While much of the focus regarding the Marlins this offseason has been on their intent to spend more aggressively (relatively speaking) and bolster the lineup, the Fish still have a pair of prominent trade candidates in the rotation. Right-handers Edward Cabrera and Sandy Alcantara are on wishlists for pitching-hungry clubs around the league, though neither is a lock to be moved.
Kevin Barral and Isaac Azout of Fish On First reported last week that the organization “expects” Alcantara to be with the club come Opening Day. MLB.com’s Christina De Nicola offers a similar sentiment today, suggesting that Cabrera is the likelier of the two to be moved this offseason — if either is traded at all. Miami isn’t actively shopping either pitcher at the moment, she writes, though it’s all but a given that there’ll be an uptick in inquiries at next week’s Winter Meetings. De Nicola also lists lefty Ryan Weathers as a potential trade candidate while rightly noting that the Fish would be selling low on a talented southpaw after consecutive injury-plagued seasons.
Acquired in the 2023 trade sending Garrett Cooper to the Padres, Weathers has been a steal for Miami when healthy. That’s been a major caveat, unfortunately. A lat strain, flexor strain and finger strain have combined to limit the former No. 7 overall draft pick to just 24 starts dating back to Opening Day 2024. Weathers has totaled 125 innings in that time and notched a 3.74 ERA with a 22% strikeout rate and 6.8% walk rate. That league-average strikeout rate is backed by a roughly average 11.7% swinging-strike rate. Weathers has sat 96.2 mph on his heater since ’24 and kept a strong 45.6% of batted balls against him on the ground. As with Cabrera, he’s a clear injury risk but has had some recent success and comes with another three seasons of club control.
Cabrera stands as the prize of the Marlins’ potential trade candidates in the rotation, but because of his age (27), affordable salary ($3.7MM projection, via MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz), former top prospect status and 2025 results (3.53 ERA, 25.8 K%, 8.3 BB%, 46.6 GB% in 137 2/3 innings), he also surely comes with the highest asking price.
Jeff Passan and Kiley McDaniel of ESPN wrote just this morning that Miami has asked for “premium prospects” in for any club that has poked around on Cabrera, and the right-hander’s lengthy injury history has left interested parties wary of making such a commitment. The 2025 season was Cabrera’s first reaching 100 innings in the majors, and he’s spent time on the injured list with an elbow sprain, blisters, shoulder impingement (three times) and tendinitis in his elbow — all since 2021.
Certainly, the Marlins could use their deep supply of starting pitching to bring in some bats to help the lineup, but free agency remains a viable path as well. They’ve primarily focused on first base to this point, but Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald reports that president of baseball ops Peter Bendix and his staff have begun to broaden their search. Miami is also looking into potential outfield and third base acquisitions, believing that the versatility of players like Connor Norby and Griffin Conine could allow them to target bats at other positions.
It’s already known that the Marlins have been considering Norby at first base. Jackson adds that the Fish are planning to get Conine some work at first next spring and also believe that outfielder Heriberto Hernandez could be an option there.
The bullpen has been another point of focus for Bendix & Co., with reports tying Miami to prominent names like Devin Williams (who has since signed with the Mets), Raisel Iglesias (who re-signed in Atlanta) and Pete Fairbanks (who Bendix knows well from his days as Rays general manager). Jackson adds veteran relievers Kyle Finnegan, Tyler Rogers and twin brother Taylor Rogers as three more bullpen arms who intrigue the Marlins.
Finnegan, 34, has closed games for the division-rival Nationals for years but elevated his production to new heights following a summer trade to the Tigers. Detroit pushed Finnegan to use his splitter more and tweaked his release point, and the right-hander was flat-out dominant in the Motor City, emerging as one of manager A.J. Hinch’s go-to relievers. He tossed 18 innings of 1.50 ERA ball following the trade and saw his strikeout rate jump from 19.6% in D.C. to an eye-popping 34.8% in Detroit.
The Rogers brothers have lengthy track records themselves. Taylor, a lefty, was a high-end setup man and All-Star closer with the Twins during his peak years from 2017-22. He’s settled into more of a middle relief role since signing with the Giants — where he teamed with his brother — and subsequently being traded to the Reds and Cubs.
While Taylor was the prominent name early in the brothers’ careers, it’s Tyler who is now the higher-profile reliever. He’s pitched 378 1/3 innings of 2.71 ERA ball dating back to 2021, including a pristine 1.98 earned run average in 77 1/3 frames between the Giants and Mets in 2025. Tyler doesn’t miss many bats, as one would expect from a soft-tossing right-handed submariner whose sinker averages 83.5 mph, but he has impeccable command (2.2% walk rate since 2024) and is all but impossible to square up due to the deception in his delivery. Tyler has the slowest “fastball” and lowest whiff percentage in the majors but also sits in the 95th percentile (or better) of big league pitchers in terms of opponents’ exit velocity, barrel rate and hard-hit rate.
