Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera have been selected to the 2022 All-Star Game, MLB announced this morning. They’ve been tabbed as the National and American League’s respective “legendary” nominees.
Ken Rosenthal of the Athletic reported this week that the new collective bargaining agreement permitted the commissioner’s office to select one or more players from each league as bonus additions to the game. The honor is in recognition of the player’s career body of work, not their 2022 performance.
“I am delighted that Albert Pujols and Miguel Cabrera have agreed to participate in the All-Star Game,” commissioner Rob Manfred said in the league’s press release. “Albert and Miguel are two of the most accomplished players of their generation. They have also represented the baseball traditions of the Dominican Republic and Venezuela with excellence for the last two decades. Albert and Miguel are two all-time greats whose achievements warrant this special recognition.”
Pujols is playing the final season of his career. He finished in the top five in NL MVP voting in ten of his first 11 years with St. Louis, claiming the award three times. After spending parts of ten seasons with the Angels and a bit more than half of last year with the Dodgers, he returned to the Cardinals for his final run. Pujols has appeared in 45 games in a part-time first base/designated hitter role.
Cabrera has seven top-five MVP finishes in his career, including back-to-back wins in 2012-13. He’s won seven Silver Slugger Awards and claimed the AL Triple Crown in 2012. He’s under contract with Detroit through 2023 and hasn’t suggested he plans to retire after this season, but he’s nevertheless a perfectly sensible choice as the AL’s first “legendary” All-Star. Cabrera has gotten the nod for 68 of Detroit’s 82 games at DH and posted slightly above-average offensive numbers.
Among active players, Pujols and Cabrera rank first and second, respectively, in career hits, home runs and RBI. Pujols is the active career leader in Baseball Reference WAR, while Cabrera ranks third among position players in that category (behind Mike Trout). They’re both locks to reach the Hall of Fame in their first years on the ballot. This will be Pujols’ 11th All-Star nod, while Cabrera is heading to the Midsummer Classic for a 12th time.
Eovaldismemes
HOLY W
Maverick12
This is so dumb. The All Star Game gets worse every year. It is meant to be for deserving players who are having a great year. There are horrible snubs every year, yet Pujols will be there while hitting under .200
bbatardo
They don’t take anyone’s spot. Was a unique spot created for them.
Maverick12
The commissioner could withhold this to see who gets snubbed this year and then make it right…so yes…they are taking a spot. No logic
Curly Was The Smart Stooge
I haven’t had enough interest in watching an all star game for years Now, I have even less interest. Both of these players will get plenty of accolades through their last 80 or so games & rightly so. However, BB players are becoming like actors, they can’t pat themselves on their backs enough, or give each other enough awards. Way to go Manfart, you’ve lowered the bar on BB again.
machurucuto
Who cares if you are interested or not?
Curly Was The Smart Stooge
WOW, did you have help with that post, or did you come up with that on your own?
Now I understand why lions eat their young
Paleobros
Manfart. Good one.
johndietz
Their not taking spots for other players
rondon
They sure as heck are. I don’t have a problem with Molina because he’s at least still relevant. Pujols hasn’t been an important player for years. And really, does he need more accolades? No.
gbs42
rondon, they’re extra players who are not taking anyone else’s roster spot, unless you are suggesting Molina in place of Pujols. Career-wise, Pujols is far and away the better player.
gbs42
Of course, this leads to the subjective determination of what an All-Star is. Is it the players having the best first three months of the season, the best players over some subjective period of time (the last 162 games, 2-3 seasons…)? And, of course, fan voting doesn’t always pick the best players as starters.
Jung Like My Daddy
There’s actually a decent idea to be had here.
Let Pujols and Cabrerea draft guys for the all star game.
I mean shake things up once in a while. Let’s have a fantasy draft every couple years where teams are drafted.
All star weekend should also have some skill challenge activities for players to participate in.
As kids we use to play stuck in the middle, would be cool to see how long a guy can last before getting tagged.
There’s ways to include fun stuff to make it more interesting for fans than just home run derby and all star game.
gbs42
Jung, those are certainly fun ideas. I’m sure the risk of injury is going to prevent them from happening.
