Headlines

  • Cubs To Promote Moises Ballesteros
  • Evan Longoria To Sign One-Day Contract, Retire As Member Of Rays
  • Diamondbacks To Promote Jordan Lawlar
  • Rockies Fire Bud Black
  • Cubs Promote Cade Horton
  • Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base
  • Previous
  • Next
Register
Login
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

MLB Trade Rumors

  • Home
  • Teams
    • AL East
      • Baltimore Orioles
      • Boston Red Sox
      • New York Yankees
      • Tampa Bay Rays
      • Toronto Blue Jays
    • AL Central
      • Chicago White Sox
      • Cleveland Guardians
      • Detroit Tigers
      • Kansas City Royals
      • Minnesota Twins
    • AL West
      • Houston Astros
      • Los Angeles Angels
      • Oakland Athletics
      • Seattle Mariners
      • Texas Rangers
    • NL East
      • Atlanta Braves
      • Miami Marlins
      • New York Mets
      • Philadelphia Phillies
      • Washington Nationals
    • NL Central
      • Chicago Cubs
      • Cincinnati Reds
      • Milwaukee Brewers
      • Pittsburgh Pirates
      • St. Louis Cardinals
    • NL West
      • Arizona Diamondbacks
      • Colorado Rockies
      • Los Angeles Dodgers
      • San Diego Padres
      • San Francisco Giants
  • About
    • MLB Trade Rumors
    • Tim Dierkes
    • Writing team
    • Advertise
    • Archives
  • Contact
  • Tools
    • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
    • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
    • Projected Arbitration Salaries For 2025
    • Free Agent Contest Leaderboard
    • Contract Tracker
    • Transaction Tracker
    • Agency Database
  • NBA/NFL/NHL
    • Hoops Rumors
    • Pro Football Rumors
    • Pro Hockey Rumors
  • App
  • Chats
Go To Pro Hockey Rumors
Go To Hoops Rumors

Astros To Acquire Ken Giles

By Steve Adams and Brad Johnson | December 12, 2015 at 12:11pm CDT

SATURDAY 12:06pm: The Phillies have announced the trade. However, several components have changed. The Phillies will receive Velasquez, Oberholtzer, Eshelman, Mark Appel, and Harold Arauz. Derek Fisher, who was originally rumored to be headed to Philadelphia, is not part of the trade. The Astros will also receive infielder Jonathan Arauz from the Phillies. Although both are Panamanian prospects, the Arauz’s are not related.

Appel, the number one pick in the 2013 draft, has experienced mixed success in the minors. The 24-year-old reached Triple-A and posted a 4.48 ERA with 8.03 K/9 and 3.69 BB/9. MLB.com ranked Appel as the Astro’s second best prospect between 2015 draft picks Alex Bregman and Daz Cameron. He’s also ranked 43rd overall. His fastball velocity has been inconsistent in the minors, ranging from the low-90s to 98 mph. He also throws a slider and a changeup.

Harold Arauz, 20, pitched in Low-A last season with a 5.75 ERA, 9.06 K/9, and 3.14 BB/9 in 51 innings. Per Baseball America’s Ben Badler, Arauz leans heavily on a low-90s cutter. Badler also commented on Jonathan Arauz. The newly acquired Astro was ranked the 20th best prospect in the Gulf Coast League. The 17-year-old middle infielder was also considered the best Panamanian prospect in the 2014 international market.

In a related move, the Phillies have designated reliever Dan Otero to make room for Velasquez and Oberholtzer on the 40-man roster, tweets Todd Zolecki of MLB.com.

THURSDAY 12:13am: The final player in the deal will be righty Thomas Eshelman, who will head from the Astros to the Phillies, the Houston Chronicle’s Evan Drellich tweets. The 21-year-old Eshelman, a second-round pick this past June out of Cal State Fullerton, pitched just 10 1/3 innings in the Astros organization. Before the draft, MLB.com characterized him as a polished pitcher who could move through the minors quickly but might end up as a back-of-the-rotation type of starter. At the time of the trade, he ranked as the Astros’ 13th-best prospect.

WEDNESDAY 7:52pm: MLB.com’s Todd Zolecki tweets that a fourth player is headed to the Phillies in the deal as well.

7:38pm: The Astros and Phillies are in agreement on a trade that will send right-hander Vincent Velasquez, lefty Brett Oberholtzer and another prospect to Philadelphia in exchange for young closer Ken Giles, reports Mark Berman of FOX 26 Houston (Twitter link). Outfielder Derek Fisher will also head to Philadelphia in the deal, