Mike Shildt’s decision to step down as San Diego’s manager opens an eighth vacancy around the game. Cubs bench coach Ryan Flaherty could be in the mix for at least a couple of those positions.
Joel Sherman of The New York Post listed Flaherty and Padres pitching coach Ruben Niebla among those to keep an eye on as potential options to replace Shildt. Meanwhile, The Post’s Jon Heyman writes that Flaherty could be among the top choices for the Orioles position. (Heyman adds that Baltimore still hasn’t closed the door on giving the full-time job to Tony Mansolino, who held the role on an interim basis after Brandon Hyde was fired in May.)
Neither Flaherty nor Niebla is confirmed to have scheduled an interview. The Padres are surely in the very early stages of the process. Kevin Acee of The San Diego Union-Tribune reported that Shildt informed the team he was stepping down on Saturday.
Flaherty has ties to both the Padres and Orioles. He spent the majority of his playing career with the O’s, appearing in six seasons between 2012-17. Even though neither owner David Rubenstein nor president of baseball operations Mike Elias were part of the organization at that time, Flaherty surely has some connections to the club.
He’s also a known commodity to the San Diego front office. The 39-year-old began his coaching career with the Padres and quickly worked his way up to bench coach. He and Shildt were the top internal candidates for the managerial job after the Friars parted ways with Bob Melvin two years ago. Flaherty interviewed but was granted permission to explore other opportunities once the Padres hired Shildt. He took the bench coach role under Craig Counsell in Chicago, a job he has held for the past two seasons.
Niebla, 53, has built a reputation as one of the sport’s top pitching coaches. He was an assistant in Cleveland until landing the pitching coach job with San Diego over the 2021-22 offseason. His hiring came a few days before the Padres tabbed Melvin, and he has held the role under a pair of managers. The Friars signed Niebla to a multi-year extension last offseason.
It’s not all that common for pitching coaches to jump into managerial roles. The bench coach position is typically more of a springboard to the top gig. Still, that’s not entirely unheard of — former Cincinnati manager Bryan Price was a pitching coach both before and after his managerial stint, as one example — and the Padres’ front office clearly values Niebla’s work with the pitching staff.

I don’t think the Padres could do better than Shildt.
Of course they can
Name Manny player/manager. Now he’s like Ohtani! Two roles for one paycheck. What could go wrong?
David Ross might be a good fit in San Diego…
That being said, I find it amusing that Craig Counsel is sitting in his recliner— eating popcorn— while watching the Brewers play for a National League Championship!!!
Counsel jumped ship from the Brewers — in the middle of the night —- for more money in Chicago!!! Yet the Brewer kept on Truckin’ without him!!!
I love it when people do things like that and their actions blows up in their Face!!!
Blew up in his face, and his bank. You realize it’s his job, and he was offered more money for a lateral move.
Would you give up $1 million if Milwaukee wins the WS? Your money, not his. No, you wouldn’t.
Would you stay at your job if you were offered twice as much to do the same job elsewhere? It’s called a business decision.
The reason alot of Brewer fans are upset is because he never gave Attanasio a chance to counter the Cubs offer. Given some of what Counsell said afterwards, it seems like money wasnt the only factor. With Stearns leaving, on the heels of a Hader trade he was against, it seems like he wanted out
So the Cubs being knocked out by the Brewers in 2025 is your basis for his decision “blowing up” on his face?
I hope Craig takes a more lifelong overall view of things.
Of course it’s ironic but it’s just 1 year and one series out of a lifetime.
I’ll bet it bothered him until he woke up the next day!
I guess you’re not counting on Musgrove to provide anything? Darvish neither? (I’m not expecting much from Yu but he’ll make some starts at least)
Sounds like moves a former Kevin Towers would make lol
Wow, you’re really shooting for the moon there, 69th rounder. I bet your parents loved your “Dear Santa, for Christmas I would like…” letters. Cheap date.
Jibber Jabber
Eight openings for manager? What’s the record for an offseason?
Why replace Matsui? The Pads are going to be paying him no matter what. Might as well let him continue as the low leverage guy.
