Diamondbacks right-hander Corbin Burnes is battling inflammation in his right shoulder, as reported by Nick Piecoro of The Arizona Republic. Piercoro adds that Arizona intends to scratch Burnes from his next start. It’s unclear whether or not he’ll ultimately require a stint on the injured list due to the issue, though Piecoro relays that manager Torey Lovullo told reporters before today’s game that they remain hopeful he’ll be back on the mound after just one missed start. The manager suggests that Burnes has been nagged by fatigue in his shoulder going back his last couple of starts, and that led to the club sending him for an MRI back in Arizona.
That MRI revealed “a little bit” of inflammation in Lovullo’s words, leading to the decision to skip the right-hander’s next start. Even as the Diamondbacks remain optimistic that Burnes will miss just one outing, the news is worrying for fans in the desert. After all, Arizona has fallen to fourth place in a hyper-competitive NL West division despite their solid enough 17-15 record. That record leaves them on the outside looking in for an NL Wild Card spot, behind the Padres, Giants, Phillies, and Reds in the standings aside from the division-leading Dodgers, Cubs, and Mets.
That lackluster pitching is a big reason for that middling record. While Arizona’s offense has been phenomenal so far, their run prevention has left something to be desired despite being a major strength on paper. The starting five’s 4.27 ERA is a bottom-ten figure in baseball this year, and Brandon Pfaadt is the only pitcher in the mix who has met expectations with a dazzling 2.78 ERA across six starts. Zac Gallen, Merrill Kelly, and especially Eduardo Rodriguez have all struggled so far this year.
Burnes, meanwhile, has a decent enough ERA of 3.58 that clocks in 18% better than league average by ERA+. That’s not quite what the Diamondbacks had in mind when they signed him to a six-year, $210MM deal over the winter, however, and his peripherals tell a more alarming story. His pedestrian 20.0% strikeout rate is the lowest of his career, and he’s paired it with a hefty 12.1% walk rate after having reliably excellent command in recent years. Burnes’s 5.08 FIP, 5.31 xERA, and 4.61 SIERA are all very worrisome, and suggest that even his mid-rotation production to this point in the year isn’t sustainable.
Perhaps this inflammation that he’s been battling is at least part of the explanation for the righty’s struggles. The 30-year-old hurler has made at least 32 starts in each of the past three seasons, and while that durability is admirable it’s the nature of pitching in this current era of baseball that hurlers need more rest than ever before as they push themselves for higher velocity and maximum spin efficiency. Perhaps this breather will be enough to calm the inflammation and get Burnes back on track, which would surely be a relief for Arizona as they fight to force their way back into the NL playoff picture after their surprising World Series run in 2023 and narrowly missing out on October last year.
Whether the inflammation forces Burnes to sit down for just one start or requires a stint on the injured list, the Diamondbacks are reasonably well-equipped to handle his absence even after losing sixth starter Jordan Montgomery to Tommy John surgery earlier this year. Ryne Nelson is in the bullpen as a long reliever but threw 68 pitches his last time out and is stretched out enough for a spot start or even to slide into the rotation longer-term as needed. He appears to be the most likely candidate to replace Burnes, though hurlers like Tommy Henry and Cristian Mena are also on the 40-man roster as potential depth options.
He was regressing before he joined the diamondbacks
And as for his dismal peripherals in 2025, I wonder if even in SSSs there’s a correlation between guys with good control and K::BB rates whose control goes blooey, and going under the knife?
OTOH he had a similar BB rate in 6 starts fr May 5–June 2, 2023, with a 5.03 FIP, and still ended up 8th in the Cy voting.
Though OTOOH Burnes was still K’ing more than 9 per 9 that year, so who knows?
And if he weren’t he would have gotten even more money. He got as much as he did because he is still very valuable and “only” got 6 years. There are only ever a small amount of very good pitchers to sign so you have to overpay. Aaron Nola got 170m after a 4.46 era season. It’s because of consistency of nearly 200IP partially. But here we see the constant risk with any pitcher.
