A trio of Cardinals underwent surgical procedures in recent weeks, the team announced Friday. Lars Nootbaar had surgery on both heels, and Brendan Donovan underwent a sports hernia repair on October 7. Ivan Herrera had surgery on his elbow to remove bone spurring on Oct. 15. John Denton of MLB.com was among those to report that Nootbaar’s procedure was to shave down Haglund’s deformities. Derrick Goold of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch was among those to note that the recovery timetables are uncertain.
Nootbaar is coming off his healthiest big-league season. The 28-year-old played a career-high 135 games and topped 500 plate appearances for just the second time. Nootbaar missed a few weeks at the end of July with a rib injury, but that was his only IL stint. He was also sidelined for a brief stretch in August with a knee issue.
While Nootbaar stayed on the field in 2025, he struggled to produce at the plate. He slashed an underwhelming .234/.325/.361, resulting in a career-low 96 wRC+. Nootbaar maintained his solid plate discipline numbers, but he fell off significantly in the power department. His .361 SLG was a career-worst by more than 50 points, and his .128 ISO was unbefitting of a corner outfielder.
Nootbaar is arbitration-eligible this offseason. MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projected him for a $5.7MM salary.
Donovan dealt with multiple injuries in 2025, with a groin strain in August costing him the most time. He initially tried to play through the injury, but eventually landed on the IL. Donovan appeared in just eight games over the final few weeks of the regular season.
The injuries capped what was shaping up to be a career season for Donovan. He hit .329 through May, before a turf toe issue popped up. Donovan earned a trip to the All-Star game and still had an OPS near .800 heading into the break. His numbers trailed off from there, but the final line was strong. Donovan finished with career-best marks in batting average and slugging percentage to go with an excellent 119 wRC+.
Donovan is also heading to arbitration. Swartz projected him for a $5.4MM salary, just behind Nootbaar.
Herrera battled several injuries himself this season, though the elbow issue is his first of the upper-body variety. He missed most of April with knee inflammation, then a hamstring strain cost him three more weeks in the summer.
A three-homer game put Herrera on the map in the first week of the season. He piled up 11 RBI in the Cardinals’ first seven games. Herrera continued to mash after the knee injury, maintaining an OPS over .900 before the hamstring injury. He scuffled in July and August, but bounced back with a massive September. Herrera wrapped up his first full big-league season with a strong .284/.373/.464 slash line. He’s been a standout at the plate whenever given the opportunity. He even saw some outfield reps this past season as St. Louis tried to find ways to get him in the lineup.
The Cardinals have several options behind the plate, which made it easier for Herrera to spend the majority of his time at DH. A potential trade could clear out some of that depth, but Herrera should find regular at-bats in the Cardinals’ lineup next year, whether at catcher or DH.
“So if we can get all three procedures done within a few hours, you’ll only charge us once for the operating room?”
Hey the economy is getting rough. Gotta find discounts wherever you can.
“Yes, sir. October 15th is also the first day of reporting to the surgical assembly line for our interns.”
“Get your surgery, here! Two for one sale!”
“Buy two, get one free!!!”
Cards aren’t going to offer Lars nootbar a contract and replace him with a snickersbar.
“Break me off a piece of that Noot Noot bar.”
Or Admiral Ackbar. “It’s a catch!”
There was a report a few weeks ago that the Herrera surgery seems to be at the heart of the Cardinals moving him back to catcher, with the team believing the bone spurs were a huge part of his throwing issue.
Jokes aside… Speedy recovery to these three!
The Surgeon General has determined that playing baseball for the St. Louis Cardinals can be hazardous to your health.
Baseball in general is hazardous to your health. I’m playing softball nowadays and after each weekend I have a new pain in a leg, foot, arm, shoulder. Maybe I should do some pickleball instead.
Anyone who understands the game knows that a season is grueling on the body. In the past we were not likely to be informed of every surgery required by the players. But now is the time to have them. Hopefully they will not have any repercussions from them.
The Nootbar situation sounds gnarly. A little AI search and, yeah, gnarly.
These guys spend mid February through October playing then many of them spend the winter recovering and rehabbing enough to do it all again.
Im surprised Noot is projected to make more than Donnie.