Headlines

  • Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony
  • Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence
  • Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.
  • Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment
  • Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery
  • Braves Select Craig Kimbrel
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

Remove Ads
  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Mets, Rockies Discussing Troy Tulowitzki?

By Steve Adams | November 10, 2014 at 7:50pm CDT

7:50pm: Rockies GM Jeff Bridich says that he’s had congratulatory and “what-are-you-looking-for” types of chats with the Mets, but no talks about Tulowitzki, MLB.com’s Thomas Harding reports.  A source tells Patrick Saunders of the Denver Post that the two sides haven’t discussed the star shortstop, though the Mets could be discussing Tulowitzki internally.  (Both links are to Twitter.)

3:43pm: The Mets just announced a two-year deal for Michael Cuddyer, but Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports reports that he isn’t the only significant right-handed bat that has the team’s eye. The Mets have had recent discussions with the Rockies about shortstop Troy Tulowitzki, Passan tweets. While they fear that they cannot afford to add him, the two sides are talking. Newsday’s Marc Carig spoke to a source who characterized the talks as “due diligence” at this point (Twitter link).

A move for Tulowitzki would be expensive both financially and in terms of prospects, but the Mets do have a large stockpile of the type of young pitching which the Rockies covet. Noah Syndergaard, Zack Wheeler, Matt Harvey, Jacob deGrom and Rafael Montero all offer varying degrees of upside, and none have even reached arbitration to this point. (Syndergaard has yet to even reach the Majors.) Jon Niese is on an affordable contract, and Dillon Gee has yet to become overly expensive.

While it’s a lot to read into the situation at this time, a Tulowitzki acquisition would mean doubling down on a pair of injury-prone right-handed bats, as he and Cuddyer have both struggled to stay on the field in recent seasons. Tulowitzki is owed $20MM annually through 2019, plus a $14MM salary in 2020 and at least the $4MM buyout of his $15MM club option for the 2021 season. That adds up to a sum of $118MM over the next six years, so it’s not hard to see why the club isn’t certain it can afford to acquire him.

Still, the Mets are better positioned than most clubs to take on a long-term commitment, at least in terms of the other long-term pacts already on the books. David Wright’s extension was front-loaded, and $20MM salary drops to $15MM in 2019 and $12MM in 2020. That contract is the only one on the books for the Mets beyond 2017, though Curtis Granderson will earn $16MM in each of the next two seasons and $15MM in 2017.

Share 133 Retweet 193 Send via email5

Colorado Rockies New York Mets Newsstand Troy Tulowitzki

Free Agent Notes: V-Mart, Hart, Grilli, Ichiro
Main
NL West Notes: Sandoval, Dodgers, Hellickson
View Comments (192)
Post a Comment

192 Comments

  1. Matt Silab

    11 years ago

    Shocker. Can’t see it happening with atleast 2 of Wheeler, Syndergaard, DeGrom or Montero going to the Rox.

    Reply
  2. Yankeeboy11

    11 years ago

    That escalated quickly

    Reply
  3. Rally Weimaraner

    11 years ago

    Rockies would have to kick in some serious cash for that deal to work.

    Reply
    • Andy B

      11 years ago

      It’s a shame that a team located in New York City can’t field the payroll that teams in Cincinnati or Milwaukee do. The Wilpons should not be allowed to own a team if that’s the best they can do.

      Reply
      • Grizzy

        11 years ago

        I believe that what OP was getting at is that Tulo’s massive salary means that it would be unlikely for the Mets to take on the whole thing in a trade, given how frugal they’ve become in recent years. That frugality is a problem in a lot of cases, but I think it’s pretty reasonable given Tulo’s injury problems and the massive scale of the contract.

        Reply
        • Andy B

          11 years ago

          Tulo played 93 games last year and was still worth 5 war. Despite his injury risk he’s still worth every penny of that contract.

          Reply
      • mikefichera

        11 years ago

        If Rockies want prospects they’ll need to kick in cash. I just can’t see why the Mets would have to give up 2-3 top prospects for a player owed 120mm when they can sign Hanley for probably around the same price and give up only a second round pick.

        Reply
        • Andy B

          11 years ago

          Hanley is no longer a shortstop, Mets can do whatever they want but Tulo despite his injury risk is an elite player and he’s worth that package and salary. And I’m not a Rockies fan, just a casual observer.

          Reply
          • mikefichera

            11 years ago

            Pretty sure he is a shortstop; league average defensively, but thats not why the Mets need Hanley. Also, they’ve been getting below league average d at short with last in the MLB offense.

            Reply
            • Andy B

              11 years ago

              Hanley is the second worst defensive shortstop in the league behind Yunell Escobar. And over the long term Hanley’s defense will only continue to erode.

              Reply
      • Mhmd Mnt

        11 years ago

        Agreed, the Madoff excuse was just that. An excuse. The Wilpons cashed in during the last decade.

        Reply
  4. EarlyMorningBoxscore

    11 years ago

    If the Mets pull off a decent deal for Tulo I take everything back I said about the Cuddy signing.

    Reply
    • Marc

      11 years ago

      What would they have to do with each other? They could have just traded for Tulo…

      Reply
      • EarlyMorningBoxscore

        11 years ago

        MLB prohibits the trading of draft picks, and by the Mets signing Cuddy it gives the Rockies an extra draft pick. Outside the box thinking to facilitate a deal for Tulo.

