In a recent appearance on ESPN’s Baseball Tonight podcast, Astros GM Dana Brown said the club had been in contact with free agent right-hander Justin Verlander about a possible reunion. “We’ve had conversations with his agent [ISE’s Mark Pieper] just to try to feel him out. I don’t know if there’s been a lot of progress, but we’re having conversations,” Brown said.
Unsurprisingly, it doesn’t sound like either side is quite ready to make a move this relatively early in the offseason. As Brown noted earlier in the podcast, the Astros’ top priority at the moment is trying to re-sign Alex Bregman. That high-profile pursuit is taking much of the team’s focus, even if Brown noted that the club is doing its due diligence on other potential moves (such as finding another third baseman) as well.
“If [Verlander] continues to work and he’s healthy, it’s going to be interesting to see where he goes and how much he gets. But I’m sure there will be a bunch of teams calling the agent,” Brown said. This is perhaps reading too much into wording, but Brown’s phrasing almost seemed to imply more of an arm’s length approach, as if the Astros were more curious spectators to Verlander’s market than active participants.
Verlander turns 42 in February, but he made it clear following the season that he wanted to return in 2025, and rebound from an injury-marred 2024 campaign. The right-hander was limited to 90 1/3 innings due to a pair of injured-list stints prompted by shoulder injury and then neck discomfort. The latter injury was particularly troublesome, as Verlander missed about 2.5 months due his neck issue and didn’t pitch well after he returned, leaving him feeling like he probably tried to come back too quickly. The end result was a 5.48 ERA, the highest of Verlander’s career apart from the 7.11 ERA he posted over an 11 1/3-inning sample size in his very first Major League season in 2005.
It was just two seasons ago that Verlander won his third AL Cy Young Award, and in 2023, Verlander was still solid with a 3.22 ERA over 162 1/3 innings with the Mets and Astros. A case can certainly be made that Verlander has more to contribute if healthy, and the righty has already defied Father Time once by delivering that last Cy Young campaigns after a Tommy John surgery cost him virtually all of the 2020-21 seasons.
That said, nobody would be surprised if age and injuries simply caught up to Verlander, and 2023 was really his last hurrah as a productive starting pitcher. As Brown noted, Verlander’s track record alone will lead to interest from multiple teams, but is understandable if the Astros were ready to move on rather than risk being left holding the bag if Verlander declined further.
Framber Valdez, Hunter Brown, Ronel Blanco, and Spencer Arrighetti are lined up as the top four of Houston’s rotation, and the in-house candidates for the fifth starter’s role all come with big health-related question marks. Lance McCullers Jr. has missed the last two seasons due to injuries, Luis Garcia hasn’t pitched since May 2023 due to a Tommy John surgery and a couple of setbacks, J.P. France missed most of 2024 due to shoulder surgery, and Cristian Javier had a TJ surgery last June and isn’t guaranteed to pitch at all in 2025. Adding a reliable veteran arm to the mix certainly makes sense for Houston, though Verlander might not fit the bill given his own health status.
First team to offer him 2 years wins. He knows he’s about to sign his last contract
What type of conversation?
Asking him if he’s willing to try working out of the bullpen.
Ala John Smoltz & Eck. Why not? Toss 3-4 innings per week as a closer or set up guy.
Verlander will never agree to toss 3-4 innings per week or be summoned to the bullpen.
Verlander doesn’t have closer stuff or high leverage inning pitcher stuff anymore. He’s a five and diver. About hitting his spots at 91 mph. He is a #5 starter, if anything.
The reason verlander is still pitching is to be the last starter ever to get 300 wins
@sad I think him and Scherzer both trying to entrenched themselves in top 10 All Time Ks. Right now only 1 of them makes list. They both can quote reasonably end up 7th and 8th. That allows a bit of a cushion as well for those who might one day join the ranks of the top 10.
I do think he was eyeing 300. But that might ve slipped away the last 2 seasons.
Sadly he won’t get another 20 win season to shorten the gap but if he pitches 4 seasons of 10 wins then he’s got it
Verlander is 38 Wins away from 300. Zero chance he agrees to be a reliever anywhere
38 wins would take him 5 seasons minimum
Whyyyyyyyy?????
42 yrs old, coming off the worst season of his career, whats he got left to prove?? just go on vacation with your supermodel wife and wait for the HOF call . he is 1st ballot
Well at least his rotary phone won’t lose service during discussions.
Damn_Yankees: What a dumb “joke,” if you can even call it that. Even people twice his age don’t use rotary phones.
