Headlines

  • Kelvin Herrera Announces Retirement
  • Braves Extend Brian Snitker
  • Giants, Scott Kazmir Agree To Minor League Deal
  • Yankees Sign Justin Wilson
  • Braves Sign Jake Lamb
  • Athletics Sign Mitch Moreland
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Indians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2020-21 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • 2020-21 MLB Free Agent Tracker
    • 2020-21 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2021-22 MLB Free Agent List
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2021
    • 2021 MLB Arbitration Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • Last 100 Comments
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Clayton Kershaw, Corey Kluber Win Cy Young Awards

By Steve Adams | November 12, 2014 at 5:53pm CDT

Clayton Kershaw and Corey Kluber have won the National League and American League Cy Young Awards, respectively.

Kershaw was a unanimous winner, with Johnny Cueto and Adam Wainwright finishing second and third, respectively. Madison Bumgarner finished in fourth place (obligatory caveat: votes were due before the postseason commenced), while Jordan Zimmermann, Cole Hamels, Zack Greinke, Doug Fister, Jake Arrieta, Craig Kimbrel, Stephen Strasburg and Henderson Alvarez rounded out the ballot. The award marks Kershaw’s third Cy Young in four seasons.

Kluber, a breakout star with the Indians, edged out Mariners ace Felix Hernandez, who finished second. Kluber received a total of 169 points in the voting, while Hernandez received 159. Rounding out the ballot were Chris Sale, Jon Lester, Max Scherzer, David Price, Phil Hughes, Wade Davis and Greg Holland. Kluber posted an 18-9 record with a 2.44 ERA, 10.3 K/9, 1.9 BB/9 and a 48 percent ground-ball rate in 235 2/3 innings.

Share 22 Retweet 52 Send via email5

Clayton Kershaw Cleveland Indians Corey Kluber Los Angeles Dodgers Newsstand

Andrew Miller Seeking Four-Year Deal
Main
Six Teams Showing Legitimate Interest In Jon Lester
143 comments
newest oldest

Comments

  1. Dogger27

    6 years ago

    Felix was completely rob of the CY Young!

    Like
    Reply
    • Scott Christopher MacGregor

      6 years ago

      Kluber was Better check the stats

      Like
      Reply
      • acottonshirt

        6 years ago

        He was better at like 2 stats. Felix bested him in almost all the stats, even the saber metrics.

        Like
        Reply
        • LazerTown

          6 years ago

          And what about FIP?

          Like
          Reply
          • charles

            6 years ago

            this is why no one takes these baseball writers seriously.

            Like
            Reply
          • acottonshirt

            6 years ago

            Right, He was better at a couple more stats than Felix. FIP is one of those stats.

            Like
            Reply
            • Christopher Rioux

              6 years ago

              I don’t know, FIELDING INDEPENDENT PITCHING is a pretty important thing to be better at. You know, what with the job of the pitcher being pitching, independently of the fielding, and all…

              Like
              Reply
              • Metsfan93

                6 years ago

                FIP is not accurate enough by its lonesome. Jeff Sullivan’s article on the matter today summed it up best.

                Like
                Reply
              • slasher016

                6 years ago

                I’m not a huge fan of FIP. Every pitcher has fielders. I get the point, but getting an out of a perfectly placed first pitch on a grounder to SS is better than a strikeout that takes 11 pitches. FIP says the strikeout is always better.

                Like
                Reply
                • Metsfan93

                  6 years ago

                  That’s why you consider innings as a whole. Predictively, going forward, unless you’re an excellent contact manager and get groundouts and popups, it’s better to just limit homers, get strikeouts, and limit walks. Quality of contact is always going to be a consideration, but Cleveland *did* have a very bad defense behind him.

                  Like
                  Reply
                • The_Unnatural

                  6 years ago

                  According to FIP, the hitter got himself out, not the pitcher and his perfect pitch. That’s what bugs me most out sabermetrics. It has no “feel” for the game and they have no idea how to calculate things like sequencing.

                  Like
                  Reply
                  • Metsfan93

                    6 years ago

                    Sabermetrics are not any different from most statistics. It’s all about large samples to eliminate noise and make it so sequencing and random variation doesn’t affect results. Sequencing isn’t a skill. Sequencing of events is luck, and doesn’t carry predictive value going forward. It’s why RE24 is a retrospective stat to analyze past results and not predict future true talent levels.