Reminder that regression is a statistical concept. What you mean here is decline.
Last season, Ranger Suarez regressed after his hot first half. (Not a perfect example since injury played a role)
Walker Buehler has declined over the last few years.
A+ Brad. That’s a tight spiral.
Tight BH Brad.
funny, all the Orioles fans that use him as the poster child for their armchair GMing are eeriely quiet on this thread.
“the reason the O’s are sucking eggs this year is bc they were “too cheap” to pony up for Burnes.”
that and they are 25th in team offense
agreed. but they’re scared to blame the young bats for being limp. so BAL fans like to just go to the starters. last night with Sugano was a great example that they’re starters can be economical on their pitch count, give the team a chance deep into the game, not tax the pen and still… bring shut out is totally not on the starter. it’s also muscle memory to say the Orioles’s owner is cheap. that worthless guy is gone and back to Nashville.
I said at the time that it was alarming how few Oriole fans knew his stats.
@Atl
Wow, your post is so true, esp with the start of this season. I agree with about 5% of the rants. and I generally am pretty patient when people are hurting. but they are out of their minds. BE A FAN, that doesn’t mean being blind to the faults but NOR does it mean that you trash you own club and throw around smug, uninformed attacks, esp when it includes calling a player a “bum”.
I’m a Os fan of more than 60 years and am more than willing to say that the fan base, as a whole, is awful (some exception). The social media channels (blogs and Reddit) are so toxic that anyone even slightly prone to statistical or fact based arguments just gives up. Elias may have the right owner, but he has the wrong fan base.
Probably has something to do with being on the Orioles last year!🤣
He dropped off in the second half. Helen Keller would have known something was wrong.
Zack Greinke 2.0 signing.
If this turns out to be a Greinke 2.0 signing then I am quite happy.
I don’t know why. Gave up 3 more runs a game after signing with you.
Well yeah when he was coming off of a year where he had a 1 ERA, you sure can make it sound negative that he “gave up 4 more runs a game”. His first year there he had a 4, but the next 2 it was a 3 and the 4th it was was 2 for the 25 starts he made that year.
If you don’t think that 4 years of a 3.30 ERA, over 700 innings, 30 starts a year. 680 Ks with less than 150 BBs, 17 WAR (right there with the WAR he provided with the Dodgers) you might not have a clue what you are talking about with baseball.
A Zack Greinke 2.0 signing is OK. It is a Madison Bumgarner 2.0 signing that the Diamondbacks want to avoid.
Are you saying that’s a bad thing? Greinkie had a 131 ERA+ and regularly tossed 200 innings a season with the D-Backs.
See the Orioles likely just avoided an albatross contract. Elias smartest one in the room after all, (just please ignore the standings). And hey at least Trevor Rogers only cost them two prospects (suspects) and no onerous contracts.
One of the “suspects” is Top 10 in MLB in RBI and OPS. The other was the Marlins 2024 MVP after the trade. The bar is low with the Marlins, but they won the trade.
Rogers is only controlled thru 2026. He’s going to need a heck of a season to justify the trade. And I am not a Norby or Stowers fan.
And that’s why I said that Elias made a uniquely odd decision to trade for “possible” short term benefits and should never do it again. Generating ad hominum social media attacks from Os fans. The loudest voices on Os social media are uniquely toxic.
Come back, Zack. Get those 21 Ks.
I wouldn’t be too optimistic about Tommy Henry. That career ERA in MLB of 5.11 is entirely deserved. As for Ryne Nelson, he hasn’t been even that good in AAA for his career.
The ‘backs would appear to be in some trouble. .
Nelson has a 5.19 ERA at Triple-A, which is actually prett good for the PCL.
Ryne Nelson was their best starter in the second half of last season. Arizona is one of the few teams that has enough starting pitching depth to weather a few injuries like this. Ryne would have made the opening day rotation on pretty much every other MLB team.
