Padres skipper Mike Shildt originally signed a two-year contract when hired to manage the club last offseason, but the club already has interest in keeping him around for a longer period. President of baseball operations A.J. Preller tells the Padres beat that the front office will sit down with Shildt and several members of the coaching staff to see if they can “line up” on a deal to keep them around on longer-term deals (X link via Annie Heilbrunn).
Under the 56-year-old Shildt, the Padres played at a 93-69 pace, good for second in the National League West and a Wild Card berth in the postseason. Shildt’s Padres topped the Braves 2-0 in the first round of postseason play before taking the archrival Dodgers to their limit in a thrilling, back-and-forth five-game National League Division Series. Ultimately, a Friars club that scored 21 runs over the first three games of the series was held scoreless in Games 4 and 5 alike.
Despite that disheartening finish to the season, Shildt’s first year in San Diego has to be considered a success. The Padres’ record improved by 11 games, and San Diego returned to postseason play after missing out on the heels of an 82-80 showing a year prior. As importantly, Shildt quickly won the clubhouse over. Kevin Acee of the San Diego Union-Tribune spoke to several Padres veterans late in the season — many of whom have been with the team for multiple prior managers — and each took the opportunity to heap praise onto the environment and culture that Shildt had brought to the clubhouse. Joe Musgrove, Jake Cronenworth and Manny Machado have all played under three different managers in San Diego (four, in Machado’s case), and all effused praise for the job Shildt has done in his first season at the helm.
Of course, while Shildt was new to the Padres organization this season, this certainly wasn’t his first experience managing. He spent three and a half seasons leading the Cardinals’ dugout, and his dismissal in St. Louis registered as a legitimate shock following the 2021 season. Shildt had originally joined the Cardinals as a scout in 2003 before getting into minor league coaching and managing. In 2017, he was added to the big league staff as a quality control coach. He eventually became the team’s third base coach, then bench coach, and then interim manager following Mike Matheny’s firing. He soon shed the “interim” label and was extended on a three-year deal. He was named National League Manager of the Year in 2019.
In the weeks prior to Shildt’s own firing in St. Louis, the Cardinals had gone on an astonishing 17-game September winning streak to come roaring back into postseason contention. They lost a then one-game Wild Card date with the Dodgers, but Shildt was generally seen as an extension candidate following that 2021 campaign. Instead, president of baseball operations John Mozeliak cited “philosophical differences” in cutting ties with Shildt and promoting current skipper Oli Marmol to the post.
Shildt landed on his feet quickly. He took a job in the Commissioner’s Office, working in on-field operations alongside former Marlins general manager Michael Hill. Just six weeks later, he was hired as a player development consultant for the Padres and allowed to work in both roles simultaneously. San Diego had previously interviewed him for their managerial vacancy which wound up going to Bob Melvin, but Shildt received another interview two years later and this time landed the job on his current two-year contract.
Barring an extension, Shildt would head into next year as the proverbial and dreaded “lame duck” manager on an expiring contract, so it’s sensible enough that the Padres — who’ve now employed Shildt in some capacity for three years — are hopeful of solidifying his standing within the organization.
CubsWin108
he deserves it, very good manager
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
Best manager in baseball, without a doubt.
Lindor's Bodyguard
What are the qualifications for this incredible honor?
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
Have you ever heard his post-game interviews? The guy lives and breathes baseball and obviously he grew up around it and knows how baseball is supposed to be played. (Not Padres fan btw) (PS do we have to put disclaimers like this after every nice thing we say about a player or team that doesn’t happen to be our own? Good, I hope not.)
User 2770661946
He was completely out managed by Roberts and it wound up costing them the series. That dude will never get them anywhere. Mistake to extend. They should start looking for someone who the players respect.
swagsuperawesomeepiccoolman123
I hope you do realize not everything is the manager’s fault. Padres hitters failed to preform at all in games 5 and 6. He can’t press a button and magically have someone hit a homer, can he?
swagsuperawesomeepiccoolman123
oops sorry i meant games 4 and 5
User 2770661946
A real manager would have made lineup adjustments and moved the batting order around a bit. It’s what historical good leaders do. He also could have taken them aside and asked if they needed help. He managed that series scared and doesn’t belong in a contending teams dugout. They need to reach out to Buck or try and pry Boone out of NY if they ever want to beat LA
Crunchtime1969
Consecutive dumb posts. Congratulations.
Gwynning
Crunchtime- the one time you don’t want to be 2 for 2!
Terry-ble takes.
el rey
And you still don’t have any offers to manage a team yourself?
Guybird
With all due respect
You are clueless
alphabravo619
Lame
CubsWin108
buck? buck in the playoffs? the guy who didnt put britton in? the guy that got swept by said padres, lol
User 2770661946
I think a cub fan with an 8 million dollar manager that produced the same record as the dancing with the stars clown they fired should sit this one out
mlb fan
“Completely outmanaged by Roberts”..Good leaders are not always top level strategists. Some excellent leaders got where they are by being good motivators and inspiring field generals that push their charges to greater outcomes.
