Headlines

  • Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base
  • Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton
  • Cubs To Promote Cade Horton
  • Mariners Claim Leody Taveras
  • Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach
  • A.J. Minter To Undergo Season-Ending Lat Surgery
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Cubs Looking At Trades For Top Closers

By Mark Polishuk | December 5, 2015 at 4:38pm CDT

The Cubs are “actively exploring a trade for” a star closer, ESPN’s Jerry Crasnick reports (Twitter link).  Most of the speculation surrounding the Cubs this winter has been focused on their search for pitching or outfield help, as Chicago’s bullpen was strong last year and current closer Hector Rondon has posted two seasons of excellent relief work.

Rondon did run into some difficulties in May of last season, though those struggles essentially consisted of two rough weeks that include two of his four blown saves.  Otherwise, Rondon was mostly spotless, as evidenced by a tiny 0.88 ERA and 51 strikeouts (against just 10 walks) over his last 51 regular season innings.  Pushing Rondon to a setup role would, theoretically, make the Cubs’ relief corps even stronger and closer to the Royals model of a shutdown bullpen that shortens games.

Aroldis Chapman, Andrew Miller, Mark Melancon, Ken Giles, Jonathan Papelbon, Jake McGee and Brad Boxberger are some of the closers who have been floated as trade candidates in what has been a crowded relief market this offseason, with Craig Kimbrel and Francisco Rodriguez already changing teams.  Chapman and Melancon could be difficult fits for the Cubs, however, depending on how the Reds and Pirates feel about dealing within the NL Central.

Share 40 Retweet 7 Send via email0

Chicago Cubs Hector Rondon

Free Agent Profile: Ian Desmond
Main
Bullpen Notes: Storen, Sipp, Astros, Rodney, Soria, Soriano
View Comments (147)
Post a Comment

147 Comments

  1. Matt Galvin

    9 years ago

    Soler,Torres,Dan V. for McGee,Jennings and SP? Cubs get a CF,Closer and maybe Cobb or Moore.
    Greg Holland cost nobody off your Roster.

    Reply
    • MLB4LIFE

      9 years ago

      HAHA..Matt are you trying to be funny?

      Reply
    • justinept

      9 years ago

      Torres and Soler aren’t likely to be dealt in a package unless a potential ace is involved …

      Reply
      • stepupjays

        9 years ago

        Not sure I would make that deal either however Cobb is an ace

        Reply
    • dkonkow24

      9 years ago

      i don’t think Torres and Soler would go to Tampa for any starter unless Archer were involved

      Reply
    • deucebaseman

      9 years ago

      Yea if that SP is Chris Archer

      Reply
      • Logjammer D"Baggagecling

        9 years ago

        They had archer they traded him and 4 others for Garza. They should had called him up when they had him.

        Reply
        • chesteraarthur

          9 years ago

          Yeah, cuz he was totally ready for MLB then.

          Reply
          • Logjammer D"Baggagecling

            9 years ago

            What’s the difference. The cubs were terrible there was no reason no to see what kind of stuff he had. Shark was brought up way to early. Castro was brought up to save jim Hendrys job he was called up way too early. You never will see what players can do unless they are called up. Cubs for years were known to call up players and all they did was play once a week with a once a month start. They did this won’t brian lahair he was way better then the aging Derek Lee but he refused to sit out. Both him and Ramirez refused to be traded to a winning team. Ramirez was one of the laziest players ever tbats why he refused to be traded. Which is why he took his contract to free agency.

            Reply
        • Benjamin 2

          9 years ago

          So they traded him. So what?

          Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      Greg Holland also doesn’t pitch in an MLB game until 2017.

      Reply
    • Logjammer D"Baggagecling

      9 years ago

      Soler isn’t going anywhere

      Reply
    • chicubbies1

      9 years ago

      If that starting pitcher is Chris Archer, then you have yourself a deal.

      Reply
  2. mike156

    9 years ago

    Papelbon to Chicago is so strange it might work. You would have to deal with the money, and I don’t think Washington can actually just give him away, but it’s interesting in some sort of a package

    Reply
    • justinept

      9 years ago

      Cubs have long been believed to be going for two starters, one through free agency (lackey) and another via trade. Under this plan, Hammel is expendable and his $9 million salary might work out in a potential Papelbon deal… Not sure I like that for either team, though.

      Reply
    • cubs101wins

      9 years ago

      I was thinking Papelbon also because of the Theo and Jed connection from Boston. I wouldn’t want to give much at all for him because when he became a clubhouse cancer again they could just cut ties and move on from him he is as much of a POS as Milton Bradley was.

      Reply
    • deucebaseman

      9 years ago

      The Cubs front office is all about team chemistry and guys with class. Papelbon will go no where near this team.

      Reply
      • yourfacedude

        9 years ago

        winning cures chemistry problems….especially with papelbon

        Reply
    • smelliott00

      9 years ago

      I absolutely hate the Cubs but I agree that Papelbon to Chicago actually makes a lot of sense. Comfortable with Lester and Epstein and would be the lock down presence they need.

