With Max Scherzer now likely headed to the Dodgers, Twins right-hander Jose Berrios becomes the clear top starter left on the trade market. The 27-year-old righty is earning $6.1MM in 2021, is controlled through 2022 via arbitration, and is in the midst of arguably his best season yet. Through 121 2/3 innings, Berrios has pitched to a 3.48 ERA with a strong 25.7 percent strikeout rate and an excellent 6.5 percent walk rate. Berrios has been as durable as they come, and while he might not be the bona fide, Cy Young-caliber ace that Scherzer is, he’s a clear option to start in a playoff game for most contenders.
It originally looked as though Berrios was a long shot to move, but the interest in him has been intense. The Athletic’s Dan Hayes reported yesterday that market for Berrios had exceeded the Twins’ expectations, making a deal increasingly likely. Virtually every contender or fringe contender has inquired, as you’d expect. Not all of them will remain in the mix as talks continue into the eleventh hour of deadline season, so with that in mind, we’ll run down today’s latest Berrios rumblings in this post…
- The Blue Jays “appear” to be the leading suitor for Berrios at the moment, Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic tweets.
Earlier Updates
- Darren Wolfson of 1500 SKOR North in the Twin Cities tweets that the Twins have at least four offers in hand, coming from teams on both coasts. The Padres, Wolfson adds, “will be in it until the end.” That meshes with last night’s report from AJ Cassavell of MLB.com, wherein he indicated that Berrios is now the Padres’ “primary target.”
- The Padres, Rays and Mets are among the teams still talking to Berrios this morning, per The Athletic’s Jayson Stark (Twitter link). The Twins’ asking price has been too steep for the Mets for weeks, and that appeared to still be the case last night as well. The Rays haven’t been extensively tied to Berrios for long, but MLB Network’s Jon Heyman listed them as one of the most aggressive clubs on Berrios last night. It’s been a whirlwind deadline for the Rays, who’ve added Nelson Cruz but also subtracted some notable pieces in Diego Castillo and Rich Hill. Berrios would immediately become Tampa Bay’s top starter, at least as long as Tyler Glasnow is out. Phil Miller of the Minneapolis Star Tribune writes that both the Rays and Blue Jays are still very much in the running.
- The Yankees and Mariners also remain in the mix for Berrios, per MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand, who also notes that interest in Berrios has picked up even since last night (Twitter links). It’s been an active deadline in both the Bronx and Seattle, although the Yankees have yet to address their starting pitching. Seattle has added Tyler Anderson, but he’s a rental and more of a back-of-the-rotation arm. Beyond that, with myriad injuries throughout their expected starting staff, the Mariners could certainly use multiple starters.
mike156
The Yankees are interested? Is there anyone left in their farm system, or do they think they can send Brett Gardner and some trading cards?
oldmansteve
They still have Oswaldo, Schmidt, Garcia, and the ever present Jasson. Their farm is pretty deep. They could theoretically get Berrios without tapping into any of them, and definitely not Jasson.
Mrivers
To jump the Padres Yanks would likely have to give up at least one of Peraza, Schmidt, Garcia, Wells.
ws_champs
Wells is likely off the table.
bucsfan0004
Blue Jays talking about a Pearson for Berrios package
iamhector24
Pearson has been injury prone hot garbage. Hard pass if I’m the twins.
larry48
Padres lose again
TheBoatmen
They found a hernia. At least they know what it is now and can go from there.
stymeedone
Twins not as likely to pay the contracts though!
Brixton
Which is irrelevant to the yankees odds of trading for him
neo
but it is?
Harrymannback77
You’re on Crack if you think they get Berrios without including any of those players. Just typical stupidity from a Yankee fan. Hilarious.
Kipp35
Not with what the Twins are asking for. They don’t have enough, if they do offer the guys you mentioned.
andrewyf
They have more than enough to get anyone they want. Trading a guy like Luis Medina for Berrios is probably an overpay, and I’m not sure the Yankees want to do that, but that’s an example where if they wanted, they could do it.
RazorRamonie
Not a pure rental he would be with them for this year and next
BadBenjamin
It takes 5 Medina’s to get berrios. What are you thinking.
BoltforLife
Medina is inconsistent and is likely going to be a reliever. Walking 5.8/9. He doesn’t even start a discussion for Berrios.
Darryl Rose
I’m a yankee fan and that’s insanity. Medina is just an unproven prospect. If he ever became a Berrios the Yankees would be thrilled.
busta37
They haven’t really given up big prospects with the trades they made.
BadBenjamin
They gave up the whole middle of their farm. They dropped from the #4 farm in baseball to #14. They’ve given up a lot.
Joe says...
