9:55PM: The Giants are “also believed [to be] interested” in Cabrera, Jon Heyman of the New York Post writes. San Francisco has already signed Tyler Mahle and Adrian Houser to join Logan Webb, Robbie Ray and Landen Roupp in the rotation, but a more controllable pitcher like Cabrera would be useful since Ray and Mahle will be free agents next winter. Beyond that starting five, the Giants have several younger arms but not a lot of experience, and conceivably one or two of these pitchers could be moved to Miami in a hypothetical Cabrera trade package.
12:54PM: The Yankees are discussing the possibility of a trade for right-hander Edward Cabrera with the Marlins, according to a report from Chris Kirschner and Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic. The report also adds that the Yankees remain involved in the market for Brewers right-hander Freddy Peralta after their involvement was first reported at the Winter Meetings last month. Meanwhile, Barry Jackson of the Miami Herald reports that the Mets and Cubs have also shown interest in Cabrera.
Cabrera, 27, is an exciting young arm with considerable upside. The righty enjoyed a breakout season last year with Miami, pitching to a 3.53 ERA with a 3.83 FIP in 137 innings of work across 26 starts. That’s decent mid-rotation production already, but what makes Cabrera an especially enticing trade candidate is the possibility he’ll take a step forward in the future. The youngster averaged a career-best 97.0 mph on his fastball this past season despite throwing a career-high in terms of innings, and paired a strong 25.8% strikeout rate with a career-best 8.3% walk rate.
With a solid 47.9% ground ball rate for his career in addition to those strong strikeout and walk numbers, it’s not hard to imagine Cabrera building on his 2025 season to emerge as a dominant starter. The righty is also controlled through the end of the 2028 season, meaning that an acquiring club would have plenty of time to work with him before he reaches free agency.
Of course, that’s not to say there aren’t causes for concern. 2025 was the first year Cabrera crossed the 100 inning threshold at the big league level due to an assortment of injury woes. The most significant of were shoulder problems that limited him in both 2023 and ’24, but even last season saw Cabrera make two trips to the injured list. His second trip to the shelf, which occurred back in September, saw sidelined due to a right elbow sprain. Elbow injuries are always worrisome for pitchers given that UCL injuries wipe out at least a year of a pitcher’s career when they require surgery, though it’s worth noting that Cabrera still struck out 26.3% of his opponents over his final two starts of the season after he returned from the shelf.
The Yankees, for their part, are seeking at least one starter to add to their rotation with both Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon poised to start the season on the injured list, while Clarke Schmidt figures to miss most if not all of the 2026 campaign. Max Fried, Luis Gil, Cam Schlittler, and Will Warren all figure to be part of the Opening Day rotation at this point, but additional injuries could crop up and it makes plenty of sense for the Yankees to add another starter to the mix ahead of depth options like Paul Blackburn and Ryan Yarbrough.
Cabrera could be a particularly appealing addition for New York given that MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projects him to earn just $3.7MM in arbitration this year. While the Yankees certainly have the budget to afford someone pricier, their primary focus seems to be retaining Cody Bellinger at this point and it’s unclear if the team has the stomach for a second nine-figure deal on top of the one Bellinger is reportedly seeking. That would leave bids of players like Ranger Suarez and Framber Valdez unrealistic, and Cabrera projects to be better than most other starters in free agency at this point.
That affordability also figures to be attractive to the Cubs, who have long been known to be searching for a player to add to the front of their rotation this winter. The club appeared to finish second in the Tatsuya Imai sweepstakes behind the Astros earlier this week, so it’s possible that missing out on Imai could spur the team to more aggressively pursue Cabrera or other starting pitcher.
Cabrera’s affordable salary would be particularly attractive for the Cubs given their reported interest in the infield market. They’ve been connected to each of Kazuma Okamoto, Alex Bregman, Eugenio Suarez, and Bo Bichette on one level or another throughout the offseason, and while Okamoto is off the market the other three remain available. Swinging a deal for Cabrera could allow the Cubs to sign one of those big bats without going over the luxury tax, something they’ve been loathe to do in recent years, and that signing of an infielder could lessen the blow to the team’s offense a trade for Cabrera might create.
As for the Mets, the team has made adding to the front-of-their-rotation a stated priority as well but so far have been focused on reworking their position player mix and bullpen. Pete Alonso and Edwin Diaz both walked in free agency, while Jorge Polanco, Devin Williams, and Luke Weaver have signed to help make up for those losses. Meanwhile, they’ve shipped out Brandon Nimmo and Jeff McNeil while bringing Marcus Semien into the fold via the trade market.