        Reply
        • Matt Silab

          11 years ago

          Still can’t see a 30-something overall pick playing a huge role other then a 3rd-best piece of the deal.

          Reply
          • EarlyMorningBoxscore

            11 years ago

            It’s still essentially a first round pick and those picks are very valuable to many teams.

            Reply
          • mauryfeldman

            11 years ago

            If this is part of the deal, terrible idea. The comp pick belongs to the Rockies now, it’s not up for negotiation, even though the deal is not complete. That’s terrible bargaining.
            I think that’s just a fan rationalizing/conspiracy theory.

            Reply
        • Anthony CARATURO

          11 years ago

          Why does everyone think that pick being given to Colorado has something to do with TULO to the mets?

          Reply
          • Matt Silab

            11 years ago

            Because who gives a 15 overall pick up to sign a 36 year old, injury prone, should-be-DHing left fielder?

            Reply
            • Anthony CARATURO

              11 years ago

              He did hit .332 and look I’m skeptical too I mean he played at Coors and was injury prone but the mets management knows that with all this pitching the time to contend is now they have to start bringing people to the park and creating excitement Alderson won’t be here forever

              Reply
              • brickman

                11 years ago

                If he hits .275 with 15 hrs, 80 RBI I’ll be happy.

                Reply
            • slider32

              11 years ago

              I agree, he is friends with David Wright!

              Reply
            • TheRealRyan 2

              11 years ago

              It’s irrelevant to the Rockies who signed Cuddyer. Once he turned down the QO, the Rockies pick is locked in after the 1st round regardless of where Cuddyer signs.

              Reply
              • Joe Schmell

                11 years ago

                Unless he’s signed by a team with a top 10 pick

                Reply
          • EarlyMorningBoxscore

            11 years ago

            Think of it this way the Rockies trading Tulo, and Cuddy to the Mets for a draft pick, and whatever other pieces are included for Tulo.

            Reply
          • Mets2016

            11 years ago

            Met fans don’t. We know the owners won’t spend money.They let Reyes walk due to his game relying on legs and his injury history along with not wanting to pay 20 million to a SS.I doubt they will give up prospects for Tulo when they let a homegrown guy walk for similar price tag.

            Reply
        • slider32

          11 years ago

          Francesca on WFAN said his sources say there is no deal for Tulo, I think his contract is too rich for the Mets blood!

          Reply
          • jjs91

            11 years ago

            Think of it this way the Mets gave up a first rounder to talk to the rockies about Tulo. Kind of like how the old posting system worked

            Reply
            • slider32

              11 years ago

              Makes sense, but the Mets and Alderson don’t have it in their blood to trade for Tulo
              1

              Reply
        • mikefichera

          11 years ago

          Yeah, and lets say the Rockies and Mets don’t get a deal done? Or the Rockies just say forget about it. Who do the Mets cry to? Last I checked there wasn’t any organized crime doing protection in the MLB; well outside of Selig’s investigations anyway.

          Reply
    • Jack Campbell

      11 years ago

      Exactly what i was going to say. Im starting to get a little excited with all the new info startibg to settle in.

      Reply
  5. Jimmy Fredrickson

    11 years ago

    It seems like the Mets could have given the Rockies a first round pick as part of the trade

    Reply
    • Betty Bloop

      11 years ago

      mlb does not allow trading draft picks

      Reply
      • Jimmy Fredrickson

        11 years ago

        I know that. The Mets already gave the Rockies a draft pick from Cuddyer so it wouldn’t be a direct draft pick trade,

        Reply
  6. JacobyWanKenobi

    11 years ago

    I hope it gets done, and quickly. I can’t wait to see who gets hosed, because somebody is getting hosed.

    Reply
    • Anthony CARATURO

      11 years ago

      The mets will be hosed. They’re not getting him unless they give up wheeler or Noah. I’ve already told myself that. I’d offer Niese Gee montero flores and Marcos Molina another power pitchin prospect who pitched well and has a on of potential and see if that at least is possible. I wouldn’t want him at the expense of Noah or Zack. And the fact that the Yankees think they have a shot if the Rockies accept any of those “prospects” from the Yankees they’ll be hosed.

      Reply
      • yclept

        11 years ago

        Isn’t a bit typical for a Mets fan to throw the Yankees into a conversation that has nothing to do with the Yankees? Meanwhile,instead of giving the Rockies the type of value they covet, you instead want to give them Dillon Gee and Jonathan Niese. Yeah, that’ll work.

        Reply
        • Mets2016

          11 years ago

          isn’t it like a Yankee fan to bash the Mets. I remember the fans being upset that Harvey hit Cano and said it was on purpose. 5 months later and people said good ridden to Cano and saying Harvey will go to the Yanks because he grew up a Yankee fan.Jeter was a Yankee fan but he didn’t take a discount to stay as one. Players will go where the money is and that’s it.

          Reply
      • slider32

        11 years ago

        The whole thing is everybody knows Tulo wants to play for the Yankees, he has said that many times!

        Reply
        • mikefichera

          11 years ago

          Show me once.

          Reply
      • mikefichera

        11 years ago

        You would rather keep Noah Syndergaard than trade him for an MVP at the scarcest position in the league.

        Sandy has brainwashed you well.

        Reply
  7. anon_coward

    11 years ago

    if the mets give up good pitching for Tulo, i’ll renounce them. the guy screams months of the DL

    Reply
    • mikefichera

      11 years ago

      90 games of Tulo is about as good as 320 games of Ruben Tejada.

