Nov. 10: The Giants formally announced Bochy’s hiring as a special assistant to the baseball operations department.
“Having Boch back in the organization means a great deal to all of us,” Posey said within this morning’s press release. “His experience, leadership, and feel for the game are unmatched, and his perspective will be invaluable as we continue building towards sustained success.”
Nov. 5: Bruce Bochy is nearing a deal to return to the Giants in an advisory role. CEO Greg Johnson first told Susan Slusser of The San Francisco Chronicle on Tuesday that the sides were working on a deal. Bochy confirmed to Andrew Baggarly of The Athletic this evening that he’s in the process of finalizing a special assistant position. He’ll be on hand as an excellent resource for first-year manager Tony Vitello. Bochy will join another future Hall of Fame manager, Dusty Baker, as special assistants in San Francisco.
The 70-year-old Bochy has spent the past three seasons managing the Rangers. He led Texas to a World Series in 2023, the fourth title of his career. Bochy famously led the Giants to three World Series in a five-year span between 2010-14. President of baseball operations Buster Posey was a face of the franchise for most of Bochy’s 13 seasons at the helm. Only Hall of Famer John McGraw, who managed for 31 years between 1902-32 when the team was still in New York, has won more games in Giants’ history.
This might close the book on Bochy’s managerial career. “I would say that’s where I’m at right now,” he told Baggarly when asked if he expects that his stint with the Rangers would be his last one in the dugout. “I’ll add you don’t ever rule anything out. You don’t, you know? But I’m content with what I’m doing now. … This is what I want to do. I want more time for myself and family but also to contribute to a game that I love.”
Bochy is sixth all-time with 2,252 managerial wins between his stints with the Padres, Giants and Rangers. He and Baker are the only two skippers within the top 10 who have not been inducted into the Hall of Fame. That’s only because both men were managing within the past couple seasons. It’s a matter of time before they’re in Cooperstown. (The same is true for Terry Francona, who is 12th on the all-time list and now the winningest active manager with Bochy back in an advisory role.)
Managers are only inducted into Cooperstown via the Era Committees. Managers who are 65 and older are eligible for Hall of Fame consideration six months after they retire. Baker and Bochy would only be up for consideration by the Contemporary Baseball Era Non-Players Committee. That’ll come up during the 2026-27 offseason. Baker should get into the Hall next winter. Bochy could be eligible for that cycle if he officially retires within the next few months, but it seems he prefers not to shut the door entirely just yet.
There’s also some news on Vitello’s coaching staff. Baggarly reports that Twins bench coach Jayce Tingler has agreed to join the San Francisco staff in some capacity. He’ll bring a decent amount of experience, as he managed the Padres between 2020-21 and had been Rocco Baldelli’s top lieutenant in Minnesota for the last four years. The Twins fired Baldelli and hired Derek Shelton to manage, so it’s not surprising there’ll be some coaching turnover. Tingler and Vitello go back more than two decades. They were teammates at the University of Missouri in the early 2000s.

As long as he is not making me wince every step he takes to the mound. Watching him used to kill me. Poor dude.
No idea on the level of input special assts provide but old heads in and around sounds logical to me.
these special advisor roles are just so these old timers can keep collecting a check in addition to their social security, holding back the young hungry hotshots within the org from getting their chance. step aside and allow for the next generation an opportunity at building their careers.
The manager is a young hungry hotshot with no mlb experience. You really believe they are just cutting him a paycheck for nostalgia reasons ?
He’s waiting in the wings just in case. If I’m the manager, I’m feeling his shadow.
These special advisor roles are given to the old heads as a move to show respect and open the door for advice when needed. The Giants treat their former players and staff well, keeping them in the family and this is another way to keep Bochy close to the team m, and give Vitello a resource where he needs it. You don’t need to have weekly 1:1s but I hope Vitello uses Bochy as a trusted resource who can help him manage the Major League season, the players, and opens the door to someone who gave them championships.
Zaidi didn’t want any reminders of past teams, players or even things on the wall (which he had taken down). Zaidi didn’t even want past players to participate in Giants celebrations. Everything was about Zaidi
Posey believes in family, tradition & winning. He’s already shown there’s tremendous value & knowledge that former Giants & HOFs have to offer
Glad Posey, Minasian & Vitello are taking their time in hiring the right coaching staff to make the Giants successful
Also feel certain Posey will bring in the right players (right fit & who truly want to be Giants) to move the Giants forward
Don’t read my opinion below as a negative because it is not. Just my experience being married to someone whose entire family are big time Giants fans, while they are more of a second team to me.
