The Diamondbacks are going to reinstate first baseman Pavin Smith from the 60-day injured list, reports John Gambadoro of Arizona Sports 98.7 FM Phoenix. Infielder/outfielder Tim Tawa will be optioned as the corresponding active roster move. The Snakes will also need to open a 40-man spot.
Smith played in just two games before left elbow inflammation put him on the 10-day injured list at the end of March. He was transferred to the 60-day IL in mid-April and the team announced that he would require surgery to remove loose bodies from his elbow. He had recovered enough to start a rehab assignment a week ago. He hit .333/.364/.381 in five rehab games and is now going to rejoin the big league squad.
The former seventh overall pick seemingly broke out in the past couple of seasons. Over 2024 and 2025, he put up a big .262/.357/.475 slash line, which translated to a 130 wRC+. However, there were some asterisks in there. For one, the sample size was just 446 plate appearances. In 2024, Smith was still a fringe roster player and was optioned to the minors multiple times, only getting 158 big league plate appearances. Last year, IL stints for a strained oblique and then a strained quad capped him at 288 plate appearances.
He has also done most of his damage with the platoon advantage. A left-handed hitter, he had a .271/.359/.493 line against righties over those two campaigns but just a .184/.340/.316 line versus southpaws. Furthermore, he finished 2025 poorly. He had a .342/.473/.630 line through April but then a .222/.311/.351 line the rest of the way, working around those aforementioned injuries.
Despite the question marks, it seems the Diamondbacks planned on him being at least a strong-side platoon guy here in 2026. They signed the switch-hitting Carlos Santana to join Smith in the first base group. Santana is a switch-hitter and good defender, so he could shield Smith from lefties and also occasionally serve as a defensive replacement, since Smith isn’t considered an especially strong defender.
They haven’t had much of a chance to implement that plan. As mentioned, Smith appeared in just two games before hitting the IL. An adductor strain sent Santana to the IL after just eight appearances.
In the interim, the Snakes have mostly been using utility guys José Fernández and Ildemaro Vargas to cover first base. Vargas, a 34-year-old journeyman, has a strong .295/.321/.465 line on the year. However, that is mostly due to an improbable 24-game hit streak to begin the season, which was technically a 27-game streak when factoring in last season. Since that streak, he has a .198/.225/.255 line in 111 plate appearances. It’s a similar story for Fernández, who had a .325/.349/.470 line at the end of April but hit .181/.224/.236 in May.
Smith could now take up the first base job, at least against righties, and bump those two back into utility roles. Smith could also slot in as the designated hitter. Adrian Del Castillo has been getting most of the playing time there this year but has a line of just .192/.252/.325. Whether he’s at first base or DH, Smith will presumably need a platoon partner. Fernández and Vargas could perhaps help there since Fernández is a righty and Vargas a switch-hitter.
As for the 40-man move, it’s possible Santana gets transferred to the 60-day IL. His 60-day count would be retroactive to his initial IL placement, which was April 6th, so it’s already been almost 60 days. He began a rehab assignment at the beginning of May but last played on May 10th. Nick Piecoro of the Arizona Republic relayed at that time that Santana had re-injured his adductor. He hasn’t yet started a new rehab assignment and presumably isn’t likely to be reinstated in the near term.
Photo courtesy of Jayne Kamin-Oncea, Imagn Images
Weird career.
They see me pavin! They hatin
If he could ever get more than 250 ABs in a season, he would probably be a decent hitter, he wouldn’t be a bad player on the right team with an opening at first base