All that being said, I didn’t see Shildt get “out managed”, I saw the Dodgers pitchers shut down San Diego’s hitters for about 2 games straight. What manager wins when his hitters don’t hit for 18+ innings?
Crunchtime1969
This is a top ten dumb post. Robert’s managed his bullpen perfectly only because his bullpen performed. He would have been a horses butt again if they had failed. The Padres bats went silent. That happens in baseball. Schildt did his job. The Padres won 93 games. Went to the playoffs and it took the Dodgers 5 games to eliminate them. Extending Schildt is the obvious thing to do. Dumb post.
LLGiants64
You are right. You ought to step in.
Brew’88
he certainly wasn’t out-bushleagued by Roberts
Brew’88
I mean, Roberts certainly wasnt out-bushleagued by Shildt
fred-3
The Padres and their fans spend way too much time thinking about the Dodgers. Who cares about being “out managed” by Roberts. There are 28 other teams.
FanDan
Shildt wasn’t the problem and neither was Melvin.
sad tormented neglected mariners fan
Uhh don’t the players say they love Mike…
Joeypower
Smart move by the pads FO
Garywally57
Good for Mike Shildt. Unlike when he was manager in St.Louis, he now works for an organization, who’s owner or owners, put fans and winning before profits, unlike the greedy billionaire, Dewallet family in St.Louis, who puts profits before fans.
User 2770661946
You tell ‘em! Padres ownership doesn’t care about profits or any of that business-y stuff. They just want happy fans and to win. Rumor has it that next year’s tickets will be free and come with flight vouchers for a Hawaiian vacation. Surprised more owners haven’t unlocked this secret to sucess.
I Believe We Can Win
Padres have a history of adjusting prices based on production
They’re good prices go up
They’re bad prices go down
Some teams opt to keep prices the same after going from winning to losing.
Longtimecoming
Terry you can even troll accurately – Gary was expressing positives for SD you imbecile troll.
User 2770661946
You’re violating my safe space. Muting you for my safety
Longtimecoming
Sweet.
Joeypower
Lol
Blackpink in the area
How many championships do the Cardinals have?
How many do the Padres have?
Joeypower
The Cardinals are one of the most successful franchises in MLB history.. and you’re crying?! Try rooting for the Blue Jays!
Blackpink in the area
I am not crying about anything. Just a stupid comment by the guy thst got 8 likes for some lame reason.
Brew’88
Cardinals and Padres have a lot in common in some religious institutions, with cardinals of course being the higher priest-daddies.
But this is baseball, and oddly enough stupid comments are expected and I actually come here sometimes just to make a few! Nice diversion from academia, though stupid comments are common in that realm too….
What isn’t appreciated here are derogatory comments, and that’s what the guy with 10 likes above made. tsk tsk
Blackpink in the area
It’s dumb and derogatory and most importantly it’s false. No disrespect to the Padres or their fans but to act as if the Padres organization is great and the Cardinals are terrible is insanely dumb. Profit before fans???
I can’t believe 10 people saw that comment and gave it a like. Heck half are probably Cardinals fans. Lame.
Brew’88
Agreed. But do you sure he’s a Padre fan? Most Padre fans I know respect the Cardinals and their history, but are also grateful to receive Shildt.
Blackpink in the area
I never said he was a Padres fan. And again I bet half the likes came from Cardinals fans many of them act like entitled fools and are mad the team hasn’t been good for w whole years.
Schildt got a raw deal in St Louis for sure. The Cardinals fired him coming off a playoff appearance. I believe he’s a good manager and wish him and the Padres the best.
Brew’88
re-read you’re post and my error. I follow your Cardinals more than most teams. Will be an interesting off-season for StL for sure.
Blackpink in the area
I hope it’s interesting. Last thing you want to do as a 500 team is stand pat.
Butter Biscuits
Idk about this. The answers were extremely vague from AJ I think he’s very much undecided about this. They should wait til after next season before taking this step at least BoMel beat the dodgers
jbigz12
They need stability in the dugout. You have to extend to avoid the lame duck situation. Can’t imagine Shildt is getting a crazy salary either. Solid manager.
Acoss1331
He won over the clubhouse and it shows with the great season they had. He’s getting an extension easily.
User 2770661946
Never posting again. Too many people are getting my takes for free. The paywall is going up. Your trial is over
Gwynning
Bye Felicia!
Flanster
He will just continue posting under a different name and the same idiotic comments
pohle
goodness prevails
HatlessPete
Great cuz i would honestly throw a buck or two in the hat for you to not post anymore. I mean…oh no what will I ever do without your incessant boring and unfunny troll posts on literally every article? Oh the humanity!
User 2770661946
Hahahahaha. Dork. I’ll haunt you till you repent then beg me to autograph your car after I spit on it
HatlessPete
Okay terry…your mommy was right all along. You truly are a “special” boy lol.
