The Red Sox have been connected to infielders all winter and and reportedly agreed to a one-year, $6MM deal with infielder Isiah Kiner-Falefa this week. That doesn’t mean they’re done, with Sean McAdam of MassLive reporting the club is still in the market for another infielder.
That aligns with Kiner-Falefa’s skill set. He’s a strong defender at many positions but has never offered much with the bat. His best role would be a utility player, providing cover at multiple positions. The Sox have an injury-prone shortstop in Trevor Story. They will seemingly give Marcelo Mayer a chance to carve out an everyday role somewhere but he has just 44 games of big league experience. Kiner-Falefa gives the club a fallback if Story gets hurt or Mayer struggles.
That still leaves the Sox with a hole somewhere. Mayer could be at either third or second base. The Sox seemingly prefer him at third but they would need to find a second base upgrade. Currently, they have a mix that includes Kiner-Falefa, Romy González, David Hamilton and others. González has value but is mostly a short-side platoon guy who can beat up lefties. Hamilton is a speed-and-defense guy somewhat like Kiner-Falefa. Kristian Campbell seems to be considered an outfielder now.
Upgrading on that group with a clear everyday second baseman makes a lot of sense but there are fewer options available at this stage of the offseason. The top remaining free agents are arguably not better than Kiner-Falefa, with Ramón Urías, Luis Urías and Adam Frazier some of the guys still out there. The trade market should be Boston’s best bet at this point. They have been connected to guys like Isaac Paredes of the Astros as well as Nico Hoerner and Matt Shaw of the Cubs.
The Astros have a bit of an infield logjam but have thus far held onto Paredes. He has some second base experience but hasn’t played there since 2023. Putting him back at the keystone might not align with Boston’s stated desire to improve defensively but he would certainly add thump, as he’s generally been good for 20-plus homers per season. It’s also possible the Sox like the bat enough that they would be willing to acquire him and put him at third with Mayer at second, despite their apparent preference for Mayer to be at the hot corner.
A trade with the Astros could also make a lot of sense from Houston’s perspective as well, as that club is looking to add a left-handed bat, preferably in the outfield. That’s something the Sox can offer, with Roman Anthony, Jarren Duran, Wilyer Abreu and Masataka Yoshida all on the roster.
Hoerner is perhaps the best defensive second baseman in the majors, so he would certainly fit in with Boston’s desires. The only problem would be convincing the Cubs to part with him. Shaw is less established and has less of a role on the Cubs right now. However, with Hoerner only signed for one more year, they may cling tightly to Shaw as well with the idea that he will take over for Hoerner a year from now.
Diamondbacks general manager Mike Hazen has said he’s not going to consider Ketel Marte trades any longer but that was before Boston signed Ranger Suárez. Maybe now that pitching prospects like Payton Tolle and Connelly Early have been pushed down the depth chart, perhaps Boston would be more willing to put them on the table in an effort to change Hazen’s mind.
Time will tell if chief baseball officer Craig Breslow can pull something off at this late stage of the offseason. Pitchers and catchers report to spring training next week.
Photo courtesy of John E. Sokolowski, Imagn Images

Funnily enough, Andy Ibanez could’ve been a good fit. I wonder if they put in a claim (doesn’t matter obviously since A’s would’ve had priority).
Either trade for Paredes (or lesser extent Jonathan India) or do nothing. Neither of the Urias or Frazier are better than whats already on hand
Pirate!
For the last time until Paredes is dealt somewhere, he’s not the answer. 17 or so home runs per season is not a needle mover given his glove is not sufficient if they truly want to have an elite infield. I promise not to mention this again … But I do agree a player like Marte is worth giving up a top pitching prospect. Not all make it. I’d prefer to give Duran, Bello and other prospects but would consider including Early if it’s just Duran, him and marginal talent. Separately, I’d consider a trade with Chicago for Shaw (not Hoerner) and again I’d consider Early (one for one seems reasonable but others may disagree). Again, you will not see me mention Paredes again until the situation is resolved.
Diamondbacks aren’t trading Marte. You have to offer a door blowing offer that’s something you don’t want to pay. Early, Duran, Bello, Whitlock. Something along the lines of that.
Astros, LOL. Didn’t the rumors start when AZ indicated he might be available? Can’t remember how this got started but as good as Marte is, he’s not worth an all star caliber left fielder, two very good young pitchers with big stuff abilities and as good of an 8th inning pitcher as there is. Whitlock is not getting dealt.
You need to overpay. That is clearly overpay. That’s what is getting the Diamonbacks to bite
Astros71:
“You need to overpay”
Why? Red Sox could easily enter the season with this lineup and look to improve later. In April, Marte’s No Trade Clause (5/10) kicks in. Both have pressure to make a move, but Arizona’s pressure is more pressing. Arizona isnt comfortable letting that 6 year lock kick in, or else they wouldnt have put him on the market.
In May… Tristan Casas, Kutter Crawford, Kyle Harrison and IKF for K. Marte.