VonPurpleHayes
I like this idea much better. Have honorary captains from each league every year. They can play too. The fans should vote on the captains.
kscheer
NHL did this for a bit
johnrealtime
I love the brainstorming here but I really hate the draft idea. It made a bad NBA all star game even worse
The skill challenge sounds like a lot of fun
JTW
I went to the 89 all star festivities and it included a game where a ball was at the warning track and the outfielder had to retrieve it, throw it to an infielder who then threw it home. Quickest home won the challenge. There were other contests too. Here’s more about it: sbnation.com/mlb/2018/7/16/17568620/baseball-skill…
gbs42
JTW, I love Grant Brisbee’s writing, and the fact that he linked to a *26-minute* video of a KBO bunting competition is delightfully goofy.
Lanidrac
You can’t split up the leagues’ players, or the fans won’t know which team to root for!
For example, as a Cardinals fan, if Pujols selects Goldschmidt to his team but Cabrera selects Arenado and Mikolas for his team, which team am I supposed to want to win?
Redstitch108* 2
We called stuck in the middle “pickle”.
stpbaseball 76
right? stuck in the middle I’ve never heard of
hiflew
I really don’t understand why people are so bothered by this. This is basically an honorary spot on the roster for two players that have spent the better part of two decades entertaining fans. And it is a chance for fans to say good bye on the big stage. Some people just want to take all the fun and history out of baseball . I hope they do this every year.
Airo13
I don’t want every year. Miggy and Pujols are a special breed that does not come around often. Forcing players in every year will cheapen the honor.
hiflew
Not to fans of those particular players. Players that might not be at the level of a Pujols or a Cabrera, but would be very deserving of the honor nonetheless. Someone like Ryan Zimmerman if he was still around. Someone like Joey Votto, Andrew McCutchen, Evan Longoria, I wouldn’t even have a problem if it someone still hanging around like Justin Upton or Kurt Suzuki.
I don’t think just anyone should get the honor, I think it should be a minimum of 15 seasons played and everyone only gets the honor once. For two players a year, I don’t think anything would be cheapened.
In fact, it reminds me of when All Star teams used to have honorary captains which was usually a 70-80 year old former player. Hell, they ought to bring that back too.
RoastGobot
Evan Longoria lol ya right maybe try playing two weeks without hitting the DL first
Lanidrac
Not every year, but yes. Besides, it’s back to being a proper exhibition match, so it doesn’t really matter if a guy hitting .200 takes a plate appearance for the NL.
dadofdonnydownvote
The all star game has been a popularity contest for years ever since the internet and fan voting came along. I’m fine with it if they aren’t taking any actual spots especially since they are both first ballot HOF playing in their last year.
dadofdonnydownvote
I guess I assumed this was Miguel’s last year and the app doesn’t let you edit. Looks like 2023 is Miggy’s last year and this is Albert’s last.
gbs42
The All-Star Game was a popularity contest well before the internet. I recall going to games as a kid and punching out the chads for all my team’s players, even if they were awful and undeserving.
LordD99
@Gbs,
LordD99
Twitchy finger! Continuing, @Gbs, you’re correct, it’s a popularity contest but it’s an uneven popularity contest. Certain teams push their players. I noticed the Blue Jays and Red Sox remind their fans to vote with overhead logos behind home plate all game long. Other teams, like the Yankees, barely even mention voting is ongoing. It’s an exhibition. The funds, I believe, help fund player pensions, which is why it should be mandatory that anyone selected show up, even if they’re on the IL.
Baseball Babe
Totally disagree. Fans want to see legendary players. It will be a moving and deserved send off for Pujols. I think it will be a highlight of an otherwise meaningless game.
RunDMC
Remember when a late-career Griffey Jr. got voted in in 2007 as a 37-year old OF who finished the year as a 0.7 bWAR? Fans will always vote on a lesser performing popular player over a better less popular name. I love Albies, but his play combined with his injury – there’s no way he should make it into the finals of 2B of the AS Game. Also, Bryce Harper is injured and won’t be able to attend, inevitably allowing a replacement that the fans did NOT vote on – so why he is eligible for votes?
Tcsbaseball
@at maverick, it was an extra spot created for legends.. I actually like it. Pujols and Miggy deserve a good send off
Lanidrac
Pujols is hitting right at .200 currently.
jmlang
As the old saying goes, “haters gotta hate.” Pujols and Cabrera, are what the good in Baseball is all about, and not some of those so called hacks you think are being overlooked.