Ignorant Son-of-a-b
He’s just going to change his persona to something else that’s obnoxious and keep on trolling away. We don’t have to respond to it though.
outinleftfield
I have thought since the day it happened that the “philosophical differences” were that Shildt was working to establish a culture of accountability throughout the organization and a focus on winning and Mozeliak was not at all interested in either of those things.
Acoss1331
Mo wanted a yes man, Schildt wasn’t into that, so that’s the “philosophical differences” that got him fired from the Cardinals.
CardsFan57
I think this will be MO’s legacy. It’s worth noting Schildt has made the playoffs every year he’s been a manager. Players respond very well to him. That’s the most important trait for a manager.
Lindor's Bodyguard
Carlos Mendoza smiles on you!
Emptyseats
Happy for Mike Schildt. Alot of fans here in St.louis miss him. He made the fatal mistake of speaking up to Mo. Only yes men managers allowed since LaRussa left.
dclivejazz
I never understood why the Cardinals fired Shildt. But Davey Martinez should have been the NL Manager of the Year in 2019 based on his turn around of the Nationals leading up to their playoff run.
User 2770661946
I can’t wait till the Padres extend him for life and you babies cry next year and want him fired. I have nothing but hate in me for all of you!,,,,,,mmm,mdjdjfnfjfjfjfjfnc
Lindor's Bodyguard
You are making a magnanimous effort at being the biggest fool on mlbtr. You’re almost there!
Kash Considerations
Objection, Lindor. Terry got there awhile ago!
3 finger split
I normally don’t reply to uneducated mentally challenged people but you have no clue about the Padres.
You do however love to bloviate your hatred for just about everyone so I would just offer up this…if you’re doing drugs then you need to stop and it you aren’t doing drugs then you need to start.
Maybe your Turnbuckle is strapped down too tight.
Is there anyway you can mute yourself?
Most people would appreciate it if you did because you bring absolutely nothing to this or any other conversation here on mlbtraderumors.
Now Yu Know
I hope the whole staff gets extensions. Schildt, Niebla, Rodriguez. These guys are solid coaches.
LFGMets (Metsin7) #BannedForBeingABaseballExpert
Schildt is a great old fashion coach. He doesn’t just look at a computer and produce a lineup. He goes by his feel for the game. Cardinals were fools to fire him for that 35 year old puppet. Mozeliak fired Schildt because he wanted full control of the decision making. Let the manager manage. Its funny how Marmol is one of the worst coaches in the league and got an extension but a proven success like Schildt has to claw his way to one. Ridiculous
Samuel
Baseball has managers.
Mike Schildt is a manager.
Brew’88
And their wear the same uniforms as the players. NBA and NFL coaches need similar dress codes
fox471 Dave
Schildt did a fine job for the Padres. Good man. Better check with the whiners on the ball club first though.
TDR
Shildt did a great job this year, but hope to see him being open to adjustments in the playoffs in the future. Padre bats going silent is not entirely on him, but it was clear that the lineup wasn’t producing well and could have used a shakeup.
Damn_Yankees
I remember stating out loud that the Cardinals were making a mistake by letting him walk and hiring Marmol.
3 finger split
I have been a Cardinals fan since Stan Musial
(Stan the Man #6) and I still think they have the best home uniforms in MLB…just so clean
but I never understood why the Cardinals fired Mike Shildt…he was the epitome of the Cardinals way…solid fundamentals at the plate, in the field and on the base paths. San Diego definitely benefited from the Cardinals mistake and I think that AJ will get something worked out with not only Shildt but also Ruben Niebla who in my opinion is one of the if not the best pitching coach in all of baseball.
Mike Shildt and Ruben Niebla really got the whole team together and the position players and pitchers all rave about the mentality that Shildt and Niebla have brought to the dugout…I for one hope they are around for a long time and I’ve been a Padres fan since they played at Westgate Park in the PCL…Pacific Coast League and saw the very first game they played at San Diego Stadium that became Jack Murphy Stadium and then Qualcomm before they got Petco built
Brew’88
3 finger. Very cool. As a 4 year old I used to compete with the big kids for the foul balls rolling off the corrugated roof at Westgate. One of my prized souvenirs is a HR ball hit by Jim Gentile.
Devlsh
Schildt did an even BETTER job than most give him credit for. Not only did the team improve markedly from 2023, they did so after losing one of the best hitters in baseball (Soto), one of the best closers in baseball (Hader), a finalist for this year’s AL Cy Young (Lugo) as well as Michael Wacha and Nick Martinez. Sure, they got some talent in return but that’s an enormous loss from one season to another, and Schildt got a team that had previously underperformed to the postseason.
Brew’88
@Devlsh. And they lost last year’s NL CY winner Snell
pjmcnu
Disheartening finish? WTF? It’s the Padres. They made the playoffs, won a round, and took the next round to the deciding game against the eventual NL Pennant winners. This is probably the, what, 3rd best season in Padres history? Certainly top 5. Ridiculous.