      Reply
      • justinept

        9 years ago

        Lester, lackey and Papelbon just has too much 2011 Red Sox feel to it for my liking

        Reply
        • twitchwashere 2

          9 years ago

          Hm, just Lackey by himself is enough to make me twitch nervously.

          Reply
      • chicubbies1

        9 years ago

        The thing is they already have a lockdown presence in the 9th inning in Rondon. He quietly has become one of the best closers in the game over the last 2 seasons. The numbers don’t lie. Of all the closers out there not only does he have a sparkling ERA, FIP, and WHIP the last 2 years, but he also walks probably the fewest batters per 9 or close to the fewest while striking out 9/9IP as well. In fact, in this small sample size of 2 years as closer his numbers are pretty similar to Mariano Rivera’s….. yet he gets Rodney Dangerfielded all the time….. no respect, no respect at all.

        Last 2 seasons for Rondon
        2.03 ERA, 59 for 67 in save opps. 2.48 FIP, 1.03 WHIP, 2BB/9IP, and 8.9K/9IP.

        Chapman (considered best closer going today) last 2 years
        1.80 ERA, 69 for 74 in save opps, 1.47 FIP, 1.00 WHIP, 4.3 BB/9IP, and 16.6K/9IP

        Pretty similar other than the FIP. Yeah, Chapman strikes out more guys than rondon…. almost double….. but he also walks twice as many guys in the process as well. Their WHIPs are identical though. Rondon has an 88% success rate in save opps. to Chapman’s 93% success rate. Kimbrel has a 91% success rate over the last 2 years….. so Rondon is in the neighborhood with the best in successfully closing out a game.

        Kimbrel’s ERA, WHIP, and FIP are pretty similar to Rondon’s over the last 2 years as well. He also strikes out more guys but not as much as Chapman, but he too walks more guys than Rondon but not as much as Chapman.

        Between Rondon, Chapman, and Kimbrel over the last 2 years here is their ERA+ over the last 2 years. I leave it to you which belongs to which pitcher….. you might be surprised.

        190, 175, 214

        I’ll tell you right now, 214 belongs to Chapman.

        Reply
    • crazymountain

      9 years ago

      Papelbon would be poison in the great atmosphere that the Cubs have right now. They could have done a trade for him last year and declined to do so. Papelbon is an egocentric idiot, past his best years and would not improve the quality of the team or its bullpen. Poison.

      Reply
    • chicubbies1

      9 years ago

      I’ve read several articles that say that Papelbon is untradeable. Not because Washington doesn’t want to trade him, quite the contrary actually, but because other teams view him as a liability…… because he put bratty Harper in his place in the dugout on live TV. I say he is very worth the taking and i don’t think it costs more than Jason hammel to get him. Nats get rid of Papelbon which they really want to do so they can aggressively go after Chapman and get rid of the guy who picked on pretty boy Harper and in the process shave $2M off payroll since P-bon makes $11M in 2016 to Hammel’s $9M. Hammel also provides them 5th starter competition after Scherzer, Stras, Gonzo, and Roark in the rotation. Cubs get another stellar reliever in their already stellar bullpen…….. which is why I don’t see the point in any of this. Rondon is one of the best closers in the game. I don’t get why the front office and Joe Maddon have a hard time seeing that. Rondon had 2 bad outings in May…. that’s it. Because of those games though he pulled him from the full time closer gig for like a MONTH. Take those 2 bad outings off the books and Rondon pitched in 70 games last year for 68 innings with a 1.05 ERA. How much better can a closer get. He had an ERA of roughly 1.67 all year. Was 30 for 34 in save opportunities and that was being removed from the gig for a month of the season. He easily could have had 40+ saves in 2015 had Maddon just showed a bit more faith in him. Over the last 2 years as closer…. granted it is super early in Rondon’s career, but his numbers are very Mariano Rivera like. He has like a 2.05 ERA, a 2.40ish FIP, a 1.05 WHIP, and is 59 for 67 in save chances. 4 blown saves each the last 2 years….. Mariano averaged about 4 blown saves a year. He, also like Rivera, has about a 9K/9 rate and a 2BB/9 rate which is a stellar walk rate for not only a closer but also a reliever in general. And they want to replace this guy with a “top closer”…… they already have one for ****s sake.

      Reply
  3. DW

    9 years ago

    I wonder what the Padres could’ve gotten from the Cubs for Kimbrel. I assume it would have had to include one of Baez or Castro. Red Sox did give up a lot though.

    Reply
  4. adshadbolt

    9 years ago

    I think Giles. McGee. and Storen and paplebon together are the only real options.

    Reply
    • ammiel

      9 years ago

      i think the cubs could make a real run at aroldis. If that fails Melancon would be amongst those you mentioned also.

      Reply
  5. clpoli1975

    9 years ago

    This entire story makes zero sense. Rondon was as good as one could be as a closer last season and had one bad two week stretch in May. This makes zero sense.

    Reply
    • PhilliesPhan08

      9 years ago

      There are a lot of funny cubs fans on here

      Reply
      • jtt11 2

        9 years ago

        The above comparison of rondon to Mariano Rivera was priceless…

        Reply
  6. jimbo504 2

    9 years ago

    Sure would be nice if Mozeliak would make a move.

