Prior to today’s 3-1 loss to the Rays, the Pirates placed closer David Bednar on the 15-day injured list due to a left oblique strain. The placement is retroactive to June 20. Left-hander Justin Bruihl was called up from Triple-A in the corresponding move.
Bednar last pitched on Wednesday, and Pirates GM Ben Cherington said in his weekly radio show (hat tip to Noah Hiles of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette) said that the right-hander “felt a little something in his left side” following that outing. Bednar and the team took a few days to rest and evaluate the situation, but after Bednar still felt some tightness after a throwing session, an IL trip was deemed necessary.
Cherington described the placement as somewhat preventative, as Bednar’s strain is considered relatively mild and there is hope he might be able to return once his minimum 15 days are up. As Cherington noted, “We need him for the biggest part of the season, as possible….Hopefully, that means it’s a short stay on the IL, rather than it turning into something bigger and it being a longer absence.”
The Bucs dropped to 37-40 after today’s loss, but remain just a couple of games out of a wild card berth in the very crowded NL postseason race. A hot week could easily get Pittsburgh into a playoff position, though the team’s struggling lineup will have to start producing, and naturally losing their closer for at least 15 days won’t help the Pirates’ chances.
Owner Bob Nutting believes his team can stay in contention, and recently said that the Pirates could make some additions at the July 30 trade deadline (and possibly receive some extra payroll space to make those adds). However, given the Bucs’ lack of offense and now this hit to their bullpen, it wouldn’t be a surprise if Pittsburgh explored being deadline sellers if the team can’t get on track, or if other NL clubs start to catch fire and create some real space in the wild card race.
Bednar’s injury could make his trade candidacy a moot point, but even if he did return in 15 days and the Pirates looked to deal some players at the deadline, it isn’t likely that he’d be on the move by July 30. While Bednar’s name has long been linked to trade speculation, the Bucs have shown that they’re eager to properly end their rebuilding period, so it isn’t likely that they would move such an effective closer in short order. It isn’t out of the question that the Pirates could still trade Bednar as his price tag continues to rise during his arbitration years, but that concept will likely be explored more in the offseason than within the next month.
An All-Star the last two seasons, Bednar has a 5.17 ERA over 31 1/3 innings this year due to a very rough start. After posting an 11.45 ERA over his first 13 appearances and 11 innings, Bednar has righted the ship and delivered a 1.77 ERA across his last 21 games and 20 1/3 innings.
With Bednar sidelined, Cherington said it’ll be “all hands on deck” for closing duties. Aroldis Chapman and Colin Holderman are the likeliest candidates to earn saves — Holderman has been the more effective of the two pitchers this season, though Chapman has a long history of past closing experience.
The Pirates could also get some bullpen reinforcements coming in the form of Ryan Borucki, as the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review’s Kevin Gorman writes that Borucki is set to begin a minor league rehab assignment on Tuesday. Borucki hasn’t pitched since April 5 since a case of left triceps inflammation sent him to the 15-day and then the 60-day injured list.
Pirates are going to get some pitching back soon, but they need to make a play for more bullpen depth.
Hope not to long! Really picking it up lately.
Glad they at least have Chapman to close.
They need to get Carmen back into the bullpen instead of wasting him for one or two innings.
Maybe Nicolas can help out.
They miss Borucki too.
But this is not good.Bednar is one of their top players.
the success of the bullpen will be determined by how poorly Shelton mismanages it
He used Holderman today after he threw 16 pitches in yesterday’s game instead of using a fresh arm like Nichols or Fleming
What? He threw Holderman after 16 pitches yesterday? Like he literally pitched him 2 days in a row? Say it ain’t so. I didn’t watch. Did his arm fall off? Can they reattach it? OMG Noooooooooo this is like really bad.
I that why you wanted JD Davis? He could pitch and be Nutting equivalent of Ohtani.
Dream- You think that that is funny but his arm did fall off like what happened in the Monty Python movie.
He will pitch lefthanded in the future..
you missed my point, Dream, which isn’t surprising
Temperatures on the field in triple digits, use a fresh arm to pitch the 8th inning
It wasn’t like they were suddenly going to hit consecutive homers when it was their turn to bat in the 8th or 9th inning
For someone who thinks they know everything, sometimes you lack common sense
I never ever said I wanted J D Davis, what I said was if Cherington wanted him he was a day late and a dollar short
You have a habit of taking comments out of context
You should have been a politician, they are good at that
Pitchers go 2 games in a row all the time. That heat is nothing. Most of them should have pitched in weather just as hot or hotter and for multiple innings in it. I never had a single pitching teammate complain about the heat. In fact most of them preferred hot weather. You got a man crush on him or something and trying to make lame excuses for him.
No need to mention him then. Cherington didn’t have any interest in him. Yankees got him absolutely nothing. No one missed out on him. Sounded like you were interested in him as no one else here even mentioned his name. Someone else seemed like they thought you wanted him to. They were like jd davis? Why would the pirates want him? My bad. Thought he was another man crush of yours.
I didn’t want Davis. I just looked at the comment section didn’t see anyone else who wanted Davis. My COMMON SENSE told me the Pirates had no interest in Davis. So that left my mind no other choice but to believe you were the only person that missed out on Davis. Can you see how one would think that? Yes? No?
yeah it’s a man crush, like it is with Sheltie, as you so affectionately call him
It was the mustache dude that suggested that they go after Davis
That’s what Cherington calls him.