      Reply
      • jho

        11 years ago

        But does it equal all the pieces the Mets would give up to obtain him? Keep in mind that Starting Pitchers face on average 700-800+ batters over the course of a season. You really want to miss out on Thor or Wheeler being the next big thing, and not only the other pieces too? Tulo is too big an injury risk…

        Reply
        • mikefichera

          11 years ago

          You don’t know what it’ll take to get him. Right now the Mets have alot of sheep, they badly need wheat. The Rockies have some wheat and they want some sheep. We aren’t giving all the sheep, just a little of the excess. Just because the sheep your trading could end up being really useful to the rockies doesn’t mean its a bad trade; it’s a win win for both teams. At this point.

          Reply
          • anon_coward

            11 years ago

            except Tulo isn’t wheat. his away splits aren’t worth the money he’s owed and the risk

            Reply
            • mikefichera

              11 years ago

              Wheat is offense. He is offense. HE is wheat =D. We need offense. This is Catan.

              Reply
              • anon_coward

                11 years ago

                you guys are stuck with him. no one is going to send players to denver and take on his salary

                Reply
                • mikefichera

                  11 years ago

                  I’m a Mets fan; I agree Denver should kick in some salary relief if they want prospects. I’m just saying DL or not Tulo makes the Mets so much better.

                  Reply
  8. TheJuanWhoKnocks

    11 years ago

    The Rockies also need a young catcher, so don’t forget about Plawecki who is a top 50 catching prospect in AAA. I think him and Syndergaard (over Wheeler and deGrom) is the starting point. If it does happen that first round pick may have been part of it.

    Reply
    • mauryfeldman

      11 years ago

      Plawecki, Flores, Syndergaard. That would be a huge haul for Colorado: basically, three good pieces for a part-time player (albeit a great one). And $20 million per in savings. I bet the three above average more WAR per year than Tulo for the next five years.

      Reply
      • TheJuanWhoKnocks

        11 years ago

        True, but Flores (not really a SS and blocked by Murphy/Herrera/Reynolds at 2B) and Plawecki (blocked by d’Arnaud) are not as big in the Mets plans anyway. Syndergaard could be a big loss even with the Mets’ pitching depth, but Tulo makes them a win now team.

        Reply
        • mauryfeldman

          11 years ago

          I think Flores 2B, Rutledge SS is an acceptable defensive middle infield. And they can both hit. Plawecki would be an above average hitting C for the Rockies, and Syndergaard their ace.
          You are right that, given how hard it is to get contender-quality bats, they probably have to take a risk.

          Reply
          • Ray Ray

            11 years ago

            Okay so where does Gold Glove winner DJ LeMahieu fit into your “acceptable” middle infield?

            Reply
            • mikefichera

              11 years ago

              He has a .600 ops at 2b where half the games are played at the most hitter friendly park in the league; you want to win games or gold gloves?

              Reply
              • Ray Ray

                11 years ago

                Since the park is hitter friendly, perhaps you don’t need all 8 hitters to have a huge OPS. A strong defense-first second baseman is offset by an extremely offensive oriented shortstop. Wilin Rosario is a really good hitter (well not this year but you get my point) and I would argue that his bad defense cost the Rockies more runs than his good offense produced.

                Reply
        • mikefichera

          11 years ago

          Could see Murphy being traded to the Rockies. His contract expires this year and he is eligible for FA; he would certainly receive a qualifying offer barring a career ending injury and that would give the Rockies another 1st round draft pick; also gives Mets salary relief, slot Flores or Herrera at second.

          Reply
      • slider32

        11 years ago

        How about Wheeler, Plawecki, and Nimmo?

        Reply
        • brickman

          11 years ago

          It won’t be Nimmo. The mets went after Cuddyer to fill the time before Nimmo comes to the bigs.

          Reply
          • mikefichera

            11 years ago

            Precisely. Unless Rockies kick in cash Mets will not trade any arms that are currently on the big league roster outside of Gee.

            Reply
            • brickman

              11 years ago

              Or Colon, who the Rockies wouldn’t want.

              Reply
      • ezrider

        11 years ago

        They’ll probably get a ML pitcher in the deal to boot. Niese for monetary reasons or Gee. I can’t see Colon going since he is an extreme flyball pitcher. I’m not seeing Wheeler, deGrom going. Would they deal Harvey just to get the headache of him and Borris out of there lives?

        Reply
        • SFGiantsfan_10

          11 years ago

          Not Harvey. Too much talent to give up just to get Boras out of there. The Rockies would likely have to be the ones to add something to get Harvey.

          Reply
        • slider32

          11 years ago

          Yes, I see Harvey as a pain in their side, DeGrom is the guy to watch!

          Reply
          • brickman

            11 years ago

            Harvey is the key to their future. If he and Boris give them a headache, they’ll take Tylenol.

            Reply
        • mikefichera

          11 years ago

          Mets will only trade Harvey for the entire Rockies team, and their affiliates. Mets unlikely to trade Niese because he is their only lefty, that leaves Gee.

          Reply
      • Ray Ray

        11 years ago

        I’d take that bet. Considering that even with his injuries Tulo had more 5.0 WAR years in the past 8 seasons (6) than Derek Jeter had in his entire career (5).

        As far as the prospects go, I direct you to the names of Drew Pomeranz and Alex White the last time the Rockies brought in “can’t miss” pitching prospects for their big name. I’m not saying Syndergaard won’t succeed, but more have failed than have succeeded. The Rockies also have two really good catching prospects in Tom Murphy and Ryan Casteel so Plawecki would just be a slight improvement. Flores seems like he is destined to be a utility guy in the bigs.