                    Like
                    Reply
                    • The_Unnatural

                      6 years ago

                      I meant pitch sequencing, and it is a skill. That and command is what separates your Felix Hernandezs from the Hector Noesis. You know pitchability. It’s why sabermetrics say Chris Young was the worst starter in baseball last year despite being one of the biggest reasons the Mariners made it as far as they did.

                      Like
                      Reply
                      • Metsfan93

                        6 years ago

                        Sabermetrics don’t say Chris Young was terrible. People who don’t understand sabermetrics – and thus give it a bad name – do. In fact, stats-savvy people have been writing articles in support of Young all season and acknowledge his contribution to Seattle. Pitch sequencing/keeping batters guessing is a skill, yeah. I thought you meant hit sequencing leading to runs being scored. Chris Young breaks FIP because he pitches up in the zone and induces pop-ups. Pop ups are as good as strikeouts and I have a feeling the next big breakthrough in sabermetrics is going to revolve around exit speed and exit angle for batted balls. Pitchers can definitely control the contact they induce. They can’t control where it’s hit and if it lands for a hit, but they can definitely use pitch sequence to keep batters guessing, get them to hit it on the weak part of the bat and either send it straight up into the air, or into the ground. That’s an area of baseball analysis I really want to see headway in. I have a feeling we’ll see that Edwin Jackson and other guys who FIP loves but generate terrible runs-allowed results, will suffer under this analysis.

                        Like
                        Reply
                • Christopher Rioux

                  6 years ago

                  It’s not that the strikeout is always better. It’s that controlling what happens to a batted ball that stays in play is not a skill that pitchers possess. The larger the sample size, the more a pitcher will regress to the mean of the league, given his batted ball rates.

                  Given that a pitcher can’t control what happens to that ball, and given that every strikeout is an out 100% of the time (dropped third strikes notwithstanding), a strikeout always is a successful result while a batted ball is not always a successful result.

                  It’s not like we’re comparing apples and oranges here. We’re comparing a delicious apple with another slightly more delicious apple. You have to have some way to pick apart two extremely good performances and figure out which one was better.

                  Like
                  Reply
                  • slasher016

                    6 years ago

                    Except they don’t always “regress” to the mean. Cueto is a perfect example. He has ALWAYS every single year outpitched his FIP. That’s seven years of pitching. How many more years until he regresses to the mean?

                    Like
                    Reply
                    • Metsfan93

                      6 years ago

                      Cueto is a very common example of a pitcher who sabermetrics acknowledge likely has an ability to control his batted ball profile, inducing a low liner rate and a high fly ball rate with many of his fly balls bordering on pop up exit angle. Cueto is someone – like Chris Young – who induces batted balls which *many* sabermetricians acknowledge break the DIPS theory. There will always be exceptions to the rule, but that doesn’t make FIP any worse of a stat. It just backs up the point that analysts need to consider all information together. Tony Blengino did an excellent article back in mid-August about Cueto’s contact management and how adept he is at inducing weak contact and strong batted ball results to complement his strong fielding-independent profile.

                      Like
                      Reply
                    • Christopher Rioux

                      6 years ago

                      The answer is four. Four more years. Definitely four.

                      Like
                      Reply
          • The_Unnatural

            6 years ago

            The big knock against Felix’s “FIP” was one game against the Nats where he gave up like 4 or 5 homers. Felix’s “xFIP” was better than Kluber’s. Felix lost because Kluber finished strong and had a few more wins. Whatever.

            Like
            Reply
            • Metsfan93

              6 years ago

              They pitched to a draw via xFIP, essentially. Kluber’s xFIP- was 68, with a raw xFIP of 2.57. For Felix, 67 and 2.51.

              Like
              Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          He gets advantages from things like isolating his runs-allowed from his defense, looking at his catcher framers (Zunino > Gomes) and his ballpark.

          Like
          Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          fWAR, FIP, K/9, HR/9 is not insignificant. They were a draw in IP (Felix got one more out) and starts (both had 34), while Felix bettered him slightly in xFIP (2.51 to 2.57) and a bit in BB/9 (1.75 vs. 1.95) and a bit more in ERA (2.14 vs. 2.44). They were actually only four runs allowed apart, 72 vs. 68 with Felix lower, because Felix allowed 12 unearned runs while Kluber allowed 8. Kluber has a 22.9 K-BB%, while Felix has a 22.2 K-BB%, and Felix had the better framer. Kluber had a 66/64/68 ERA-/FIP-/xFIP-, and Felix had a 58/70/67 split in those three stats. They’re basically even in many stats with small advantages either way. I’d pick Kluber, but I don’t mind Felix being slightly ahead. I don’t think it’s a landslide either way, and the voting reflected that.