At the moment, Miami has a projected 2026 payroll of just $59MM, per RosterResource. They’re sitting just under $70MM in luxury tax obligations. The general thinking has been that, like the A’s last offseason, the Marlins will want to push that CBT number closer to $105MM in order to avoid any type of MLBPA grievance that might jeopardize their revenue-sharing status. That could be achieved by bringing in free agents, trading for veterans on guaranteed salaries, or extending players already on the roster. The Marlins have reportedly spoken to both Kyle Stowers and Eury Perez about long-term deals; talks with either player could pick back up later in the offseason.

27 games in 3 seasons is hardly a steal
27 games in 2-1/3 seasons.
Cabrera didn’t put it together til this last season. Whole lotta hype about a guy who is has still only had one really solid year.
The idea with Cabrera is he has good stuff but didnt know where it was going. He’s coming off his best year and could be turning a corner into a really good pitcher. I personally dont trust him but I see the appeal if hes available.
Cabrera has some of the best stuff in MLB. Great velo, sits 97 with the four seamer, two looks to the fastball with the sinker, the movement on his fastball is wicked. 45% whiff rates on his curve ball and his slider and he has confidence in his changeup.
He is a head case sometimes, when he gets behind early he has struggled to pull it together but matured in this regard late last season. If he gets the mental down, he will be one of the leagues best.
A 3.70 ERA for what hes making isnt really a great deal. And thats ignoring how he performed the other starts in 2025.
He pitches in an extreme pitchers park. Put him in Boston his numbers look different.
Are you sure about that, professor? That production over a full season would cost twice as much in free agency.
A 3.70 ERA in a pitchers park costs 34 million a year in free agency?
No
People are really underestimating how awful the catching situation in Miami was this year. They allowed 191 stolen bases. That’s the most by 21 SBs from any team from the past DECADE. The Royals only allowed 47. That’s almost 150 more free bases.
And it’s not even the downstream impact on runs allowed, but the extra mental pressure their pitchers probably felt as soon as a hitter reaches first base
Well SB numbers have been significantly impacted since new rules were added in ‘23.
Miami started a catcher who was at an A ball level defensively last year. It was very bad.
Even if Joe Mack doesn’t hit a lick they’ll be in a much better spot.
Catcher is a concern in Miami.
The White Sox could potentially put a very tempting trade chip on the Marlins table. Kyle Teel.
Teel hit last season .273/.375/.411 in 250PAs — power, AVG and OBP out of the C position.
White Sox have Edgar Quero and Korey Lee at C, and if they get a haul for Teel, they probably would trade him.
Have to be nice. Thomas White or Robby Snelling nice, with a pair of position player prospects.
I don’t think the White Sox have any interest in trading their C’s tbh and the Marlins have Joe Mack knocking on the door, who is supposed to be good defensively behind the plate.
My guess is the Marlins lean on Ramirez more at DH and find a defensive-first C to pair with Hicks (who also stinks defensively).
Teel to the Marlins would be a s”teal” for the Fish (the trade idea was born as a Teel / teal concept).
If the Marlins like the idea of having Teel on the roster for the long term and put together an extraordinary package of prospects, it wouldn’t be out of the question for the White Sox with Edgar Quero having had a good season at C too.
As a White Sox fan, I like Teel in our lineup but a return of Max Meyer / Joey Volini / Jacob Berry / Joe Mack would be enticing.
I think the Fish have to go for it this season. If they don’t feel like Mack is ready to step in, and his high strike out rates might be an issue, then trading for Teel might be a good line for them and they might part with a package of players that is too good to pass up.
Weathers is another one of those former top picks by the Padres like Gore that have turned out to be very mediocre pitchers in the big leagues. He has had a 4.11 ERA and 4.51 FIP in 26 starts in 2.33 seasons with the Marlins.
Health has really been a factor for both weathers and gore. They have the stuff to be 1-3 type pitchers but at some point every season have some sort of health issues.
The padres sold on both of them not reaching their peaks. Even if they have done so in spurts.
3.74 ERA abd 4.26 FIP the last 2 seasons. Not great but certainly much better than the first 2 months they had him.
Fans keep talking about these guys like they are potential Aces just because they were drafted high in the 1st round. Their performance shows they are not that good. .
You are quoting a 4.51 FIP vs a 4.26 FIP for Weathers. There is not much difference and both are worse than the 4.18 FIP average for starting pitchers in 2024-2025. Both are mediocre. Middle of the rotation starters at best, not Aces. That is my point.
Conine and Weathers are legacy Marlins. At this point i don’t think we’ve seen enough of either to know what they can really do.