        Reply
        • brickman

          11 years ago

          Most ” can’t miss” prospects disappoint. Even the good ones end up like Greg Jeffries.The ones who hit are the ones who become superstars. Noah could be one, but the odds are against it. The Rockies are currently not going anywhere with Tulo. Time to roll the dice.

          Reply
  9. Lefty_Orioles_Fan

    11 years ago

    Mets should get Car Go too!
    Really go for the Gusto.

    Reply
    • Matt Silab

      11 years ago

      Where would CarGo play?

      Reply
      • Lefty_Orioles_Fan

        11 years ago

        I have no idea, but they should get him!

        Reply
        • Matt Silab

          11 years ago

          I like it! He’ll go play shortstop!

          Reply
          • Melvin Mendoza, Jr.

            11 years ago

            Would it be like baseball video games where if you put a lefty in at a non OF/1B position, they magically turn right handed?

            Reply
      • mauryfeldman

        11 years ago

        Special assistant to the medical trainer. Where he has the most experience!

        Reply
      • Anthony CARATURO

        11 years ago

        LF. Blindfold grandy and send him and his contract over to Japan or to Jason bays house so they could discuss what what wrong when they came here

        Reply
      • Pei Kang

        11 years ago

        center field :P~

        Reply
        • Matt Silab

          11 years ago

          They like Largares. Plus CarGo shouldn’t play CF anyways in that big park.

          Reply
          • Pei Kang

            11 years ago

            That was a joke 🙂

            Reply
  10. Dogger27

    11 years ago

    Wow Wow Wow

    Wilpons are showing us they love their fans!!!

    Anyone have a feeling that the Rockies gave the QO as part of the Cuddyer trade! It’s kinda old Cuddyer rejecting the QO unless the round one pick was part of the deal!

    Reply
    • Joel Peterson

      11 years ago

      The Mets lost the 15th pick in order for the Rox to gain a pick in the 30s. This was not a prearranged deal. Think about it.

      Reply
    • vtadave

      11 years ago

      Sarcasm?

      Reply
  11. hiflyer000

    11 years ago

    I give the over/under on combined games played next year at 162

    Reply
  12. LGMets2020

    11 years ago

    I’m not sure I’m down with the plan of adding older, often-injured, past their prime players. To me it seems they could find a young SS (maybe deal with the Cubs?) instead of adding a guy who is only likely to play half a season.

    Reply
  13. tanque

    11 years ago

    really? really? is the gm in this too?

    Reply
  14. Rally Weimaraner

    11 years ago

    In related news the Mets have announce the team will change its name to: “The New York Mets Formerly of Colorado”

    Reply
    • gursky_1989

      11 years ago

      Because they have two players?

      Reply
      • Rally Weimaraner

        11 years ago

        Because their entire offense will depend on two players from Colorado

        Reply
        • gursky_1989

          11 years ago

          No… Most will depend on a healthy David Wright, d’Arnaud building off his second half, Duda continuing to rake and Granderson bouncing back

          Reply
          • Evan

            11 years ago

            I have an advanced degree in Satire and Sarcasm from Professional Gentlemen’s Mustache and Monocle University. I’m gunna waive my professional fee and just let you know for free that WhoKilledTheRallyMonkey was joking……

            I will also add in a harrumph…good show sir

            Reply
            • gursky_1989

              11 years ago

              Well that would put my mind at ease

              Reply
    • Doug

      11 years ago

      Better than the “New York Mess of Flushing,” which they’ve been the last few years.

      Reply
  15. Rbase

    11 years ago

    hmm. Tulowitzki and Chacin for Tejada, Wheeler/Syndegaard and Gee/Niese. That would give the rockies 2 solid starters and that is the only way i see a deal (for tulo or gonzalez) getting done.

    Reply
    • MB923

      11 years ago

      Lol. Zero chance. Tejada is terrible, and both Gee and Niese are overrated and are a product of Citi Field. Career ERA+ of under 100 for each.

      Reply
      • Rbase

        11 years ago

        Did some more research on Niese/Gee. I saw them (especially niese) as very solid starters, but you are correct about their ERA+. Also, their home-road splits are pretty bad over the past 2 years. This comes as a bit of a suprise to me as their basic stats (ERA…) are pretty solid.

        Yes, Tejada is not that good, but someone is going to have to play short for the Rockies (Adames/rutledge might be a possibility)… And i don’t see them signing Hanley/Asdrubal/Lowrie since they are wanted by a lot of other teams as well.

        Reply
        • yclept

          11 years ago

          Rockies will not want Tejada. They would take Flores over him, but obviously not as a centerpiece.

          Unless the Rox are really desperate to dump the salary, the a Mets (or whoever) is going to have to pay a big premium here. The Rox only trade him for players who can help them win in the future while also being cost-controlled. Tejada, Gee, and Niese simply do not fit that definition.

          Reply
  16. Loody

    11 years ago

    Is it possible for the Mets to offer Colorado either Wheeler or Syndergaard (lets say Wheeler) and say that in order to get Wheeler the Rockies would have to take on the rest of Granderson’s contract. Mets could add additional piece or two such as Kevin Plawecki, Wilmer Flores and perhaps a Jennry Mejia. I am thinking that Granderson would rake in Coors field and be a great clubhouse and veteran leader. Mets would sacrifice one of their young pitchers and inherit a large contract but they would be willing to do so because it enables them to escape one of the few large contracts they already have.