All that maneuvering has left the starting rotation virtually untouched, and the Mets have made clear that they’re willing to deal from their collection of young infield talent (including Ronny Mauricio, Mark Vientos, and Luisangel Acuna) this winter as they look to improve the rest of their roster. They also have plenty of young pitching of their own, which could be attractive to the Marlins as a way to keep their deep rotation well-stocked with talent even after dealing Cabrera.

Yankees, Mets and 27 other teams are interested
I would much rather have Cabrera then Peralta.
So, first acquire Cabrera *then* follow up with a trade for Peralta? Or you would much rather have Cabrera *than* Peralta?
GBS
Yes, obtaining both of them would be great in either order of acquisition!
Nah the Cubies or Mutts need Cabrera and Peralta a lot more than the Yankees do.
I would probably choose ‘then’.
Peralta is so much better and doesn’t have a bad elbow
Why? He’s an injury machine.
Go Get em’ Giants!!!
Truth Mr Hung. Most teams in MLB would love to have him.
I also am in agreement with Well on this one.
Cubs would have to part with Nico for the Marlins to bite. 2nd baseman as good as Nico has been, are hard to find in MLB now.
No
Negative. Marlins aren’t going to want a rental second baseman. Especially when their current 2b is fine.
Marlins don’t need someone with only a year or two of control. They want controllable talent. Maybe Shaw would be involved.
Shaw has more trade value than Cabrera. I’d doubt that.
Also no
No way not close.
pass on Nico. Edwards and Lopez are set in the MI.
I dont know that the Cubs have the prospects to get the trade done.
Ben Brown
Jaxson Wiggins
Kevin Alcantara
is probably where it begins.
The Mets probably have to include:
Jonah Tong
Brandon Sproat
Ronny Mauricio
Id say thats about right for Cabrera. It would have to be an overpay in terms of prospect capital.
Cubs dont have the Prospects????
Thats funny
Their minors is almost as good as Marlins MLB Team
The Cubs are not trading any of their top 3 for Cabrera, they are all on them at this point.
That might be true but if they arent the right prospects for the Marlins..then..no the cubs dont have the prospects..Just because someone thinks they have good prospects doesnt mean another team will part with thier player for them..how bout the cubs develope thier great prospects and win with them?
Funny. Because the last time fans of a team (Braves) said that their minor leage team was better than the Marlins, their MLB team literally finished behind the Marlins….
@junior: A couple of years ago, that was true, but the Cubs’ system has fallen rather precipitously in BA and other rankings since.
The Braves entire front rotation either went down or spent significant time on the injured list the only time that happened in the last 6 years. Maybe take another crack at that?
For Cabrera who has injury concerns? No way they are parting with Sproat AND Tong.
Maybe one and I doubt that…
And why is everybody trying to trade Hoerner? He is probably the most critical Cub other than PCA.
Cabrera is an ace, is on the level with Crochet, it will take a similar return of MLB ready prospects and top prospects.
No, he isn’t. He’s young and has good stuff. He is a 3-4 pitcher. Comparing him to Crochet is not an apt comparison.
Never had a FIP lower than 4 until this year..3.83. Has a K/BB ratio barely above 3 this year but more like 2s
Maybe he becomes an ace, but he isn’t.
Same as Crochet? In what ways? I don’t see anyone choosing Cabrera over him.
Has the best stuff Ive seen, I watched many of his sequences, he can be great.
keyword being can be .. hasnt shown it yet and also hasnt pitched a full season at the mlb level yet in 4 years heck only made 100 innings once
tong can be great too heck peterson can be great too
This. Dustin May had some of the nastiest stuff I had ever witnessed, but unfortunately it never materialized into sustained success, in large part due to injuries. Potential is often never reached.
Your definition of an “Ace” labeling Cabrera as such is a bit scary….25-29 lifetime, 4.07 ERA…..and hurt this last year….a big NO GO for the Yankees…….unless he comes cheap which won’t happen with the Marlins making him sound like Sandy Koufax reincarnated……and please no analytics that make a dead person sound alive…….
Good analysis….potential, but so is him being injured….he’s got a long way to go before anyone can call him an ACE….he’s more like a #3-4 that might be a #2 in time….
@Mi
Please stop confusing with “production”. Stuff doesn’t mean your an ace. Joba Chamberlain has stuff but couldn’t stay healthy and keep it together.
Be realistic. No way the Mets would pay that price.
Tong and sproat plus mauricio for cabrera? I wouldnt deal tong alone for cabrera.