          Like
          Reply
          • davbee

            6 years ago

            You’re giving the voters too much credit. They saw Kluber with 18 wins and Felix with 15 and voted accordingly. They may have gotten the right result, but for the wrong reason.

            Like
            Reply
            • Metsfan93

              6 years ago

              I absolutely disagree. Completely, wholeheartedly, 100%. I don’t think you’re giving the voters enough credit. CY has been moving along better than MVP as far as embracing sabermetrics, because team performance is less of a consideration in the definition. I think the voters did their due diligence here and rightfully recognized it was essentially a draw. Do I think they looked at fWAR, xFIP, etc.? No. Do I think they might have seen a combination lots of strikeouts, not a lot of walks, low ERA, finished strong, 236 IP, poor team defense, good framers, worse home park for Kluber? Maybe.

              Like
              Reply
              • davbee

                6 years ago

                Take out the “good framers” argument (which I still think is beyond most voters) and I essentially agree with your conclusion. I think they saw two pitchers who were very close , and then looked at some of the things you mentioned (strikeouts, K/BB ratio, ERA–which Felix actually was better in), and then one you didn’t mention (wins). I doubt that more than two or three voters considered fWAR or fFIP, let alone even know what they are.

                Like
                Reply
      • Reuven Bolnick

        6 years ago

        Felix was so dominant this year that they named a statistic after him. Making MLB history didn’t win him the award. He was robbed.

        Like
        Reply
      • Jonathan Barlock

        6 years ago

        Felix broke a long lasting record

        Like
        Reply
        • disadvantage

          6 years ago

          So did Phil Hughes (with a record breaking strikeout-to-walk ratio) if we’re going based on records.

          Felix was the man this year (as he is every year), but Kluber is deserving of the win.

          Like
          Reply
        • thirteenthirteen

          6 years ago

          So did Yusmeiro Petit! Just robbed!

          Like
          Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          Many pitchers break a record each season. It’s a whole-season award. I also think Phil Hughes’ K/BB and Yusmeiro Petit’s batters retired records are as impressive.

          Like
          Reply
    • Jonathan Barlock

      6 years ago

      Agreed

      Like
      Reply
    • Kris N

      6 years ago

      Blashphemy

      Like
      Reply
    • Eric Droegemeier

      6 years ago

      Kluber had a higher WAR, lower FIP, and better K/9 and HR/9

      Like
      Reply
      • monkeyking42

        6 years ago

        And Felix had a lower ERA, lower RA9, lower BB/9, lower H/9, higher GB%, and lower xFIP.

        I don’t think he was robbed. Could have gone either way. But there’s definitely a legit case for Felix.

        Like
        Reply
        • davbee

          6 years ago

          Agreed. This was an extremely close race that could have gone either way. I don’t think Kluber is any more right than Felix. You can make a good argument for either. And by the way, I live in Portland and while I don’t bleed Mariner blue, I do root for them when I make the pilgrimage to Seattle 10-12 games a year.

          Like
          Reply
    • Metsfan93

      6 years ago

      It was extremely close. Isolating Kluber vs. Felix is hard, but I think they made a very defensible, fine decision. I’m happy.

      Like
      Reply
    • LazerTown

      6 years ago

      Not really. Kluber had lower FIP, Felix got 1 more out. It was incredibly close, and the voting showed that.

      Like
      Reply
    • Alex Villas

      6 years ago

      nope corey kluber deserved it

      Like
      Reply
    • $3513744

      6 years ago

      he should report it to the police.

      Like
      Reply
  2. Pricemcdice

    6 years ago

    Didn’t see this coming.

    Like
    Reply
  3. Joshua Robinson

    6 years ago

    If Felix didn’t win it this year, what will it take for him to win it again? What a joke. Oh well.

    Like
    Reply
    • Robert Eichhorn

      6 years ago

      Pitching on the east coast. I know the frustration.

