Veteran righty Josh Johnson has decided to retire, according to ESPN.com’s Jerry Crasnick (via Twitter). The 32-year-old had agreed to a minor-league deal with the Giants for the 2017 season but will instead hang up his spikes.
Johnson was working his way back from Tommy John surgery — his third such procedure — and would have faced an uphill battle to crack the San Francisco roster. He hasn’t pitched in the majors since 2013, owing to a series of arm injuries.
Johnson’s most recent big league campaign was his least successful, as he struggled to a 6.20 ERA — but still racked up 9.2 K/9 — over 81 1/3 innings in his lone season with the Blue Jays. Before that, though, he had provided the Marlins with eight seasons of largely outstanding work. Over nearly 1,000 innings in Miami, Johnson pitched to a 3.15 ERA with 8.2 K/9 against 3.0 BB/9.
Since wrapping up his time in Toronto, Johnson twice signed agreements with the Padres in hopes of sparking a return to form. But he was stopped short by injury and never threw a pitch for San Diego, which had invested a total of $9MM in hopes of securing a bargain.
At his best, Johnson was one of the game’s most dominant starters, as he worked off of a mid-nineties heater to post strong strikeout tallies and induce mostly weak contact. His 2010 campaign, at age 26, was his best overall effort. He threw 183 2/3 innings over 28 starts, posting a 2.30 ERA with 9.1 K/9 and 2.4 BB/9, picking up his second-straight All-Star nod and coming in fifth in the National League Cy Young vote.
While it’s tempting to view Johnson’s career as a disappointment, given his lofty peak and evident talent, it’s hard to fault him for the physical ailments that derailed him before his thirtieth birthday. Even after accounting for his forgettable year in Toronto, Johnson posted 21.3 fWAR and 23.8 rWAR over his parts of nine total MLB seasons. MLBTR wishes Johnson the very best as he moves on to the next phase of his life.
a1544
Well I wish jarrod Parker better luck coming back
stymeedone
Tommy John is the most tracked surgery, but other Injuries have cost pitchers their career as well. Anyone want to give 2/20MM with an opt out to Greg Holland after reading this article?
jdgoat
Looking back, that huge blockbuster has turned out to be one mess of a trade for everybody. Buehrle turned out fine in Toronto, but Reyes was a hot mess and Johnson just fell apart after so many dominating years. The guys Miami should’ve kept are the ones they gave up (joe musgrove, Anthony deaclafani) and Henderson Alvarez’s arm blew up. Hat tip to heicherveria I guess.
To top it off Miami could’ve had their pick of any of the Lansing three; Aaron Sanchez, Noah Syndergaard, or Justin Nicolino…
Let’s just file this as a loss-loss and try not to look at this beautiful train wreck of a transaction
slimjones92
Care to explain how Reyes was a hot mess?
jaysfan1994
While Reyes was good offensively, he was easily one of the worst defensive shortstops in the league. He had an inopportune time with making routine errors with guys on base. Which should be pretty obvious by how he’s no longer a starting shortstop in the league.
babyk79
Boom! Great point Reyes was sooooo good that when in a playoff race they deemed him so invaluable as to sip him off for tulo
slimjones92
Clearly neither of you understand reading comprehension.
slimjones92
“Boom!” …You’re awesome
mcdusty31
Boom! So rave
BJLVR
If you asked a schoolyard full of kids, Reyes sucked. Because he did. Boom.
slimjones92
Lol
DoItDoug
Reyes for Tulo. I’m not complaining
slimjones92
Yea, and the Mets aren’t complaining about getting him back at league min. Thanks.
ukJaysfan
The Jays traded Musgrove to Houston for JA Happ, not Miami
jdgoat
Aw you’re right I got him and hake marisnick mixed up
Kayrall
Who else has 3 TJs and does anyone have 4?
AddisonStreet
Jason Inringhausen had 3 I believe.
Ry.the.Stunner
According to Wiki, Josh Johnson and Jarrod Parker are the only players with three TJ surgeries.
antonio bananas
pretty sure jhonny venters has like 9
Ry.the.Stunner
Venters! That’s who I was trying to remember (Kris Medlen kept coming to my mind when I was trying to remember).
Venters has also had it 3 times, and tore it again at the middle of last season and was contemplating a 4th surgery…not sure why he wasn’t listed in the Wiki article.
davidcoonce74
Venters has had three. Jose Rijo had three (and claimed to have more in undocumented Mexican medical clinics). Isringhausen is the only one to come back to pitch effectively after even two TJs. And he had to come back as a reliever.
markmc1235
Daniel hudson had 2 tommy John’s as well
davidcoonce74
Oh yeah. I meant to qualify that remark – no starter has ever come back from two TJs and continued starting. Hudson and Isringhausen both had to come back in the bullpen. A lesson perhaps for all the people still waiting on Mike Minor and Kris Medlen and Brandon Beachy.