    Reply
    • tim815

      9 years ago

      I think he’s done a great job so far.

      Reply
      • johnnya

        9 years ago

        And that is what? Let lackey go to rival Cubs!?? Our best pitcher last year!

        Reply
        • jimbo504 2

          9 years ago

          tim is clearly a cub fan.

          Reply
  7. Eric D.

    9 years ago

    Kimbrel for Soler and Gleyber Torres. Seems ridiculous? Agreed. About as ridiculous as giving up Margot and Guerra PLUS two other decent prospects for him!!! GRRRRR Dombrowski. the Cubs are going to make you look even dumber.

    Reply
  8. wilymo

    9 years ago

    “Most of the speculation surrounding the Cubs this winter has been focused on their search for pitching or outfield help, as Chicago’s bullpen was strong last year”

    does bullpen work not count as “pitching”

    Reply
    • justinept

      9 years ago

      Pretty sure they specifically said “multiple starters”

      Reply
      • justinept

        9 years ago

        … They being the Cubs front office

        Reply
  9. HopefulTwinsFan

    9 years ago

    I’d love it if the Cubs took Perkins away from the Twins… But that’s not gonna happen. They could make a run at Chapman during the Winter Meetings.

    Reply
  10. slider32

    9 years ago

    Baez for Miller.

    Reply
    • cubs101wins

      9 years ago

      pfffff

      Reply
  11. link2217

    9 years ago

    Miller and Gardner for Edwards, Castro, strop, almora???

    Reply
    • MLB4LIFE

      9 years ago

      That would center around what the Cubs FO really thinks about Almora.Defensively he is MLB ready,waiting on that bat to catch up tho.

      Reply
      • justinept

        9 years ago

        So much thump in the lineup, tho. Not sure they need anything more than a .300 OBP from Almora.

        Reply
    • yanks02026

      9 years ago

      Yankees could match up real well with the Cubs for a trade.

      Reply
      • ammiel

        9 years ago

        Miller and Gardner for Baez makes sense.

        Reply
        • lukeski4

          9 years ago

          Yanks want young starters, not more middle infielders. And Miller is only getting traded for one hell of a package.

          You’d be lucky to get Gardner for Baez b

          Reply
    • cubs101wins

      9 years ago

      this is the 2nd dumbest thing I have read all day.

      Reply
    • coreytburk

      9 years ago

      You’re joking, right?

      Reply
      • link2217

        9 years ago

        Like stated above it depends on how the Cubs FO feels about almora. Personally I’m not as high on him as most. Still seems fair on both sides. Basically Castro for Gardner and two prospects for Miller is the price of a good closer. Strop just as a sweetener to maybe get cash from Yankees to cover gardeners cost.

        Reply
  12. Thegreatandpowerfulsimba

    9 years ago

    Grilli, Vizzy, Folty, Cabrerra… Pick two and Miller and get a trade done b4 the dodgers beat you to the punch

    Reply
  13. piratefan17

    9 years ago

    Melancon for Schwarber lol I wish

    Reply
    • jleve618

      9 years ago

      No NL team should want Schwarber, he’s a DH.

      Reply
  14. Ken M.

    9 years ago

    Kris Bryant for Gardner and Miller.

    Reply
    • justinept

      9 years ago

      Jesus Christ…

      Reply
    • MLB4LIFE

      9 years ago

      Just throw in Arieta,Schwarber and Addison and make it a clean sweep lol

      Reply
      • Ken M.

        9 years ago

        6 years of below market All-star players for 6 years of Bryant?

        Reply
        • justinept

          9 years ago

          …I thought you said they’d be getting Miller and Gardner though.

          Reply
        • jedihoyer

          9 years ago

          24 yr old, vs aging OF and solid closer at market rate, they aren’t below market rate. so 100 mil surplus value for breakeven, yeah no thanks.

          Reply
        • chesteraarthur

          9 years ago

          Yeah cuz Bryant isn’t a below market all-star player or anything…

          Reply
      • Logjammer D"Baggagecling

        9 years ago

        And why not Rizzo for teixeira too. Aging declining first baseman for one of the top players in the league.

        Reply
      • jleve618

        9 years ago

        Arieta will be terrible next year, Schwarber doesn’t have a position, and Addison, well he might have some value. Bryant is way overrated though. That guys proposed deal sucks, but the cubs roster is not as good as people make it out to be.

        Reply
    • Eric D.

      9 years ago

      And people say Red Sox fans trade proposals are ridiculous…

      Reply
    • Otto371

      9 years ago

      may god have mercy on your soul

      Reply
    • cubs101wins

      9 years ago

      that is the dumbest thing I have seen all day.

      Reply
    • raiders

      9 years ago

      That is the funniest thing I’ve ready all day. Thanks!

      Reply
    • beyou02215

      9 years ago

      This would never ever ever happen.

      Reply
      • aff10

        9 years ago

        Man people, this guy’s a troll. He does this all the time. He’s not serious about that

        Reply
  15. Blah blah blah

    9 years ago

    I don’t believe this report at all. From Rondon, a rule 5 pick, Strop a throw-in in a trade, Rodney, Cahill, Richard, Brothers, it is apparent that Chicago’s strategy for relief pitching is to acquire them cheaply due to the volatile nature of the relief pitcher.