      Like
      Reply
      • Eric Droegemeier

        6 years ago

        When was the last time a player on an east coast team won a major award

        Like
        Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          This year. Jacob deGrom, RotY. Or, if you want a Cy Young or MVP, 2012, R.A. Dickey and David Price. In 2013, Wil Myers won AL RotY, too. In 2012, Harper won the NL RotY. Also, in all of these cases except I guess Myers and deGrom, there was a better choice not on the East Coast in, respectively, Kershaw, Verlander and Frazier/Miley.

          Like
          Reply
        • LazerTown

          6 years ago

          Dickey won CyYoung in 2012, Price did that same year.

          Like
          Reply
      • Metsfan93

        6 years ago

        Cleveland is not on the East Coast. Kluber has far, far less name recognition than Felix, a future Hall of Famer. Voters actually looked at all the numbers and saw a draw, IMO. Kluber was deserving, and Felix was deserving. If there was ever a year to will co-Cy Youngs, this was it, IMO.

        Like
        Reply
      • jp1198

        6 years ago

        Just like Josh Beckett in 2007. Oh wait…

        Like
        Reply
    • LazerTown

      6 years ago

      It’s not a joke. You can argue all day, and essentially it could have gone both ways. The voting was incredibly close, and could have gone either way.

      Like
      Reply
      • Joshua Robinson

        6 years ago

        No, it’s all good, the joke to me is that Felix is going to need an even more monstrous season to win it again, that’s all. Even though this year woulda been the year for him to win it.

        Like
        Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          Or, yknow, there could just be worse competition. Felix was great. Felix could also have been better and not crumbled a little down the stretch. I’m obviously speaking quite specifically, as Felix was still very good, but Kluber was excellent competition. A 7.3 fWAR/7.0 RA9-WAR season is nothing to sneeze at, and neither is a 269/51 K/BB ratio. Kluber had a monstrous season as well. Both were fantastic.

          Like
          Reply
          • davbee

            6 years ago

            Felix had a 1.66 ERA in Sept. Kluber had a 2.09 ERA in Sept.

            Like
            Reply
            • Metsfan93

              6 years ago

              I don’t care about Felix’ ERA when he allowed four unearned runs that were directly his fault in a single September start. I don’t care about the R/ER distinction, especially when it’s the pitcher who makes the error that causes them to be unearned. Whose fault were those four additional runs? Felix made the throwing error and then allowed those unearned runs to come in. How are those not credited/subtracted from his runs-allowed value? ER/R distinction is subjective. He still imploded and surrendered those 8 runs that day, regardless of how many of them are considered earned. That’s a large reason why I feel Felix faltered down the stretch. He had a meltdown start near the end of the season. If those runs are included, he throws up a 2.55 ERA post-All Star break. Still good, but not as dominant as the 2.16 he has not including those runs.

              Like
              Reply
              • davbee

                6 years ago

                But by baseball rules you don’t include those runs. And if you suddenly want to include those 8 unearned runs (and for good measure, the four other unearned runs that Felix gave up), then you have to include the 8 unearned runs that Kluber gave up last season. After which, Felix still has the better “run average,” 2.59 to 2.75.

                Like
                Reply
                • Metsfan93

                  6 years ago

                  2.75 to 2.59 paints a starkly different picture than 2.14 to 2.44. Just saying. And we still haven’t adjusted for team defenses, framing, and park. But, yes, I look at runs then at defense. I don’t really care about the R/ER distinction until I look at overall defense and adjust based on how good the defenses are.

                  Like
                  Reply
              • kstreetdawg

                6 years ago

                Well if you think about it, Felix’s error had nothing to do with how he pitched. So while he “earned” those runs by making the error, the runs scored as a result of his fielding, not his pitching. Not sure how people who quote FIP as a stat struggle to understand that concept.

                Like
                Reply
                • Metsfan93

                  6 years ago

                  They’re unearned runs, but they’re still Felix’ fault. He still gave up those runs. He faced many batters after that error and none of the runs (except for the guy who reached *on* the error) were unearned until he recorded a second out, which would have been the third. The runs after that out were also unearned. It’s those runs I mostly have an issue with being singled out. But like I’ve said, I hardly care about the distinction between unearned and earned runs. They’re runs.

                  Like
                  Reply
    • monkeyking42

      6 years ago

      Was there some other year when Felix was allegedly robbed?

      Like
      Reply
  4. Julie

    6 years ago

    What a joke.. Poor King Felix. We love you man! Thanks for a great season..