Giants fans lap up nostalgia. They live for the constant references to past players (Forever Giants) and success. Most fans do, but the Giants take it to the Nth degree. I have watched plenty of their live broadcasts during the past 11 seasons. There’s plenty of nostalgia to be had when your broadcast team has 100+ years of collective broadcasting experience. Nostalgia has become a brand for the Giants. Have to admit even hard-core fans find it annoying/irritating at times when live play calling takes a back seat.
Point being, Bochy coming back makes perfect sense if only for the nostalgia.
If you think Giants fans are super extreme nostalgia addicts, you haven’t met a Mariners fan. Folks up here still bring up Edgar’s game 5 double.
It’s not just collecting a check dude, I’m sure they’re getting by just fine with the big fat pension they’re collecting. They do it for the love of the game
They don’t need pensions after making millions
“They don’t need pensions”..Plus endorsements and hundreds of free meals, hotels, etc
Some people here don’t understand the thinking or motivations of millionaires and billionaires.
They rarely do things only for sentimental or “nostalgic” purposes.
@Blah Bochy and Dusty both have a lot to contribute. Just what Vitello needs to be successful-like training wheels while he sorts out pro milieu and culture.
You think there are “young hungry hotshots” that are being held back from being special advisors? The position is usually specifically created for retired players and coaches to perpetuate organizational culture while retaining their knowledge from years of experience so that the younger guys have an opportunity to learn from them. “Young hotshots” aren’t chomping at the bit for such a niche and probably part time position.
Posey isn’t even 40 yet, and Vitello has zero experience in pro ball. They can add Bochy’s decades of baseball/managerial experience to that.
@blah
The dude took 3 different teams to a world series, winning 4 out of 5 times.
He’s forgotten more baseball than you’ll ever learn.
“Young hungry hotshots… getting their chance.” Wasn’t that a subplot of Top Gun: Maverick?
Aloha folks, much respect for Bochy and his tenure as a Giants manager. Nice to see him come back and team up with an ole pupil, Posey! Mahalo!
Padres really burned that bridge when they canned him.
Fact Check Fail: Bruce Bochy was not fired by the Padres; rather, he left to manage the San Francisco Giants after the 2006 season because the Padres’ new CEO, Sandy Alderson, wanted a younger manager and allowed him to explore other options. Bochy had a year remaining on his contract with the Padres, but the Giants offered him a more secure three-year deal.
To be fair, Bochy managed the Padres during many of their “dog years”
when Ownership was reluctant to open up the company checkbooks to spend money to retain players and on free agents
When the Padres Ownership committed to winning like in 1998 with John Moores as Owner, Larry Lucchino as Pres of Baseball Ops, Kevin Towers as GM, Bochy was Manager and won the NL pennant with the Padres. Dr Charles Sterberg, Theo Epstein and others were trainees in the marketing and communications in the Front Office at that time. They, then received promotions in the Padres Front Office while working their way up.
Add more wood to the fire. As if the Bochy Curse on San Francisco when playing against San Diego has been running low on fuel.
Advisor and Backup manager if they have to break glass in case of emergency.
I do think the new manager will do well in game and clubhouse.
The advisors are going to be helpful with navigating the off field duties of a major league manager. Which I think is the hardest part for an inexperienced MLB manager.
This is a brilliant move. He codifies the changes there in dugout management with tenure and a backdrop of decades in experience as a voice of dissension if things go awry.
I’m probably the only SF fan who doesn’t like this move. The Giants have a great legacy, but sometimes that legacy hinders them from moving forward. The last thing Vitello wants is someone looking over his shoulder. He isn’t a kid who’s never managed before. I wish they had just moved on from Bochy and kept things fresh. What’s next, Johnnie LeMaster as hitting coach?!
I’ll bet you wouldn’t mind one Barry Lamar Bonds coming back as a hitting coach tho.
You’re right, I wouldn’t.
It’s an advisory role. Nobody knows the scope of Bochy’s authority if any. He could be assisting with the draft to the buffet spread choices for all we know.
Bochy gonna teach the newbies how to pound beers after the games.
Suppose Bochy would come in handy if/when a veteran like Chapman, Adames, Ray or Devers tells Vitello to “FO rook.”