Maverick12
Yes those 2 old steroiders that couldn’t get in off of merit this year, but those people having good years are hacks. Get out of here, try using some logic sometime
Airo13
No one has ever even whispered that Cabrera was a steroid user, but ok…
dclivejazz
Seems appropriate to me to have special recognition for career All-stars. It’s surprising to me that it took this long to come up with the idea.
miltpappas
More of the “Everyone gets a trophy” movement. Pretty soon, every player will be in the ASG. It’ll be a tournament.
gbs42
milt, back in the “good old days,” there were two All-Star Games each year. That’s twice as many participation trophies.
It’s a career recognition. It’s not the end of society as we know it.
ArianaGrandSlam
How is it getting worse every year? so the 2021’s game was worse than that of 2019’s right? In what way? So who won the MVP each of that year? Tell us these and we’ll decide if we’re with you or not. NOT.
Poster formerly known as . . .
Come on, man. It’s an exhibition game. If Miggy and Pujols aren’t “stars” in this game, who is?
The game became a joke when genius Bud Selig decided that the All-Star Game would determine home field advantage in the World Series. Happily, they finally abandoned that nonsense.
As for the voting, it’s always been an exercise in homerism since so many of the fans who bother to vote stuff the ballot box for their hometown favorites.
As long as the game is recognized for what it is and should be — an exhibition game that gives fans a chance to see their favorites on the same field in the same game, without having any bearing on home field advantage or anything else consequential — what’s the harm? The younger players get to hook up with some of their own idols and they have a great time. The fans get a star-studded show. A splendid time is guaranteed for all — unless you make a big deal about something that’s just for fun and promotional purposes.
gbs42
Fink, what’s with your crazy rational thinking? Some people just love to get worked up about trivialities.
Poster formerly known as . . .
I once heard a guy say something that really resonated:
“Most people, most of the time, are looking for a reason to be offended.”
machurucuto
If you don’t like it, don’t watch it
yankista
Dammm….. you are sooo stupid …. didn’t read the article??? READ IT idiot!!!
LordD99
They should have waited until next year for Cabrera.
Joe says...
I’m sure they wanted someone from both leagues the first time they did this and there’s really no one else but Miggy unless it’s maybe Greinke.
GOAT Closer Esteban Yan
Greinke would probably say, “nah, I’m good.”
LordD99
My issue is it’s creating a precedent. If a great, such as Pujols, is retiring, all well and fine. The odds in any given year that a true great is retiring is slim,let alone two, one from each league. Honor Pujols. It doesn’t matter if one league every once in a while gets an extra pinch hitter.
Joe says...
I agree with your sentiment. I just think for the first year, they wanted to have both leagues represented.
LordD99
@Joe, yes. It is after all an exhibition, so I’m fine with creating extra interest.
stymeedone
Miggy just passed 500 hrs, 600 doubles, and 3000 hits. They probably did this for Miggy and it’s Pujols who’s been added to balance things out.
machurucuto
Long live the King
yankista
Why, do you know the rules ??? Read again and let me know
stan lee the manly
This is awesome to see. MLB finally making an effort to do something for the fans instead of their pockets.
Skeptical
Right, making the All-Star game into the All-Jokes Game. The game is no longer relevant and hasn’t featured the best for many years now. Just fan favorites or the results of organized campaigns to get team favorites on.
hiflew
That is all it have EVER been.
johnrealtime
I liked the game when it had stakes. When they took away the WS connection, it became truly pointless
bhambrave
I thought the WS connection was a mistake, and I’m glad they severed it.
Lanidrac
If the managers were truly trying to win, they wouldn’t take out their best hitters halfway through the game, so making the result meaningful never made any sense.
It’s no less fun to watch just because it’s an exhibition game, anyway.
miltpappas
I’m old enough to remember when they played for the pride of their league. Listen to Pete Rose talk about it.
gbs42
Skeptical, how has the game not featured the best for many years now? Fans so a pretty good job of selecting the starters, and the league, players, and managers work together to choose the rest. Aside from every team having to have a rep, I’d argue the selection process is pretty good.
hiflew
Every team SHOULD have a rep. Every team has its fans. Some might not have as many, but they deserve to have someone to cheer for in the ASG also. I know MLB network and ESPN would prefer there only be like 16 big market teams, because those are the only games they ever want to show, but at the very least the ASG gives fans of EVERY team a reason to watch.
