The Mets announced their full coaching staff for the 2026 season today. Some of last year’s staff are coming back and some of the new hires have already been reported. The new developments today include the confirmation of Justin Willard as the new pitching coach. Prior to the official announcement, Willard confirmed to Rob Bradford of the Baseball Isn’t Boring Podcast that he had been hired in that role. Also, the Mets promoted J.P. Arencibia to catching coach, Dan McKinney to assistant pitching coach and Gilbert Gomez to first base and outfield coach.
It was reported earlier this month that Willard was highly likely to be the new Mets pitching coach. It has seemingly taken a few weeks to cross the Ts and dot the Is but he has now been officially put into his new gig.
The Mets and pitching coach Jeremy Hefner parted ways after 2025, which was their sixth season together. The club’s pitchers had disappointed in 2025, with a collective 4.04 earned run average, which put them 18th out of 30th in the majors. However, the club also suffered a number of injury setbacks and it’s always tough to parse the contributions of a coach from the players on his team. Regardless, the Mets are changing things up. Hefner quickly landed a new pitching coach gig within the division. He’s heading to Atlanta for 2026.
Willard, 35, spent the 2018 to 2023 seasons working with the Twins in the minor leagues as a pitching coach and pitching coordinator. He then got hired by the Red Sox going into 2024 to serve as that club’s director of pitching. As mentioned, it’s tough to know when to give a coach credit for the performance of the players. For what it’s worth, the Red Sox finished fifth in the majors in 2025 with a collective 3.72 ERA.
As for the three promotions, they all get bumped from the minors to the majors. Arencibia, 39, is the biggest name of the bunch. He played in the majors from 2010 to 2015, suiting up for the Blue Jays, Rangers and Rays. He spent the three most recent seasons in the Mets’ system, serving as bench coach and assistant hitting coach for Triple-A Syracuse. He was primarily a catcher during his big league career and Will Sammon of The Athletic reports that he recently helped Francisco Alvarez, who was optioned to Triple-A for about a month in June and July.
Gomez, 33, has spent the past seven seasons in the system. He’s been the manager of High-A Brooklyn for the past two of those. McKinney, 31, has been in the system for three years. He was pitching coach for Single-A St. Lucie in 2023, High-A Brooklyn in 2024 and then Double-A Binghamton in 2025.
Photo courtesy of Brad Penner, Imagn Images
I will both congratulate them and send my condolences.
Congrats on getting the job.
Condolences that you will be the scapegoats this year…like all the guys before you.