@69th Rounder
Sears has hardly cemented the idea he’d be a better option than Matsui in his work for the Padres thus far.
Preller can’t go back in time and uncontract Matsui. Might as well let him soak up garbage time innings and see if he can improve. Someone’s gotta pitch in garbage time. Might as well be the guy you’re paying.
Roster spots are valuable but there are different ways to utilize the value.
Last RP in pen is garbage time.
Last bench guy is utilized very rarely and most of the time , just to get him some AB’s.
Teams use these spots with cheap options; or with a player that is out of options and they would lose him and many other ways – not just the best guy available.
And AJ survives again …
I think niebla has a real shot at getting the job. He is very well respected by the players. Every time they add a new pitcher the players are on record telling them to listen to Niebla.
He would be respected by the players.
Niebla has embraced analytics as well.
While there isn’t the track record with pitching coaches being managers like there is with catchers. I think if anyone can do it, Niebla would be able to. It also allows some stability within given he has been with the padres for years now.
He would need to find a replacement which they could just promote the one coach who is also highly respected.
Then working with Preller to locate the correct offensive philosophy and coaches that can get the most out of the offense.
I’d actually be surprised if anyone else got the job over Niebla.
Could be right there
Why not Scott Servais? He is currently working with the Padres. He did a nice job with the Mariners. He is a good guy with a consistent demeanor. I thought that the Mariners had a good clubhouse under his leadership and they went to the playoffs for the first time in over twenty years under his guidance.
I actually like Servais for the Baltimore job if they don’t go for a bigger name guy. I don’t think Flaherty is the answer at either place right now.
I’d prefer Ross to Servais but agree that Flaherty needs a little more experience before he’s ready to manage a team hoping to immediately make a deep run. But I feel that he will get his chance.
David Ross deserves another shot at managing. Not sure if that’s with the Padres, but I think he’ll get his shot with one of the many managerial openings.
I’m sure Preller will be making moves to field another competitive team for 2026, the man has done a nice job in my opinion.
O’s fan here. I’d love to have Buck Showalter’s favoritest utility player ever, Ryan “Flats” Flaherty managing next year. That guy made a lot with his playing career by being a cerebral player despite some shortcomings talent-wise. It would have been nice to have his career stats linked up here. I like Mansolino, but the O’s couldn’t ask for a better guy to manage this young club.
And Padres fans, you definitely want to add Ryan O’Hearn, but you already know that. I loved his grind it out style at the plate, he’s a vocal leader and that swing is a beast. I miss him as an Oriole. From a Royals cast-off to a sweet 2026 paycheck. Great story.
Flaherty fits the bill as a figurehead who can carry out orders from the front office genius.
I’m wouldn’t want him to derail his career being labeled a bobble head for the FO/POBO. I think he’ll likely be a good manager one day but without more experience, it might be hard for him to find his voice against a headstrong POBO.
Please hire Niebla just so we don’t have to watch him walk to the mound every inning.
As another Orioles fan, I don’t see Flaherty as the answer. I think we need someone who has good management experience, especially in the postseason. I would rather see Britton if they are going to go with a first time MLB manager.
How about Scott Servais or Lloyd McClendon?
I like the idea of Servais. I actually responded to another comment about him and said I think he’d be a good fit!
They have to do whatever it takes to keep Niebla. Offer him the manager role or make him the highest-paid pitching coach. They need another manager with an edge; I don’t care for Servais. I don’t follow the Mariners that closely, but this is a clubhouse with some big personalities, and I don’t want a manager who had a 10-game lead evaporate in 24 games (!) If Pujols or Molina weren’t tied so closely to Anaheim and St. Louis openings, I would go hard after them.
Straight – Niebla is under contract as pitching coach so he isn’t going anywhere – well, unless he retires.
No Musgrove or Darvish?
I’d rather have Josh Naylor. I’d rather have Campy and his potential bat catching 50 games than Hedges as backup.
You do know that SD traded for a starting C that can hit and plays pretty good D at the deadline with 4 years of control, right?
$40MM for Pat Murphy!
Most interesting aspect of what Craig did was he shifted the pay scale of managers collectively. Now with all these old dogs retiring. Who is getting paid this time?