Lanidrac
Agreed, the selection process nowadays is more fair than it’s ever been before, especially now that the voting is online only with the players’ major stats readily available (although if they’re going to include RBIs, they should include Runs as well, and SBs would be a good addition to the stat line, too).
Meanwhile, the biased managers no longer have exclusive rights on the final selections.
Rsox
@Skeptical
MLB already did that a year ago when they pulled the game from Atlanta for political reasons that had nothing to do with them.
Let Cabrera and Pujols have an “All Star farewell” it’s really no different then when they did the whole ARod to 3B to let Cal play SS in the 2000 game.
Baseball Babe
Totally agree it was outrageous to pull the game last year. I boycotted watching it—the first in my life that I can remember not watching. While obviously that gesture mattered not one whit to Manfred, it mattered to me.
paddyo furnichuh
I’ll take your “boycott” over the likelihood that more than a few star players would have opted out of the game.
stan lee the manly
It’s mostly based on fan voting, it’s already been completely meaningless since that was instated. Giving the fans the chance to see iconic players in that setting one last time is a great use of the platform that doesn’t mean anything, the game will be a heck of a lot more meaningful to a lot of fans because of the inclusion of these two players.
yankista
That’s your opinion and nobody care about… so, just keep your mouth closed
bucsfan0004
Funny how guys like Ortiz and Jeter didn’t need charity like this. They were good enough/popular enough to make it to the all-star game on their own merits. And isn’t Miggy under contract for the next three years anyway?
etex211
It’s really just one more year. His vesting options are irrelevant at this point.
yankista
Correct
mamss
Jeter getting voted in 100% was charity. He was performing well below an all star level player his last season.
coolhandneil
Ortiz was a cheater.
etex211
So does Miggy get to do it again next year, too?
What if Pujols has a reunion tour with the Angels next year?
xXTheFETTXx
Miggy has been playing at an All-Star level this year, he might of gotten in as a ‘legend’ but he legit deserved a spot.
etex211
Since he is the best player on his team this year, that is probably true.
So since he’s in as the legend, I guess the Tigers still get another token all-star. THAT steals a spot from a deserving player from another team.
LABeachguy
Yes, surprised they announced that already. Once Skubal has fallen back I thought Miggy would make the team as a DH for the Tiger’s all star representative. Given his decent year he is having and no one on the team is worth it. Maybe Fulmer or Soto get the nod.
paddyo furnichuh
@etex211…..By season’s end, I suspect Riley Greene will have established himself as Tigers’ best.
bucsfan0004
Soto is the best player on the Tigers, not a .700 OPS aging hitter. 10 years ago, Miggy was the best hitter in baseball. Now? Let the kids play
etex211
Paddy, probably so, but you don’t go to the ASG after playing in the league for three weeks.
paddyo furnichuh
I get that. While it was mostly Miggy being a great teammate, I took note when Cabrera noted that Greene was the Tigers’ best hitter in ST.
Granted, it was only Spring and that was a veteran heaping praise on his young teammate.
24TheKid
You really think Pujols would have any interest in a “reunion tour” with that organization?
etex211
How much does it pay?
duffys cliff
Even though Miggy is not the offensive player he once was, and his power has evaporated, he is still one of the better offensive players for the Tigers. First in hits, RBI, AVG, OBP, OPS, and second in SLG. That may be more of a testament to how bad the Tigers offense is this year, but I’m glad to see him doing well.
etex211
He gets a ton of credit for not mailing it in and just collecting his paychecks. He got himself into better shape, and he isn’t embarrassing himself at all. He is hitting .308 this year while the league average is s0mewhere around .240. He is the greatest player of this generation.