Being that the Yankees haven’t given up any top prospects yet, I would say yes there is enough left in the farm system to get whoever they want. They will also likely get the other team to pay said players salary too.
Kipp35
I think your comment of they can get ‘whoever they want’ is more indicative of mentality of a Yankee’s fan. Just because you are the Yankee’s does not mean the rest of the league just gives you whatever you wish.
The Twins have an asking price, and for many teams that price has been too high. I am a Twins fan and feel they need to unload Buxton before Berrios. But, if they can get talent that will impact us going forward, I am good with off-loading Berrios. But, they do need to get a haul back for a guy under team control for another year on a team friendly deal, doesn’t get hurt and is a top of the rotation starter.
GoldenJabs
Voit will be thrown into any offers by the Yankees.
whyhayzee
Gum. From the trading cards. Wicked stale.
FullMontilla
Berrios is a good pitcher but not a break-the-bank type of player – whoever overpays for him will likely regret it
Baldkid
A guy who is controllable through next season, has post season experience and is a pretty decent pitcher (I did not say Cy Young worthy), sounds like a guy most teams, if not all, would covet. What % of prospects make it to the show and stick, half? a third?
jakethesnizake
I like Berrios a lot but the dude doesn’t really have any real postseason experience to tout…
Baldkid
12 innings pitched, with 2 starts is better than none
jakethesnizake
Yeah I guess. Not really a high enough volume of innings and success to use as a selling point.
Baldkid
What do you want? 158 innings pitched? hahahahaha
Darryl Rose
Far less.
Example last night I googled Yankee prospects and a 2009 list came up of their too 30.
Betances was 6 or 7.
Gardner 11
David Robertson 13
And the catcher who went to Detroit was on there.
The rest I never heard of including 1-5.
Kipp35
He doesn’t break the bank for what he is, just what a team may give up. A team is giving up what someone MAY be to get what Berrios IS.
He is a top of the rotation starter on any team he goes to. He is durable and eats 200 innings a year. Put him on a team that will score for him and he’ll give you 20 wins per season.
rangers92
So Padres get Berrios, Redsox get Gibson and Kennedy, and the Mets will get Jordan Lyles
MannyPineappleExpress9
Unless the Brewers snag him a third time (I don’t think they’re necessarily looking to add a starter, but acquiring him a third time would be kinda funny).
larry48
Padres do not get Berrios !
Central Valley
I guess the Giants are throwing in the towel for this season?
philstripes
They have the best record in baseball how are they throwing in the towel ? They will end up with Kimbrel.
Sheep8
Yes they are! since the deadline is not over, we should evaluate moves/non moves minute by minute and not when the deadline has passed.
Dodgers pitching coach Mark Prior can show the giants how to do the towel drill.
fox471 Dave
They are in 1st place! Geez!
VTGiant
ROTFLMFAO, yep, i guess they’ve resigned themselves to first place.
Where’s the weak schedule BS excuse ive heard, beat LA two opening series and forced them to give up the farm for Scherzer and Turner.
smfh
Giant3324
Let’s no forget, they still have that woman beater on their team BAUER
bellybombs
The farm that’s left is certainly better than what the Giants have.
44McCovey
Sometimes the best trade is no trade at all. If the asking price is too high, don’t do it.
batman123
Wow this is why sports are having less people watch super teams suck
Joel Peterson
No doubt about that. Only sport doing it right is the NHL. And from what I understand Tampa is working the system there but still you need a salary cap. You need a salary floor more importantly.
Dustyslambchops23
I’ll never understand this POV
The goal is to win, owners who are willing to spend and trust their GMs to make major moves should be celebrated and praised.
The top payroll team has won once in the last 1 years, you can’t buy a good chance but you can’t buy a championship
Dustyslambchops23
Last 10 years (also last 1 year also works)
Ronk325
Once more small to mid market teams learn how to properly build a team the big market teams will have a tougher time building their “super teams”
ruckus727
I’m sure Kyle Hendricks could be had for the right pieces. He has a lot of post-season experience and success.
Joel Peterson
If you have a hard throwing guy going in game 1 or game 2 of a series then you bring him in its like night and day. He’s a heck of a pitcher. Could be the kind of guy to help the young Cubs pitchers develop.
CalcetinesBlancos
I knew the Twins would come to their senses. Was hoping they wouldn’t though lol.
slslinde
Yankees have no one in their farm system. Worth of trading with MN. Besides we hate the Yankees
Lonniemac
I am sure your hatred for the Yankees will be a factor for the Twins front office.
Cuso
False
Dustyslambchops23
I would suspect they would have a tough time having the twins eat his salary
bobtillman
The Orioles moved Armstrong to make room for Berrios. As Maxwell Smart would say, they were THIS close to getting Scherzer.