Except…the Marlins have no need of nico …try again
ROTFLMAO. No, they wouldn’t. Cabrera is a 3rd tier starting pitcher. He has never had a full healthy season. He has a 4.15 ERA with a higher FIP and questionable peripherals over the last 3 seasons. He has started an average of 22 games per season over the last 3 years with <5 IP per start. He gets hit and hit hard. At his best his HH% was in the bottom 8th percentile and his average exit velocity was near the bottom in the 22nd percentile.
This is not a guy that any team is trading a 6 WAR player for. Not even a 3 WAR player. Maybe a low Top 100 prospect or just outside of that and a couple of minor leaguers outside the Top 100.
If you are thinking Cubs, then a MLB ready package along the lines of a Alcantara, Neely, and BJ Murray.
If the Marlins really want Hoerner, then a package like Cabrera, Mack, and Ekness. They may still have to throw in a lottery ticket to make that really fair to the Cubs. Johnson? He is a long way from the majors, but at least he plays MI.
Skip- that’s a lot of words that in the end are nonsense.
Hoerner’s value is very limited because of his one year of control. Spouting his war number means very little because of the years of control.
Simm,. thanks for the poor attempt at an insult. It means you read every word.
His 6.2 WAR made Hoerner worth more in one year than Cabrera in 2, maybe 3 seasons. Looking at the two players performance over the past 3 seasons shows that there is about a 50/50 chance that Hoerner will provide more value in 2026 than Cabrera will from 2026-2028.
Cabrera is a third tier starting pitcher and even with Hoerner having just one year of control, the Marlins could not get Hoerner for Cabrera.
Just to pile on, everything I said through the 3rd paragraph is correct. The most the Marlins will get for Cabrera is a low Top 100 prospect or just outside of that and a couple of minor leaguers well outside the Top 100.
The only reason the 4th and final paragraph is not 100% correct is that Hoerner only has one year of team control. If he had 2 years of team control like I thought originally, that paragraph hits the nail squarely on the head as well.
Don’;t know about the Nico comments but the comments about Cabrera are spot on…..the Marlins and their fans are making this kid sound like Sandy Khoufax reborn…….not even close…..
Other than the fact that Nico is a FA after this year, you nailed Cabrera’s value. The Marlins would not trade for Nico at all. What they need is prospects.
Cubs should not trade Nico.
Marlins should not obtain Nico.
Nico is a FA after 2026.
Cubs want one year rentals to win in 2026. E.g., Nico. An extension would be awesome but not expected.
Marlins want controllable talent not a one year rentals.
Bad deal for Cubs, even worse for Miami.
I didn’t realize Hoerner was a FA after 2026. For some reason I thought he had a few more years on his deal. My bad.
lol gonna take a lot more than that. Have you seen what mediocre SP like Baz are worth these days? Yikes!
Not one of the prospects the Orioles gave up were top 100 prospects. The best of them, deBrun, is #8 on MLB Pipeline and #10 on BA top prospect lists in the Rays system. Alcantara is MLB ready and a better prospect than deBrun or any of the other prospects the Orioles gave up for Baz.
Baz was the #12 prospect in baseball on MLB Pipeline and #8 on Ba prior to the 2022 season. In 2025 he made 31 starts in his first full season back from TJ. He didn’t throw his first pitch in 2024 until August.
He is considered a better pitcher than Cabrera and he didn’t get a return that included even a single top 100 prospect in return.
The guys the orioles traded haven’t played a full season of professional baseball yet. Give them a year before you proclaim they aren’t of value. They very well could be in multiple top 100 lists after a season. Baz is not considered a better pitcher than Edward Cabrera. He’s an oft injured, once highly regarded prospect, that has yet to put a full season of quality pitching together. History would say he’s closer to a bust than an all star.
We can do this dance again, but there’s nothing more than a half season of success on Baz resumè that says he has any value. Other than that it’s all hype. And yes, before you say it, Cabrera has injury concerns as well. Cabrera is the better pitcher.
Baz is better. He was a better prospect with a 60-65 FV vs a 50-55 FV for Cabrera on MLB and BA respectively. He has a lower FIP and SIERA for his career than Cabrera.
Baz made more starts in 2025 than Cabrera ever has and that was Cabrera’s best season for # of starts. As the person you are responding to pointed out, it was Baz’s 1st full season back from TJ surgery. Baz went deeper into games than Cabrera did last season.
Yep with a nearly 5 era and 84 era+. Clearly Baz is superior. Or are we projecting success again? That’s called hype.
I appreciate that you don’t understand FIP and SIERA. That’s fine. Not going to argue the point. Ask any GM in baseball who they would prefer. Come back and tell us what you find out.
@MikeBSoxFan
Please check out the Marlins organzational chart before making such trade suggestions.
