The Cubs have optioned infielder Addison Russell to Triple-A Iowa and activated catcher Willson Contreras from the injured list, the team announced to reporters (Twitter link via ESPN Chicago’s Jesse Rogers).
Russell, 25, began the season on the restricted list while he served out a 40-game suspension under the league’s domestic abuse policy. His return to the lineup has been underwhelming — not surprising for a player who has never posted a league-average offensive season by measure of OPS+ or wRC+ — as he’s posted a .247/.329/.404 line in 158 plate appearances. Much of Russell’s career-high 10.7 percent walk rate has been a function of batting seventh or eighth in front of the pitcher.
In recent weeks, Russell has begun to cede time at second base and in the lineup to rookie Robel Garcia, who now stands to receive additional starts at the keystone. Russell’s demotion could also open up some time for David Bote at second base, although he’s been used exclusively at third base since late June. Still, he’ll be a depth option there and perhaps at shortstop as well, given that Russell had been the primary fallback option should Javier Baez ever need to come out of a game.
The Cubs have been tied to Eric Sogard on the rumor mill recently, and it stands to reason that they’re also exploring the possibility of adding another cost-efficient option at second base while waiting to see whether Ben Zobrist returns to the lineup in 2019. Speculatively, that could include players such as Jonathan Villar, Tim Beckham, Adeiny Hechavarria or Neil Walker, though a move isn’t a foregone conclusion.
Clearly, the demotion only further calls into question Russell’s future with the club. That’s been the case since the time of his suspension, although the Cubs chose to stand by Russell, with president of baseball operations Theo Epstein speaking of second chances and supporting Russell in “stabilizing his life” and “growing.” That said, Epstein was also candid that the club would be prepared to move on from Russell if need be. His lackluster performance at the plate, recent defensive miscues — he dropped a pair of pop-ups over the weekend — and recent, eye-opening acknowledgment that he “need[s] to become more familiar with the signs” (via Rogers) in the wake of a baserunning gaffe certainly don’t paint a favorable outlook.
See ya.
No. This cannot be happening. First Ian Happ. Then Edwards. Now Addison Russell? Whose next? Almora? Didn’t they get the memo? All the Cubs’ young players were so talented that they were elected to the Hall of Fame even before they came to the bigs. They were going to win a dozen World Series, consecutively, then retire as a group to baseball’s Valhalla. Please tell,me this cannot be happening.
Yeah conveniently forgot to mention rizzo Baez Contreras and Bryant and the 90 plus wins they produce every year.. but go Sox lol
You’re right. All those guys? Hall of Famers, every one. Why wait for retirement? Let’s just vote them in right now. And why bother with all those pesky games they have to play on the field? Let’s just declare them winners of every game every year. Really, don’t be sensitive or defensive. You have history on your side. As for the Sox? Yep. LOL. No argument here. But wait. They just signed Jimmy Cordero. Add A. J. Reed to the mix. Can those World Series flags be far behind?
Hey I wasn’t bashing your sox I think they have a ton of talent and a strong future ahead,nor did I say hof for anyone to early for that stuff… just having a lil fun with this stuff and how much you hate the cubs which was evident by how you are quick to hate on the cubs every chance you get
Cant we all just get along?
The really funny thing is Jim Hendry is responsible for Baez & Contreras. The only good bat Theo actually acquired is Rizzo. Bryant was a layup for whoever had that draft position. I wouldn’t call it skill.
So 1 bat, that’s it.
And that world series ring.
The White Sox are the Jan Brady of Chicago and the Cubs are Marcia.
Marcia with the big nose from a football toss. Ha!
Haha Cubs fan but this is still funny
Marcia, Marcia, Marcia
About time somebody said that! Hell they called Garcia A “ budding star” after one game!
Sox looking for .500. Remember when the Sox won it all? The Cubs outdrew them. No wonder Sox fans have an inferiority complex. Or are they just inferior?
Spot On!
What a loser this guy is. Addition by subtraction for the Cubs.
Good call. They can use Willson’s bat in the lineup and deploy him to the outfield on off-catching days and use Caranti a bunch more.
Bout time.
Wish they would’ve just DFA’d him. So tired of this guy, should’ve never even tendered him a contract this offseason
I know this guy is the worst but boy are there some teams that could use a shortstop – Tigers, Orioles, etc
Everyone’s obsession with this guy never made sense to me…. I never thought he was that good… in fact, I’d almost say he’s bad
You should be a scout
I’ll never forget the time about one year ago when one Cubs fan tried to argue that Russell and Baez were both top three shortstops league wide.
Haha yes! I got into an argument with someone on here saying the Cubs shouldn’t even consider dealing Russell and Montgomery for Machado in January 2018. Not only did the person say it was way too much for a rental, but he thought Russell was better than Baez.
There are plenty of guys similar to Russell. He was an elite prospect who flashed in the big leagues but never showed anywhere near enough consistency to reach his potential.