LarryJ4
It doesn’t help other teams help these “super teams” out by covering the entire contract so the teams don’t go over the luxury tax! It’s a joke! Rangers and Cubs should be ashamed of themselves right now! The highest prospect given up was a 5!!! Terrible.
Joel Peterson
Completely disagree. I would like to see more teams pay the salary. Or a bad team could take on a bad contract or 2. That improves the selling teams return and theoretically speeds up the rebuild. It’s a good thing not a bad thing. Whats bad is a team looking to sell only for money aka the Pirates in past years.
AndyWarpath
I thought that regardless of what money exchanged hands, that the salary cap hit was the same? In the same way that it doesn’t matter what a guy is paid year to year, but that his cap hit is his contract / years.
I could be wrong or maybe they changed it?
Bi Soxual
I would like to see Javy Baez & Kyle Gibson in Phil today,so we can at least see some div races.
Camden453
Probably doesn’t go to the Mets in a bidding war. Unless they want to cough up Alvarez (they won’t) and maybe Baty. After Alvarez or Baty I don’t think the Mets top prospects (Mauricio, Ginn) can stack up to what other teams have
Robrock30
I too doubt Mets will outbid others for Berrios or others. Not their DNA
The other problem is their prospects are overhyped and not ML close.
whynot 2
Essentially all prospects are over hyped, it’s just the nature of beast. It is only a rare few that live up to the unrealistic expectations put on them.
re-tweeted cleats
Everybody is talking Berrios. What about the the 3 Marlins young stud starters? Anybody asking about them?
whynot 2
No
Dustyslambchops23
Probably but why would the Marlins trade any of them ?
californiaangels
I say Angels go for blood and trade for Bauer lol
tgallagher
If the freaking Padres get Berrios without trading a top prospect I’m going to scream. As a White Sox fan I would be happy to see him in the NL through 2022.
bucsfan0004
Blue Jays are talking Pearson for Berrios package
jimmertee
No, the BlueJays are not talking about a Pearson for Berrios package. Not even Atkins is that stupid. Berrios is not worth a top 50 prospect let alone a top 5.
Harrymannback77
You clearly haven’t been paying attention.
augold5
Lol its Martin and Richardson
dave frost nhlpa
For Berrios I would offer Garcia and Dalpe but would also want Simmons.
tbfern
Berrios’ bidding war too much for the Rays along w/Preller getting sniped by Friedman (LOL) I say Berrios goes to the Friars.
Berrios – Padres
Báez – Mets
Gibson – Stays
Morton – Rays
I’d like to see out-of-nowhere moves like Sonny Gray or John Means getting traded, or maybe the Giants bring back Tim Linceum. Really get deadline day poppin!
sergefunction
Preller seeks Berrios for Hosmer, and Twins pick up the entire contract.
Yanks seek Berrios for Frazier and Andujar.
Twins want Lux for Berrios.
Is it Saturday yet?
802Ghost
Why isn’t Atlanta calling?
therealryan
It’s not a bad idea. A 3 team involving the Braves, Rays and Twins does make sense to me also. Morton to Rays, Berrios to Braves, prospects from both Rays and Braves to Twins. Rays get a SP for this season’s run. Braves get a SP for next season when they’ll be expecting to compete and the Twins get the prospects they desire.
GB85
Let’s go Jays, get ’em boys!
VonPurpleHayes
If you scroll through recent history, leading suitor tends to mean he’s landing somewhere else. It’s great to see the majority of the ALE going for it.
geoffb1982
If the Blue Jays don’t get him, please stop declaring the Blue Jays as the favorite for every single damn rumor
fox471 Dave
Blue Jays got him. Batten down the hatches for the Madres weeping and gnashing of teeth. Half of the Madres fans will say they didn’t really want Berrios. The other half will blame the Dodgers.
Aoe3
Yes Berrios would be great, also hoping they acquire Josh Donaldson. Put him at third with Biggio as a backup. Take some of Joshs salary imagine him. batting along with our top 5!
Orel Saxhiser
A caveat regarding Berrios is his bad second-half numbers.
Career before the all-star break: 3.65 ERA, 1.108 WHIP
Career after the all-star break: 4.77 ERA, 1.409 WHIP
August ERA is 5.57 over 135.,2 innings.
Here are his splits for anyone interested.
baseball-reference.com/players/split.fcgi?id=berri…
Not saying he’ll be bad; just that there’s a possibility he will tick off some fan base.
Perhaps a Twins fan can speak of Berrios’ late-season struggles Should it be a concern?
Harrymannback77
You clearly haven’t been paying attention.
bigdaddyhacks
The Jays got fleeced dang.