    Reply
    • anon_coward

      11 years ago

      nope, the mets just hired kevin long

      Reply
  17. MetsEventually

    11 years ago

    In the words of Cleveland…”No, no, no, no, NO!!!”

    Reply
  18. Adrian Garcia

    11 years ago

    this is basically not happening without Thor, Montero, and Plawecki in a best case scenario for the Mets I don’t think

    Reply
  19. mauryfeldman

    11 years ago

    I wouldn’t give up very much for Tulo. I just can’t see him being the elite player he’s been with the Rockies with the Mets; not because of the field, but because of his age and the serious hip surgery he recently had. Just a gigantic risk.

    Reply
  20. iedodgerfan

    11 years ago

    The Colorado Mets of Flushing Meadows

    Reply
  21. genius.gm.on.mlb.the.show

    11 years ago

    oh dang?!

    Reply
  22. i'm me ..

    11 years ago

    Wheeler will head to Colorado in any deal for Tulo.

    Reply
  23. Freddie Morales

    11 years ago

    The mets cannot have Cuddyer be their big offseason splash. A trade for Tulo makes so much sense. They have the pieces and the money (they should at least) to do it. Trade Syndergaard, Herrera, Tejada, and Plawecki. They still have Montero, Matz, Molina, Nimmo, Conforto, Smith, and Rosario. He is the type of player you take a risk for because the reward is that great!

    Reply
    • Danny Phillips

      11 years ago

      Tulo isn’t worth what acquiring would cost any team. If he had no injury history, maybe.

      Reply
      • Freddie Morales

        11 years ago

        He is the best shortstop in baseball, he is worth it. Name a SS that is better. He can bat 3 and give great defense

        Reply
        • Danny Phillips

          11 years ago

          I’m not basing my statement on how good Tulo is. When he is actually on the field, I’m aware. Simply the fact that Colorado is only dealing him if they completely glut a farm system.

          Ian Desmond has also won the last three NL silver sluggers’ at SS.

          Reply
          • Freddie Morales

            11 years ago

            He will cost 3 prospects and maybe one lesser prospect, someone like leathersich or mazzoni or someone. You don’t know what these prospects will do in the majors, Tulo is proven and you do what you need to to get him

            Reply
            • Danny Phillips

              11 years ago

              Just saying for the Mets they are at minimum likely losing two of Harvey/Syndegaard/DeGrom/Wheeler for the Rox to part with him. Not worth it and the Mets won’t do it.

              Reply
        • Rally Weimaraner

          11 years ago

          Tulo is the best SS when HEALTHY, Tulo hasn’t reached 600 PA since 2011 which severely limits how valuable he is. Tulo has average 117 games per season for his career. Basically any team with Tulo needs to plan on the backup SS playing for 1/3 of the season.

          Reply
          • Freddie Morales

            11 years ago

            I am not saying he is not risky but he is the type you take the risk on. Why continue settling for lesser players. Act like the big market team they should be and stop playing 2nd fiddle to the yanks.

            Reply
  24. Howie

    11 years ago

    Mets doing what they do best…wasting talent to take on more money, which gets them nowhere as usual lol

    Reply
  25. Melvin Mendoza, Jr.

    11 years ago

    Not sure I like this for either team, assuming the deal would be built around one or more of the pitching prospects. I think the Mets would be better served to try and sign someone like Lowrie, Drew, (maybe even Hanley?) and stand pat with all those arms. I think that would be a competitive team. On Colorado’s side, I don’t think I would give up Tulowitzki to bring pitching prospects to Coors where you never know what could happen.

    Reply
  26. blueNorange

    11 years ago

    I rather take the 6 years and $114 Million and try to make a play for Hanley with that money. If they do decide the trade route I hope it is Castro not Tulo.

    P.S.- What do you think Hanley gets on the open market?
    P.P.S- The Mets also would not lose a first round pick because they already gave it up.

    Reply
    • DippityDoo

      11 years ago

      I get the offensive value may be pretty close, but where do you put Hanley in 2 years when he not only has bricks for hands, but range like he has cement shoes?

      Reply
      • rct 2

        11 years ago

        Second? Left field when Cuddyer’s gone?

        Reply
  27. Senor_Met

    11 years ago

    Syndergaard+Plawecki+Nimmo+Reynolds…I’d do it. If they wanted someone like Niese, I’d throw it in too. Hopefully the Mets would get some cash in exchange.

    Reply
    • blueNorange

      11 years ago

      I would be more inclined to trade Wheeler and I think part of the issue is that Colorado does not want to eat any of the salary

      Reply
      • Senor_Met

        11 years ago

        If Colorado was committing to a rebuild enough that they’d trade Tulo, they would definitely eat some of it. They wouldn’t be able to get a good return if they didn’t.

        Reply
        • blueNorange

          11 years ago

          New GM and his first move is to trade the franchise player. So he might require the farm to pry Tulo because Colorado’s gm cant afford to look bad

          Reply
          • Ray Ray

            11 years ago

            Dan O’Dowd’s first moves in Colorado were to trade Bichette and Castilla. New GMs like to put their impression on a franchise not ride the same losing train that cost the predecessor his job.

            Reply
  28. Vandals Took The Handles

    11 years ago

    A team deep into rebuilding that is finally beginning to be competitive, is supposed to trade 3 of its plum prospects that they’ve been waiting on, for a guy on the wrong side of 30 with an astronomical contract that has been one of the most injured position players in MLB for years?