Lanidrac
How small do you define a generation? Between Pujols and Trout, Cabrera only had the four year span from 2010-13 as the greatest hitter in the game, and that’s without even mentioning pitchers.
etex211
To me, a generation is around 20 years. So let’s say in the 20 year period, 2001-2020, Miggy is the greatest. He won the World Series, he won the MVP twice. He led the league in hitting and OBP four times. He was the first triple crown winner in 70 years. I believe he has the highest career batting average of any active player or any recently retired player. 3000 hits. 500 homers. 17th all-time RBI leader and still climbing.
Trout’s a great player, but he’s never won anything. Pujols was a great player for the first half of his career. Neither of those guys are Miggy, IMHO. I’m sure some will disagree and other arguments can be made, but this is my opinion.
WillieMaysHayes24
Pujols is hands down the best between the two. 3 MVPs (runner up 4 times also), multiple World Series rings, and he has about 30 more WAR than Cabrera. Nearly identical OPS but Pujols was an excellent defender for many years. Pretty much has him beat in every statistical category.
Cosmo2
Statistics would disagree quite strenuously.
Cosmo2
Pujols is way better than Miggy career wise. It’s really not even close.
Roy Rodgers McFreely
It’s what the nba did that one year with dirk and Dwayne wade
mlb1225
The All-Star game is only there to get the sport more attention. It’s an exhibition game that means nothing in the grand scheme of the season. To MLB, it’s more of a marketing tool than anything. Why not give two guys who are generally liked by most fans one last ride?
jgoody62
I think the 2 representatives should be announced last… that way they can earn a selection based on their current year stats if they’re deserving
Sunday Lasagna
They already have a future stars game for top minor league prospects and a celebrity softball game as part of the All Star break festivities. Albert Pujols, Miggy, Nelson Cruz, Wainwright, Molina, Votto, Greinke, etc can all go play in a special “yesteryear’s All Star game”……sign autographs, take photo ops…..but they don’t belong in the actual all star game.
stan lee the manly
It depends on how you define what makes an allstar. “Best overall career” is just as legitimate of a case as “best numbers over this arbitrary half season even if the rest of their career is below average.”
SupremeZeus
ASG is a marketing tool for to baseball celebrate its great players, adding a bit of nostalgia is in line with that idea. However it is striking that MLB and these two players have so much in common: greedy + all about the money, once great and in steep decline.
YankeesBleacherCreature
I agree with your first sentence but why is it surprising that both owners and players want to make money? We just had a lockout over this. If you don’t agree with MLB’s business model, don’t support it and stop watching games.
ARC 2
The fan voting is just a popularity contest of the rich elite teams. This year the AL will heavily Yank players while the NL will be heavy Dodger players. So who wants to watch it besides fans of those 2 teams? After all these years you would think they could come up with a point system to take best players at each position.
theroyal19
You clearly have not seen the voting for this year
xXTheFETTXx
Miggy has been playing like an All-Star, he deserved this.
Lanidrac
Only in the sense that he’s best player on his team. His 108 OPS+ is good but nowhere near All-Star level.
Airo13
Cool to honor these two together. Two of the greatest RH hitters of all-time. I hope the “legendary” selections aren’t chosen every year.
hiflew
Why? Every year at least 2-3 great players walk away from the game. Just because you don’t think they are “great enough” shouldn’t matter. We need to celebrate these guys that have given 15-20 years of their lives to entertain us. Not to mention the 10-15 years they spent working toward the goal to begin with.
Just think of the honorary spots as a player’s “gold watch” of sorts.
Airo13
Ok well Molina already isn’t getting his “gold watch”…
hiflew
Have you already seen the finalized rosters of the All Star Game?
mike156
The All Star Game is an exhibition game. It’s not really the best players anyway. I’d just have seen them voted in an a honorary captain, but for many fans, this might be the last time you see them play. Eh, it’s neither good nor bad.
ntorsky
Well, great. If Miggy doesn’t count as their required one All-Star, who the hell is gonna be the Tigers’ representative now?
For Love of the Game
Alex Lange. Filthy power curve, slider, and 97 mph fastball. So much for not getting anything for Castellanos.
