Over the coming days, MLBTR will look at next offseason’s option class. Steve Adams highlighted the players who can opt out of their current deals, while we’ll take a division-by-division look at those whose contracts contain either team or mutual options. Virtually all of the mutual options will be bought out by one side. Generally, if the team is willing to retain the player at the option price, the player will decline his end in search of a better free agent deal.
We started with a look at the NL West yesterday. While every team in that division had at least one player whose deal contained a club or mutual option, its American League counterpart only has two teams that are slated to have any option decisions.
Athletics
- None
Houston Astros
- None
Los Angeles Angels
- Kevin Newman, SS ($2.5MM club option, $250K buyout)
The Angels brought in Newman on a $2.75MM contract early last offseason. The contact-hitting infielder was coming off a solid .278/.311/.375 slash over 111 games in a utility role in Arizona. He added necessary shortstop depth with Zach Neto opening the season on the injured list after last fall’s shoulder surgery. Newman had a rough Spring Training, though, and the Angels went with minor league signee Tim Anderson as their primary shortstop until Neto’s return tonight.
Newman’s cold spring has carried into his early regular season work. He has managed three hits, all singles, without taking a walk in 23 trips to the plate. Newman has never walked much or hit for any kind of power, but he generally puts the ball in play and can move around the infield. Neto’s return means he won’t get much playing time at shortstop, while Kyren Paris and Luis Rengifo are respectively getting the majority of work at second and third base.
Note: José Quijada and Evan White each have club options on their respective contracts. They’ve both been outrighted off the 40-man roster and are very likely to be bought out. If they’re added back to the 40-man, the Angels would control both players via arbitration even if they decline the options.
Seattle Mariners
- Mitch Garver, DH ($12MM mutual option, $2MM buyout)
Garver’s two-year, $24MM contract remains the only multi-year deal that the Mariners have awarded to a free agent hitter under Jerry Dipoto’s leadership. It hasn’t gone well. While Garver’s injury history made that a somewhat risky investment, he looked like a good bet to hit whenever he was on the field. Garver was coming off a .270/.370/.500 showing for the Rangers during their World Series season, and he brought a career .252/.342/.483 batting line to T-Mobile Park.
The 34-year-old’s production tanked almost immediately. He managed a career-high 430 plate appearances last season, but it came with easily his worst rate stats in a full season. Garver hit .172/.286/.341 while striking out at a 31% rate. It wasn’t simply a product of Seattle’s pitcher-friendly park. His .186/.290/.324 line on the road wasn’t any better than his .153/.281/.363 showing at home. He doesn’t look to be on the verge of a rebound. Garver has begun this season with four singles, six walks, and zero extra-base hits across 34 trips to the plate.
- Andrés Muñoz, RHP ($6MM club option)
The Mariners worked out an extension with the hard-throwing Muñoz during the 2021-22 offseason. He’d made all of one appearance in a Seattle uniform at the time. Muñoz had undergone Tommy John surgery while a member of the Padres in 2020. Seattle acquired him early in the rehab process. They believed he’d blossom into a late-game weapon. They were right.
Muñoz has rattled off three straight sub-3.00 ERA seasons since signing his extension. He has begun this year with 10 scoreless innings, recording 13 strikeouts with an AL-leading seven saves. He carries a 2.35 earned run average with a huge 34.7% strikeout rate over 184 frames in a Seattle uniform. This has quickly become one of the most team-friendly contracts in the game.
The option is essentially a lock unless he suffers a significant injury that’d cost him all of next season. The team has respective $8MM and $10MM options for 2027 and ’28, so they could keep him at below-market rates for three years. Next season’s option has a $6MM base value. It’d climb by $250K apiece if Muñoz finishes 20, 30, 40 and 45 games this year. He’s already at eight games finished and should get to 45 by season’s end. The option price will probably end up at $7MM, but it’s an easy call for the front office.
- Jorge Polanco, 3B ($8MM mutual option, $750K buyout)
Polanco’s option begins as an $8MM mutual provision, but he can convert it to a player option if he hits a vesting threshold. If he reaches 450 plate appearances this season and avoids a lower half injury that’d require him to begin next season on the injured list — which is protection for the team given his recent knee concerns — it’d become a $6MM player option. Getting to 550 plate appearances this year would push the player option price to $8MM.
If Polanco does not hit the vesting threshold, it’d remain an $8MM mutual option with a $750K buyout. He has been dinged up by knee and side discomfort that has limited him but not prevented him from playing. The switch-hitting Polanco is currently unable to play the infield or hit right-handed in games. He’s a lefty-swinging designated hitter for now. Yet he’s been on such a tear that the Mariners will happily live with the limitations.
Polanco has connected on three homers and a pair of doubles through 13 games. He’s hitting .378. That not only leads the team but ranks sixth in the majors among hitters with at least 40 plate appearances. He’s obviously not going to keep up this pace, but Polanco was fairly consistently an above-average hitter during his run as Minnesota’s second baseman. The Mariners felt that last year’s career-worst production was attributable to the knee injury through which he played a good chunk of the season. Polanco has done his best to prove that right so far.
Texas Rangers
- None
*Sacramento Athletics
The No City A’s
*West Sacramento
I don’t know why they aren’t willing to be associated at all with Sacramento, the city is doing them a service letting them play there temporarily
Exactly. And Sacramento has direct flights to Las Vegas.
Try to build some good will and add some fans while you’re there.
Sacramento has direct flights to Las Vegas?!?! No way… You’d be hard pressed to find an airport in the United States that does NOT have multiple direct flights to Vegas.
Newman has been abysmal here. It’s like having a pitcher hit.
At this point Angels fans would kick into a go fund me to raise $250k just to not see him take another at bat.
The A’s need to figure out a way to get Kurtz in the lineup with Soderstrom and Rooker.
Not sure why the Ms resigned Jorge Polanco.
They weren’t willing to spend much money and were desperate for bats (and a 3b).
Polanco’s hitting thus far, but the 3b….
I think they were right to gamble that 2024 was the worst of his career and that 2025 would be a bounce back. Seemed like a no brainer reunion. He was never going to command a long commitment to re-acquire.
GHarris: Surely this is an attempt at humor? The M’s signed Polanco because up until his signing they had question marks at every INF position except SS. Their INF plan pre-Polanco was to have Donovan Solano (who’s been utter rubbish,) platoon 1B with a former RFer with very little experience at 1B position – Luke Raley. They were also planning on a Platoon at 3B between D Solano and Utility Player Dylan Moore. A Rookie with about 25g MLB experience (R Bliss) at 2B with an emergency backup plan at 2B of D Moore and/or Myles Mastrobouni in case Bliss didn’t work out.
So……when you think about that INF with SS JP Crawford coming off a career worst year, Solano, Mastrobouni, a Rookie and 2 extreme Platoon players …….Polanco was a luxury signing! And like the article states- has literally been the M’s best player
Mariners did well when they acquired Muñoz from the Padres He has blossomed into a dominant closer, and the Mariners’ early bet on him when he was an unproven risk has yielded a contract that’s among the most cost-effective in baseball.