    Reply
    • csamson11

      9 years ago

      Based on separate reports Rodney looks to return to his role as a closer and Cahill would like to return to a starting role, which simply aren’t going to happen with the Cubs. They can certainly do better than Rondon as he isn’t a top of the line closer (by no means is he bad though,) so maybe their plan is to acquire such a closer and then fill in around him with cheap arms.

      Reply
      • twitchwashere 2

        9 years ago

        Outside of Chapman, no, they really can’t do better than Rondon. He is very close to top of the line.

        Reply
        • jtt11 2

          9 years ago

          No he really isn’t. Miller, oday, Jansen, chapman, Davis, Robertson, rosenthal, Perkins, betancesMcGee, Kimbel, melancon, familia are all better. Rondon is more at the aj Ramos/ty clippard level

          Reply
    • jedihoyer

      9 years ago

      that was when they werent planning on competing.

      Reply
    • t_o__n_y

      9 years ago

      Strop was not a throw in, Cahill and Richard are former starters. And when the Cubs acquired Richard from the Pirates in July for cash, he was used as a starter after Wada became injured.

      Reply
    • EB

      9 years ago

      Except that there is value in playoff baseball for the elite relief guys. Chapman for example. When you have a solid base it can may make sense to invest more money in your bull pen.

      I really wanted the Cubs to acquire Kimbrell but the Red Sox went too far. I’d part with a couple top prospects for a year of Chapman, however.

      Reply
  16. csamson11

    9 years ago

    If this is true, hopefully they use prospects instead of the likes of Castro, Baez, and/or Soler.

    Reply
  17. ironnat

    9 years ago

    Seems obvious that a front line closer like Papelbon would not want to be a set up man. Storen would be a good fit.

    Reply
  18. Voice of Reason

    9 years ago

    Papelbon for hammels.
    Papelbon makes $11 million in his final year and hammels makes $10 million in final year.
    Done

    Reply
    • mdvorak

      9 years ago

      I’d rather have Soren

      Reply
      • Brixton

        9 years ago

        Then its going to to cost you more than Hammel.

        Reply
    • ammiel

      9 years ago

      Is papelbon going to fit in with a very young roster? I dont think he fits the chemistry makeup of the team.

      Reply
  19. Brixton

    9 years ago

    Ken Giles for Starlin Castro, CJ Edwards and cash?
    Seems like that could fit for both clubs.

    Reply
    • cubs101wins

      9 years ago

      said the guy wearing the leather helmet.

      Reply
      • Brixton

        9 years ago

        What? Would you not be happy with this deal from a Cubs standpoint?

        Reply
        • link2217

          9 years ago

          cubs take this deal before the Phillies do I’m sure. As a Cubs fan I’d be happy with it. All the homers somehow believe they can get talent for scraps or that all their prospects are future HOFers. If the Cubs trade for a top closer be prepared to lose some good prospects.

          Reply
    • Philliesfan4life

      9 years ago

      I think giles or miller would fit the cubs best, but giles is cheaper and the phillies are rebuilding.

      Reply
    • eilexx

      9 years ago

      What would the Phillies want with Starlin Castro? Their top prospect is a shortstop, and Starlin, quite simply, is not that good. He’s decent, but not an all-star, regardless of how many times Cubs fans want to say it.

      Reply
      • Philliesfan4life

        9 years ago

        they can put Castro at second

        Reply
      • Brixton

        9 years ago

        He can play 2B. Who do the Phillies have there?
        Cesar Hernandez…?
        If the Cubs threw in enough money to make him cheap, he has value.
        Hernandez and Utley combined for 0.4 WAR last year, and they have no notable 2B prospects.

        Reply
        • eilexx

          9 years ago

          “If the Cubs threw in enough money to make him cheap, he has value.”

          Not to the Phillies. Giles has more value to them than Castro would. Not a good match.

          Reply
          • Brixton

            9 years ago

            If the Phillies can get an everyday 2B and a potential SP or good reliever for Giles, then its a win.

            Reply
      • ammiel

        9 years ago

        He would add depth and can play a utility role. Not only shortstop.

        Reply
        • eilexx

          9 years ago

          But again, the main point I was making, is Castro is simply not that good. He’s not a huge upgrade for them, not someone who’s going to change their course, so why bother? Giles has more value to them than that, and they have no need to trade him.

          Reply
          • ammiel

            9 years ago

            Yeah i agree. I think houston or pittsburgh are more viable fits for giles services.

            Reply
    • coreytburk

      9 years ago

      Finally a reasonable trade proposal.

      Reply
    • EB

      9 years ago

      As a Cub fan I’d do that but I think the Phillies will want a lot more, especially since they have Crawford to play at short.

      I think a Soler and Edwards package might intrigue the Phills and I’d seriously consider that if I were the Cubs.

      Reply
    • jleve618

      9 years ago

      HAH! And cash? Do you think we need money? We eat salaries like it’s our job, we’re not the penny pinching mets.

