The Guardians placed right-hander Paul Sewald on the 15-day injured list due to a right shoulder strain, reports Tim Stebbins of MLB.com. The move is retroactive to July 12, and a corresponding transaction has not yet been announced by the club. It’s not clear how long Sewald is expected to be out.
It’s the second time this season that the 35-year-old Sewald has been placed on the injured list due to a strain in his throwing shoulder. The former D-backs and Mariners closer signed a one-year, $7MM deal with Cleveland in free agency and struggled for much of April before heading to the IL for what would wind up being a stay of more than two months. Sewald was only reinstated from the injured list on July 5, but it seems his return will only last for a week.
In his limited time with the Guardians, Sewald has pitched to a 4.70 ERA with terrific strikeout and walk rates of 29% and 6.5%, respectively. That’s all come in a sample of just 15 1/3 innings. Sewald allowed eight runs in 11 2/3 innings prior to his original IL stint (6.17 ERA) and returned with 3 2/3 shutout frames before now heading back to the 15-day IL. He’s been more homer-prone than usual in that small sample (1.76 HR/9) and has seen his fastball velocity dip from an average of 91.4 mph last year to just 90.3 mph this season.
Sewald has never thrown particularly hard, but his velocity has been in a steady decline in recent seasons. He averaged a career-best 92.5 mph in 2022 but dipped to 92.2 mph, 91.4 mph and 90.3 mph in subsequent seasons. His swinging-strike rate has dropped accordingly in each season, though he’s still managed to continue posting strong strikeout rates.
Sewald’s placement on the injured list just over two weeks before the trade deadline is increasingly notable, given his team’s recent slide in the standings. The Guardians dropped 10 straight games from June 27 through July 6, though they lessened some of that sting by closing out the first half with six wins in seven games. They’re now three games under .500 and four and a half games out of the final Wild Card spot in the American League.
Cleveland will open the second half with winnable series against the A’s, Orioles, Royals and Rockies — all of whom have records that are comparable to or worse than the Guardians’ own mark of 46-49. If the Guards slip further down the standings, they’d be increasingly likely to listen to offers on short-term veterans like Sewald. If he’s facing a notable absence, that scenario is off the table. Conversely, if the Guardians slice through that slate of opponents in the two weeks between now and the trade deadline, they’d presumably be more apt to add to the club, and Sewald’s absence could increase the front office’s desire to add to the bullpen.
The Sewald signing is still such a whacky move to me.. I get bringing in a veteran to reinforce the bullpen after they carried a heavy load last year but $7 million seems like a ton of money for a guy like him.
Free agent pitchers are expensive.
Especially when Pedro Avila, I thought, earned a shot at keeping his spot in the bullpen last year. Two years in a row (Barlow and now Sewald) where they’ve added an expensive veteran to the bullpen that didn’t work out.
My biggest issue with the way the Guardians have operated is that they’ve put their offseason budgets toward a few “depth pieces” (read: replacement level players) instead of combining it on one bigger name.
Barlow and Sewald are two examples, but also Laureano, Junis, Hedges/Zunino, etc.
Jose wanted hedges back for 2024 season. Jose said hedges was the missing link. Guardians didnt make playoffs in 2023 because austin wasnt there.
I know Jose wanted him and I agreed with that logic in 2023 when Hedges wasn’t there, and to an extent I still believe it now. (I love Hedges too, for what it’s worth.) Most of his value is pretty tough to quantify, but at least on paper he’s a replacement level player. But something has been off with them this year too, even with Hedges there.
Either way, that doesn’t explain the rest of those moves. Adding Sewald had some logic because of Vogt’s familiarity with him in Seattle and their bullpen usage last year, but dedicating around 7% of your small payroll to a guy who would have been your fourth best reliever in a best-case scenario was probably a poor use of resources. Especially when you had guys like Walters (who was healthy at the time), Aleman, and Enright who were major league ready options to slide into that same role for the league minimum.
I agree, especially because it’s the Guardians. They’re usually pretty conservative in how they spend their money. $7 million for an aging reliever who had an ERA north of 7 after July 1st last year was a bit surprising. I would have expected $5 million max.
Sabrowski level up.
And so it goes for Guardians fans
Dolan choking on Sewald’s $7 million salary.
Straw and Gimenez are no longer on the payroll. “Let’s blow some cash on Sewald!”