Headlines

  • Stuart Sternberg Has Agreed To Sell Rays To Patrick Zalupski, Deal Expected To Be Final By September
  • Nationals Select Eli Willits With First Pick Of 2025 Amateur Draft
  • 2025 MLB Draft, First Round Results
  • Red Sox Place Hunter Dobbins On 15-Day IL Due To ACL Tear
  • Astros Promote Brice Matthews
  • Red Sox Likely To Activate Alex Bregman Tomorrow
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2025 Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

MLB Mailbag: Guerrero, Alonso, Yoshida, Alcantara, Cubs, Mariners

By Tim Dierkes | February 5, 2025 at 11:58pm CDT

This week's mailbag gets into Vladimir Guerrero Jr. vs. Pete Alonso, whether the Mets should move on from Alonso, whether any MLB trade was as shocking as the NBA's Luka Doncic deal, those who feel this MLB offseason has been dull, how much the Red Sox would have to eat on Masataka Yoshida's contract, possible Sandy Alcantara suitors, and much more.

Jed asks:

Why is the general expectation that Vladimir Guerrero Jr. will get over $400m in free agency next winter for 10+ years despite being a defensively limited, slow-footed, right-hand batting first baseman. With Pete Alonso, I've seen so much coverage about how he may not get more than a $23m AAV from the Mets for no more than three years total. Obviously Pete is 4 years and three months older than Vlad Jr., and would be playing his age 30-32 seasons on a three-year deal. But Vlad Jr. will be 27 in 2026, the first year of his presumptive 10+ year mega deal. After those first three seasons on Vlad's hypothetical 10+ year mega deal, he will also be playing his age-30 season in the fourth year of such a contract, presumably at a $40m AAV.

Aside from getting his age 27-29 seasons, why are pundits convinced that an expensive, long-term deal for Vlad Jr makes more sense than a short-term deal with a $23m AAV for Alonso (especially considering that since their 2019 debut seasons, Alonso has hit 66 more homers and posted a higher slugging percentage)? Why is everyone convinced that Vlad Jr represents a better long-term bet to succeed than Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, and all the other countless examples of RHB 1B who failed to produce in their 30s?

I can't speak to general expectations; only my own.  I encourage you to re-read what I wrote on this on December 10th.  A key point was, "So much depends on which Guerrero shows up in 2025."

I strongly prefer the wRC+ stat to home run totals and slugging percentage.  We need to account for offensive contributions other than the home run, and in a more logical way than slugging percentage (a home run is not worth four times as much as a single, for example).  Guerrero has two elite seasons with the bat: 2021 and 2024.  In those years, he hit so well that his defense was an afterthought and he was worth 5-6 WAR.  Juan Soto had six 5-WAR-ish or better seasons under his belt prior to free agency (extrapolating his rookie year and the shortened 2020 season), and it's because he's never posted worse than a 143 wRC+.

Guerrero sandwiched a 132 and 118 season between his 160+ ones, and hitting in that more human range can drop him all the way to 1-3 WAR.  That's a guy you very much don't want to be paying $40MM a year.  But Vlad always has the batted-ball data to back up elite offense, and with another 160+ season I do think offers reach $400MM+.

Alonso's best season was his rookie year with a 144 wRC+.  His second-best was 141 in 2022.  He's been at 121 over the last two years.  He's a 2-3 WAR player who's shown a ceiling of 4 WAR.  Guerrero has shown more variance, but his ceiling has been 6 WAR and he nearly reached it in the recently-completed season.

In comparing age, I'd look at the Opening Day difference of each player's first year under a new free agent contract.  In other words, comparing age at 4-1-25 for Alonso to 4-1-26 for Guerrero.  Using that approach, Guerrero is 3.27 years younger.  Those being prime years, they're incredibly important when it comes to free agent contracts.

Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription

BENEFITS
  • Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams, and Anthony Franco.
  • Join exclusive weekly live chats with Anthony.
  • Remove ads and support our writers.
  • Access GM-caliber tools like our MLB Contract Tracker
Share 0 Retweet 0 Send via email0

Front Office Originals

MLBTR Podcast: Jack Flaherty Back To Detroit, Max Scherzer, And What’s Next For The Padres
Main
The Opener: Bregman, Twins, 40-Man Moves
View Comments (51)
Post a Comment

51 Comments

  1. Mets Era Thumping Soto

    5 months ago

    A home run should be worth more than 4x a single. A home run is guaranteed runs while a single is not. The point of baseball is scoring runs and preventing runs.