I don’t think it will take long for you to see the name of a 2B on their team named Xavier Edwards.
“Interesting”
To Athletics for Butler, Jump and Gelof.
Yessir.
What a dumb trade (for the A’s). Why trade a player you extended, and I would not trade Gage Jump.
The A’s shouldn’t trade Gage Jump simply because of his ultra-cool name.
Marlins are in a good spot here.
Hope the Marlins leapfrog over the Nets into 3rd place.
At present, I think they have.
I’m pretty pumped for today’s Dolphins vs Islanders game.
Haha Strunk Flugget!
Heck why not go straight for the Knicks
They will be on the cusp of making the playoffs. The Marlins are the 3rd best team in the East. They will have a winning record this season. I think the Amazins drop to 4th in the NL East.
Nobody on the Nets can hit a curveball.
… from the 3 point line.
@DavRozNYY
If the Marlins can borrow Bam and Powell from the Heat, they are easily better than the Nets.
As for the Marlins on the baseball side, they are currently better than the Mets.
@Bill M
“Nobody on the Nets can hit a curveball.”
Are you sayin’ that the Nets can’t hit a curveball? Get outta here with that JoBu stuff!
“The club appeared to finish second in the Tatsuya Imai sweepstakes” which can link us to an article saying the Yankees were never heavily involved. Mixed messages much?
Finishing second on a guy who didn’t get much of a deal. Tells me the Yankees didn’t have much interest.
It was saying the Cubs were the runner up not the Yankees
Somehow I missed that the topic switched to the Cubs. Oops.
I thought it said the Cubs were 2nd.
Yankees-Elmer Rodriguez, Kyle Carr, Chase Hampton, and TJ Rumfield for Edward Cabrera
Cubs-Jaxon Wiggins, Jonathan Long for Edward Cabrera
Mets-Brandon Sproat, Ryan Clifford, Jonathan Santucci for Edward Caberea
I don’t know any of these teams very well. Which trade would Miami pick, and how could you alter them to make them more realistic because again, I don’t know any of these teams very well.
Seems like Mets give up quite a bit in your scenarios
I feel like the Yankees trade is the best of the three and pass on all three.
Jaxon Wiggins should be the Cubs on the untouchable list.
Cubs fans always have a long list of untouchable prospects
Wiggins and Long would be fair for Cabrera. I think Marlins will hold on to him and go for it this year. I’d rather the Cubs keep Wiggins, too.
Wiggins, by the way, was the comp pick for Willson Contreras.
Wiggins, Long, Conrad and Florentino might get it done but Wiggins and Long alone is well off.
There is ZERO chance Elmer Rodriguez is part of this pkg as he has better upside than Cabrera without the injury history Cabrera has. I don’t see Yankees moving him in any pkg unless it for Skenes.
Another Yankees fan overrating their prospects, how unexpected!
He’s a Top 100 prospect, #3 in our system, we’re not doing the ratings here.
And I agree Elmer is too much and may end up being better anyway. Gladly would give the others and another depending on what the Marlins are looking for.
For the Yankees, maybe for Mackenzie Gore or Freddy Peralta but not Cabrera. You think the Tigers might bite for Elmer, Lagrange, Spencer Jones, and GLJ?
No. Jones as a regular is a mirage and he will turn into Rob Deer and the other two pitchers are pop up prospects who need more of a track record. I don’t know who GLJ is?
I can’t see anybody playing up the crazy ask for Skubal.
GLJ=George Lombard, Jr.
He never er said Skubal. I figured he wanted Gipson-Long.
Uggh I am brain dead today. Him I like a lot!
@Motor
What is a “pop up” prospect?
A prospect who was not highly ranked and had a year that led to them becoming highly ranked. I stole it from somewhere else;)
Id make that trade for Skubal or Cabrera. Cabrera isn’t far off from Skubal’s echelon in my opinion.
I thought the word was George Lombard Jr was off limits in trade. That package above seems like it is higher than the Yanks would be willing to go.
Cabrera is nowhere near Skubal yet in terms of production. Lots of control and projectability though.
No sit ups, you are hilarious. Do you practice your comedy routines before you post them here?
One guy has been effective on those few occasions when he’s not injured. The other guy is the best pitcher in baseball. Egad.
@Wria
I don’t think the Yanks would trade Elmer for a guy who right now is more of a mid rotation guy with control issues. We have a guy like that already in Gil. And Peralta neither with him being a 1 year rental.
My trade package was for 1 year of Skubal
Too much for Mets.
That’s our Pete Alonso replacement and Sproat has such good stuff I really think they’re gonna hold on to him at least I’m hoping so.