      Reply
  20. Joe McMahon

    9 years ago

    I wonder if the Cubs have soured enough on Baez to trade him for Andrew Miller. As a Yankees fan,I would love to get a young guy with his upside. I understand if that’s too much to trade for a closer though.

    Reply
    • Philliesfan4life

      9 years ago

      I think that is a little too much for a closer, I think if the cubs are going to trade baez, it would be for a starter or an outfielder.

      Reply
      • Joe McMahon

        9 years ago

        Yeah, probably.

        Reply
        • Philliesfan4life

          9 years ago

          I heard there was a rumor of the angels trading Heaney for Gardner, I wouldn’t do that trade if I was the angels.

          Reply
          • Ray Ray

            9 years ago

            Don’t think of it as trading Heaney for Gardner. Think of it as trading Howie Kendrick for Gardner. I’d make that trade easily.

            Reply
    • chicubbies1

      9 years ago

      Cubs aren’t sour on any of their players, really. They’ve got to feel reeeaaaal comfortable with the return they get in a potential trade in order to pull the trigger. If Baez or Soler is traded it will likely be for a starting pitcher of similar age and MLB experience, with nearly equal upside. Not an expensive 30 year old setup man. Fact they’ve already got a statement making circulations that this winter and spring Baez will be playing CF to try it out makes me feel like if they even make a trade it will likely be Castro or Soler….. maybe. If Baez shows a hint of positive vibes out in CF this winter they’ll likely just sign a backup option for the OF and then sign another SP….. my guess is a one year deal to Latos or Fister…. or Cliff Lee…. or two of them or even all 3 and see who pitches the best in spring training and trade away the other two early in the 2016 season. Bottom line is, the Cubs don’t NEED to make a trade this offseason. It’s just always been a possibility…. but that is the case every offseason. People, myself included, have gotten carried away, starting to talk like it is a foregone conclusion that the Cubs WILL make a trade. Rotation as of today is Arrieta, Lester, Lackey, Hendricks, and Hammel….. that’s a good rotation. Their bullpen is stacked. All but 1 starting position gig is set, but with the announcement about Baez even makes CF possibly filled. All they DESPERATELY need is maybe a starting CFer/lead-off hitter. I won’t be shocked if they re-sign Fowler to a 3-4 year deal. Likely a 3 year deal if he’s still on the market if he is still available late in the offseason. We’re only about 10 weeks from pitchers and catchers meeting up for spring training. If Fowler is still available in 5 weeks I bet they can ink him to a 3 year deal. MLBTR has him signing a 4 year $60M deal in their predictions. If he’s available mid-late January I bet the Cubs can get him for 3 years and $45-48M.

      Reply
  21. gwreck209

    9 years ago

    Don’t you even think about it Billy Beane.

    Reply
  22. ammiel

    9 years ago

    I think the cubs might pursue a trade for mark melancon, maybe for an young bat like alcantara or szczur.

    Reply
  23. Aaron Sapoznik

    9 years ago

    For the life of me, I don’t know why a closer would be a priority for the Cubs this offseason. Hector Rondon profiles as a top closer with his stuff and demeanor and he has already established himself as one of the better ones in MLB.

    That being said, if the Cubs are so “hot to trot” for one as the article suggests, why not call the White Sox? GM Rick Hahn has already indicated he would be willing to listen on any offer for any of his players, that nobody was untouchable. The White Sox and Cubs already match up well with the south siders having some desirable depth in their starting rotation that might be available to a Cub team looking for more quality. Chris Sale or Jose Quintana would certainly fit the bill for the Cubs.

    Theo an Jed might as well expand their parameters and inquire on David Robertson as a potential new veteran closer.

    Why stop there? The Cubs single biggest need following their signing of FA John Lackey is a CF and a lead-off man. How about Adam Eaton? He could do both!

    The Cubs and White Sox don’t trade very often, but it’s not like they refuse to do so. Hanukkah begins on Sunday, December 6th at sundown, on the eve of the winter meeting in Nashville. Theo Epstein and Rick Hahn could celebrate together by exchanging gifts, perhaps creating the biggest blockbuster ever between the two clubs with so many potential pieces involved that each club would covet from the other.

    As a rare die-hard fan of both franchises in Chicago since the early 1960’s, I would welcome such a possibility with the hopes that both teams could improve and reach the postseason on a regular basis going forward, something I have not experienced much in my 60 years of watching baseball.

    Reply
    • ammiel

      9 years ago

      Which white sox closer do you suggest is a fit?

      Reply
      • Philliesfan4life

        9 years ago

        I think the white sox can contend this year if they get off to a good start

        Reply
        • ammiel

          9 years ago

          Agreed. I think they need one more good rotation arm though a kennedy or chen type.

          Reply
          • Philliesfan4life

            9 years ago

            they could trade baez for robertson or somebody else, they have a hole at ss.

            Reply
      • Aaron Sapoznik

        9 years ago

        Did I not mention David Robertson?

        Reply
    • Overbrook

      9 years ago

      What ML ready prospects do the Cubs have to trade? No one wants Castro for that $ and years. Baez is high risk. Who else?

      Reply
      • ammiel

        9 years ago

        Arismendy alcantara is one. A few arms with limited big league experience like cj edwards or neil ramirez. Szczur.