    Reply
    • Steinbrenner2728

      5 months ago

      Slugging percentage values more hits than home runs as it is an indicator of the number of bases a hitter gets per at bat, that was part of the example given.

      1
      Reply
    • WCSoxFan

      5 months ago

      A better way to put the above example is that a player who goes 4/4 with 4 singles is much better than a player who goes 1/4 with a home run. By OPS (which also isn’t a great indicator, but it’s widely understood) that’s a 2.000 player vs a 1.250 player.

      The best way to win in baseball is to avoid outs offensively while obtaining outs defensively.

      In the micro environment of a single game won 1-0, the home run can be more valuable, but over a larger sample of games it isn’t close.

      3
      Reply
      • Mets Era Thumping Soto

        5 months ago

        would disagree. Let’s look at Griffey compared to Ichiro. Griffey accounted for 3498 runs in his career. Ichiro accounted for 2200 runs in his career. Ichiro had plenty of those 4/4 games while Griffey hit home runs. You can say anything is mathematically proven if your predetermined outcome is swaying your math to come up with that outcome.

        Reply
        • bob9988 2

          5 months ago

          And rinse repeat, your cherry picking.

          Reply
        • Chester Copperpot

          5 months ago

          Apples to oranges. If you’re assuming Griffey = HR and Ichiro = single, your equation would be 1 Griffey (3498) 1 single.

          Reply
        • Chester Copperpot

          5 months ago

          My post got all messed up. For brevity, the comparison should be 1 Griffey to 4 Ichiros. In which case 3498 < 8800.

          1
          Reply
        • Mets Era Thumping Soto

          5 months ago

          Well there isn’t a single player that only hits home runs or only singles. I’m just giving more value to a home run by more then x4 then a single. Of course it all gets put into the overall equation . I’m just valuing a .260 hitter with 40 hrs more than a .300 hitter with 20 hrs.

          1
          Reply
        • Chester Copperpot

          5 months ago

          Still a false equivalence to compare two players when the discussion is about 1 HR versus 4 singles.

          Reply
        • extreme113

          5 months ago

          Good point but you have to subtract 630
          from Griffey’s total and 177 from Ichiro’s because a HR isn’t worth two runs as you added Runs scored and RBI in your total.

          1
          Reply
        • Fever Pitch Guy

          5 months ago

          mets – I don’t disagree with you, but the way you present your case is inadequate.

          Yes Jr has a lot more RBI in large part because he hit for a lot more power than Ichiro.

          But you are totally excluding PA context which is a key factor in determining value.

          Ichiro bat leadoff for nearly all of his PA’s, which is a big reason why he stepped to the plate with RISP 833 fewer times than Jr …. and that in turn is obviously a huge reason why Ichiro had a lot fewer RBI.

          4
          Reply
        • Atloriolesfan

          5 months ago

          .

          3
          Reply
  2. Chris Sabo Rec Specs

    5 months ago

    I think the question referring to the logic of Alonso vs. Vlad Jr. is in response to the perception that the Mets are all in on Vlad next off-season. That’s the way it’s been consistently framed through nearly all media. Sitting here today, I’d rather have Alonso short term than Vlad long term. I’m not even sure that a big 2025 season from Vlad would change my mind. History would almost guarantee that Vlad would be well overpaid for half or more years of a 10 year deal.

    5
    Reply
    • Boston’s Alignment

      5 months ago

      Mets will not sign another future DH, another unathletic slug. Nope. Media = clicks.

      Reply
      • Dustyslambchops23

        5 months ago

        If you think Vlad is an unathletic slug you either have never watched him play or don’t know ball.

        Reply
    • Fever Pitch Guy

      5 months ago

      Chris – That a justifiable stance, especially considering Cecil Fielder was done at 34 and his son was done at 32.

      Panda was done at 34 too.

      4
      Reply
  3. dejota

    5 months ago

    I’d take 4 singles over 1 HR any day – I get a run guaranteed and the bases loaded at worst 99% of the time. Over thousands of innings and games the 3 singles will produce more runs than 1 HR with a random number of baseball runners between 0-3.

    14
    Reply
    • dejota

      5 months ago

      Look at it another way – A random game where you don’t know the outcome has occurred. Your team hit 2 HRs or 8 singles – which will produce a victory more often?

      8
      Reply
    • BPax

      5 months ago

      Look at the box scores of really high scoring games. It’s remarkable how many don’t have lots of homers. I’ve noticed this for years.

      2
      Reply
    • Boston’s Alignment

      5 months ago

      BITA only comes here to argue.