That was one reason, but they were also looking for a nice return and they are contenders.
Paredes hit 20 HR last season in 102 games. The power plays in the right park, Houston is ideal but Fenway would be one of the next best.
Dewey… I wholeheartedly agree with you. I am tired of people pushing Isaac Parades as the “Holy Grail”.
I would prefer to not deal with an AL contender.
Sandoval, Pablo
Who around the league had a very down year last year and plays the infield compared to previous years? That is Breslow’s next target,
Marcus Semien, Gavin Lux, Isaac Paredes, Brandon Lowe, Josh Jung, Ozzie Albies. Do they really want Jung or Albies?
I think only Jung is available.
This has got to be the weakest Sox line-up since before Ortiz and Manny.
Gotta love it when a team who plays half their games in the second most hitter friendly environment decides to abandon the offense.
I would say 3rd behind Coors (always the king) and Great American Ballpark (Cin). Massive home run boost, especially for right-handed hitter, Routine fly balls turn into HRs. then Fenway, Not homer-crazy, but insanely hitter-friendly overall, singles into doubles off the Monstah, High BABIP.
Medic – I was going off of statcast’s Park Factor, which defaults to using a 3 year rolling average.
In addition to these three, I’m surprised to see Arizona and Minnesota at the top of the list. Not sure what other parks I expected, but it wasn’t those.
Rockies have tried this recently and went from bad but fun to historically awful and unwatchable.
You’re full of it.
The Red Sox can have James Triantos for a cup of (in the voice of Ace Ventura) New England Clam Chowder. And a liter of cola
Liter is French for ‘give me some f-ing cola’
If they really want Marte, something around Campbell, Tolle and/or Abreu might work.. The first 2 don’t really have a spot on the big league club and Abreu is redundant.
Sox should package young pitching & a prospect to acquire the desired infield bat. Trading the likes of Duran or Abreu for a bat is not the offensive leap forward required in Boston. Further, I will personally drive Yoshida to any other big league city if the Sox are able to rid themselves of the light-hitting DH.
What about Luis Rengifo?
Nico Hoerner is an elite defensive 2b. I believe he’s also really good at SS too. If the Red Sox did trade for him would it make more sense to put him at short and move Story to second?
Yes it would.
Cubs want too much for Hoerner who is a free agent after this season. Shaw is the one to target.
They want infielders, they should have pursued Arreaz. They seem to want to play small ball, anyways.
I mentioned Arraez previously but not if you truly prioritizing defense.
We got our guy!
Tsung Che-Cheng. The missing piece. He crushed minor league pitching last year with a whopping .207 batting average and 1 homer spanning over 400 plate appearances.
Rumor has it, there’s an inner Roberto Alomar-hurricane of 2B talent just waiting to be unleashed from within Tsung Che-Chung
Sadly, Darragh McDonald succumbs to the oft-repeated but outdated & inaccurate assessment of Romy Gonzalez at 2B: “González has value but is mostly a short-side platoon guy who can beat up lefties.”
Gonzalez certainly mashes lefties (2025: AVG:.331; OBP:.378). But he’s no slouch vs. righties either (.286;.318)
Those numbers best IKF by a wide margin: (vs. lefties: AVG:.227;OBP:.250; vs. righties:.250;.315).
So Romy is the better choice at the plate, including against righties.
In the field, at 2B, IKF’s Fielding% = .987, only a few points better than Romy’s .980.
Meanwhile, Mayer, though southpaws pretty much have his number (.185;.231), did outhit Gonzalez vs. righties (.294;.446). And in a small sample size, boasted a 2B F% = 1.000.
I suppose you could play Romy at 2B vs. lefties & Mayer vs. righties. (But then what happens to Cora’s expressed intention of having Mayer concentrate & settle in to one primary field position (presumably 3B)?
Even then, if Mayer plays 2B against righties, I’d prefer to see Nate Eaton at 3B, rather than IKF: vs. lefties,.279;.347; vs. righties,.316;.350).
At 3B, Eaton had a F% last season of .979, compared to IKF’s .964.)
Overall by my lights, the best outlook is with Gonzalez as the starting 2Bman vs. both lefties & righties; & Mayer at 3B, with Eaton to spell him there if his plate production against lefties doesn’t improve.
And Breslow need not continue to search for a right-handed hitting infielder. He’s already got one.
When the Red Sox had elite hitters (J.D. Martinez, Devers, Schwarber), fans complained that Boston had terrible defense, led the MLB in errors, and lacked starting pitchers.
Breslow has solved the pitching and defense problems, and now fans are complaining that the Red Sox don’t have an elite hitter.
While the Red Sox have a fairly well-rounded hitting lineup, there’s bound to be someone who puts up a strong, elite offensive performance this season if they stay healthy.
Story, Abreu, Anthony, Duran, Contreras, Rafaela, Narvaez, Casas – these are potential players who can hit 20+ home runs in a full season, and some of them 30 (Abreu, Anthony, Casas).
Breslow has not solved the infield defense problem.