1:27pm: ESPN’s Jeff Passan tweets that hard-throwing righty Ray Black will also go to Milwaukee.
1:25pm: Lefty Drew Pomeranz is one player headed to the Brewers in the swap, tweets Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. If the Brewers are parting with a prospect of Dubon’s caliber, there’ll surely be other names in play.
1:23pm: The Brewers ad Giants are in agreement on a “significant” trade, reports Robert Murray of The Athletic (via Twitter). The big league players involved in the swap remain unknown, but well-regarded second base prospect Mauricio Dubon is headed from Milwaukee to San Francisco as part of the exchange. Madison Bumgarner is *not* going to Milwaukee, tweets MLB Network’s Jon Heyman.
In Dubon, the Giants will acquire a Major League-ready 25-year-old who can step directly onto the roster. Dubon’s 2018 season was cut short by a torn ACL, but he’s returned to bat .297/.333/.475 with 16 home runs, 22 doubles, a triple and nine steals in the hitter-friendly Triple-A Pacific Coast League. He’ll face a much more daunting offensive environment in the big leagues when he plays his home games at the cavernous Oracle Park in San Francisco.
Scouting reports on Dubon peg him as a hit-over-power prospect, and the move to Oracle Park doesn’t figure to do his power numbers any favor. But he’s never batted lower than .274 in a full minor league season, and he’s maintained strikeout rates south of 15 percent on a year-over-year basis. Dubon doesn’t walk much, but his knack for putting the ball in play should help his on-base skills in the big leagues. He’s considered capable of playing an average or better second base even after last year’s knee injury.
The veteran Pomeranz is the more well-known of the two arms being acquired by the Brewers, but he seems like a secondary piece in this swap. Pomeranz had an awful year in the Giants’ rotation but has garnered some attention following a (very) recent shift to the bullpen. In four relief outings, he’s tossed 5 1/3 shutout frames with just one hit and one walk allowed against eight strikeouts. The lefty has ample experience in the rotation and could return to that role if the Brewers feel he’s a mechanical adjustment or pitch-selection alteration away from returning to hi 2017 form, but his recent success in a return to the bullpen is more intriguing.
Black is already 29 years old but is the more appealing piece for Milwaukee. Durability has been an issue for the right-hander, but if he’s healthy he’ll be among the hardest-throwing pitchers in Major League Baseball. Black has averaged 99.1 mph on his heater in a tiny sample this season and regularly hits triple digits with a fastball that draws 80 grades on some scouting reports. Black has averaged nearly 17 strikeouts per nine innings pitched in his minor league career and might not even finish the season with a full year of MLB service, meaning he can be controlled through 2025.
Madbum
no madbum…
Not Bumgarner confirmed
MadBum???
Not Bumgarner. Relaxx!
ITS MAD BUM TIME
sounds a lot like the Kratz trade to me
Lol
This made me belly laugh
Not at all like the Kratz deal. This is the best deal of the day for the Giants. Dubon is a top prospect.
Probably Will Smith
Mad bum
If it’s not madbum or Smith than it isn’t significant
Bumgarner!!
Not Mad Bum
Will smith headed back to MIL
lol “Paul Molitor”
Who were you expecting, Gorman Thomas?
The Fresh Prince?
Drew pomeranz just traded
Watson?
Holmes?
Buehler?
It’s not MadBum or Will Smith
Will Smith
Drew Pomeranz?!? Well done Giants! Haha
LMAO
Yeah, that’s a light return for a good prospect. The Brewers already had the worst farm in the game, now it’s even worse. Gotta at least get Watson+ for an organizational top 3 prospect in an already depleted farm system.
Crawford
There goes madbum
If it’s for Bum or Smith, the Cards better get going if they want to keep competing.
MadBum
Lol. Pomeranz.
Significant trade for me to poop on.
HAHAHA Pomeranz…LMFAO
Not even the entire deal. Chill
no kidding, Black too, what a steal by SF
Yeah I mean I like black and his 105 MPH fastball but for Dubon? Gimme gimme gimme. Brewers got robbed
Yep
Pomeranz as reported by Rosenthal. Da fuq
pomaranz ik miss spelled
Pomegranate?