Shoulder inflammation is the flavor of the week for pitcher injuries….
The problem with the type of shoulder injuries you get from throwing is they don’t usually show up on MRIs very well. So you have someone like Reynaldo Lopez going on the IL multiple times before he actually has surgery. So the diagnosis always leaves room for uncertainty.
Ryan Nelson was one of the best SPs in MLB the back half of ’24 so he may surprise some people.
Be original at least
It is quite a coincidence that Burnes, Bradish, Rodriguez, Means, and Wells are injured in some way. Or is it? All were starting pitchers for the Orioles during the spring in 2024. Now, we can add Eflin, Suarez, Rogers, and McDermott to injured list. Only Dean Kremer has avoided this.
“quite a coincidence..injured in some way”…First people blame the Rays for pitching injuries. Then, it’s the Dodgers who are ruining pitchers. And you clearly blame the Orioles.
When will people learn that pitching is a risky proposition and that injury is virtually guaranteed in that occupation?
There is a reason that virtually all baseball teams are seeking “depth” practically all 7 days of the week throughout the season.
I knew it! The Dodgers played the Orioles 3 times in August 2024. Obviously they caught the injury bug from the O’s.
No blaming. Just interesting. Correlation is not Causation.
Facetiousness is not Fact.
Rumor is not research
A rain delay is boring. Dodgers Braves now rumored to be starting at 10:15 ET. I have done my research.
Only if he knew how to throw a football slider..
Don’t say his name 3 times or he might appear and desecrate the thread!
Posey may have made a smart move not pursuing Burnes & potential long term contract
Yeah but then you have to face the fact of Willy Adames.
Willy has been great. Sure, needs to improve the numbers but what he has brought outside of that has been phenomenal. Very happy with the smarts in the Adames move.
Well Adames is below replacement level -.6 WAR with diminished fielding metrics from last season which in itself was a big cratering from his 2023 numbers. I hope he completely rebounds, he still has youth on his side. No reason to write him off of course. I am happy about Robbie Ray, loved his last start. He’s a good dude, I hope he excels for the Giants.
The poor numbers make the attitude and vibe he has bought more noteworthy. Impressive stuff. I don’t think anybody inside Giants Inc. would become having second thoughts.
It’s been barely more than a month of baseball. You can’t start judging a dude by his numbers.
They’re ~20% of the way through the season and he’s been awful. Not just bad, awful. Out of 163 qualified players, he’s tied for 13th worst by fWar.
well it’s also a coincidence that they’re all pitchers. I think we should investigate the Orioles’ pitching coaches for their negative impact on the Dodgers and Yankees too. it’s all their fault.
When a pitcher like Corbin Burnes struggles to find a feel for a pitch especially if it’s not the one he’s known for that’s a warning sign.
The Football Slider should be his putaway pitch and it’s what helped him become very successful.
It’s still early, but his K/9 has dropped from 13.3 to 12.6 to 10.8 to 9.3 to 8.4. You seldom see pitchers with 4 consecutive drops in the K-rate.
To me, the bigger concern about the DBacks is the number and type of early season injuries. Coincidence? Insufficient conditioning? Age? The team needs to investigate this trend and respond with some appropriate changes.
AZ has had relatively few injuries. Marte missed a month, but he is not exactly a kid. Puk is out, but he’s had a long injury history. They still have not missed a start out of their rotation, and that’s generally the biggest injury concern.
I think it’s kind of sad that here we are in very early May and the story says the DBacks are on the outside looking in for a wild card spot…this is going to change SO much before September 1st when it really matters.
Teams are still trying to figure out what they have
Ooooosh. They have a weird track record of big SP FA to just totally bomb for them.
Bumgarner, Greinke, Montgomery and then Burnes would be 4 pretty rough ones. They seem to miss on big FA a lot but nail trades.
Russ Ortiz too
“Meanwhile” has to start the sentence, not come in the middle between commas.