The Marlins need to sign a couple of bats, add a Closer and let this rotation see what it can do. Could be a Wild Card contender if health is on their side
Marlins needle is pointing up. They have a glut of young players at around the same level though.
They need to make decisions on Norby, Ramirez, Hicks, Agustin Ramirez, Pauley, Wagaman, Conine etc.
They were feeling the team out last year and seeing what stuck but there’s a lot of fringe guys with possible low end starter upside. They need a couple more impactful bats to make a run at the postseason.
If they are trying to increase payroll and compete, why sell low on any of their top starters?
Between overpaying FAs and/or trading nonprospects for expensive yet productive veterans makes more sense.
Someone like Willson Contreras if he would waive his no trade.
All this talk about the Marlins trading away their frontline starters is misguided to me.
Adding Finnegan and/or Rogers would solidify their bullpen. Bullpen was good last season and Faucher, Henriquez, Bender and Bachar are back this season.
Best front three in MLB with Alcantara, Perez and Cabrera and their 4/5 could be the best back end with Weathers / Meyer and Garrett.
Marlins have the prospects to add a bat. Yandy Diaz would be a great fit on this team. Jaren Duran would be a good fit too. I think they could get those trades done. How about this lineup:
Duran
Diaz
Ramirez
Stowers
Marsee
Conine
Hicks
Norby
Edwards
With Sanoja and Hernandez on the bench and Joe Mack on the farm. Marlins have to be thinking about trading for an impact bat or two and winning a title this year.
Astros should go for Ryan Weathers.
Colton Gordon
Prospect
So, we’re going to trade a guy one year younger for a guy one year older?
Um, I didn’t realize that the Marlins are in the business of trying to make the Astros better. I thought they were in the business of making themselves better.
Guess I need to revise the package.
Which I’ll when I have time and feel like it.
Yes. It’s best when offering trade suggestions to consider what the other team can expect from your team – not trying to dump lesser value for more.
Normally I try to do that. I didn’t do it then.
Christian Walker, 10MM each year, Cole Hertzler, Kenni Gomez? Marlins get power hitting first basemen, 2 prospects. Astros get SP. What do you think.
Better then the guy that said Josh Hader and Jake Meyers for Kodai Senga. Didn’t think about Hader’s value.
It’s a good offer, but the problem is that Walker contract, which I understand that the prospects added would be to compensate the Marlins for it, but I doubt the Marlins would go for it just on the years of Walker’s contract at his age. Also, hitting in Arizona and in the Astors parks are far different than hitting in LoanDepot/Marlins Park. It could easily turn into an Avi Garcia situation, while giving a piece to get it instead of just money.
The Astros are covering 10 million each year. He has 2026 and 2027 left. Let’s add Trey Dombreski to the Astros package and maybe a lottery ticket to the Marlins package. What do you think about that?
It’s great to add on, but essentially it’s adding what borders on being a bad contract for one too many years for a team that can easily just stick with internal options for far less price, no commitment, and get to keep their pitcher.
To clarify, why do the deal for Walker when the Marlins can simply stick with Liam Hicks, or try out Griffin Conine, Heriberto Hernandez, Connor Norby, or Augustin Ramirez at 1B? Anyone of them shows they can handle 1B and that is a much better option than trading away Weathers and coming back with Walker and iffy prospects that the Marlins would have to hope that one becomes a serviceable MLB player. Again, why do that for what is essentially a bad contract when there are other, much younger options?
I follow what I read.
climbingtalshill.com/marlins-sudden-strategy-shift…
And the title of that Astros fan site article wasn’t enough of a hint that it made no sense for the Marlins?
Again, the Marlins aren’t in the business of making the Astros better.
It seems that this is more about you Astros fans trying to find any sucker to bail you out of the Walker contract than it is about adding a pitcher.
Lemme just change everything. Let’s make a trade that benefits both the Marlins and the Astros.
What are your thoughts BannedMarlinsFanBase?
I honestly don’t see anything in the Astros organization that fits the Marlins needs. The Marlins need a Closer or high-leverage reliever, and they need a RH bat, preferably at 1B. And the prospective solutions to both have to make sense as to where the Marlins are right now, and with the rest of the roster.
For 1B, it has to be something that makes more sense than giving one of the internal possibilities a try.
For Closer/high-leverage reliever, it just has to be a legit high-leverage guy to pair up with Ronny Henriquez.
People (Astros News), have talked about the Astros possibly trading Bryan Abreu. Obviously, the neither the Marlins or the Astros would entertain the idea of trading for and trading away the reliever, what would a package for one of the most reliable relievers look like?
I’m not really sure. With a guy like him, it all depends on what Peter Bendix thinks he’s worth. Years of control would be a factor in that for the Marlins as well.
Yeah if Astros were to trade him (which they likely won’t), it’ll go to a bigger contender.