@Blue Baron
I still have mine. Work great. Better than the new-fangled junk they sell nowadays!
You still have a landline? You do you realize it’s 2024, right?
@laynestaley2002
Rotary phone. You do realize it’s 2024, right?
Why are you so mad, blue? Is it because of red?
Blue is always mad. All his comments are negative and he’s just here to stir the pot. Once you catch onto his shtick it’s easy to overlook.
Crane can’t quit JV.
Verlander owes them Come back on a club friendly deal, and go for being the last 300 game winner.
He has 262 wins. How the heck is he gonna get to 300?
Not likely that he will, but I’ll bet he won’t completely embarrass himself in 2025. If Giants don’t sign a top of rotation guy, I could see them bringing Verlander in for one last season like they did with Randy Johnson.
And he’d be a great mentor to all those young, excellent Giant arms.
@ Pete’sView Correction: he could make a great mentor. Don’t know that he would. Have we ever read anywhere about his mentoring younger players? Nothing he did in NY showed any signs of him caring much about anything other than his own performance. That ’23 Mets team was desperate and starved for some kind of leader to step up. He and Scherzer were the most seasoned, most accomplished, and had the most experience on contenders. And neither of them said or did anything. They just coasted like prima donnas and assumed that their talent would eventually yield better results.
By winning 38 more games?
After his age 41 season Randy Johnson had 263 wins. So it is possible lol
Verlander doesn’t owe anyone anything. He fulfilled his part of the contract, which nobody forced the Astros to sign.
Just crossing some “t”s here: the Astros didn’t sign the contract, they traded for him. That said, they knew the terms when they made the deal.
The debate is: with Verlander not pitching enough innings to trigger the vesting option on 2025, did the Stros get off easy? Or did they want him to A) be healthy enough as it wouldve helped them, win, AND the Mets would’ve been paying half of that salary? Or did the Stros not want to pay the other half at $17.5 million?
The Astros and Mets both lucked out.
If Verlander is indeed a hope for Houston with Lance McCullers Jr. Still injury issue. Has not pitched and I mean pitched strong since WS in 2017.
We had short seasons with Covid and then after that he was hurt and briefly pitched in 2022 and was ok during regular season part but not great
The WS game he pitched was definitely not great. Luis Garcia injury issues, France and Javier lucky if may pitch this season ahead. They dumped Urquidy so do need some help there.
Third base is a big issue. First may go with Singleton again and Caratini.
Outfield myself Chas and Meyers is not good. Neither is a blockbuster. Chas stunk last season maybe a change of scenery would have done him good. Meyers is a closer for the 9th as he only has D to help him. Started last season great first 2 or 3 months then flopped the rest.
Whether keep Tucker beyond this upcoming season is anyone’s guess. But probably won’t be much activity till next year. IF lucky anything happens with teams during winter meetings and such even.
Probably when Soto signs, maybe more will fall. Then rest after holidays.
Of names really Snell, Soto and Bregman are ones really hearing on or teams having talked too. Bregman don’t think they have talked to other teams just to get a feel.
Verlander will NOT come out of bullpen but maybe a one year deal with heavy on incentives or such. I do not think Verlander has much left. Like it said maybe 2023 was his last good year.
Like with Brantley they brought him back too soon after his shoulder surgery and he had nothing so retired. Verlander at 42 not sure what he has left. Even Scherzer I think he is 40 and he was injury prone last season. Is that a sign for him.
But I hope something perhaps happens soon one way or the other as far as Bregman. Who they use to replace him unsure
Tigers should have interest if the price is right
Agree. Finishing off his career in Detroit just seems right.
Nah. They need younger.
Love to see him comeback to Detroit for a last few seasons. Would be cool to see him in the Old English D once again
My money is on Detroit signing him.
I can tell you this he will only go to big market so Houston, Yankees, Dodgers , Red Sox
Yankees, Dodgers, and Red Sox all have their own old cranks to deal with in Cole, Kershaw, and Giolito.
Verlander retired about 8 years ago, right?
Verlander is perfect for a team with young pitching in the minors that’s a year away. I wouldn’t do the deal if I was Houston, but a Kansas City or Tampa? Two teams that could contend but still has youth maybe a year or two away from being impactful. Teams that could use a veteran leader to teach young pitchers how to grind.
@ kingbum That speaks to a concept that is not necessarily a reality. Why would you assume that Verlander is interested in teaching anyone anything? He showed no inclination towards leadership or mentorship when he was with the Mets. Did he mentor any of the younger pitchers who replaced him and other injured Astros pitchers last year?