Airo13
Probably one of their bullpen arms. Their bullpen has been insane, especially given their usage with such a patchwork rotation.
phillyballers
I’ll say this, at least Miggy is hitting above 300 at this stage.
bravesfan
This is a pretty classy move. Love it! So long as the game continues to strictly be for fun and has no actual meaning, then I’m all for this
Camden453
Extreme literalists who insist you have to “earn it by putting up numbers” are the most ridiculous aspect of the All-Star game these days
Camden453
It used to be fans would vote for the actual all-stars. In other words who actually emerged as the standout, star players over the long haul
Ryne Sandberg would be the all-star despite having a down season for example
Now, it’s potentially Joc Pederson over Juan Soto. Which is absurd. But literalists will scream Pederson “earned” it. No he didn’t. Because he hasn’t done it over the long haul
They should put the career numbers when they list the stats
getrealgone2
This is one of the dumbest comments I’ve seen on here in awhile. Congrats.
Doug Dascenzo's Mob Boss Dad
Two more reasons not to watch the All-Star Game.
Camden453
Oh I see. So you don’t want to see Pujols come out to pinch hit as the fans give him a standing ovation and he tips his cap
This after a great amount of hard work and sacrifice over the years
You’re a real winner, for sure
getrealgone2
Get off your high horse.
Doug Dascenzo's Mob Boss Dad
@Camden453,
No, I don’t. Besides, based on his current abilities, Pujols would probably just weakly ground into a double play after the conjectural ovation and tip of the cap you had described. The ASG is already lame. Why make it more unwatchable by putting these washed-up (but admittedly HOF worthy) has-beens on the rosters?
He and Cabrera have already been rewarded for their production with more money than you and I will ever see in our lifetimes. Sorry, MLB does not owe them final ASG appearances.
I see you’ve resorted to personal insults. Always the sign of someone making a losing argument. Way to go.
hiflew
Then don’t watch. I won’t miss you.
Doug Dascenzo's Mob Boss Dad
@hiflew ,
Thanks, I won’t. I haven’t sat through an ASG since 1994. As for not being missed, I wasn’t planning on watching it with you anyway. I have other, more interesting plans for that night. Have fun.
YankeesBleacherCreature
@Doug Have you ever not invested time into watching a TV show with a great first season and then it going downhill from there? No one is forcing you to watch the ASG. It’s an exhibition game for fan entertainment. I loathe reality shows and can yell at the sky all day but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t have its loyal audiences.
Doug Dascenzo's Mob Boss Dad
@YankeesBleacherCreature,
To answer your question, no. 99+% of TV shows are a waste of time.
That’s right. No one is forcing me to watch the ASG. I never made any claim to the contrary.
My point is that MLB’s audience is shrinking, or at the very least is certainly not growing. The sport has to find a way to keep older fans and, more importantly, to attract new young ones in order to stay relevant. The gimmick of putting two broken-down players who were once genuine All Stars in the game isn’t going to help on that front. It’s just a lazy, unimaginative move that reeks of desperation.
hiflew
There are a lot of things I have not done since 1994, but i never continue to complain about them with strangers on the Internet in 2022. Just my two cents.
Doug Dascenzo's Mob Boss Dad
@hiflew
“I know MLB network and ESPN would prefer there only be like 16 big market teams, because those are the only games they ever want to show…”
Are these your words? It sure looks a lot like complaining to strangers on the internet. How long have you been beating that dead horse? Since 1994? Or for longer than that?
hiflew
You are not worth talking to. Have a nice life.
angt222
Curious if Manfred will utilize this discretion every year or only if the players fit the “legendary” criteria. Regardless, I think this is a great idea and reminiscent of Ripken & Gwynn repping the ASG in 2001.
YankeesBleacherCreature
I think that’ll depend on ASG TV ratings honestly. I’m sure he’ll be receiving feedback from the league, union, and fans. People in this thread are acting like Manfred made this decision unilaterally.
LouWhitakerHOF
The all star game, the mlb draft, the home run derby. Add the great Miguel Cabrera…. I can’t wait!!
YankeesBleacherCreature
I’m also looking forward to the All-Star Futures game.
getrealgone2
Not sure why everyone is so bent out of shape. I just don’t watch the game.
Rsox
The All Star game is an exhibition. It’s not to be taken this seriously. From 1959-1962 they held two All Star games per season. And then after a ridiculous tie in 2002 they attached home field advantage in the World Series to the game until 2016. Every once in a while you get a hilarious moment like the John Kruk/Randy Johnson AB in the 1993 game or the even better Larry Walker/Randy Johnson AB in 1997.
