1:00pm: Patrick Saunders of The Denver Post reports this afternoon that there’s “no truth” to rumors that the Rockies’ search for a new front office leader have stalled or that they have begun looking at alternative candidates. That doesn’t necessarily mean a deal with Sawdaye or Forman is close or even expected, of course, but it suggests that the team’s search continues with the same group of finalists they had narrowed the field to in recent weeks. While Sawdaye and Forman are the only two names known to be in that group, it’s possible that additional finalists have been in the mix throughout the entire process who simply haven’t been named publicly.
11:50am: The Rockies have been on the hunt for a new head of baseball operations ever since GM Bill Schmidt departed the club at the beginning of October. With the offseason now officially upon us, the pressure to find the next person who will lead Colorado’s front office is growing significantly.
While Diamondbacks assistant GM Amiel Sawdaye and Guardians assistant GM Matt Forman both emerged as finalists for the job in recent weeks, today a report from Jon Heyman of the New York Post suggests that, at least for the time being, neither Sawdaye or Forman appear poised to be named the Rockies’ head of baseball operations. Thomas Harding of MLB.com adds that conversations with both Sawdaye and Forman have been “productive,” but the Rockies are still in the midst of their search and “the feeling was” that other candidates were still in the mix despite Sawdaye and Forman being the only two publicly identified finalists.
It’s not clear if Sawdaye and/or Forman are still in the running for the job or if they’re no longer under consideration, but at the very least it seems as though the Rockies will spend at least the first few days of the offseason without a proper head of baseball operations. That’s not completely unheard of, as the Astros famously parted ways with James Click early in the 2022-23 offseason and didn’t hire a new head of baseball operations until late January, with club chairman Jim Crane running baseball operations in that interim period.
As previously mentioned, Sawdaye and Forman are the only two names who have been confirmed as finalists for the role. Click and Royals assistant GM Scott Sharp were once part of the search but are reportedly no longer in consideration. Former Twins GM Thad Levine was connected to the position immediately after Bill Schmidt’s departure, but has never been confirmed to have even spoken to the Rockies about the role to this point.
Whoever ultimately ends up taking the reins of baseball operations in Colorado, their first decision will be one that becomes less flexible the longer the search drags on. The Rockies finished the season with interim manager Warren Schaeffer at the helm of the dugout, but his future in the role as well as the futures of the rest of the coaching staff in the organization are set to be determined by the club’s eventual baseball operations hire. If the team’s search for a new baseball operations leader drags deep into the offseason, the continuity offered by keeping Schaeffer and much of the Rockies coaching staff in the fold could become more valuable as other candidates settle into roles elsewhere around the league.

Some version of the Albert Pujols/Matt Holliday baseball cartel wants involved with the baseball side of a team’s operations. Rockies seemed primed to give them a shot. Whoever the GM of that would be part of the management package.
Pretty sure the Blue Jays had a really good chance to win the World Series this year. Dodgers make it two years in a row now everyone is ready just to crown them champs. Ridiculous and I’m not even a Dodgers fan
Towinagain is right. No team matters except for the Dodgers. It’s our league and we just let you guys play in it. I’ve been telling you guys for years and now some of you are finally waking up to the fact that LA is head and shoulders above the rest of you plebs.
Be grateful we even let your teams step on the same field as our team.
Bro you aren’t apart of the Dodgers. The Dodgers are amazing, you are the complete opposite
Please do us all a favour and just stop watching baseball
In an ideal world, the Rockies would do everything they could to bring in former Rockies reliever Jerry DiPoto. It fits everything the Monforts stand for. He is a “member of the family” and has proven that he can build a winner. Plus, all that trade activity would be exciting for the fan base. Of course now that I said that, it makes sense why the Rockies AREN’T going after him.
Monfort has a lot of former talent they’ve burnt bridges with.
I think if DiPoto would have considered the job in Colorado, it would have been 4 years ago instead of Schmidt. Now he’s established a winner in Seattle and that’s where he will stay. Now that the Holliday boys have big league careers, I would like to see Matt manage the Rockies. He’s done a good job getting Jackson and Ethan to where they need to be.
Dipoto would be a great option for Colorado but there’s no way in hell he would ever leave Seattle to work for that dumpster fire that exists in Denver.
Coors field makes that job incredibly difficult and Monfort makes it extremely undesirable.
If Monfort had any brain cells alive he would give Jeff Luhnow a blank check and tell him to do exactly what he did to build Houston into a perennial contender.