        Reply
        • antonio__27

          9 years ago

          Ken Giles, Nick Williams for Starlin Castro, Corey Black, Albert Almora

          Reply
          • Brixton

            9 years ago

            Phillies aren’t trading Nick Williams

            Reply
      • Aaron Sapoznik

        9 years ago

        No team in baseball possesses more MLB ready positional prospects than the Cubs. Few teams in MLB need as as much help with their batting order and afield as the White Sox. Both teams have been viewed as excellent matches this offseason by the media in Chicago and that has also been acknowledged by each of the front offices.

        Who to trade and what prospects? Depends on how big a deal the teams might pursue.

        The Cubs needs would clearly indicate an interest in Chris Sale or Jose Quintana as rotation possibilities, David Robertson as a closer and Adam Eaton as a lead-off hitting CF.

        The White Sox need more offense and power in their feeble batting order and specifically can use upgrades at 3B or corner OF to satisfy it. They would certainly have an interest in players such as Kyle Schwarber, Jorge Soler and Javier Baez who could man those positions. The White Sox also need a short term solution at SS until their #1 prospect Tim Anderson is deemed ready for prime time, which is probably 2017 as well as potential help at 2B pending the development of Carlos Sanchez and Micah Johnson. These targets are all MLB ready. The White Sox might also have an interest in some of the top Cub prospects who are not quite ready for their MLB debuts, like CF Albert Almora (a return in a potential Eaton trade) and LF Billy McKinney, among others.

        The White Sox have organizational depth in pitching that could potentially cover the loss of Sale, Quintana and Robertson now or down the road. That might include Carlos Rodon, Carson Fulmer and Frankie Montas, as well as others. They also have Trayce Thompson who can cover CF short term and other prospects who might take over in the future, like Jacob May and Adam Engel.

        Bottom line: I’m not necessarily advocating trades between the two clubs, just that the potential is there to make them happen, some combination of which could benefit both clubs significantly.

        Reply
        • ammiel

          9 years ago

          You make valid points. I think eaton and robertson for soler works.

          Reply
          • soxhatz

            9 years ago

            Quintana and Robertson for Schwarber

            Reply
    • HalosFan

      9 years ago

      Adam eaton is hot garbage

      Reply
      • Aaron Sapoznik

        9 years ago

        Maybe compared to Mike Trout, Mr. Angel fan.

        Fact is, Adam Eaton’s WAR numbers the past two seasons might say otherwise. His 9.9 metric exceeds that of slugging teammate Jose Abreu, who sports a 9.3 WAR over the same time period. Both numbers suggest All-Star capability and ought to improve given their short MLB careers thus far.

        Reply
        • Ray Ray

          9 years ago

          That’s because WAR overrates center fielders and underrates first basemen just because of their position. I’d bet if you polled all 30 GMs, at least 28 of them would take Abreu over Eaton.

          Reply
        • Aaron Sapoznik

          9 years ago

          Correction: Adam Eaton’s career WAR is 9.9, his WAR over the past 2 seasons is 9.1, still about the same as Jose Abreu’s.

          Reply
  24. crazymountain

    9 years ago

    Actually, Bryant is the best CF the Cubs have on the roster right now. I’m not a fan of Baez and think he could be wrapped in a package to get a MLB ready CF and another starting P, young with a live arm.

    Reply
  25. clark9jhu

    9 years ago

    Soler for Giles, Cubs get younger of options with team control for years and Phils get a corner outfielder they desperately need

    Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      Phillies would probably take it, don’t think the Cubs would.
      FYI; the corner outfield is probably the least needed spot for the Phillies.
      They have Bourjos for 2016, Altherr, Williams, Quinn, Randolph and Herrera all as long-term outfielders if they develop properly.

      Reply
  26. Logjammer D"Baggagecling

    9 years ago

    Do not over pay for papelbom he’s a hothead and overrated.

    Reply
  27. antonio__27

    9 years ago

    Ken Giles, Nick Williams for Starlin Castro, Corey Black, Albert Almora

    Reply
    • dylanp5030

      9 years ago

      i don’t think Phillies even think about trading Williams right now. Just doesn’t make sense. If they like Black, they could take him in the Rule 5 draft.

      Reply
  28. EB

    9 years ago

    Would love to se the Cubs acquire Chapman. A lights out reliever to bolster the pen would help offset missing out on the top starters available this season.

    Reply
    • dhud

      9 years ago

      Would hate to see Chapman traded within the division. If the Reds did that, they had better take a king’s ransom from Chicago

      Reply
    • CascadianAbroad

      9 years ago

      Have to give him and Rizzo lockers on opposite sides of that new locker room! 😉

      Reply
  29. beyou02215

    9 years ago

    Paps is on his way out on a rail in DC. He would fit the Cubs nicely for a year. And I imagine that he would come very, very cheap, although not $-wise.

    Reply
  30. gomerhodge71

    9 years ago

    I smell an Epstein-Papelbon reunion.

    Reply
  31. babycubsW

    9 years ago

    While it is fun to hash up trade rumors . I don’t believe anything this article has to say and Pap to the Cubs is just not gonna happen, he is a cancer and won’t be signed until after Spring training, if then.

