Poll: The Yankees’ Biggest Need At The Deadline

It’s been a tough few weeks for the Yankees. On May 28, the club was riding high with a seven-game cushion in the AL East. At that point, it seemed as though their biggest concern this summer would be vying for a bye through the Wild Card series rather than holding off their division rivals. That’s not how things have played out. New York has gone just 7-15 over its past 22 games and now sits 3.5 games back of the Blue Jays in the AL East with just a one-game cushion in a highly competitive AL Wild Card race.

The good news for the Yankees is that we’re just a few short weeks from the trade deadline, and help should be available for the club. As GM Brian Cashman and the rest of the front office gear up for trade season, it’s fair to wonder what the club’s biggest need this summer is going to be, although they may have provided some clarity on that as recently as this morning.

The Yankees’ need at either second or third base has been plainly apparent since the offseason. Jazz Chisholm Jr. has played both positions this season and delivered when healthy this year, with an impressive 136 wRC+ in 59 games, but he missed a month with an oblique strain and has battled injuries throughout his young career.

Chisholm has played third base since returning from the injured list early last month, but skipper Aaron Boone revealed this morning that Chisholm is moving back to second base. Boone called third base a “fluid” position and noted that Oswald Peraza will get the first look there tonight. DJ LeMahieu, who’s being displaced at second base by the Chisholm move, has plenty of experience at third base but hasn’t played there this season. Boone said today that playing third is now physically challenging for LeMahieu and not a consideration going forward.

Peraza, meanwhile, has not answered questions about whether or not he’s capable of hitting in the majors. The 25-year-old has hit just .154/.225/.262 (37 wRC+) this year with a 28.2% strikeout rate and little power. While he’s a solid enough defender all around the infield, he’s shown very few signs of life on offense. Jeimer Candelario just signed a minor league deal, but he’s a reclamation project at this point.

The early season heroics of Aaron Judge helped to mask the lackluster offensive production the Yankees were receiving from the tandem of LeMahieu and Peraza, but the team has gotten below average production from both second (89 wRC+) and third base (93 wRC+) even with Chisholm chipping in at both positions. A bat like that of Eugenio Suárez could transform the Yankees lineup, but even less flashy additions like Willi Castro, Amed Rosario, and Ryan McMahon could be a major help. Not only would that sort of addition shore up an infield in desperate need of additional depth, but it could help jump start a lineup that’s been in a collective slump of late. Over the past month, the Yankees rank just 16th in runs scored. They’ve scored one run or fewer runs seven times in that span. That type of offensive production is hard for even a dominant pitching staff to turn into wins.

Of course, the pitching staff has been far from dominant of late. Yankees starters have generally impressed on the season, with an 3.72 ERA and 3.79 FIP, but since the calendar flipped to June that’s ticked up to a 3.94 ERA and 4.15 FIP. They’re just 15th in the majors in rotation FIP since the start of June, and that’s including strong work from Clarke Schmidt, whose season appears finished as he awaits a likely Tommy John surgery. Schmidt joins Gerrit Cole on the shelf for the remainder of the year. The Yankees’ rotation now includes Max Fried, Carlos Rodon, Marcus Stroman and rookie Will Warren. Prospect Cam Schlittler is being called up to make his MLB debut and start tomorrow’s game.

Luis Gil is expected back at some point down the stretch, but a team relying on rookies like Schlittler and Warren (who has a 5.02 ERA in 18 starts this year) could benefit from another playoff-caliber starting pitcher. Given their long-term strength in the rotation, it would be understandable if the Yankees weren’t interested in paying for a controllable arm like Sandy Alcantara or Mitch Keller. Even so, swinging a deal for a solid veteran rental like Merrill Kelly or Seth Lugo would go a long way to improving the look of the team’s rotation headed into the stretch run.

The Yankees’ bullpen has also had some troubles throughout the season. Early in the year, newly-acquired closer Devin Williams was lit up badly enough that his ERA crept up over 11.00 and he was removed from the ninth inning. He’s eventually gotten to the point where he’s looking right for the most part again, with a 2.31 ERA and 1.54 FIP since the start of June. Even so, the step forward from Williams has been balanced out in recent weeks by injuries to key arms like Mark Leiter Jr., Jake Cousins and Fernando Cruz. Meanwhile, late-inning arms like Luke Weaver and Jonathan Loaisiga have struggled considerably returning from IL stints of their own. Adding some sort of depth to a bullpen that’s shown cracks all throughout the season would make some sense.

Judge, Fried, and more recently Williams have provided the sort of superstar production that can help paper over issues and keep the team afloat, but the depth behind those stars is clearly lacking. Which of the Yankees’ needs to MLBTR readers think is most important to address? Have your say in the poll below: