After being traded from the Red Sox to the Giants in a shocking June blockbuster, Rafael Devers hasn’t quite looked like himself in recent weeks. At least some of that downturn in productivity can likely be attributed to injury, as Janie McCauley of the Associated Press writes that Devers is facing a disk injury in his lower back that has hampered him during his time in San Francisco. Manager Bob Melvin discussed Devers’s status with reporters (including McCauley) yesterday and suggested that the club is hopeful their new superstar will be able to avoid a stint on the injured list thanks to the impending time off associated with the All-Star break.
Aside from that impending opportunity to rest up for the second half, Devers began taking anti-inflammatory medication to help combat the symptoms and underwent an MRI exam on Thursday as he continues to play through the issue. Melvin suggested that the issue bothers Devers the most when he’s running the bases, though he acknowledged that the injury was “probably a little bit” of a problem for the slugger at the plate as well. The manager went on to suggest that his back injury is the reason Devers has remained entrenched as the club’s DH rather than moving to first base, where he has not only agreed to play for San Francisco but also begun working out before games in preparation for the move.
The news that Devers isn’t fully healthy sheds some additional light on his performance so far with his new team. It’s likely hard for Giants fans to not be a bit disappointed in their recently-acquired star’s performance so far given that he’s hit just .220/.350/.354 (104 wRC+) in his first 23 games as a Giant. That’s already a sample size of 100 plate appearances, but it’s easier to dismiss those numbers as an outlier and believe that better days are ahead given the possibility that he’ll be able to produce more like his usual self if he can rest up and get healthy. Additionally, Melvin’s comments suggest that Devers playing through injury is the reason they’ve been reluctant to deploy him at first base rather than any struggles adapting to the new position in drills or resistance from Devers himself to the move.
While a physical explanation for Devers’s slump offers reason for optimism that he’ll bounce back when fully healthy, it’s fair to wonder whether or not the All-Star break will actually be enough time for him to shake the injury. Back issues are hardly uncommon for sluggers as they age. Mike Trout, Kris Bryant, and Miguel Cabrera are among a number of star players who have had their careers impacted by back problems at varying levels as they aged, and injuries of that sort can often be nagging and become a matter of pain tolerance. While Devers is still just 28 years old, he’s often battled through day-to-day injuries to other areas of his body in the past: shoulder, hamstring, knee, and groin issues have cropped up at various points the slugger’s time in the majors.
While that aforementioned trio are known for their struggles remaining healthy later in their careers, a large number of hitters deal with back problems at one point or another but go on to stay healthy in the future and avoid ongoing issues. It’s a situation worth monitoring for the Giants, who have Devers have locked up for eight seasons after this one, but there’s little reason to automatically assume this will be a long-term problem for him throughout his time in San Francisco at this point. In the short-term, the Giants will continue relying on a combination of Dominic Smith and Wilmer Flores at first base while Devers heals up and gets ready to take over the position.
I definitely didn’t read that as “disk” at first 😳
A ruptured dish is bad too
/s
paddyo – Agreed! Though there’s no way to know for sure, since his decline began on June 9th perhaps the Sox became motivated to act quickly on the trade for this exact reason.
It’s not like it was an impact-related injury that could be pinpointed, it was probably beginning to really bother him around that time.
Well on behalf of all the good people here, get well soon Raffy! We love you and we pray you will recover quickly.
That would be incredibly unethical on Boston’s part, like actionably so. Remember when the Padres shipped us Pomeranz, knowing he was hurt and they got in trouble for it?
The receiving team didn’t review his medicals?
I’m wondering how you paired that with “lower back.”
He was raw dogging.
At least it has been obliterated
We see what we want to see.
That was the first thought glance as well…
Way too early to be disappointed.
We get this guy for the next 8 years.
You’ll probably hear about this type of problem the entire time.
Or not.
Never did subscribe to the doomer crystal ball society.
It’s not that, as @ohyeahdam said back injuries never end well.