    Reply
    • dhud

      9 years ago

      Papelbon isn’t a free agent; no “signing” to be done

      Reply
  32. chesteraarthur

    9 years ago

    It makes no sense for the cubs to trade for any of these closers who are at market rate. If they wanted that, they could just sign o’day. If they are going after a closer, it is someone that is younger or on a below market contract.

    Reply
  33. cubsfever

    9 years ago

    Anyone ever thought about this: The Cardinals have lots of shoulder injuries: Wainwright, Carpenter, Martinez, Lynn. I am sure I’m missing some. And yes, many times someone steps up, but I am predicting a down year for the Cardinals. Unless they sign Cueto (probably not going to happen) or Leake, it’s going to be rough potentially.

    Reply
    • CascadianAbroad

      9 years ago

      That’s what everyone said last year…

      Reply
  34. cubsfever

    9 years ago

    My thought to solidify the rotation and not have to trade players or spend more money this year is to stretch out Carl Edwards Jr. He was a stud before his injury. Players bounce back and if he shows what he showed before, he could slot as a four and bump Hammel or Hendricks out. Stretch him out in Winter League ball.

    Reply
  35. clooz

    9 years ago

    If I’m Theo and Co. I’m gonna make damn sure I sign Greg Holland (2 years, laden with incentives) and then acquire a guy like Melancon or even Giles. Allow the latter to close, and if Holland can find his magic again, give him a shot at the job.

    Reply
  36. AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres

    9 years ago

    To be honest the Cubs should trade Arrieta at this point. His value will never be higher, he’s only 2 years out from free agency and he’s not likely to take an extension.

    Reply
    • jleve618

      9 years ago

      I agree. 2015 was a fluke, and in no world should he have won the Cy Young.

      Reply
  37. chicubbies1

    9 years ago

    I don’t understand the desire for a closer or any bullpen help for that matter. Rondon, Strop, Ramirez, Grimm, Wood, and Edwards are solid already and quite possibly one of the best bullpens in the game innings SIX through 9 with Grimm, Ramirez, Strop, and Rondon. Ramirez in 2014 was lights out. Strop and Ramirez could easily be labeled setup man 1a and setup man 1b. Wood showed he is a pretty stellar reliever seeing his K rate skyrocket in the pen and pitching to a 2.95 ERA in like 45 or so appearances.

    As they currently stand Hammel and Hendricks are in the rotation, but if they get another bona fide starting pitcher my guess is Hammel slips into the bullpen meaning Edwards goes back to triple A unless they carry 8 relievers….. or becomes trade bait. Hammel as the 7th reliever makes a stellar bullpen…… However, if they were to sign or trade for another starter trading Hammel and his $9M 2016 salary for Papelbon and his $11M salary makes sense for both teams. Washington doesn’t like or want Papelbon because he put their cocky pretty boy in his place (which I loved), and from the way reports make it sound will take almost anything for him in order to aggressively go after Chapman. Cubs get a solid reliever, Nats shave $2 mil off payroll and get a 5th starter candidate in hammel behind Scherzer, Strasburg, Gonzalez, and Roark. Cubs Bullpen would then be Rondon, Papelbon, Strop, Ramirez, Grimm, Wood, and Edwards. With Richard and Brothers as potential replacements if Edwards turns out to be a bust. In his VERY VERY limited showing in 2015 Edwards looked shaky. With Rondon, Papelbon, Strop, Ramirez, and Grimm the last 3 innings are pretty much doomsday for opposing teams which is awesome to have and to think about……. but is it really a necessity? They’re already stellar as is. Seems like a wanted move for the sake of making a move. DEFINITELY not a need. I don’t get why they want to replace Rondon who is quietly one of the best closers in the game. Had Maddon not been so quick to lose faith over that BREIF stretch when he struggled he would’ve had over 40 saves and a sub-2 ERA. That’s elite status. in his 72 appearances last year he had 4 games allowing 2 or more runs….. he only had 8 games when he allowed any runs. So in the month of May in which he “struggled” it was more like just 2 bad games he had in which he allowed 3 and 2 ERs. take those 2 bad games off his 2015 season and he pitched in 70 other games for 68 innings to the tune of a 1.05 ERA…… again, elite. I don’t want to compare him to Mariano Rivera so early in his career, but his 9K/9IP and very low (for a reliever) 2BB/9IP the last 2 years as closer is very Mariano Rivera-like. his 2.03 ERA, 2.48 FIP, and 1.03 WHIP is also very Mariano Rivera-like the last 2 seasons…….. So why do the want to replace that again?

    The Papelbon for Hammel deal makes the most sense. But if they were to get Papelbon he’d almost likely demand and whine to be the closer and they’d likely comply despite Rondon being much more deserving of that role. Rondon is as good if not better than all the guys listed as potential targets. I don’t get why you replace him. It sounds like I’m pleading for Rondon out of fairness, which is partially how I feel, but more importantly it just makes no sense.

    It would be like if the Cubs signed both Zimmermann and Price this offseason making their rotation Price, Arrieta, Lester, Zimmermann, and Hendricks…… then them saying that they want to target one more top starting pitcher…… why?