Roark to a’s
Pomeranz and ray black
“its not going to be madbum”
so madbum AND will Smith?
It’s for Pomeranz
dang that’s a steal for the Giants if Pomz is the headliner going to Milwaukee
This aged well lol
Smith or Dyson to Milwaukee
Complete robbery for Giants….Dubron can start NOW for Panic…..
The best trade so far. Zaidi looks brilliant for this one
I think all the Zaidi haters are gonna have to shut their mouths after this. A guy demoted to the bullpen and a 29 year old prospect in exchange for a guy who can start right now. This is amazing.
Ok, they say he can start right now, but at the same time the Brewers continued to roll out guys like Tyler Saladino, Hernan Perez, and an underachieving Orlando Arcia instead of giving him a chance, so it shows that maybe they weren’t as bullish on his outlook as some of these scouts.
Well the brewers just traded their number 3 prospect for a guy who was nearly DFA’d and a guy who has never had any sort of success at the big league level and is already 30 so maybe they should listen to the scouts more
True
Only giving up black and Pomeranz? Even better.
ROBBERY. Pomeranz and Black for Dubon? Lmfaooo what are you doing brewers
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!! What a fleece!!
This makes no sense
Pomeranz and Ray Black.
Highway robbery. Great move SF.
TWO castoffs for Dubon?
still a steal for SF
I’m sure it will be Smith headed back to the Brew Crew
already confirmed it’s not, but OK
Heyman confirmed it is not Smith too
I dont like your rather either.
Smart move by Zaidi. Young, athletic middle infielder who appears to have all the tools. Nice upgrade without giving up too much if it’s just Black and Pomeranz. They had to address 2b. Dubon is young and will have growing pains but a nice move towards the future. Maybe Panik gets released? Assuming Dubon will join the 25 man roster
Dubon may sit in minors till September call ups because Giants also scooped up Scooter Gennett from the Reds. This doesn’t look good for Joe Panik, who I’ve always liked but who has looked over-matched the last two years.
Zaidi=stud
LOL, Black and Pomeranz for Dubon, fleece job by SF
it’s buster
Another move that doesn’t move the needle…
I remember a poster saying Dubon would headline a deal for Smith lol. Good pickup for the Giants considering it was just spare parts
unreal really, what is milwaukee doing?
The gm must have done some lines before calling the giants lmao I can’t see any other way this deal gets done. This kind of steal doesn’t even happen in MLB the show
No madbum is not involved. Steal for the giants.
Pomeranz and Spin rate darling Ray Black going back. They’re banking on the spin rate and Pomeranz being an elite reliever. Dubon didn’t have a place in Milwaukee with Hiura. Good return for the Giants though. Dubon is better than panik tomorrow.
Didn’t have a place in Milwaukee? How about at SS where Arcia has routinely disappointed with the bat and forgotten how to play defense this season on top of it?
Turang is a MUCH better option at short. He’ll probably take another year at least to develop, but he’s the Crew’s SS of the future. Dubon projects as an average major league SS, so it’s better to trade him if the Crew won’t use him. Still disappointed by the return though.
Even I wouldnt have made this deal. i wish Dubon all the luck in the world have a good career.
If this is all there is with this trade, the Giants just robbed the Brewers blind. This is a GREAT TRADE! Dubon is a stud. We gave them very mediocre wobbly pitchers. Awesome move.
Thank you Mark A.
Love,
Theo E.
What does the Brewers owner and the Cubs GM have to do with any of this?
Brewers loading up on 4th and 5th starters hoping they strike 2018 Chacin gold again.
Nice i remember people saying Dubon for Will Smith was too much ahhaha
I guess Farhan knew what he was doing when he ignored the fan base who was calling for Pomeranz to be DFA’d a couple weeks ago. Nice pickup for essentially a bucket of balls and a rosin bag.
Contenders switching to plan B or maybe C.