    Like
    Reply
  5. dt

    6 years ago

    Kluber was better down the stretch but I thought Felix was winning it by having the lowest AL era in years plus he had the MLB record for 7+ innings allowing 2 or less runs.

    Like
    Reply
    • Metsfan93

      6 years ago

      The AL ERA as a whole is lower than it’s been in years. Sale bested him in ERA+, and Greinke, back in 2009, posted a 2.16 ERA, just barely higher than Felix’ 2.14. There’s also the matter of the unearned runs that got chopped from Felix’ ERA to give him the title over Sale.

      Like
      Reply
  6. MB923

    6 years ago

    I can’t believe Kluber beat Felix

    Like
    Reply
  7. acottonshirt

    6 years ago

    This was based off his one start in Toronto. Felix set a major league record this year and was better than Kluber in almost every stat. Kluber is deserving and had a great year. He was not, however, better than Felix.

    Like
    Reply
    • Vandals Took The Handles

      6 years ago

      I really doubt that voters looked at one start and/or the stats generated from it.

      Like
      Reply
      • The_Unnatural

        6 years ago

        Well, they didn’t look at the entire season or at context. As an example, Lloyd pulled Felix after the 8th regardless of his pitch count. He thought that Felix throwing 120 instead of 105 would destroy his arm. He cost Felix like 4 complete games. Lloyd also messed around with the rotation and cost Felix like 2 starts. I bet Felix would like to have those potential wins and 20+ innings back.

        Like
        Reply
        • davbee

          6 years ago

          There is a reason Lloyd often pulled Felix after 7 . His ERA in the 8th inning was 4.50 and his ERA in the 9th was 20.25. His ERA after 100 pitches was 4.00, almost double his regular ERA.

          Like
          Reply
          • The_Unnatural

            6 years ago

            Based on what? 1.1 innings? Are you you using that as your argument? Get out of here. He throws a perfect 9th and that gets cut in half.

            Like
            Reply
            • davbee

              6 years ago

              And you’re using what exactly to back your argument? The knowledge that you can make better pitching decisions than Lloyd McClendon?

              Like
              Reply
  8. Vandals Took The Handles

    6 years ago

    Last August I came on here and said that Kluber was the best pitcher in the AL. A bunch of people threw stats at me.

    Kluber absolutely dominated.

    Like
    Reply
  9. Uncontrite

    6 years ago

    Felix got robbed

    Like
    Reply
  10. Jayne

    6 years ago

    Wow, Hughes was in the running. What a difference Minneapolis made for him.

    Like
    Reply
  11. Snoochies8

    6 years ago

    This was a great CY Young race, hard to go wrong with either one since their peripherals were so dang similar. Just had to go to the one that had the edge on WAR. Congrats Kluber!

    Like
    Reply
  12. iedodgerfan

    6 years ago

    Kershaw baby! Should be 4 in a row.

    Like
    Reply
    • Sean Casey

      6 years ago

      At least he gets the 2014 MVP to make up for it.

      Like
      Reply
  13. disadvantage

    6 years ago

    At what point do they change the name of the award to the “Clayton Kershaw Award”? (This coming from a huge Giants fan).

    Like
    Reply
    • Angels25

      6 years ago

      Maybe Kershaw’s award; Lets wait 5 more season

      Like
      Reply
    • oleosmirf

      6 years ago

      Matt Harvey will push him for it as soon as next season.

      Like
      Reply
      • Tre-Day

        6 years ago

        I’m not as sure. Using 2013 as a lens, take a look at Kershaw vs. teams over .500, and then look at Harvey vs. teams over .500

        Its not even close.

        Like
        Reply
      • Joe

        6 years ago

        Yea right. Nobody in the game today can replicate what Kershaw did this season (other than Kershaw), and this is coming from a Giants fan.

        Like
        Reply
        • Puig Power

          6 years ago

          It looks like the only way the Giants fans are nice to Dodgers is when they win the World Series and feel bad for us. Of course I’m kidding, it’s nice to read your comments.

          Like
          Reply
      • iedodgerfan

        6 years ago

        Harvey is not even close to the same level as Kershaw. We will see how Harvey comes back from TJ and how big is the decline in velocity and secondary pitches.