Also Luis Angel Acuna kinda already feels like he belongs on the Marlins.
Will stay with the Mets because he’s loyal to NY like Pete Alonso was?
That’s way too much for the Mets to give up to a guy who has so far only been a mid-rotation arm at best. I get that he has potential for better, but you could say the same thing about Sproat and Santucci. Two of those three would be enough, imo.
YOu’re dreaming with that Yankees package…..Rodriquez isn’t being traded for a guy who can’t pitch more than 5, has an ERA over 4 and was hurt as recently as this past season……
New season. All stats start at zero.
@Astros71
None of those trades work for the Marlins goals for this year and beyond.
Well I don’t know the Marlins well (or any other teams) so thanks for telling me.
The usual interested suspects.
I hope to see Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz get his big league chance in pinstripes.
No thanks
You dont want to see Elmer in the Bronx?
I was talking about cabrera I would much rather see elmer
I think he will, but not this year (with any leash, that is). I have hopes that he performs like Schlittler.
I like Cabrera’s upside potential, obviously, but this has Cashman written all over it. A former top-tier pitcher, coming off recent injury which lessens the total asking price. At least he will likely help the club if he is acquired.
We do need hitting, imho. Trade Jazz, sign Bo to play 2B, sign Bellinger. They can do both and over 50% of their contractual obligations coming off the books by the end of the ‘28 season. Rodon, Cole, Stanton, Jazz, McMahon, Grish, and so on.
Yanks have some good upside pitchers coming in Rodriguez, Lagrange, Hess, Cunningham, Hampton, and Beck.. All have potential to be top end starters.
Why trade him, at all?
I agree
They need him. Unless some team offers something crazy, like many of the suggestions on this thread, he’ll be a Marlin.
@blakestreet
This all is coming from NY and Chicago news outlets for teams that have disappointed their fan bases, so they are looking to send a glimmer of hope. Unless one of the teams makes an offer that the Marlins absolutely can’t refuse, there will be no trade. And when I say ‘can’t refuse’, it takes into account that the package addresses Marlins organzational needs and helps them in their hopes to contend this year and beyond. For any trade suggestions, people will need to look at the Marlins organzational chart and to look at MLB-proven (not MiLB-proven) young players who will help the Marlins this season.
Expect the Cubs to finish as runners up and their media shills to say that the asking price was too high..
Unfortunately, the Cubs don’t have the prospects that would be necessary to land Cabrera.
Also, I’m not at all sure that the Cubs are in the market for a SP anyway. When we heard they were very early in the off-season, that was when they were assuming Imanaga would reject the QO. They were planning to replace Imanaga with someone they thought was better. But when Imanaga surprised them by accepting the QO, that killed that idea, and they decided to go with the same rotation as last season.
Yeah, pretty sure Hoyer is only signing reclamation projects the rest of the offseason.
@Acoss: And maybe less of that than usual. Hoyer seems to be almost thumbing his nose at the fans, and at the idea that the team needs to improve. I sense a new level of arrogance coming from the front office.
Depends on what the Marlins want in return. If their focus is pitching, Cubs definitely don’t have enough. If Miami is looking for position players, I would think the Cubs could put a decent offer together. Will it beat all other offers? Probably not. And a trade would leave the Cubs with a bottom 5 farm system.
Shaw, Ballesteros, Caissie, Alcantara, Long, and Conrad could all be in play for Cabrera.
Shaw may be considered “untouchable” w Nico set for FA and no current answer at 3B.
@Robert: I think other teams rate most of those players less highly than the Cubs (and their press) do. Alcantara, for example, is seen as a guy who basically didn’t make it, and Long is seen as not a major-league prospect. Even Caissie might be seen as a guy whose stock is falling–too much swing-and-miss. I think that in the eyes of other teams, Shaw was a qualified flop last season. Ballesteros might be thought of as interesting, Conrad probably, Wiggins definitely–but that might be about it.
The Yankees should be trying to deal with the reds for a starter
The Yankees report has the most legs as it was corroborated by Ken Rosenthal. Not saying there’s a deal imminent, but to me it sounds like an actively progressing story.
Cashman has said he was looking to trade for a starter so this is probably he’s at least working on with the Marlins.
Hey look it’s another mediocre arm that’s going to need TJ by the end of next season: WHO CARES?
It doesn’t cost anything to be interested… and apparently we are very interested this offseason.
✋️
Jed continues his “interested in” dominance over all other GMs. Leading the league in “check-ins” without a contract offer this offseason.
Warren & a B prospect for Cabrera – done!