Why not? It’s not like Seattle has never been a dumpster fire in its history. It doesn’t take long for a bad team to become a good team IF you try and are not just content collecting draft picks. If the Rockies made a splash and signed Bo Bichette to play second and signed Luis Arraez to play 1B/DH and maybe signed or traded for a vet starter or two, they could improve to near .500 ball next year and more importantly teach their young players not to just accept losing.
The Rockies need a hell of a lot more than that to get near .500.
This team won 43 games.
@hiflew –
What you’re describing are moves at the margin that might help a team with around .500-ish level talent.
The Rockies have an awful major league roster, paired with a farm system that MLB.com ranked #24 in its mid-season rankings.
And, going by articles such as sports.yahoo.com/mlb/article/why-are-the-colorado-…, a completely antiquated front office that has failed to keep up *at all* with how other teams approach player evaluation and development.
The Rockies need a full-scale overhaul, starting from a position that’s probably worse than other MLB team.
The Rockies would still have a below average 3B and DH. They got sub 2 WAR from each of their Of’ers. (That’s the spot where they have some potential from young players to do better) A lot of those promising young OF’ers have stalled in the upper minors though.
They have 0 pitching outside of a couple of good not great relievers.
The next FO has a lot of work to do and it’s going to take years.
Farm system rankings are nothing but an opinion. There are no guarantees with any prospects. As I said, I don’t expect a division title or anything in 2026. But some upward movement is possible. Getting to 70-75 wins would be a huge improvement and a good sign. Doing nothing to improve and winning 50 games next year just might make question whether there is a better way to spend my time and money. I don’t mind losing, but I hate not trying.
I watched over 150 Rockies games this season and it would be nice to not have to shut them off early because they were basically just playing out the string after the 3rd inning.
Farm system rankings if you knew anything about them directly have correlated to many World Series titles in the past 15 years. Astros top farm system lead to a decade of winning, cubs top 5 farm won in 2016. Redsox top farm won. Nationals same. Braves yep story checks out. Dodgers secret to success yep always a top farm.
Rockies will have sustainable success when they learn how to draft and develop better given their market small and restraints.
They need to hire someone that’s going to be innovatived with building a team in that ballpark because they’re at such a disadvantage.
Id say the vast majority of pro athletes across all sports and teams do not just accept losing. They have reached the apex of the game, very very few players reach that level on talent alone. The majority have put in a ton of work to get where they are and many have no doubt had their ups and downs and not quit. So any notion that they “just accept losing” is ridiculous.
Maybe the problem is that no one worth hiring would want that job.
The position could be a seat warmer for his son Walter.
Is it too soon to worry that everyone good is going to turn the Rockies down? I know we’re only one day into the offseason but I can’t help but wonder already if candidates don’t feel like Monfort will give them autonomy.
No one pitcher wants to sign with the Rockies. Dollander, Hughes, Sullivan and Brown aren’t going to be able to compete with other top teams. The Rockies hitters also strike out too much.
The Monforts are a joke. They either simply don’t care about winning, or have no idea how to do so.
I think that’s a reasonable possibility.
If we believe some articles, the Rockies are way behind pretty much every other team on analytics and player development. The Rockies’ MLB payrolls have usually been reasonable relative to market size/revenue, but Monfort reportedly hasn’t wanted to spend on organizational infrastructure. Plus a fair number of people in important front office jobs have been with the Rockies since the 1990’s.
Someone coming from the Guardians, for example, is very likely going to look at that situation and only want the job if given the ability to overhaul the way that the front office operates, including replacing a bunch of people and spending a bunch more money on the front office than the Rockies currently do.
Which they should want to do since there’s no point in spending much $ on the major league club right now. They were able to get from under Mcmahon’s contract. There’s really nothing long term aside from the Bryant debacle and Tovar who is young and has potential.
It’s a pretty clean situation if you’re allowed to build from the ground up. You aren’t saddled with a ton of bad cash.
Ruben Amaro Jr still trying to get the job
LOL
I’ll do it. It’s not like i can realistically make them worse…
Word on the street is the Rockies are hot on the trail of their first general manager Robert Gebhard. Rockies executives have been seen in Fort Wayne with shovels looking for him.
At least Bob G. got the Rockies into the playoffs in their 3rd season. But was was 1995, ages ago in the era of big data analytics.
I’ve sent the Rockies a bunch of emails and even a hard copy of one of my letters. What have they got to lose? Another 100+ games?
Should be interesting to watch. Not expecting the Rockies to make the resulting decision interesting, but the process hopefully will be.