Clarke Schmidt To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

Yankees right-hander Clarke Schmidt will undergo Tommy John surgery tomorrow. Manager Aaron Boone passed the update along to reporters today, with Chris Kirschner of The Athletic  among those to pass it along. The righty is on the 15-day injured list but will be moved to the 60-day IL once the Yankees need his roster spot.

The news isn’t surprising. It was reported a few days ago that Schmidt had been recommended for the surgery. It seems he and the Yankees took a few days to perhaps due some final tests before confirming the path forward.

Now that Schmidt’s fate is sealed, he will miss the remainder of this season and possibly all of 2026 as well. It normally takes 14 to 18 months for a pitcher to return from such a procedure. That gives Schmidt a shot to return late in 2026, though only if he doesn’t experience any setbacks.

It’s a rough blow for the Yankees, who have already taken a few rotation hits. Gerrit Cole required Tommy John back in the spring and will miss the entire 2025 season. Luis Gil has been on the IL all year so far due to a lat strain. Marcus Stroman has also missed most of the season due to left knee inflammation.

Despite those injuries, the Yankees held the top spot in the American League East for most of the first half. Their rotation was held aloft by a strong one-two punch of Max Fried and Carlos Rodón. That duo was supported by strong performances from Schmidt, Ryan Yarbrough and Will Warren.

More recently, Yarbrough has been sidelined by an oblique strain and now Schmidt has hit the shelf as well. Perhaps not coincidentally, the Yanks have found it a bit more difficult to win games lately and have slid to second in the division behind the Blue Jays.

Even before Schmidt’s injury, it seemed likely that the Yankees would look for more starting pitching at the deadline. Now the need should be even greater. General manager Brian Cashman spoke openly about this week about the club placing a priority on pitching.

For Schmidt, it’s his second straight injury-marred campaign and next year will be three in a row. He logged 159 innings for the Yanks back in 2023, though with a middling 4.64 earned run average. Last year, he dropped his ERA to 2.85 but a lat strain put him on the IL for about half the season, limiting him to 85 1/3 innings. Here in 2024, he logged 78 2/3 innings with a 3.32 ERA before this elbow injury shut him down. Now that he’s got a date with the scalpel, he won’t be able to add to that total and will be capped in 2026 as well.

A Super Two player, Schmidt is currently in his second of four arbitration seasons. He made $2.025MM last year and is making $3.6MM here in 2025. He’ll be due an arbitration raise for 2026 and 2027 but the lengthy injury absence will limit how his ability to push that number up. He’ll turn 30 in February and will be 31 in his final season of control before he’s slated for free agency.

Photo courtesy of Vincent Carchietta, Imagn Images