As of right now, Warren is probably our #3 pitcher behind Fried and Schlittler until mid to late May…
@Wrian
Freid/Gil/Warren/Schlittler
Marlins need a C. Cubs can deal them Amaya and Alcantara
It’d take a lot more than that.
Maybe they can try turning Ballesteros into a catcher. They can have him too. Throw in a lower level pitching prospect lotto ticket and that seems reasonably fair, if catching is a priority for Miami. Amaya is actually pretty solid if he can stay on the field.
Marlins would probably want Caissie over Alcantara too.
Marlins have one of the best catching prospects in baseball and seem committed to seeing if Ramirez is serviceable (I really doubt he is). They don’t need Amaya right now. Any trade for them should start with a CIF or COF and some pitching.
@iron
Please see Marlins organizational chart before making a trade suggestion.
also, take note of an FYI – The Marlins are looking to contend this year.
Yankees going to do anything this off season?
Marlins keep being light on offense. Ballesteros from Cubs can already hit if they are okay with DH + probably another position player prospect. Hyped power of Jones from NYY also may be a headliner risk worth taking paired with a pitcher.
Ballesteros is such a good bat, but I worry he isn’t as beneficial to MIA as he is to CHC. He’s not likely to be a 1B due to height and marlins don’t really need a C/DH.
Please look at the Marlins organizational chart before making trade suggestions. Also, take note of an FYI – The Marlins are looking to contend for a Wild Card spot this year.
The obligatory Cubs, Red Sox, Mets, Yankees or Phillies are interested in headline.
Click, click, click, click.
Oh goodie! We have come full circle back to Cabrera rumors.. I take it the Dodgers aren’t trading Glasnow? This team management is clown shoes. Well at least it’s better than another article I saw essentially blaming Boras for the lack of activity. Another offseason of excuses.
The Dodgers aren’t interested.
So he will be traded to the Guardians, Padres, or Rangers?
Just throwing out 3 other teams. Please don’t be offended if those 3 are the ones you root for.
Ben Hess, Dillon Lewis and one other lower end prospect is getting it done for Yankees
Hess, Lagrange, Hampton, Dominguez.
Not a chance…I assume you are being sarcastic
Mauricio, Vientos, and Acuna are together not worth even close to Cabrera. That’s just a collection of the Mets’ failed prospects.
Can’t disagree with that. Mauricio is too raw and undisciplined. Acuña’s ceiling is a super utility guy who can’t hit. Vientos’s value is as low as it’s ever been right now.
Vientos: ever hear of a down year? What’s your definition of failure?
Forget what they are as prospects. Why would the Marlins take them when the Marlins are looking to contend this season?
I could see Vientos to take 1B for us, and shifting Morel into another part of the plan. But the other two are worthless to the Marlins.
The Marlins are looking to contend and Acuna and Mauricio don’t help anything in our organizational chart as we have other options.
Cabrera is young and has some promise. Hes not elite. Therefore Marlins can keep him if they are asking for elite pitcher packages.
From the Mets vantage, Mauricio, Jett Williams and Wenninger would be a more than fair package.
And I wouldn’t do it.
He has had injury concerns
His BEST FiP was 3.90
Um, why would the Marlins take pieces for the future when they are looking to contend this year?
And why would they help the Mets when, at this moment, the Marlins are the better team?
They aren’t. They are a decent young team, with very young players who could make some decent strides.
That said
They allowed 100 more runs than they scored and overperformed in their record by 7 games.
Their starting pitching is considered to be a strength (and should be in that park), but really was pedestrian overall.
They only had three players who had an OPS+ over 100. Most of the WAR was from defense.
So respectfully disagree they are better than the Mets at this point who collapsed, but still maintain elite performers and potentially as many gifted youngsters as the Fish.
To quote a sports coach that had a great moment of a wise analogy…
You are what your record says you are!
Last season, the Mets were only 4 games better than the Marlins. For most of the season, after the Mets hot start and the Marlins slow start, the Marlins were the better team. The Mets have lost key pieces since the season ended.
If you want to pick certain stats, pick the timeline when the Marlins young players figured it out and the Mets flaws showed themselves. You’ll see it.
And look at the rosters as they stand today. Marlins pitching staff is flat out better than the Mets. Position player-wise, you all still have a bunch of holes while we nearly have our entire position assignments filled.
Good luck with thinking the Mets have as many gifted young players as the Marlins. As far as elite, you have Soto. Who else? Alonso is gone. Lindor is hit or miss and an overpay. No other player on the Mets strikes fear in opposing teams.
