from it.
xabial
Im sure Price takes all posts from Red Sox fans to heart.
jmi1950
Ellsbury earned every penny of that 153 MM by helping the Sox win 2 WS. It was very nice of the NYYs to pay it.
Gordon Lightfoot
I thought Price’s demeanour during the Sox celebration, and later with the media, was interesting – he seemed to be brooding, as if he was working out an internal conflict. Competitive fellow and I commend his playoff performance.
Bruin1012
Price has earned his contract. Everyone plays to win a World Series and he has helped accomplish that. Thanks David Price anything else from Price is gravy here on out . Also DD had the balls to pull the trigger on some deals and signings that turned into a World Series great job DD as well. I am not sure what happens in the next few years, the Red Sox have a young nucleus, I’m sure they will be competitive but it’s all gravy after this year what a ride for us Red Sox fans.
triumph13
It’s easy to say that Bruin… and If we are talking about his making $30M this year I’d be right with you saying his performance this postseason was worth every penny and more. But if he opted out – wouldn’t most still sigh with relief?
As a Sox fan this season has been remarkable… greatest team in history. Dombrowski has been blasted by many, myself included, for giving this team a short window to compete for a championship. But he’s delivered inside of that window… and deserves praise for what he’s done.
jdgoat
That’s not really a good way of looking at it. Guys like Price and Heyward shouldn’t get a pass just because their teams won.
Bruin1012
Yes but Price was huge reason why they won the World Series. The Cubs won in spite of the struggles of Heyward. Price has earned his contract in my book and came through at the biggest moments when he was needed the most. David Price is just fine in my book and glad DD signed him.
Chriss
Funny how a few weeks change things. A month ago, if this article had been published, their would have been such a collective sigh from the Northeast, we would have heard it all the way down in Florida. Now, Sox fans are pretty much good with it…..
MB923
I think a majority of both Yankees and Red Sox fans are happy about this.
thefenwayfaithful 2
If you’d asked me this question 365 days ago I’d agree. Please David. Opt out! However I think advanced metrics are a little off on Price and aren’t factoring in his new found deceptiveness. He is willing to use 3 pitches on strike one instead of 2. He’s not afraid to go breaking ball or fastball on 3-2. It reminds me of Curt Schilling’s reimergence. Price never had to pitch. His stuff was that good. He’s stopped throwing and started pitching. The results were very real against very good teams.
I may be one of few Sox fans that says welcome back David Price and I strongly believe that he’s got 2 years as a huge part of the Sale/Price/Porcello combo if Sale resigns.
Flapjax55
Totally agree.
Lanidrac
I couldn’t really see any teams giving him a significantly better deal at his age even if he was still putting up Cy Young caliber numbers…well, maybe the Yankees, but even they’ve become relatively somewhat more frugal over the last few years
thefenwayfaithful 2
I tend to agree. He may have gotten something like 5/130 on the open market given his resume, but realistically at worst he’s leaving 5-10 million max benefit on the table and risking $126 million. Opting out never made sense. When it was signed the Sox didn’t care about the opt out because they knew in advance this was a 7 year deal. The opt out was almost more to the teams benefit then the player from day one. It was likely just a throw in so Price would have a hard time turning it down.