        Like
        Reply
      • Bounded

        6 years ago

        I wouldn’t count on Harvey having a Cy Young season next year, since he’s coming off Tommy John surgery, But maybe in 2016 tho.

        Like
        Reply
    • Sean Casey

      6 years ago

      Giants fans have always shown a lot of respect for Kershaw. I’ve always had a similar level of respect (and envy) for Bum, Cain and Tim. Congrats giants fans on the recent, and hopefully last, world series ring.

      Like
      Reply
  14. Bounded

    6 years ago

    Pretty sure Kluber winning caught everyone by surprise.

    Like
    Reply
  15. Robert Eichhorn

    6 years ago

    King Felix. And I’m not even a Mariners fan. At least they got Kershaw right.

    Like
    Reply
    • disadvantage

      6 years ago

      Not being a Mariners fan and picking Felix isn’t that surprising. Now if you were an Indians fan, it would be.

      Not because Kluber won. But because you’d be an Indians fan.

      Like
      Reply
    • LazerTown

      6 years ago

      It could have gone either way. I don’t think you can make a decisive argument that one should have won by a large margin.

      Like
      Reply
      • $3513744

        6 years ago

        i can. the guy with more votes deserves it more. having a good season doesn’t earn you the award, it just earns you a shot at it. two awesome pitchers. somebody had to be second in voting.

        Like
        Reply
  16. Metsfan93

    6 years ago

    I love these decisions. I would have been fine with Felix, but I’m happier with Kluber. More strikeouts, similar walks, more hitter friendly park, worse defense, worse framing. Felix is excellent at taking advantage of his defense and park, and I have them at about a draw, but I’m still happy Kluber won. They’re extremely close.

    Like
    Reply
    • Angels25

      6 years ago

      I really dont care (both deserve it), but actually feliz is better in the road and have better numbers against 5 top offensive team in the league

      Like
      Reply
      • Metsfan93

        6 years ago

        His road numbers couldn’t have possibly been helped by getting to take on the depleted Houston and Texas offenses and having good pitcher parks somewhat mitigating the offenses in Oakland and Los Angeles, could they have? He faced better offenses overall, though. I did forget that consideration. They each faced average hitters with exactly a 100 wRC+ in 2014, but projections favor the guys Felix faced. They’re incredibly close any way you slice it, and the voting (169-159) reflects that. 10 point differences among a 30-voter sample are hardly meaningful enough to crown one over the other. This Cy Young debate will be talked about for awhile, I’m guessing.

        Like
        Reply
    • Lefebvre Believer

      6 years ago

      Felix dominated everywhere, not just at Safeco.

      Like
      Reply
      • Metsfan93

        6 years ago

        That’s not how park factors and home ballparks work, at all. And Felix is indeed dominant. Nobody would deny that. So is Kluber, though.

        Like
        Reply
        • Lefebvre Believer

          6 years ago

          I said nothing about park factors and home ballparks, nor who should have or shouldn’t have won the award, just wanted to point out that the only thing Felix “took advantage of” was his own dominance over the entire league anywhere any time.

          Like
          Reply
  17. Vandals Took The Handles

    6 years ago

    Good to see that performance and not pub/reputation still holds weight with some.

    Like
    Reply
  18. MikeTroutForMayor

    6 years ago

    Corey Kluber, Jake Westbrook, Ryan Ludwick amazing this trade in hindsight.

    Like
    Reply
  19. nelson_c

    6 years ago

    I wonder how many 1st place votes that next to last start vs the Jays cost Felix. 8 runs (4 ER) in 4 2/3 innings when his team needed the W.

    Like
    Reply
    • Metsfan93

      6 years ago

      Felix also is at fault for the other 4 runs, too. It was his own error that led to those runs. They can’t be pinned on anyone except for Felix.

      Like
      Reply
  20. Jose marrero

    6 years ago

    Kluber Was a slight better very deserving the voters did right

    Like
    Reply
  21. Lefebvre Believer

    6 years ago

    That 4 HR game against the Nats at the end of August cost King Felix.

    Like
    Reply
  22. Christopher Rioux

    6 years ago

    The vote reflected reality; that this was close.

    I’d like to know who the one guy who watched baseball this season was, who decided “yeah, there’s 5 guys in the AL I’m going to put on my ballot before Chris Sale.”

    I HATE the White Sox but that guy was the goods.