    This reads a bit like the Lakers trading with the Suns for Steve Nash. What could possibly go wrong?

    Reply
  29. Danny Phillips

    11 years ago

    Just trade for Alexei Ramirez instead.

    Reply
    • MB923

      11 years ago

      No reports of him on the trading block. That last report was about teams interested. Teams are interested in certain players all the time (Stanton comes to mind) but it doesn’t mean they are available.

      Reply
  30. Christopher Hoffa

    11 years ago

    this trade would all be relative to what the Mets would be giving up to be completely honest. no matter what though, I would be absolutely ecstatic as a Mets fan if Tulowitzki were to be acquired

    Reply
  31. DKallday

    11 years ago

    Obvious trading partners are obvious. Mets have needed a SS for awhile now while, Colorados pitching IS the reason why theyre not contenders.
    But, knowing the Rockies. They will try to deplete the entire plethora of Mets pitching prospects in order to let their star Tulo go.
    Sorry Yankees fans and their dreams of Tulo as their SS but the Mets are really the only team that can entice Tulo away from Colorado.

    Reply
    • Tony Wilson

      11 years ago

      Don’t lose any sleep over this, he won’t be a Met. His desire is to be a Yankee, everyone knows this and contrary to popular belief the Yankees do have pieces to get him. Judge, Severino, Bird, Sanchez, Clarkin Lindgren and maybe lesser prospects such as Williams, Banuelos or Bichette Jr. He either stays with Colorado or goes to the team he WANTS to play for and it’s not the Mets.

      Reply
      • Dock_Elvis

        11 years ago

        Desire might be to be a Yankee..though I see no point in him voicing that opinion publicly. Yankees might not have the return for him now. Of course, he and they can wait out the contract and the Yanks can use him as an aged corner infielder.

        Reply
      • Terry Janiak

        11 years ago

        News flash buddy. Tulowitski isn’t a free agent. The Rockies can trade him to any team they want whether he likes it or not, Yankees farm already blows and there roster is filled with aging players. Do you realy think they will trade their already depleated farm system away for an aging injury prone player? LOL. Tulo will not play for the Yankees unless they want to sign him as a 37 year old free agent

        Reply
        • astoriacub

          11 years ago

          Yanks don’t have the pitching prospects the Rockies would want.

          Reply
      • jho

        11 years ago

        Who?

        Reply
  32. slider32

    11 years ago

    Strange, the Mets are the only ones giving a first round draft pick for him!

    Reply
  33. Mikenmn

    11 years ago

    i really don’t understand this. if they need to move payroll to sign cuddyer, how do they pay for Tulo? And what’s the point of building up a vaunted farm system only to diminish it for a player you may not be able to afford?

    Reply
  34. Tony Wilson

    11 years ago

    Everyone calm down he has been very open about wanting to play for the Yankees. So if he plays for a NY team it will be them not the Mets. The question is do the Yankees get involved.

    Reply
    • Dilip Sridhar 2

      11 years ago

      True but the mets can offer a far better package. There is no debate about that

      Reply
      • rct 2

        11 years ago

        Sure, the Mets can offer a better package, but ‘will they’ is a better question. I could see the Yankees mortgaging part of their future, the Mets not so much.

        Reply
      • Tony Wilson

        11 years ago

        Severino, Sanchez, Clarkin and Williams may get it done. He has openly spoken about his desire to play for the Yanks and the owner has such a good relationship with him it’s been rumored that he will try to accommodate him as much as he can. I don’t think Colorado would be dumb enough to trade him within the division so I could be wrong but I think he stays, or goes to the Yankees. With St . Louis being a dark horse but u are right, the Mets would be able to offer the better package.

        Reply
        • Dilip Sridhar 2

          11 years ago

          they want betances, they have made that evident

          Reply
    • jb226 2

      11 years ago

      I don’t see a no-trade clause in his contract according to Cot’s, so it doesn’t really matter what Tulo’s preference is unless Colorado chooses to ask him.

      Reply
      • Tony Wilson

        11 years ago

        Reports are that because of how close he and the owner are, he will have a say irregardless of the fact he’s not a 10/5 guy.

        Reply
        • petrie000

          11 years ago

          Noah Syndergaard trumps any and all friendships when it comes to baseball… especially when you’re the guy shelling out 118 million dollars to say no

          Reply
    • Jimmy Willy

      11 years ago

      The player has no say in this situation. The Rockies will deal him to the team that gives them the best offer. I do the Yankees have the pieces to get it done but I don’t think they should trade the 4or 5 prospects it will take for a player who might miss significant time.

      Reply
      • Tony Wilson

        11 years ago

        Reports released earlier this evening state that even though Tulo doesn’t have a no trade clause, they will allow him to dictate where he goes and his choices are NYY, SF and LAD and I have a hard time believing they will trade him within the division.

        Reply
  35. Wooltron

    11 years ago

    20 mil a year for a guy who has averaged 117 games played per season for his career doesn’t seem like a good idea. He just turned 30. Doubt he suddenly shakes the injury bug. It’s a shame, too. He would have been one of the all time greatest shortstops if he could have staid on the field.

    Reply
    • Ray Ray

      11 years ago

      How about 20 million a year for a guy with more 5.0 WAR seasons (6) in eight seasons even with those injuries than Derek Jeter (5) had in his entire career?