9 injuries (not counting this one) during the past 3 years for Devers in Boston, Get used to it.
foxsports.com/mlb/rafael-devers-player-injuries
Especially when the back in question is supporting a large belly.
Jimbo – Mayer has chronic back issues as well. I wouldn’t say they *always* don’t end well, but yes they often don’t.
@FPG I guess what I mean is it’s one of those issues that’s always lurking never completely resolved.
Fever pitch guy making stuff up again. Mayer had one back injury that resulted in an extended absence. That is not a chronic issue.
Lower back injuries, see Kris Bryant, aren’t the best sign
Red Sox hiding medicals maybe? Ooooooohhhoo!!!
oh – They wouldn’t be the first team guilty of it.
More likely they were aware of the issue but didn’t do any imaging or have a specialist check it out, which means there would be no medicals.
Trading team ALWAYS has a chance to look at the medicals. This is BS
Pudge – Please re-read my post.
I made it quite clear there could be no medicals ON AN ACTIVE BACK INJURY.
Nowhere did I say there were no medicals of any kind. Certainly there would be medicals on his shoulders.
And you get to pay this guy for the next 8 years. Whether he plays or not.
That is indeed how contracts work.
*mlb contracts
Yea, moving to a league is usually a disadvantage for hitters because they don’t have much experience with most of the pitchers.
On the other hand, Red Sox trading him right as he’s developing back problems does seem worrisome.
He passed a physical. Either the Giants missed something or the injury appeared during his time in SF. In case of the latter, stuff happens.
Oldg: You’re going to be sorry he’s on your team as early as 2027. He’s not 28, bad defensively, and rotund. He’s declining already. Boston (who I loathe) rooked you guys bad on the deal.
One tweaked back and the dumbasses start with this nonsense. Im pretty stoked to have Raffy Devers on my team.
He no-showed Will Clark for fielding practice. He’s a prima donna. Enjoy the next 8 years of watching him go all Anthony Rendon.
rhand – As the saying goes, misery loves company.
And as Clemens once said, “Reports of my demise are greatly exaggerated.”.
That was Mark Twain, I believe.
That was Samuel Clemens.
hayzee – That was also Roger Clemens after Duquette said he was “in the twilight of his career”.
See what I did there? ;O)
Poor Duquette. Never has a guy been so perfectly spot on with a comment, only to have it overcome by massive PED use. Though perhaps he was naive to not factor that element in!
Hahaha. Yep. 8 years. Hahahaha. Sorry.
$30 million a year for a guy with a 100 OPS+. That is pretty disappointing,
Shoulda bought the warranty!
Interesting that this wasn’t identified during the physical prior to the trades completion.
Mondesi: How do you know it wasn’t?
Stuart: How do you sleep at night?
Stuart replied: on a mattress from Mattress Firm.
Lloyd Emerson: By turning off the lights, closing my eyes, and breathing very deeply.
That’s how we humans sleep. What about your species?
With one eye open. Good luck 🙂
Actually, during NREM sleep human’s breath becomes shallow.
outinleftfield: Details
Google is your friend. Or if you are up to the deep dive, NIH.gov
outinleftfield: It’s not that serious an issue. But go look it up if that’s your thing.
@Baron: Because the Giants tend to exercise extreme caution (remember Carlos Correa) and the fact this is coming out just weeks after completion without any prior inclination.
Mondesi: But you don’t know that it wasn’t identified and discussed before the deal was done anyway.
There was not necessarily a physical just an exchange of medical info between team doctors
I bet that degenerative disk condition really flares up when they ask him to get his first baseman’s mitt.
Don’t bet because you made up the “degenerative” part.
M m my degeneration.
I didnt make anything up. All bones, joints, spines, muscles, etc… are degenerative in a sense. The human body is degenrative unless you’re Benjamin FN Button.
I merely included the adjective to extend the emphasis of what was intended to be a simple sarcastic quip but thanks for putting you’re pouty and accusatory two cents in the pot.