The obsession is two-fold. Fans of his team obsess over what could have been (or should have been) while fans on rebuilding teams dream about buying low on a guy that was once considered a cant miss type talent.
FWIW, some of these guys do adjust and reach that potential after being moved. Others continue on the same trajectory. But most just flame out, never to be heard from again.
Given Russell’s off field issues, coupled with a complete inability to accept any responsibility for his actions (or to even admit he did something wrong) makes me believe he will flame out with his next team. But I’ve been wrong plenty of times…
I 100% agree with your entire statement. It’s easy to fall in love with the prospect pedigree he had and the 2016 season he had, but we’re now 3 years removed from the best he will be. It’s time for people to let it go. Strictly from a baseball standpoint, he’s just not a good player. From a human standpoint, he’s worse than that. There is no appeal left, it’s over, the time to move on was this past offseason. Just cut him.
Not all players develop at the same rate. think Josh Donaldson, max muncy, Whit merrifield, etc. just because he hasn’t lived up to expectations now doesn’t mean he never will
Yeah agree with the commenter who says you should be a scout since you can tell what’s up with these ballplayers
Option Brach….or just dump him
Good riddance wife beater
It fair to Iowa, I wonder who’s roster spot he took there. Shoulda sent this clown to Japan!
Joe Panik replacement
He couldn’t carry Panik’s J… Strap
The Giants would never trade for anyone that has been accused of any type of domestic violence. If the A’s traded him then why would the Giants want him ??
I’m a big Joe Panik fan, he’s coming around at the plate and will be fine going forward.
It’s about freakin’ time. Next up, a DFA!
While in AAA, perhaps Addison Russell can also get a refresher course in Sign Reading 101.
I’m surprised comments are open on this.
I have no sympathy for him.
Many A’s fan including myself hated trading Russell. He was probably their highest rated hitting prodpect in over a decade. Shark trade part 2 and getting Marcus semien, turned out well. Never couldve i imagined him being a top 20ish ranked player in mlb in WAR
About time
Hey I thought you said Russell will be the centerpiece for a trade for Smith and Dyson from the Giants? Good luck getting those bullpen help with your unwanted garbage like Russell, Ian Happ and Maldonado LOL
Cubs should make another move to replace Lester for today.
Chatwood won’t win Cubs a road game.
Yikes
Cubs win but Chatwood had to be bailed out.
The bullpen taxed again. Won’t make it to August. Flaming out.
Chatwood was outstanding. He isn’t stretched out, wasn’t supposed to go very far.
Castellanos for Happ and Russell
Designate Descalso and Brach next.
Good
All else aside, Addison Russell is still useful in the field and not an automatic out. Meanwhile, Daniel Descalso is the epitome of dead weight.
It’s rotten apples and rotten oranges here. Ideally, you dont rely on either for much. But if you have to keep one around, you keep around the guy who people want to be around. That’s clearly Descalso.
While you’re right that Russell is a better defender, that’s entirely true because of his gold glove calibur work at SS. But as 2B, he’s below average. He simply cant make the throw to 1B from that angle. Problem for him is that you are never going to push Baez to 2B to accommodate for Russell’s platoon quality bat. So you’re stuck with his below average ability at his secondary position.
Hitting wise, you might get one extra hit every 20 at bats out of Russell. So what? They’re both terrible…
Glad he’s gone he was useless out there. Don’t know where the guy with 95 RBI’s who was hitting grand slams in the World Series went but have a nice life. Don’t let the door hit ya where the Good Lord split ya…
Even that year he was a below average hitter…
I would bet that Theo has explored the trade market for Russell and has come up empty or the diminished returns weren’t acceptable or insulting.
Thanks Einstein. If Jed and Theo found a deal that would yield an all star and a couple top 100 prospects for Russell, you think they would jump on it? Of course, Russell’s name has come up in talks and they are not finding value. If you make those kind of bets all they time you are a very, very rich man.
Sorry…didn’t know that Theo and Jed’s lap puppet was the moderator of the board. You believing that Russell’s value should net an all star or top 100 prospect is delusional.
Russell’s trade value is so negative that the AAA team might not want him.
I think you need to read his comment again.
@ lefty—–ends up my Einstein comment may have been spot on….you are correct—I did mean to say…if they were able to get top 100 talent and all star for him they would have, with the exact same meaning he had saying they obviously can’t get squat for him…..
The Cubs would move Russell for a fringe talent. If a rebuilding team wanted to give up a veteran, rental pinch hitter to take a chance on Russell, the Cubs would pull the trigger.
I’m not entirely sure why you’re conflating Russell not having significant value with what the OP is saying- which is that Rusell has zero value.
But that’s the case with him. Teams dont even seem to want to give up a 25th guy on the roster for Russell.
It’s about time. The Cubs have at least a couple more moves to go before the deadline.
So much potential when he got there. Now is just to has been before he ever was a was
To be honest, I’ll take him over Descalso any day. Why hasn’t he seen the boot yet. I understand he’s a veteran with experiance, but he’s been batting .100 with horrible fielding. Why hasn’t happ been promoted.