Am I missing something? Dubon’s numbers aren’t off the charts, but he seems like a quality piece to give up for that return.
you’re missing nothing, just the Brewers overthinking themselves again, just like the off season,
wow nice pickup for Giants
dubon has played 2 big league games. he’s 25. i dont see it
And black is 29 and Pomeranz was almost DFAd
We trade raped em. Hhahahahahha. WS champs, odd year, take it to the bank.
Let’s not get ahead of ourselves.
SF did decide to go for it after all
I trust in Farhan!!!
Inconsistent Pomeranz and a wild fireballer for Dubon?! Hell yeah I’ll take it! Nice trade, Farhan!
Yikes. Milwaukee needed to aim higher. Pomerania isn’t any good.
I dont get it, Pomeranz sucks!
Been good since moving to the pen and the Brewers could definitely use some lefty pen help, but still…..
bummer to see black go, wanted to see him succeed in sf but a good return
He is almost 30. I was stoked on him a few years ago but if a guy like that hasn’t put it together yet he probably never will. Hopefully Dubon and Solano are starting at 2B and SS, and Panik and Crawford take their wet noodle bats to the bench or another team.
And Zaidi still has Smith, Watson, Dyson, Gott, and even Moronta to offer other contenders before the deadline, without mentioning Bumgarner. Well done.
And I think you wrote this post before they traded Melancon to the Braves. Happy to get some talent and/or salary relief back in exchange for spare parts.
Bro, the Brewers have 1 game better record then the GIants. Pomeranz is trash, got moved to the bullpen and had 2 good appearances. Thanks Brewers. Hhahahhaha
This make the Schoop trade look good.
Nah. At least there’s a little bit of reason behind this one. They need bullpen help and especially lefty help. The Schoop trade was for a scraping player at a position they didn’t need, and they gave up 2 prospects and an MLB player with pretty equal numbers to get him. Don’t like either trade, but I still think the Schoop one was worse than this….
Scraping player? At the time of last year’s deadline, Schoop was a raking player and I think Stearns was hoping that would continue after the deal… and into this season. That trade didn’t pan out. At all. The need was, of course, also questionable…, but what he dealt to Baltimore seemed like a fair deal at the time for a guy who appeared to be getting back to what he displayed in 2017. All star form.
All this trade really tells me is that they don’t think much of Dubon. That being the case, you would still think other teams would potentially value him more than this trade would indicate. Seems like the Brewers are not really adding salary in the moves they’re making.
He had had a hot 2 1/2 weeks before that trade, but was not having a good season as a whole and those 2 1/2 were more about running into some HRs and not acutally playing well rounded ball. And Villar who they gave back was also a former All-Star. That trade made zero sense to me. Shaw was playing at 2B, Villar was here, Ortiz and Carmona were both pretty well liked prospects in the system, just bad trade all around.
I agree that they obviously don’t think much of Dubon though. That should have been obvious when they refused to give him a chance earlier in the year.
If it’s Pom and Black for Dubon, Brew got totally shafted
Giants got a solid prospect for chump change!
I sure hope they got more than Pom and Black for a young player like Dubon yeesh thats a bad haul.
I’m Can’t help but feel this’ll be the biggest move the Giants make. I think they’re gonna go for it this year, for better or worse, and try to give Bochy one last shot.
If that’s it, two for one, Stearns WAY overpaid. Someone above said, this makes the Schoop trade look awesome.
Can’t wait until January when Stearns says “I screwed up on that Dubon trade” like he did last January regarding the Schoop trade. EGAD.
Ha ha ha, you’ll be waiting for a long time then
Sooo. This makes the Pirates look a little better. Lets see if they can make some moves like this. Stealing prospects for spare parts.
To the Brewers fans, from a Giants fan. Ray Black throws gas, hasn’t been able to put it together at the MLB level, but he could become a great reliever. What’s up with Dubon? Don’t know much about him.
Good contact, adequate defender at SS but probably better suited for 2B long-term. HR rates are a little inflated in the PCL, as are all the offensive numbers to a point.