Marlins, as of today, are the better team. I’m pretty sure if you ask most baseball experts – not the media ones needing clicks and ratings and subs – the Marlins are considered the better team as of this moment.
Is fangraphs expert enough? If so, Mets, AS IS, project for 43.2 WAR, Marlins 32.6.
Again, you are what your record says you are.
And if you want to bring in the analytics that have never accurately correlated with team records, at least look from the point I mentioned of the Mets flaws showing themselves and the Marlins young team figuring it out last season. For the bulk of the season, the Marlins were the better team after the Mets hot start and the Marlins poor start. But I guess you want to ignore that part.
And again, compare actual players on the team as of today. The Marlins are the better team.
Here’s a bit since it seems you don’t want to bring this stat in. It comes out of the ‘You are what your record says you are’ concept. And it goes to what I’m pointing out with last season.
At the end of the day on June 12, 2025, the Mets were 45-24 while the Marlins were 26-41…69 and 66 games into the season respectively. The Mets were 18.5 games better than the Marlins.
From that point on, the Mets flaws started to show and the Marlins players started to figure it out. From that point on, the Mets were 38-55 while the Marlins were 54-42…through 93 and 96 games respectively. That was the bulk of the season. During that time, the Marlins were 14.5 games better than the Mets. In addition, under your mention of run-differential, during the time frame of that period, the Mets were -44 while the Marlins were +4. Again, this is before the Mets loss key pieces, and while they have many holes, while the Marlins have their team nearly close to being set.
To me, a team’s record and game results carries weight. I’m not in the school of ‘this team had this stat during the game and season, so they were better despite losing the game and have a worse record’. At the end of the day, you are what your record says you are. The Mets were an 83-win team and the Marlins were a 79-win team. The Mets loss players since, while the Marlins maintained and added some pieces so far.
Oops…the Marlins were actually 25-41. Typo.
Aren’t the Marlins trying to compete? Why all the minor leaguers? Wouldn’t they want players who can help NOW??
Exactly. Most of these posters don’t even realize this because they are still going by ESPN’s tired, lazy, fictional narrative about the Marlins.
FYI to all the dimwits who don’t realize that the Marlins are looking to contend this year, go look at the Marlins organizational chart and last year’s standings. The Marlins are not going for these ridiculous trade suggestions.
Stop watching ESPN or testing trades on MLB the Show!
@Banned
Them if they are indeed entertaining offers, then why if they’re trying to contenders next year? They still Jane him under control for 3 years and I think this is first arb year. He had the lowest ERA last year. Why move him if they wish to compete? They can’t use their prospect to get what they need at other positions? I trust their nature.
The Cubs have been “interested” in every FA and “In” on every possible trade candidate and in the end they do nothing.
Nice to hear the Cubs were second for Imai. So close! Keep trying Jed. Go get em next time.
They better be ready to cough up Spencer Jones and Volpe for Cabrera.
That would actually be a win for the Yankees. Volpe is no longer well regarded.
Why the heck would the Marlins need Volpe? Um, do people even look at teams’ rosters when they make suggestions?
Are the Marlins stupid enough to trade with the Yankees? They have nothing of value.
Cubs ain’t doing anything. They will let the kids play and patchwork the bullpen as they’ve done the last several seasons.
Cabrera is getting traded to the Expos for Cliff Lee, Grady Sizemore and Brandon Phillips. Hopefully for the Marlins sake at least one of them will pan out.
Cabrera is an “unload the farm” guy now. If you’ve seen what Baltimore gave up for Baz… just go ahead and double that for Ed.
@Sean. I’m not unloading the farm unless it’s for Skenes. The Yankees better not get Peralta. Any pitcher on Miami instead Please.
Oh no I agree. I’m just saying that’s the new price
He’s a mid-rotation arm with control issues and a FIP around 4.00. You are overvaluing him by quite a bit.
Orioles overpaid for Baz. Doesn’t mean someone else should overpay for Ed.
It’s not me overvaluing him. I think it’s bananas. It’s the new market for young controllable SP with talent. Baz was a massive overpay
I guess we’re on the same page then. As a Mets fan, I hope they’re smarter than the Orioles. I thought the Baz trade was a poor one by Baltimore.
Please, the Marlins turned down what O’s traded to Tampa for Baz. I don’t think they get offered more than that for Cabrer.
I saw a source indicating that the Giants were interested too. Meanwhile I don’t remember MLBTR saying anything about the Astros interest in Imai. Must mean they had no interest.
Oh they just updated the article to say that the Giants are interested too! Who ever would have thought, or saw that coming?
I imagine the interest is a quick phone call until the Fish value Cabrera like Skubal.