      Reply
  36. rct 2

    11 years ago

    As much as I would love Tulo, I sort of selfishly want to see the young pitchers stay with the Mets. Statistically speaking, all of them most likely will not work out. But just as a fan, I’m pretty eager to see a very cheap rotation of Harvey, Syndergaard, Wheeler, and deGrom. Toss in a guy like Matz in 2016 and I’m excited.

    I’m not as attached to Montero, and Niese and Gee have pretty much proven to be average. Seeing as it would take a lot more than any of these three (even if you added Plawecki and others), I’d probably pass on Tulo. He’s amazing (especially in his small sample at Citi), but the injuries have been piling up, he’s 30, and six more pretty expensive years seems like a lot. I’m thinking more as a fan than as a GM would, but I’d pass on Tulo if the asking price included Wheeler, Syndergaard, or deGrom.

    Reply
  37. MARLAHOOCH212

    11 years ago

    Please dont sign Tulo. Very injury prone, and way too expensive. Better off going after Starlin Castro.

    Reply
  38. Daniel Morairity

    11 years ago

    No way the Mets can pull this tulo trade with Colorado

    Reply
    • Danny Phillips

      11 years ago

      They can, but they shouldn’t.

      Reply
      • Daniel Morairity

        11 years ago

        Tulo might go to the Yankees since the Yankees have money

        Reply
        • petrie000

          11 years ago

          too bad money can’t pitch and that’s what Colorado badly needs right now.

          Reply
          • Daniel Morairity

            11 years ago

            Look if the Rockies want yo trade cargo and tulo the time is now

            Reply
            • petrie000

              11 years ago

              that’s true.

              Still doesn’t change the fact that Colorado badly needs pitching prospects to get out of last place anytime in the next few seasons.

              Yankees don’t have enough of them to make a trade happen, the Mets have them in spades.

              the money doesn’t factor in to it.

              Reply
              • Jimmy Willy

                11 years ago

                Money’s not the main factor but it can certainly play a role.

                Reply
                • petrie000

                  11 years ago

                  not really. Salary relief is pretty much a given no matter who acquires him. There’s probably 10-12 teams more than willing to take on Tulo’s full contract while still being able to offer a better trade package than the Yankees.

                  Reply
                  • Jimmy Willy

                    11 years ago

                    Highly doubt that. Don’t think the Mets would take all of Tulo’s salary. And most other teams can’t fit him into their budget.

                    Reply
  39. Cam

    11 years ago

    Tulo for a PTBNL – which has to be Michael Cuddyer.

    Reply
  40. Guest 3584

    11 years ago

    Red Sox, plese 🙁

    Reply
  41. Jonathan P.

    11 years ago

    Red Sox please 🙁

    Reply
  42. Longdistance O'S fan

    11 years ago

    The only place he can hit is in MILE HIGH and do not want anything to do with that contract

    Reply
  43. Kevin 18

    11 years ago

    If the Mets take that huge contract, it shouldn’t cost them more than one top pitcher (Snydergaard, Wheeler or de Grom) and one second level pitcher (Niese or Gee), maybe a piece with a contract (Murphy or Colon) and some lower prospects. With that contract it shouldn’t clean out their prospect pool, like a Stanton trade would.

    Reply
    • MetsEventually

      11 years ago

      It could cost Murphy and Syndergaard of they take on the entire contract

      Reply
  44. Dock_Elvis

    11 years ago

    Is there anyone left to answer the phone in the Colorado front office, or does it ring and ring when other teams call?

    Reply
  45. Dock_Elvis

    11 years ago

    They aren’t going after Tulo. I don’t think there’s enough management in Colorado to make that happen right without a circus of teams jumping in. Mets fans need to be looking Alexei Ramirez or Starlin Castro.

    Reply
  46. Tommy Med

    11 years ago

    I’d give up Thor for Tulo in a heartbeat. The mets also have Steve Matz who is under the radar because he missed time with Tommy John a couple years back but he may be their plbest overall pitcher in the minors. Thor may have upside but Tulo is a once in a generation talent. Yea is health is worrisome, but it’s worth the risk.

    Reply
  47. Joanie Yan

    11 years ago

    If the Mets weren’t willing to pay Reyes because of questions they had about him staying healthy, there’s no way they’ll pay Tulo. This is just hot air they are blowing on the same day they send out a mailer to fans about buying tickets for next season ( I received one).

    Reply
  48. Bob Smith

    11 years ago

    Just say no Mets! How will his numbers be impacted not playing at Coors? If I’m not mistaken (someone correct me if I am), his numbers aren’t nearly as impressive on the road. Add the price tag and the injury woes and he is not worth gutting the farm over.

    Reply
    • paqza

      11 years ago

      Actually, Tulowitzki is the best hitting shortstop in away games in the Majors since 2010. Hanley Ramírez is second. fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx?pos=ss&stats=bat&#…

      Reply
  49. MetsTalk5

    11 years ago

    The Rockies are dying to unload tulo. Who are they kidding? They will never be able to rebuild with his contract on the books. They will be lucky to get 1 top prospect and 75% of his remaining salary paid.

    Reply
  50. Terry Janiak

    11 years ago

    Rockies get: Wheeler and Syndagaard
    Mets get: Tulowitski and money

    Rockies finally fix their pitching problems with young cost controlled pitching. The Mets get the best shortstop and arguably the best player in the game. Rockies are one step closer to contention and the Mets are contenders and arguably NL east favorites and still have a deadly 1 2 punch with Harvey and Degrom

    Reply
    • stl_cards16

      11 years ago

      I’d be very interested to hear an argument that Tulowitzki is the best player in the game. I have a feeling if you really thought that, you would have spelled his name right.