Oh please. Really ?
You changed the reality.
No pouts or accusations, just sound advice on your future bet, even if it is only for my 2 cents.
Tough crowd. Advice – Ad – Vice – A – D – V – I – C – E – I don’t get it?
Thanks for trying to enlighten me.
In reality, I have a disk problem in my back that reoccurs from time to time, I can go a year or two without it ever being an issue and then for a couple weeks I injure it and Im down for two weeks with this nerve pain that is difficult to deal with. Now, I have had it diagnosed. I dont take oain meds or go the doctor for it, I just ride it out, and it usually subsides. But, would I consider it a degenerative condition? Yes, I never had the issue in my thirties. All conditio s and injuries can be described as degenerative. Like your teeth and your smelly breath, your mouth is degenrative.
So you made it up
6th grade name calling will never help, but good luck with your degenerative condition. I sincerely hope you improve. Back pain sucks.
There’s a 28yo with a disc related sore back and then there’s Chris Bryant with a degenerative disc disease. An early aging of the spine issue. One is not the other.
You know whats funny about people like you, who act polite and proper all the time, you are usually the most rotten of all. From my perspective, you’re comment on my joke was the most ignorant of all the comments made in this back and forth between you and I, because it was a baseless correction to what was clearly meant to be a sarcastic joke. That’s my own viewpoint. I think you are likely a
“Artistic liberty refers to the freedom to deviate from strict rules, realism, or established norms to achieve a desired effect or to express their unique vision.”
The news article above is the facts, this is the comments section.
Not giving the sarcasm enough weight is fair criticism. Point taken.
You’re digging your own grave there BW, no one believes your bs.
People like me ?
Pouty, smelly breath, ignorant, most rotten of all guys ?
Dude. Sorry I hurt your feelings.
Nice chat. I think you’re great !
Indeed, no clear Dx yet that indicates it’s a herniated disk.
Ha ha. I’ll just change “disk injury”to “degenerative disk condition” and hope no one notices.
This is probably a crazy conspiracy but I think this whole thing is a work to cover for Devers. Giants want to please him and are covering for the Will Clark fiasco.
I’d buy that. Short quick dl before the all star break is the perfect time
Probably not, but core strength is crucial, and Devers hardly appears to be a guy that is a poster boy for that.
The Will Clark thing was an interesting followup to the rest of the story. He wouldn’t get back to David Ortiz when he offered help, and he doesn’t communicate with Will Clark who shows up for three straight days to work with him at 1B. On top of the rest of the RS fiasco. At some point one sees that the pattern is pointing in a certain direction.
Dudes hanging tough and playing hurt. How does that fit the pattern ?
Too bad the Will Clark fiasco was mostly made up in the first place.
What part was made up?
None of it was made up. Devers skipped out without talking to Will first because he was afraid to face his former teammates. That is what will said happened. Will tried to cover for Devers but the complete truth made Devers look even worse than what the media had indicated happened in the first place.
What he really said was that he totally understood why Devers didn’t want to be working out in front of the Boston dugout with all the media present. Read it yourself.
sports.yahoo.com/mlb/breaking-news/article/red-sox…
Andy – Will Clark isn’t exactly a saint, but on this issue he was 100% correct about Flemming. Just like Dave O’Brien, typical cheapshot artists when star players leave Boston.
I loved Clark’s response to Flemming, he was right on target:
“Will Flemming, you can go eff off, MF.” Clark said, much to the delight of Byrnes. “You want to effing take a conversation that we’re having and then blow it out of proportion because you’re a effing East Coast POS reporter, eff off”
It’s guys like Flemming and O’Brien that make me embarrassed to admit I’m an East Coast/Boston guy myself.
What a gigantic dropoff from the ALWAYS classy and professional Joe Castig, oh how I miss him. Listening to Flemming and O’Brien is absolutely unbearable.