      16
      Reply
    • larkraxm

      5 months ago

      There are lots of “wasted” home runs. A-Rod used to be the king of hitting a solo HR in a game the Yankees were winning 8-2. Now its 9-2. Big deal. I know you are about to say a single in that situation is wasted as well, but it puts the pitcher in the stretch and makes him work harder. Maybe you work the bull pen over and eliminate some arms for the next couple of games. Not trying to argue the value of four singles vs one home runs. Just pointing out that a home run can be wasted.

      7
      Reply
    • Pete'sView

      5 months ago

      Conforto’s HRs are like that.

      1
      Reply
    • JoeBrady

      5 months ago

      Your team hit 2 HRs or 8 singles – which will produce a victory more often?
      =========================
      8 singles in a row will produce far more runs than 2 HRs.

      And teams with a high OBP usually outscore teams with high HR levels.

      Reply
    • dejota

      5 months ago

      It desnt even have to be in a row to work out more often than not. To compare you’d have to assume equal opportunities otherwise. Obviously we can all point out scenarios where 1 HR vs 4 singles would come out for the HR but baseball is the great equalizer and over a large sample size 4 singles will always contribute more win shares than a singular HR.

      Reply
  4. Chicken In Philly?

    5 months ago

    I wonder why Jose Ramirez wasn’t able to attain a no-trade clause in his extremely team-friendly contract with the Guardians.

    Reply
    • Digdugler

      5 months ago

      I am 99% sure he does because he took a big discount. He must really like the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame.

      1
      Reply
    • Rsox

      5 months ago

      He has a full no trade clause

      Reply
    • Baseballisthebest

      5 months ago

      He does have a full NTC. Tim said that in his answer.

      Reply
      • Fever Pitch Guy

        5 months ago

        Best – I thought NTC stands for “No TimAnderson Clause” which means Cleveland is not allowed to acquire Anderson as long as Ramirez is on the team?

        1
        Reply
  5. Ben4MVP

    5 months ago

    I think the easier way to understand this is to look at how many runs singles and homers are worth on average. This varies slightly by year, but in general a single is worth .7 runs more than an out and a HR is worth about 1.65.

    These are averages that are computed every year. Sometimes a single leads to 0 runs and sometimes it leads to 1, 2, or occasionally even 3 runs. A home run can lead to 1, 2, 3, or 4 runs.

    On average, 4 singles will be worth more runs than 1 home run. This has been mathematically proven.

    6
    Reply
    • Mets Era Thumping Soto

      5 months ago

      I would disagree. Let’s look at Griffey compared to Ichiro. Griffey accounted for 3498 runs in his career. Ichiro accounted for 2200 runs in his career. Ichiro had plenty of those 4/4 games while Griffey hit home runs. You can say anything is mathematically proven if your predetermined outcome is swaying your math to come up with that outcome.

      Reply
      • bob9988 2

        5 months ago

        OMG….Please tell me you didn’t just do that. Those two players played in vastly different times. And their primes both were on the Mariners when each played in a completely different ballpark. Runs created by individual players is the exact way you can cherry-pick data just like you accused Ben of doing.

        3
        Reply
      • Mets Era Thumping Soto

        5 months ago

        What difference does the ballpark or era have in valuing a single or home run. I’m valuing run production. You are making the case that a home run is even more valuable because the ballpark or era limits runs and once again the home run is guaranteed runs. At the end of the day the point is to score as many runs while limiting the least.

        2
        Reply
      • Scott Kliesen

        5 months ago

        HOF voters have spoken, and they value Ichiro more than any hitter to ever play in MLB.

        Idiots!

        2
        Reply
    • Ma4170

      5 months ago

      Problem is the likelihood of a team getting four consecutive hits or 4 hits in 6 AB is low, which is why the run(s) from a HR are more valuable. In this hypothetical, we’re assuming a HR then three outs. Instead of four singles, lets say its a HR and three singles. And depending on when the HR happens, it can be even more valuable.

      3
      Reply
  6. Badfinger

    5 months ago

    According to Tim’s answer, Ramirez does have a no trade clause.

    3
    Reply
  7. Ezpkns34

    5 months ago

    If anything, this discussion proves why “statistical paradox” suggestions trick so many people when they have no, or at best minimal, background in math

    Reply
  8. Baseballisthebest

    5 months ago

    Start here. library.fangraphs.com/misc/re24/

    1
    Reply
    • Baseballisthebest

      5 months ago

      BITA, that tells us volumes. If you can’t understand the math that is ok. Ask someone who does before making comments.