He’s not some 20-something rookie, he won the damn national championship last year. He’s not learning on the job. Some differences, but it’s still high caliber baseball. None of those players would disrespect him like that.
Bullpen Tutor for sure.
Isn’t Posey the one that fired Bochy?
No.
Welcome back Bochy. You’re truly a Forever Giant
Having Bruce and Dusty around is great!
Mentorship is important. Vitello has guys he can go to and vice versa. It also lessens the potential micro-management from the front office and puts it on the two retired managers.
Wish more old Giants were involved with the team. Specifically:
Kevin Mitchell, Atlee Hamaker, Billy Swift, John Burkett, Candy Maldonaldo, Chili Davis and Robby Thompson. Eventually, bring back Matt Williams and Bob Melvin after a cooling off period. One last guy, Russ Ortiz! Not his fault Giants lost game 6 in 2002.
Too Bad Boch won’t go back to the Padres to cap off his career with another World Series Championship!
Trader Jack McKeon took over the Marlins in season and lead them
to their 2nd World Series Championship in 2003 @ age 72!
Dusty Baker won a World Series Championship in 2022 @ age 73!
Analytics is great as one of the tools in a Manager’s tool box,
but nothing replaces knowledge, experience, outside the box thinking
of some of those Hall of Fame caliber managers!
Shadow manager secured
Might be too many old timers in the building with Posey being very young for the position. Tis’ a delicate balance there. Could be a positive could be a negative. They could be a wealth of knowledge but it’s also just human nature to pine for the good ole’ days the way things were done when “men were men”. It’s the cycle of life and we all live it. I think Bochy is humble and intelligent enough to know how to handle the situation with grace though.
Pining for the good old days is not human nature. It’s what some individuals choose to do.
If you’re lucky enough to live to 70-80 I can almost guarantee you aren’t going to like change all that much. It is 100% human nature. Look at our generation of boomers and the work and effort they are putting forth to stop change.
Ok. I’d like to politely suggest that your current crop of boomers are a bit unique. Way more egotistical and selfish than the norm. A lifetime of relative success and comfort will do that to you. Plenty of boomers happily kicking back and saying “Go for it, kids. Shape it how you want to live it. I’ve had my go at that.”
I think that might be more normal than you think.
Not in good ole’ Long Island lol. Change is not an option for these boomers. Wish I grew up with that mentality you speak of. What part of the country are you from?
Different country. Australia
Dam that’s right!!! No wonder your name looked so familiar we def had a good chat back in the archives somewhere lol
Australia was always the dream for me. Wanted to study abroad and surf there when I was younger but could never swing it.
Ps – sorry our country is being such asstards to you lately. I’ve heard the nightmare stories of Australians being held hostage and sent back on a plane from over here bc of anti-party messages on their phones (after they make you unlock it). I definitely have zero to do with any of that.
Ha ha. Apology accepted. Yeah. You got to clear the phone of anything anti trump. No chance I’m getting in.
Is what it is. Asstard is accurate. Immoveable tariffs when we have a surplus with you. Reporter babes getting shot in the arse by ICE. Whole country threatened when one of our reporters asked a hard question. Making us go back to the table on a vital submarine deal and bend the knee while saying nice things. It’s cool. The deal got done…..for now. Our guy is doing a solid Switzerland impersonation.
The biggest issue is your dumb people rile up our dumb people with their dumb ideas. It’s the way it’s always been. Your cultural influence is huge. All of a sudden we have to deal with our minority of idiots doing anti immigration protests for example. It’s a bit frustrating.
Never mind. Get your sh&t sorted and we can all move on.
I write in generalizations for a reason. I can’t be too specific these days based on exactly the things you alluded to. Unfortunately it’s not going to get better over here….they are just scratching the surface. The frozen water agency you speak of is a scary force who are now mobilizing against actual citizens who pose a threat. Google the name Debbie Brockman….events like that signify it’s the early days of a gestapo/KGB type force. History always seems to repeat itself, not sure if you ever dove into cliodynamics, but according to the ebbs and flows of history we are counting down to something brutal.
Yeah mate. I’m aware. The world’s leaders have demonstrated awareness. Their efforts to come together and insulate their people from what’s likely has been all but manic. Gives a Dad of a couple of twenty somethings some degree of comfort. Still crazy though. Never thought I’d live to see what’s happening to the good old USA. Here’s hoping you can turn the ship around. All the best.
hopefully it does NOT turn out to be “Too many chef’s in the kitchen” type of thing.