I laughed so hard when I read Will’s comments on the matter. Classic. Excellent use of emphasis.
There was no “Will Clark fiasco” though
Yes there was, and it was caused by space lasers and a weather machine.
Ha ha ha. And the twitter ecosphere.
Will didn’t hold back in his attack…..on the Red Sox guy !
Makes sense. As we’ve seen in Colorado, fans really warm up to a new acquisition they’ll have for the next 8 years when they find out he has a back disk injury.
Yeah, it’s a crazy conspiracy.
If they wanted to explain why he wasn’t taking the field, all they would need would be to drag out the shoulder injuries (both shoulders?) from last year. His body has not been aging well the last couple years (to put it mildly).
Mine isn’t aging all that well either, but happily my job doesn’t involve performing as an athlete at the highest level.
What’s the over/under on how many doctor appointments he’s going to miss?
As long as he’s got Will Clark making sure he’s there, he shouldn’t miss any.
Too soon to call the Sox the victors in this trade?
It’s quite obvious that the Sox fans are suffering. The constant lashing out on every thread about Devers. It sucks to lose good players. Sorry for your loss.
But really happy for SFGs gain.
So, yes way too soon.
Yeah, those Red Sox fans suffering through winning 12 of their last 13. Must be very tough on them.
dan – That’s the thing that is so very sad.
Even with the current win streak, certain Sox fans still insist on bashing Devers.
Not being able to get over the loss of a superstar player is extremely unhealthy.
Bash Devers, bash ownership, bash bash bash for some. All I know is that I found a lot to love about the team and sport pre-2004, and since then I have absolutely nothing to complain about. There was a window of mediocrity that I definitely didn’t want to see extended much longer, and fortunately the team seems to be either preparing to escape that or perhaps even already has!
The Red Sox were 36-36 the day he was traded. Today they are 52-45 having gone 16-9 since the trade. From what they are saying on here and on other boards, Red Sox fans are extremely happy he is gone.
They got rid of Devers. That was a huge win for the Red Sox. You can see it in how well they have played since they traded him.
Nope
Christian Yelich’s back problems turned him into a mere mortal in his age 28 season.
It not a surprise…that’s a lot of team to have to put on his back.~
He’s probably done as we know hm. Tough break for SF but they didn’t give up much to get him.
$250 mil is nothing to shake a stick at.
On other injury notes, it looks like Konnor Griffin will get some IL time after getting smashed in the wrist during the Futures game.
Pirates season is officially over.
Carrying that big paycheck to play 1st base really hurts, see ya Devers.
Yikes, back problems can be a killer. Hope he can get back to full strength, but you never know with an injury like this.
Love how the conspiracy theorists jump out to wonder if the red sox were hiding something..this dude wouldn’t even take the field for them and was mashing at the plate prior to getting on that plane to SF..if the giants didnt do a complete physical once he landed thats on them.this is 100% a SF problem..like the man said “ill play anywhere” …yep except boston…good luck
Isn’t Devers likely to mess himself up more if they put him in the field and he is diving for ground balls? I was happy Boston kept him at DH so he wouldn’t slam himself into the ground.
Are you really expecting him to dive? Ain’t getting paid enough for that!
It doesn’t look like there is a mortality rate for this injury so no thoughts and prayers from me…
Did the Red Sox dump him just in time or is this part of the injuries that kept him out of spring training games until March 15th?
He wasn’t injured in ST. They just had to wait for him to quit pouting.
Both shoulders were injured during spring training. Its why he didn’t play in any games until March 15th. But that doesn’t make your comment any less funny. It put a smile on my grumpy old face.
Buyer beware market…the acquiring team gets a chance to do a physical and review medicals and unless there’s something really material, I wonder what the accepted obligations of a seller really are. The teams must have some sense of who cuts corners and who is straight
Boston playing like a team that loves Devers is no longer part of it.
Probably that extra 40 pounds on the midsection!🤣
Craig Breslow redemption arc incoming.