      4 singles are worth roughly double in terms of creating runs than what 1 HR is worth on average.

      3
      Reply
    • Dustyslambchops23

      5 months ago

      lol you are throwing a lot of stones for someone who isn’t interpreting the data properly.

      4 sequential singles are worth on average more, but hits are spread out.

      There are factors to this but on average a 50 HR hitter is going to be massively more valuable than a player who hits 200 singles.

      2
      Reply
    • Baseballisthebest

      5 months ago

      Dusty showing he didn’t understand the math either.

      1
      Reply
  9. Multi Position Eligibility

    5 months ago

    Would you rather have a player who hits 50 homeruns (and no other hits) in a season or a player who hits 200 singles?

    Reply
    • Baseballisthebest

      5 months ago

      Its more about would you rather have 4 straight singles or 1 HR on the first at bat.

      2
      Reply
      • Ignorant Son-of-a-b

        5 months ago

        @BaseballIsTheBest Is that a UFO in your avatar pic??

        Reply
  10. Scott Kliesen

    5 months ago

    The baseball trade nearest in equivalence to the Luka to Lakers trade is Ruth to Yankees.

    1
    Reply
    • Dustyslambchops23

      5 months ago

      Luka is not the best player in the generation. He’s good but probably not top 5

      1
      Reply
      • mlb fan

        5 months ago

        Guys that play zero defense are not generational players. It was just 6+ years ago when people were saying that Kevin Love was an all-time great player because he put up big stats.

        Reply
  11. CTS4

    5 months ago

    Guerrero Jr. is LAZY and is Brutal running the bases…He is Not Worth what he thinks he is…

    3
    Reply
  12. Ignorant Son-of-a-b

    5 months ago

    But if the home run is hit right after a single than that home run is worth twice the amount a solo home run would be worth.

    Reply
  13. John Dan

    5 months ago

    Vlad jr. needs to grow up , shut up , stand up from the buffet table and start doing push ups if he thinks he is getting the bag.

    1
    Reply
  14. JoeBrady

    5 months ago

    Why is everyone convinced that Vlad Jr represents a better long-term bet to succeed than Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, and all the other countless examples of RHB 1B who failed to produce in their 30s?
    ============================
    I don’t care for the examples.

    Fielder was not just fat, he was morbidly obese. Vlad might be fat, but can still mostly handle himself.

    Howard’s contract started when he was 32 and was already in decline.

    I still wouldn’t sign Vlad, but at least you’ll get 3 prime years, 3 okay years, and 4 slowly-declining years.

    1
    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

    Top Stories

    Stuart Sternberg Has Agreed To Sell Rays To Patrick Zalupski, Deal Expected To Be Final By September

    Nationals Select Eli Willits With First Pick Of 2025 Amateur Draft

    2025 MLB Draft, First Round Results

    Red Sox Place Hunter Dobbins On 15-Day IL Due To ACL Tear

    Astros Promote Brice Matthews

    Red Sox Likely To Activate Alex Bregman Tomorrow

    Phillies Reportedly Targeting Controllable Relievers

    Yankees Prioritizing Pitching, Also Searching For Infield Help

    Orioles Trade Bryan Baker To Rays

    Yankees Release DJ LeMahieu

    Trevor Williams To Undergo UCL Surgery

    Nationals Fire PBO Mike Rizzo, Manager Dave Martinez

    Brewers Activate Brandon Woodruff

    Clarke Schmidt Expected To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Bobby Jenks Passes Away

    Braves Release Alex Verdugo

    Top 40 Trade Candidates For The 2025 Deadline

    Rays Reinstate Ha-Seong Kim

    Yankees Have Shown Interest In Ryan McMahon

    Royals Interested In Bryan Reynolds

    Recent

    Stuart Sternberg Has Agreed To Sell Rays To Patrick Zalupski, Deal Expected To Be Final By September

    Adolis Garcia Drawing Trade Interest

    Poll: Who Will Win The 2025 Home Run Derby?

    Royals Place Michael Lorenzen On Injured List

    Yankees Claim Rico Garcia

    Blue Jays, Joe Mantiply Agree To Minor League Deal

    Submit Your Questions For This Week’s Episode Of The MLBTR Podcast

    D-backs Have Listened To Offers On Outfield Depth

    Vinny Nittoli To Opt Out Of Brewers Deal

    The Opener: Home Run Derby, Draft Day 2, Rodriguez

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • Sandy Alcantara Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Alex Bregman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android App Store Google Play

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • Trade Deadline Outlook Series
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    Do not Sell or Share My Personal Information

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version