The best part of the All Star used to be the Hone Run Derby and even that has lost it’s luster
Wowwwwww
Makes no sense to do Miggy. One he’s batting .308 last I checked and has a year remaining in his deal. Just do Pujols and Longoria. And make Longoria play for the AL. Sounds like Longoria is hanging the spikes up after the year
For Love of the Game
A more logical approach would be to just select Miggy because he has earned it this year, unlike Pujols and Longoria.
MannyPineappleExpress9
Both players will also be entered in the HR derby, and regardless of how many they hit each round (do they still do rounds..?) will face off against each other in the finals.
In addition to competing in the derby, every HR hit will count towards their career number in an effort to reach new milestones. If necessary, the total number accumulated in the derby may be doubled to reach said milestone.
etex211
If it gets either of them ahead of Bonds, then I’m all for it.
Four4fore
Let them both leadoff the game and from gthat point on let the All Star game proceed.
Four4fore
Let them both leadoff the game and from that point on let the All Star game proceed.
Four4fore
Let Pujols lead off for the NL and let the game proceed. Cabrera is still producing.
etex211
Maybe one could throw out the first pitch to the other, and then be done.
InherentVice
People who complain about this are the same people who complain that players don’t take the Home Run Derby seriously enough.
etex211
I take the homerun derby very seriously, because I know all of the participants are going to tank in the second half of the season.
SugaMonkey
What a joke!
PipptyPoppitygivemetheZoppity
I think that the Cardinals should release Albert and have him wear a wife beater during the game.
EricTheBat
this news will have major ramifications on trade rumors
David Barista
I like it…. The young players get to be around these Hall of Famers and pick their brains
nottinghamforest13
Having a skills competition would be a lot of fun and no it would not mean more people would get hurt. If the arm goes – like it did for Barry Larkin – it was about to go anyway. It isn’t the skills game that causes it.
No Salary Cap For You! (Come Back One Year)
Both are deserving, but because it’s la and Dodger Stadium, would’ve liked Kershaw to have been considered, not at pujols’ expense but as another honorary spot.
stan lee the manly
Why would they even consider this? Keyshawn isn’t even close to being a legacy player
BobGibsonFan
But… But… But… Miggy is signed for next year? You people are clowns.
BobGibsonFan
They should include Bonds. LOL
JimmyForum
When Miguel is introduced, I’ll be outside smoking a cigarette. When Pujous is introduced I’ll be on the toilet.
machurucuto
You are such an idiot
Crab L. Winston
An evangelical Christian and a Catholic that practices Santería walk into the MLB All Star game…
machurucuto
The foundations of MLB are shaking because some misfits don’t like the ASG.
Crab L. Winston
Could be the end of the game as we know it, right? Remember when people were upset that the game “counted”? Those same people are now upset that the game really, really doesn’t count.
Allerdings
The futures game, home run derby, the actual game, something else? Maybe spice things up with agents vs GMs in a 3 inning game, and if there’s a tie after 3 start the 4th with the commissioner on second base.
Crab L. Winston
Should they go back to the game determining home field so you can complain about that too? Or would it be best to disband the game altogether?
News flash: it’s for the kids who want get to see all of their heroes in one place at a time, not you. I’m on the phone with the doctor for you now. He’s writing the Prozac subscription.
Allerdings
I’ve no problem with the ASG, and in fact have enjoyed it over the many seasons I’ve followed MLB. In trying to inject a little humor to counter the series of comments that are overly critical of the ASG festivities, it seems I’ve triggered your little hissy fit. Lighten up, have a Prozac!
Sorry for being an Angels fan
The rosters will be a hundred deep in no time
SugaMonkey
I can see it now, The GM’s home run derby, to see who gets the rights to negotiate with the top draft pick of the season!
jaybest
why??
Amanda
so cabrera can get arrested charged and pulled over for drunk driving while yelling at the officer ‘ dont you know who i am’ and hes an all- star,
what am i missing?
Cosmo2
All star appearances aren’t based on behavior during traffic stops? What are you looking for here exactly?
Amanda
oh he also has 2 kids from a mistress hes paying child support for, sry forgot that!