      Reply
      • Terry Janiak

        11 years ago

        Tulo averages between 5-6WAR per season.

        Last 5 seasons:

        .340/.432/.603 25 hrs
        .312/.391/540 21hrs
        injured
        .302/.372/.544 30hrs
        .315/.381/.568 27hrs

        Reply
        • Terry Janiak

          11 years ago

          He is one of the best players in baseball.

          Reply
          • paqza

            11 years ago

            I’d put Trout, Stanton, and McCutchen ahead of this guy. Tulo’s more like Hanley – prodigious talent but made of glass.

            Reply
            • Terry Janiak

              11 years ago

              Stanton isn’t near Tulo in regards of what each player has done. Just compare their stats then come back to be. Has Stanton ever hit above .300? Besides 2014 has Stanton ever had a WAR over 5? Nope. These are things Tulo does annually

              Reply
              • paqza

                11 years ago

                Let’s agree to disagree. I agree Tulo has had the better career but we’re not talking about career – we’re talking about who the better player is.

                Reply
    • sfes

      11 years ago

      “Syndagaard”? That Noah’s rap name?

      Reply
      • Terry Janiak

        11 years ago

        yup

        Reply
  51. Jordan Torres

    11 years ago

    don’t want troy he not worth it go out and get castro

    Reply
  52. mike tyson

    11 years ago

    this might sound like a bad idea, but I suggest we trade niese, dillon gee, bartolo colon and maybe rafael montero for tulowitzki

    Reply
  53. mike tyson

    11 years ago

    i mean they’ll get 3 good pitchers and maybe and a upcoming pitcher in montero

    Reply
  54. Grebek7

    11 years ago

    White Sox need to be talking to Mets & Rockies, don’t know that we have enough trade bait though

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

    Top Stories

    Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony

    Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence

    Angels Acquire LaMonte Wade Jr.

    Braves Designate Craig Kimbrel For Assignment

    Corbin Burnes To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    Braves Select Craig Kimbrel

    Jerry Reinsdorf, Justin Ishbia Reach Agreement For Ishbia To Obtain Future Majority Stake In White Sox

    White Sox To Promote Kyle Teel

    Sign Up For Trade Rumors Front Office Now And Lock In Savings!

    Pablo Lopez To Miss Multiple Months With Teres Major Strain

    MLB To Propose Automatic Ball-Strike Challenge System For 2026

    Giants Designate LaMonte Wade Jr., Sign Dominic Smith

    Reds Sign Wade Miley, Place Hunter Greene On Injured List

    Padres Interested In Jarren Duran

    Royals Promote Jac Caglianone

    Mariners Promote Cole Young, Activate Bryce Miller

    2025-26 MLB Free Agent Power Rankings: May Edition

    Evan Phillips To Undergo Tommy John Surgery

    AJ Smith-Shawver Diagnosed With Torn UCL

    Reds Trade Alexis Díaz To Dodgers

    Recent

    Red Sox Promote Roman Anthony

    Mariners Designate Leody Taveras For Assignment, Outright Casey Lawrence

    Red Sox Designate Robert Stock For Assignment, Select Brian Van Belle

    Trade Rumors Front Office Subscriber Chat Transcript

    Rich Hill Has June 15 Opt-Out In Royals Deal

    AJ Smith-Shawver Undergoes Tommy John Surgery

    Poll: What Will The Rangers Do At The Deadline?

    Mets Select Justin Garza

    Submit Your Questions For This Week’s Episode Of The MLBTR Podcast

    Latest On Dodgers’ Rotation

    ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

    MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

    Latest Rumors & News

    Latest Rumors & News

    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Nolan Arenado Rumors
    • Dylan Cease Rumors
    • Luis Robert Rumors
    • Marcus Stroman Rumors

     

    Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

    MLBTR Features

    MLBTR Features

    • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
    • Front Office Originals
    • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
    • MLBTR Podcast
    • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
    • 2025 Arbitration Projections
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Extension Tracker
    • Agency Database
    • MLBTR On Twitter
    • MLBTR On Facebook
    • Team Facebook Pages
    • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors

    Rumors By Team

    • Angels Rumors
    • Astros Rumors
    • Athletics Rumors
    • Blue Jays Rumors
    • Braves Rumors
    • Brewers Rumors
    • Cardinals Rumors
    • Cubs Rumors
    • Diamondbacks Rumors
    • Dodgers Rumors
    • Giants Rumors
    • Guardians Rumors
    • Mariners Rumors
    • Marlins Rumors
    • Mets Rumors
    • Nationals Rumors
    • Orioles Rumors
    • Padres Rumors
    • Phillies Rumors
    • Pirates Rumors
    • Rangers Rumors
    • Rays Rumors
    • Red Sox Rumors
    • Reds Rumors
    • Rockies Rumors
    • Royals Rumors
    • Tigers Rumors
    • Twins Rumors
    • White Sox Rumors
    • Yankees Rumors

    ad: 160x600_MLB

    Navigation

    • Sitemap
    • Archives
    • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

    MLBTR INFO

    • Advertise
    • About
    • Commenting Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Connect

    • Contact Us
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • RSS Feed

    MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

    hide arrows scroll to top

    Register

    Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version