Chapman isn’t obviously the same pitcher he was when he was the closer for the Reds, and while he still throws in triple digits, he’s wild, walks too many and has an era of 4
Not to be undone, Bednar’s is 5.71
Shelton should give Nichols a chance at being the closer but of course they would need to score enough runs for that to make sense
Nichols is pretty wild himself. Has a lot of walks. In time he could be the closer. Chapman has been very good and not as wild since the Dodges series. Bednar’s ERA is high do to his bad start to the season but has been very solid over the last month or so. Takes a long time for a short reliever to bring a 10+ ERA gown.
Bednar gave up a home run in a recent game so please don’t make it sound like he’s been perfect since the series with the Dodgers
Bednar gave up 2 earned runs over his last 5 appearances, both homers
Never said he was perfect. Just said he has been solid. Every closer will give up some homers. Solo ones are not a big deal if you ha e a 2 run lead. I like Nichols but he is still inexperienced. He could be an excellent closer in time.
I would hope someone—anyone-can work with Nicolas. The kid throws 99-100 on the gun but jeez, as you said he’s often all over the place. He could become a real stopper but why do I have to believe it’ll happen with some other team?
why you ask, Tired? Because this general manager has a history of giving up on pitchers who have potential
TheMan 3: A “relief pitcher” SHOULD be able to pitch consecutive games. I mean really, is Holderman really gassed “after he threw 16 pitches yesterday”.
perhaps in triple digit heat throwing that many pitches wore him down some
It’s always hotter on the field than in the stands
Holderman should be given the closer’s role in my opinion.
Let Chapman be the setup man unless his control gets worse
Holderman was used to close for a couple of games last year when Bednar was unavailable and failed miserably.
He has been excellent pitching the 8 th when the Pirates were winning. But you saw what happened today when they were tied.
Chapman is it now,and maybe Nicolas if he turned the corner like today.
He had an 0.68 era coming into today’s game. Mendoza. I dunno. I think he could close games
We have a group of guys who step into that role. Sheltie will utilize these guys on a situational basis game by game. But we expect Chapman and Holderman to both be a big part of it until Bednar gets back.
Oh and Holderman will now be pitching left handed.
“Sheltie will utilize these guys on a situational basis “
Like how he utilized his lineup?
Pirates will not be buyers. Come on
Who’s closing in Indy? Hitting is a joke for this team. Trades need to be made before they are double digits out!
They have nothing to trade in return for big time sticks. That’s just the reality of it all. Not when there are countless other teams also going for a playoff berth
They either need to take on a salary dump or commit to finally signing a couple big timers this off season
And in Pittsburgh, it’s hard to see that happening
Lots to trade. No problem getting a bat or 2 or 3.
It’s gonna be interesting, Dream. To me, they have to spend either now or in the off season to get to the next level. The rebuild, while technically complete, didn’t quite accomplish what they’d hoped. No reason to not augment their building blocks
I’ve said enough. Time for a cigar
Same here. But I haven’t said enough about what I believe is my real concern. Other teams have better playoff odds. GMs on more of a hot seat. Weaker gms. Cherington could outbid them but should he? Will he want to? How many of your 3 to 10 best arms do you want to lose? I believe he will go after average to even above average players but will stop there. Improve the team but keep the prospects he wants to.
in other words, Cherington will dumpster dive for players that might ( haha) help the team offensively
( Is Josh Van Meter available?)
Cherington’s idea of improving the team for this year was signing Taylor, Grandal, Tellez and our $10 million dollar reliever, Chapman
and trading for a player no one else wanted, Oliveras
3 of them have been busts, one is an overpaid reliever
Yes,but will those bats be any good.
Honeywell has the most with 6
Whatever the Pirates need to do to win, they need to do it. Rebuild has been taking way too long. Pirates need to take advantage of having good young starters and make a push. Season ticket holders and casual Bucco fans deserve a winner.
the entire city and the taxpayers who paid for the construction of PNC Park deserve a winner
We have been waiting 23 years since the opening of the stadium for a winner and another 45 since the last WS Championship
Here’s the solution to the buccos problem. First MORON and Haines underwear need FIRED. And whatever happened to closers pitching more than 1 inning?
MORON has no clue on how to manage game situations. To field such an anemic batting order yesterday was ludicrous. Especially when you had skenes pitching.
You have the big three, the ACE Keller, and the two rookie stalwarts. Nutjob Nutting needs to let cherrington make some moves.
Giving guys off when you have off days coming up is a prime example of MORONS inability to manage. HE HAS GOT TO BE FIRED
Read today’s column from Mark Madden in the Trib online
I don’t know or care about his radio show persona but the guy is easily the best sportswriter in this market, beholden to no owner or team—and that’s quite novel
He simply reinforces everything we’ve been saying here about this team and its owner. He could have thrown their GM in, too
I’m counting on the Pirates adding no one of substance between now and deadline time
The real demonstration will come this off season, when they’ll have the chance to bring in a big name free agent. Or two.
I’ll put my money on them deciding on more Tellez and Taylor-like additions
If they plan on waiting till July 30th to find a couple of hitters then they are already sellers!
Trouble is, they’re in competition with ten other teams who want hitters, and they have nothing to trade in terms of legitimate, mlb-ready players
So that leaves guys like Josh Bell. Guys on teams like the Marlins, A’s, Rockies, etc who are under-performing, big salary guys that GMs want to dump. Some will eat a lot of the salary. Some not
But with almost every team still in it, just what’s available? Not much
20 other teams but who’s counting.
They must make a splash at the trade deadline. They can’t stay pat or the season is lost
Now you have to blame Haines and THE MORON
So Falter is “exhausted,” Marty is showing us what an “A+ signing” he was and by the looks of things, Marco may never return. Skenes, Jones…who knows if they’ll eventually be shut down.
So going into late summer, maybe Keller can pitch on two days rest along with Ortiz? Sheesh