    Like
    Reply
    • shysox

      6 years ago

      Yuzo Hayakawa of the Kyodo News

      Like
      Reply
  23. oleosmirf

    6 years ago

    I think the right decision was made. The only thing Felix had on him was ERA (and BB/9 too) but you have to take park factors into consideration. And while W/L record shouldn’t really be indicative, he did have more wins despite pitching for a weaker team and I think that is notable too.

    Like
    Reply
    • Angels25

      6 years ago

      I agree with you about a weaker team, But the wins depends team’s offense, You remember the time he pitch 16 game in a row 2 run less, he got 13 undecisve and one lost

      Like
      Reply
  24. theUpdate23

    6 years ago

    Congrats CK!

    Like
    Reply
  25. Jimmy Willy

    6 years ago

    Thought Kluber was some type of soft-tossing control guy. With 269 k’s, boy was I wrong.

    Like
    Reply
    • paqza

      6 years ago

      Had a better fastball in 2014 than guys like Sale, Scherzer, Verlander, and Felix to name a few: fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=all&stats=sta&…

      Like
      Reply
  26. Joe McMahon

    6 years ago

    Wow! I’m very pleasantly surprised that the voters picked Kluber. Not that Felix would have been an awful choice, but Kluber was a little better. It was a tough call and for once the voters chose right!

    Like
    Reply
  27. marinest21

    6 years ago

    As a Padres fan, Kluber’s win is bittersweet. On the bright side, it shows our farm system is capable of producing something successful at the ML level.

    On the down side . . . we gave him away. For nothing.

    Well, basically nothing. I just realized it was for Ryan Ludwick, who was entirely worthless for us. (My apologies).

    Like
    Reply
  28. jp1198

    6 years ago

    Everybody is saying Felix was robbed… Kluber had a higher WAR (by a full win!!), a lower FIP, and more strikeouts; Felix had a lower ERA, lower xFIP, higher GB%… could’ve gone either way. I’m not sure who I’d vote for, but to say that Felix was “robbed” is a gross overstatement.

    Like
    Reply
    • Alex Villas

      6 years ago

      Finally someone that agrees

      Like
      Reply
    • Sean Casey

      6 years ago

      Those are the same 6 stats (+RA/9 & BB/9) I was trying to boil it down to and I still couldn’t really say who I would for vote for. Felix was Cy worthy but I tend to be a sucker for K’s.

      Like
      Reply
  29. Joe

    6 years ago

    Kershaw is obviously the most deserving candidate, but if the postseason was included, I think Bumgarner would have placed 2nd.

    Like
    Reply
  30. MetsEventually

    6 years ago

    No votes for deGrom? :/

    Like
    Reply
    • Matt Silab

      6 years ago

      Only played 2/3rds of the season.

      Like
      Reply
  31. harmony55

    6 years ago

    This Mariner fan was pulling for Felix Hernandez, who perhaps had his best season, but Corey Kluber was deserving.

    Like
    Reply
  32. baseballbill77

    6 years ago

    For the voters and all the people who would give Kluber the award over Felix: If your season came down to one game would you still pick Kluber to pitch over Felix? No way I say.

    Like
    Reply
    • davbee

      6 years ago

      By that argument, if your season came down to one game and you could choose Kershaw or Bumgarner, who would you pick?

      Like
      Reply
      • baseballbill77

        6 years ago

        I would roll the dice with Bumgarner.

        Like
        Reply
        • davbee

          6 years ago

          Exactly! Yet Kershaw won the Cy Young. That’s your exact argument, only in a NL version.

          Like
          Reply
          • baseballbill77

            6 years ago

            But I would not have voted for Kershaw to win the Cy Young.

            Like
            Reply
            • Metsfan93

              6 years ago

              It’s a regular season award based on what happened during the 2014 regular season. What you’re talking about is simply who you think the best pitcher currently is, not who had the best 2014 regular season. Also, Clayton Kershaw is miles better than Madison Bumgarner. Kershaw is wrapping up a Hall of Fame peak.

              Like
              Reply
              • davbee

                6 years ago

                Yet the question was who would you want to pitch one winner take all game? So far Kershaw, as great as he is, has failed in those situations and Bumgarner has excelled.

                Like
                Reply
                • iedodgerfan

                  6 years ago

                  Are we talking regular or postseason? Kershaw is obviously the better pitcher. He just has not got it done in the postseason.