I won’t say I’d rather have Russell.. but Descalso needs to be gone. I can’t understand what they could possibly see in him. He is hitting far worse than poorly. I think they are hoping he turns a corner, but how long can you give him?
He needs to realize his playing years are over and take a coaching position. That’s his role right now. Promote happ with the open roster spot.
what a shame for the former Vermont Lake Monster!!
Too little too late. This POS was accepted back by the Cubs organization after beating his baby momma on numerous occasions. NOW they’re going to make an example of him? Give me a break. They way the Cubs handled this situation has left a black eye on the organization and it has had an effect on the whole clubhouse.
Uh… I think outside of the human part of this, no one cares. I expect my GM doesn’t confuse moral issues with putting a good baseball team on the field, and wouldn’t want him as GM if they did. I do think they handled it as well as he could. I wouldn’t treat a player any differently if he had a DV background after he had served his suspension. Proud of the way the Cubs handled this issue, and I’d say the same about any other athlete, Ray Rice, etc. There’s no place for enforcing morals in sports.
But cubs fans swore he was the greatest short stop of all time and they swore he was the most clutch player of all time. Hahaha
I just hope the Cubs don’t bother with Beckham but I am glad to see Russell go. Strop and Brach next please.
Well that only leaves one option….Whit Merrifield!!
Perfect fit if they’re willing to give up whatever top prospects they have.
Agreed! I would love to see Whit at 2b and move Garcia to the outfield to platoon with Schwarber.
So glad Descalso made the cut… I was worried there for a minute
Seems Theo was serious the purge has begun Montgomery Edwards russel who will be next
I think Russell needs to go somewhere with low expectations so he can develop properly. Trying to develop a kid and have WS aspirations. Send him to the Marlins for spare change. There fans don’t show up anyways. Won’t b backlash for his off field crap.
Russell and ian happ for Starlin Castro
Cubs continue to pay a heavy price for sticking by Russell. There is no happy ending to this story. The should have done the right thing immediately and they would be better for it.
Not sure what price that is. At worst they have a replacement level starting SS playing as a backup who you can option at any point. That has value. I think very few people care would care what he did off the field if he was producing. I don’t even if he’s not, beyond from a general human perspective. He can play on my team. They all can if they’re good enough.
Robel Garcia… I was looking at his stats… he was out of baseball for 5 years? Where did he go from 2014 to 2018? Wherever he went, he learned how to hit. Prior to 2014 he was a .210 hitter with no power at the A level. He comes back this year and he has 21 homers in the minors, 4 in the majors and an OPS around 1.00. Very suspicious.
I believe Italy not sure how long he was there
Looked it a little bit in writing about his promotion:
mlbtraderumors.com/2019/07/cubs-promote-robel-garc…
Thanks Steve.
The Castellanos for Russell and Happ idea is not a bad trade, for both teams.
With the right situation, the right team and the right personnel around him along with the right PR he will be ok – so long as he works at it. Not everyone will forgive and not everyone believes he deserves another chance. It will be a risk for any organization willing to help him find redemption.
Agree fresh start might help him.. cubs should just cut him say they did there best to help him wash their hands of him..doubt they can get a can of soup for him at this point
Yes. In the offseason. Non-Tender him.
I agree as well, but as a Cubs fan I’d prefer to trade Russell and salary comp. for Castellanos. Happ hasn’t abused anyone that I know of so I’d like to see if he finds his swing by February. Of course, at this point I doubt anyone would trade a quality bat for Russell straight up.
I was listening to a podcast and one of the guys made an observation about Russell. He can hit the ball and field the ball but after all this time as a player he has no baseball instincts..After this past weekend it all makes sense. In any case I hope he can figure it all out. Personally I think we should pass on Castellono’s, I don’t like the idea of Heyward in CF with Schwarber in LF and the other guy in right. Heyward is a great fielder but even he can’t cover the whole outfield.. Just sorry Brad Bach wasn’t shown the door. I know this is a small thing but somebody tell Strop how to wear a ball cap.
Ian Kinsler is available!
Robel “stick” Garcia!!??
but but but he has trade value
I agree with an above mentioned comment regarding a purge. But, I must say this team needs an enema. Edwards Jr, Russell, Brach, DeScalso just to name some of the headliners who seem to drag this Cub’s team down. Soon to add Morrow, who the Cubs will buy out for 2 million this off season. I don’t believe Russel is a trade candidate either. No sensible GM will make a deal Russell at this current time. He still needs to prove he has been rehabilitated and can at least marginally function as an MLB caliber player.
I think he needs to mature as a person before reaching his full potential
That notion doesn’t seem to apply to Tyrek Hill.
Too bad they can’t get Roberto Osuna type of return Russell.
He’s an everyday player. Needs to change clubs, go back to SS, work on his confidence and tweek his swing. Easily a future 10+ year career in MLB.
Happ coming up.
Second (maybe last) chance.
Who is going down this time?