    Reply
  38. chicubbies1

    9 years ago

    2.03 ERA, 59 for 67 in save opps. 2.48 FIP, 1.03 WHIP, 2BB/9IP, and 8.9K/9IP

    That’s the STELLAR stat line Rondon has produced in the last 2 years as a closer. The save total and opportunities would be about 10 higher a piece had maddon not been so quick in 2015 to pull him out of the full time closer’s gig for like a month last year. Rondon’s ERA+ for the last 2 years is 190….. compare that to Kimbrel’s 175. In fact, other than the number of saves and opportunities differences between Kimbrel and Rondon they have pretty similar stats the last 2 years. While Kimbrel strikes out more guys than Rondon, he also walks way more as well. I don’t get why they have no respect and little faith in Rondon to say they are looking to trade for a top closer…. THEY ALREADY HAVE ONE. Adjusted ERA or ERA+ For Kimbrel, Rondon, and Chapman is as follows: 175, 190, and 214.

    Reply
  39. twitchwashere 2

    9 years ago

    Not a fan of this at all. I feel like Rondon is already on the verge of being a top level closer, and none of the rest still on the board (aside from Chapman, who isn’t realistically attainable anyway) strike me as a definitively better 9th inning option. I’d be fine with getting Giles or McGee to be setup men, but no one left (again, besides Chapman, which ain’t happening) has any business automatically bumping Rondon.

    Also, the idea of Papelbon to the Cubs (or literally anywhere else with an established closer, for that matter) needs to be killed with fire immediately, if not sooner. We’ve already seen that Hindenburg-esque disaster play out once, and it should’ve put the fear of a vengeful god into every top ranking player personnel decision-maker in the league. I know some men just want to watch the world burn, but those men don’t have any business being GMs.

    Reply
  40. jleve618

    9 years ago

    Please don’t trade Giles. Please don’t trade Giles. Please don’t trade Giles.

    Reply
  41. dresman92

    9 years ago

    Like to see Storen in a cubs uniform. Not sure what it would take but a Almora and CJ Edwards might do it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

  • Top Stories
  • Recent

Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base

Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton

Cubs To Promote Cade Horton

Mariners Claim Leody Taveras

Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach

A.J. Minter To Undergo Season-Ending Lat Surgery

Blue Jays Sign Spencer Turnbull

Blue Jays Sign José Ureña

Ross Stripling Retires

Rangers Place Leody Taveras On Outright Waivers

Triston Casas Likely To Miss Entire 2025 Season Due To Knee Surgery

Orioles Recall Coby Mayo

Dodgers Recall Hyeseong Kim

Triston Casas Suffers “Significant Knee Injury”

Angels Place Mike Trout On 10-Day Injured List

Rangers Option Jake Burger

Tigers Designate Kenta Maeda For Assignment

Reds Option Alexis Diaz

Orioles Move Charlie Morton To Bullpen

Astros To Activate Lance McCullers Jr. This Weekend

Brewers Designate Vinny Capra For Assignment

The Biggest Trade In Nationals History Looks Better Every Day

Rangers Select Sam Haggerty

Rays Select Connor Seabold, Transfer Ha-Seong Kim To 60-Day IL

Front Office Subscriber Chat With Anthony Franco: Today At 2:00pm Central

Braves Designate Eddie Rosario For Assignment

Royals Notes: Outfield, Caglianone, Harvey

The Opener: Horton, Quintana, AL Central

Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base

Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton

ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

Latest Rumors & News

Latest Rumors & News

  • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
  • Nolan Arenado Rumors
  • Dylan Cease Rumors
  • Luis Robert Rumors
  • Marcus Stroman Rumors

 

Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

MLBTR Features

MLBTR Features

  • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
  • Front Office Originals
  • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
  • MLBTR Podcast
  • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
  • 2025 Arbitration Projections
  • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
  • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
  • Contract Tracker
  • Transaction Tracker
  • Extension Tracker
  • Agency Database
  • MLBTR On Twitter
  • MLBTR On Facebook
  • Team Facebook Pages
  • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

Rumors By Team

  • Angels Rumors
  • Astros Rumors
  • Athletics Rumors
  • Blue Jays Rumors
  • Braves Rumors
  • Brewers Rumors
  • Cardinals Rumors
  • Cubs Rumors
  • Diamondbacks Rumors
  • Dodgers Rumors
  • Giants Rumors
  • Guardians Rumors
  • Mariners Rumors
  • Marlins Rumors
  • Mets Rumors
  • Nationals Rumors
  • Orioles Rumors
  • Padres Rumors
  • Phillies Rumors
  • Pirates Rumors
  • Rangers Rumors
  • Rays Rumors
  • Red Sox Rumors
  • Reds Rumors
  • Rockies Rumors
  • Royals Rumors
  • Tigers Rumors
  • Twins Rumors
  • White Sox Rumors
  • Yankees Rumors

ad: 160x600_MLB

Navigation

  • Sitemap
  • Archives
  • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

MLBTR INFO

  • Advertise
  • About
  • Commenting Policy
  • Privacy Policy

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS Feed

MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

hide arrows scroll to top

Register

Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version