If I am the Mets, for example, Sproat, Tong, Benge, probably Jett (though I mentioned him above), Reimer and Ewing are no goes. One of Sproat and Tong (and Santucci) will likely exceed Cabrera’s production.
Which is why Cabrera is still a Marlin. They talked him up at the Winter Meetings.
The guy with the bad elbow?? no thanks
Imagine having a screen name based on Ohtani’s nickname…
Cabrera was home run prone and mostly awful away from his cavernous home park. Those that play in small parks may want to steer clear of giving up the farm for him.
Nothing more than show and tell with th cubbies because until the price drops, cubs choose not to compete.
Cabrera and Belli would make me quite happy as a Yankee fan.
He would fit in with the TJS-potential crowd.
He’s just not as good as some are saying and his elbow is a ticking time bomb.
He’s got 3 years of control. The injury concern is fine if the price is right. He doesn’t need to be an ace. A solid 3 for 2 of the next 3 years would be fine. I would give up Jones and a couple of the decent AA pitching prospects for him.
Mets……
Yawn!
I see the NY and Chicago papers had nothing to report on, so they went back to their ole ‘Marlins Trade Target’ clickbait material.
Do I feel like reading all the stupid trade suggestions that are based on the unresearched, ESPN-esque fictional narrative that the Marlins are a bad team that aren’t trying to compete this season, so they will make trades that will make the hopeful fans’ teams better instead of themselves better? I’ll see if I decide to…again.
Let me just make this statement. Unless some team is willing to make a trade that the Marlins absolutely can’t refuse in that it makes the Marlins better this year for their playoff hopes and beyond, there will be no trade.
Mets are a longshot to get anything from the Marlins because the Marlins will be competing with them this year…and as things stand at the moment, the Marlins are the better team.
Cubs will have to give up a lot to get a SP from the Marlins.
Yankees will need to give up an offer we can’t refuse…again, something that helps us this year and beyond. And no, we do not want Jazz back! Keep him, suckers!
The Marlins were in the playoff race until September last year. They’re an up and coming team, not a tear-it-down shopping mall for big boys. You ain’t getting Cabrera – who’s a mid-rotation guy already with higher ceiling, controllable cheap for three years – for anything but a package of major league or near majors hitters whom it will hurt you hard to lose. No spare parts here; the Marlins can easily keep him. Cabrera is a better asset than Mackenzie Gore, for example, by a substantial margin.
Casey Schmitt, Luis Matos, & an AA arm.
3B problem solved.
Hayden Birdsong, Luis Matos and Drew Gilbert. Or Matos, Gilbert and a AA arm. Problem solved.
Ramos
Just the other day, you said Gilbert can’t hit MLB pitching (I have no opinion) and that Matos is not very good (too early to tell). My point is you want to send players you think poorly if in the deal.
I think Marlins would want Eldridge. I think Giants would consider it but decline.
Eldridge would be first ask in every trade. I think they would decline too.
Gilbert has a .190 career batting average in MLB. I don’t think it’s me saying that he can’t hit MLB pitching well. That said, he’s young and has plenty of time to make adjustments and improve. He’s got first round draft pick pedigree and is louded for having good tools. Obviously he’s been valued as a valuable MLB trade piece, considering that he’s already been traded twice.
I think highly of Birdsong, and hope he gets it together. He’s shown that he’s very good, when everything lines up.
Luis Matos is out of options, likely has to go somewhere. I don’t foresee him earning the starting RF job in spring training, especially given the amount of competition that already exists for that spot. If the Giants sign Tucker or Bader, it likely would fully seal Matos’ fate. Honestly I think he might get DFA’d tomorrow, to make room for Mahle. I think he’s toward the front of that line, now that Luciano, Meckler and Wiemer have already been designated.
I think the Marlins asking for Eldridge in this situation would be wishful thinking.
2026 Cubs line up
1. 2B Hoerner right handed bat
2. RF Happ left handed bat
3. SS Swanson right handed bat
4. 1B Busch left handed bat
5. LF Suzuki right handed bat
6. DH Ballesteros/Caissie left handed bat
7. 3B Shaw right handed bat
8. C Kelly/Amaya platoon
9. CF Crow-Armstrong left handed bat
Keven Alcantara right handed bat is back up center fielder
Caissie left handed bat is back up corner outfielder
Austin backs up Busch
Cubs need one more free agent starter not hitting. The additional free agent starter lets them use Rea and Assad in bullpen if Horton, Boyd, Taillon and Shota are healthy. By the time Steele returns, someone will be injured they need depth and length for season.
Amaya and Kelly bat right handed
As does Tyler Austin