Going to be more of a line drive gap to gap hitter. Had decent speed, but hasn’t shown it as much after the ACL last season… Saw him play a lot at Colorado Springs, and I like him and didn’t know why they didn’t give him a shot at the big leagues earlier this season while they scuffled at 2B and SS. Think he ends up more as an average to slightly above average every day player though, not the stud some of these people seem to think he is…..
Dubon is an excellent prospect.
The Giants just got their 2nd baseman for the next 6-10 years in exchange for ..uh, a 29-year “prospect” who can’t figure out AAA, and Drew “DFA” Pomeranz. Arguably the best SF trade in decades.
Calm down grasshopper. Two years ago Giants fans were saying the same thing about Joe Panik. Dubon has done nothing in the majors yet.
Pomeranz and Black don’t do anything in the majors now
thanks captain obvious
just doing my duty
I like it. Right handed. Second base. Can play the infield. Hopefully a higher average guy.
Austin probably gone. With Longo coming back. The offense might uptick. I think Longo is coming back on Monday vs. the Nats…
Now, To get another outfielder. Sans Slater.
Pom was expendable. The couple outings raised his stock. Good. But toi small a sample to say he’s Great. . .
Goodbye Black. Never got it fully together here. . .
-Still in this thing. Gotta keep taking series. . .
The Brewers have picked up a couple not so good pitchers in the last few hours.
Best they can do without trading Hiura
Big Splash by the Brewers! Between the 3 arms we acquired this week we get to inherit 15.58 in ERA. David Stearns coming in clutch in the big chair this week. What a joke!
They actually acquired 4 so far. Lyles, Faria, Pomeranz, and Black) They were desperate for pitching and got some possible up-side in Faria and Black, who are controllable til 2024 and 2025 respectively. Pomeranz has been more effective out of the pen the last 2 years and they needed lefty help out there, and Lyles can eat some innings and cost next to nothing. They didn’t have the prospects do get anything super major done. (though the Jays did give up Stroman for cheap.).
Finally some reason in MLBTR comments
Stearns is picking up hacks and wash outs. Milwaukee needed a stud and they got duds. They will be out of the playoff hunt soon. Cheapskate transactions. Worst starting rotation in NL. Nice job Stearns.
“What’s a bad rotation when you have 8 closers?”
-Brewers fans
A great trade for the Giants, and I think the Brewers will like the guys they got.
I hope Farhan makes more trades in the next 33 minutes!
I love this! Brew fans thought bumgarner was on the way and got pomeranz instead! Its like being rejected by the model for a date and being forced to take out her ugly out of shape cousin instead. Enjoy arbys you two!
Smith maybe. Any Brewer fan with any common sense at all knew it wasn’t going to be MadBum.
there are brewer fans with common sense?
Scratching my head today. I can’t believe I’m going to say this but the trades the brewers did today are making the Jordan Lyles trade look great. ouch
Don’t mind the Faria for Aguilar trade at all. Still has some starter potential and if nothing else should have a decent floor in the pen. Both guys seemed to need a change of scenery. I’ll take that one over the Lyles trade all day.
Thanks, sounds like he could be the Joe Panik 2B replacement.
brewers traded a hell of a prospect for a bum not madbum
I hate this trade. Dubon should be their starting shortstop and would have been last year if it wasn’t for the injury. All he does is hit and play a respectable short. Now their stuck with Arcia until Turang is ready. Great job at giving him away for crap.
I’m sorry offseason the Brewers should try and get Iglesias as there starting shortstop.
This will go down as the best deal Farhan made all day. Good for the Brewers, excellent for the Giants.
Seems Giants came out ahead on this one but Pomz has been superb out of the pen.
Black has always been someone you hoped on. Good guy, incredible arm, who knows, maybe the beer will help him out.
Why can’t more comments be like this one? Instead we get dray16 making generalizations about entire fanbases from his mom’s basement while he craps into a bedpan that she’s holding under him. smdh
He has pitched five innings. Ray Black I like, but at this point he is what he is and needs a change of scenery.
He has pitched five innings. Ray Black I like, but at this point he is what he is and needs a change of scenery.