Ya gotta tell him ya paying him for that and not so much field production anymore. The organization has to make it known and let him decide if that is what he wants.
He should have to pay to play
I love JV, but I’ll say it; if he wants to get top dollar, get lost. The Astros gave up their top two prospects to get him back, he was mediocre last year and a total waste this year. If he isn’t willing to sign a cheap one year bounce-back deal with the team to make it up to them, if he doesn’t feel like he owes them that, despite being stupid rich already, despite all his talk of loving Houston and wanting to stay, then get lost. So somewhere else and make a few more dollars you’ll never be able to spend I guess.
You’re right, Astros don’t deserve Verlander, therefore, I wish him all of the best to reach 300 wins,preferably against Houston.
First off, if Brown’s lips are moving, he is lying. Second, the Astros have much greater needs than .Verlander returning. I would go so far as to say if they bring him back, they are not really serious about the 2025 seasson.
Astros_fan_in_Aus;
Love your posts.
Don’t know why Brown won’t turn the page. The Astros made the playoffs but the embarrassed themselves. This aging dynasty thing about getting to one last WS never happens. The Astros need to get younger, Period.
I think they’re trying to hold onto Bregman thinking that if he goes, Valdez and Tucker follow him out after next year.
A couple of issues regarding Bregman’ situation…..
Why would he sign up long-term if he can go to a situation like Detroit or Boston with a number of good young players coming up that will be under team control for years? What it he re-signs with the Astros, then Valdez and/or Tucker leave
–
As for Valdez and Tucker…..
Say they get the big money. Then Yordan Alvarez will ask for a kings ransom. Shortly after that Hunter Brown and possibly Spencer Arrighetti follow.
The Astros need an influx of young star players.
–
The Astros situation is why Mark Elias won’t trade his abundance of top prospects with the Orioles. Dynasty’s have to keep regenerating. James Click may have won a WS, but he didn’t keep the ball rolling by replenishing the minor league system. Rather he lived off of what Luplow, Elias and Sig left him. Exactly the same thing John Mozeliak did with the Cardinals when those 3 gentlemen left that franchise.
–
Signing or not signing Bregman won’t change what’s happening. Brown and his staff need to address the issue. Bringing in quality young players under team control for years.
Lot’s of spelling errors.
Sorry.
Tired.
“That high-profile pursuit is taking much of the team’s focus” I find it difficult to believe that in 2025, a baseball team isn’t able to pursue multiple signings concurrently
Why?? When does his Medicare kick in?
Verlander’s allegiance to the Stros is just annoying at this point. He’s cooked – just admit the talks are for keeping Kate happy at this point.
What’s with all the negative comments in this thread? Justin Verlander had accomplished more by age 25 than his critics here will in their entire lives.
I remember his critics back in ’08 when he had that one bad year by his standards.
Remember the people on here who called Ohtani and Vladdy Jr. busts? How about the Mets fans who moaned about Lindor’s albatross contract?
El Kabong, EXACTLY! If I were an Astros fan I’d be thanking JV for what he brought you when he was at his best, A WORLD SERIES TITLE! Dude won a Cy Young Award at the age of 39 for God’s sake! Without him on that staff, there is no way you’d have won, period. And now that he is starting to resemble a 40 year old pitcher, he owes it to you as a franchise to take a 1 year, incentive laden BS contract? Tell you what, throw him out like trash and let him come to Detroit where there is plenty of young talent on the roster rather than staying on an aging, injury-prone team like the Stros. Sometimes fans have it so good that you don’t even realize what you have right in front of you. He was probably the best pitcher of a generation, and HE OWES YOU? Come on man…..
Putting feelings aside, sometimes it’s just time to move. This should likely extend to Bregman as well.
Hahaha!
Justin is looking to start both the regular-season game and the old-timers’ game on the same day.
Jays 5th?
I bet the conversation was short.
Would be great to see Justin Verlander top off his Hall of Fame career in a Detroit Tigers uniform.
They won’t give him 40M a year.
But, the could come up with a reasonably competitive offer
( 1 year with mutual options for year 2 or 3)…
He has yet to prove that he has completely recovered from the surgery he had in 2023.
If JC decided he can live with out Verhandler in the 2025 season, hopefully it will be an incentive heavy agreement that their GM can negotiate (thank goodness theirs on in place). In addition, hopefully, the club realizes that McCullers will never pitch in the majors again. Despite the fact someone made a horrible deal signing him prior to his surgery, understanding the severity of the procedure.