Sid Bream
Peter Moylan. Not a starter, but he still has been effective out of the pen.
mark0817
Fish ruined this guys arm and shortened his career big time
Kayrall
I hate to defend the marlins, but how did they ruin his arm? His innings total doesn’t seem ridiculous.
I recall him always being a porcelain doll.
mark0817
In my opinion I think he has had terrible pitching mechanics and it’s something they should have corrected while he was in the minors, also they should have taught him to be a pitcher instead of a thrower, again just my opinion
chesteraarthur
I think it’s kinda hard to take a guy and just completely change the way he’s been pitching for the last 10+ years, especially when he is succeeding with his current mechanics.
Priggs89
You really think it’s that easy? If so, why doesn’t everyone have perfect mechanics?
mark0817
It worked well for Javier Lopez and Tim Collins. I’m not saying it’s easy for pitchers to change the way they do their thing but to lengthen a career and be more successful it’s worth doing. I believe carter capps will be another injury prone pitcher if nothing is done to correct his mechanics while they still can.
mark0817
As I said I don’t think it’s easy, however when a pitcher is being scouted the pitchers mechanics are one of the most important things the scouts look at and is why many don’t get signed. What’s the point in throwing a ball that hard that your arm can’t stay healthy? Can’t help a team if you’re sitting on the DL 3/4 of a season or constantly in rehab.
chesteraarthur
Messing with mechanics can screw them up though, look no further than jake arrietta and the O’s trying to change his cross fire delivery and placement on the pitching rubber.
Sometimes funky works. Chris Sale has managed to stay more or less healthy despite the fact that he is a string bean and has wonky mechanics
mcdusty31
In reality, throwing a baseball in itself is such an unnatural thing for a human to do it’s kind of inevitable that a player, particularly a pitcher, will have issues with their throwing arm…that being said, there are definitely some guys out there that make you think it shouldn’t be long for their arms to fall off because of their goofy mechanics…either way it sucks for him, he had some success and you hate to see a guy’s career get derailed because of injury…good luck on the next one Josh
pukelit
Pitchers screw with their mechanics a lot. They’ll even do it in-game if they’re struggling. Pitchers change their mechanics a lot to lengthen their careers. Johnson could’ve done the same thing. It doesn’t work for everyone but it would’ve been worth a shot.
stryk3istrukuout
I think his 100 MPH fastball and 6 ft 7 frame did that
Z-A 2
He only had 4 real years, but 3 were pretty dominant. Honestly thought he was retired though for a few years now.
davidcoonce74
He basically has been retired since like 2013. He was on the Brandon Webb/Mark Prior retirement plan. One year contracts but never actually pitching.
chesteraarthur
He was fun to watch and was very good, but pitchers break. I agree that it’s hard to fault him for that. It’s not like he didn’t try to come back from it
mcdusty31
Yeah it’s crazy to think about but there are probably guys out there working 9-5 jobs that had just as much, if not more talent than the guys getting paid big bucks to play in the big leagues…it’s always a bummer to see a guy’s career get cut short
brat922
Sorry to hear we already lost Josh. Best of luck to him. #almostagiant
pustule bosey
Yeah I was kinda hoping when they signed him that he would be a one season bounce back guy in the pen that the giants have been so good at creating in recent years.
chop
As a Braves fan, I always hated to see Josh Johnson in the mound for the Marlins. However, he was definitely fun to watch! I sure wish he could have kept it all together and been in Cooperstown. Thanks for the memories, Josh!
slimjones92
I hear that
squish
I remember going to a braves v Florida game with Johnson, and he dominated, giving up 1 R in 7 IP, and the braves were down 6-1, but they scored 3 in the eighth and won on a walk-off by McCann that was originally ruled a ground-rule double then changed to a HR
chop
I remember that game!!
CubsFanForLife
Well said.
hamelin4mvp
Mark Prior v 2.0
cubsfan2489
Prior was more dominate than JJ could ever dream of.
66TheNumberOfTheBest
Josh Johnson was my ace in MLB: The Show 11.
ernestofigueroa87
This really breaks my heart.I wasn’t a fan of any of the teams he signed with and never met him.
I want great things for him.
brandons-3
I thought he was the next big thing there for a while. Guys like him and Jarrod Parker who undoubtedly were successful, high quality MLB talents prior to energy.
HarveyD82
one of those “what if” guys. injuries hit him hard.
Soxman81
Johnson always reminded me a bit of Erik Bedard, in that both showed glimpses of true ace potential only to be derailed by one injury after another.
vinscully16
Enjoyed watching JJ pitch. Best of luck with what comes next, Josh.
RealHalSteinbrenner
More money well wasted by Preller….. how does that guy keep his job