                  Like
                  Reply
                • Metsfan93

                  6 years ago

                  And yet, if asked for a game tomorrow, I’d still take Kershaw. He’s simply a better pitcher. Looking just at their postseasons and ignoring hundreds of other innings is odd to do. Kershaw has been the best pitcher in baseball for four years running.

                  Like
                  Reply
    • Vandals Took The Handles

      6 years ago

      I’ll bet you haven’t see Kluber pitch 3 games.

      Like
      Reply
      • baseballbill77

        6 years ago

        You’d win that bet. Would you pick Kluber over Felix if your team’s season was on the line?

        Like
        Reply
        • Metsfan93

          6 years ago

          I would strongly consider it if all I had was the data from the 2014 regular season. Yes, I would. They were essentially equals, so I would strongly consider picking Kluber.

          Like
          Reply
          • baseballbill77

            6 years ago

            That’s not a very definitive answer in favor of Kluber. I would strongly consider a few guys but I’d still pick Felix over Kluber 10 times out of 10.

            Like
            Reply
            • Joshua Robinson

              6 years ago

              Just remember, Felix is on a whole other level when something is on the line. The last game of the season? He struck out something along the lines of 7 Angels hitters in 3 innings. So I too would pick Felix if the season was on the line.

              Like
              Reply
    • paqza

      6 years ago

      I would. Klubot is incredible to watch and anecdotally implodes less often.

      Like
      Reply
  33. 0vercast

    6 years ago

    You could make a solid argument that both deserved it, but that’s not how it works; there’s only one award per season.

    One of these pitchers had to get hosed.

    Like
    Reply
    • Metsfan93

      6 years ago

      There’s one award, but they were ten points apart. A few vote switches and we could’ve seen a tie at the top, which would’ve been fitting. It has happened before in the Cy Young, and in the MVP voting, so it’s not unprecedented.

      Like
      Reply
  34. EskimoYanks

    6 years ago

    Tanaka was robbed.

    Like
    Reply
    • Matthew Kitson

      6 years ago

      he hardly pitched in the 2nd half

      Like
      Reply
    • paqza

      6 years ago

      If you’re serious, I disagree. Had he pitched a full season, things would be different.

      Like
      Reply
  35. Jason Champion

    6 years ago

    Congratulations to Kluber, and Indians fans. Good to see some new names in the ALCY mix. I’m hoping Sale continues to shine too. Just not against my A’s!

    Like
    Reply
  36. Sean Casey

    6 years ago

    Kershaw has 3 Cy Youngs and likely a MVP before the age of 27, I wonder what his peak will look like. I’m only kidding, I don’t expect him to best 2014’s ridiculous GB%, K/9, and BB/9 numbers but it’s so fun to dream.

    Like
    Reply
  37. Melvin Mendoza, Jr.

    6 years ago

    Would Bumgarner have had a shot if postseason performance factored into the votes?

    Like
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.
Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Kelvin Herrera Announces Retirement

    Braves Extend Brian Snitker

    Giants, Scott Kazmir Agree To Minor League Deal

    Yankees Sign Justin Wilson

    Braves Sign Jake Lamb

    Athletics Sign Mitch Moreland

    Yankees Re-Sign Brett Gardner

    Giants To Sign Jake McGee

    Mariners CEO Kevin Mather Resigns

    Athletics Sign Trevor Rosenthal

    Recent

    MLBTR Poll: Shortstop Extension Candidates

    Chicago Notes: Baez, Pederson, Kopech

    Health Notes: Yordan, E-Rod, Bailey, Nottingham, Parra

    Giants Claim Jordan Humphreys

    Minor MLB Transactions: 2/26/21

    Braves Outright Phil Pfeifer

    Angels To Sign Jesse Chavez

    Kelvin Herrera Announces Retirement

    Braves Sign Terrance Gore To Minor League Deal

    Diamondbacks Designate Travis Bergen, Keury Mella For Assignment

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Kris Bryant Rumors
    • Jackie Bradley Jr. Rumors
    • Jake Odorizzi Rumors
    • Taijuan Walker Rumors
    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Go Ad-Free
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • 2020-21 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • 2020-21 MLB Free Agent Tracker
    • 2020-21 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2021-22 MLB Free Agent List
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2021
    • 2021 MLB Arbitration Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Indians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • Feeds by Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrowsFOX Sports Engage Network scroll to top
    Close

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version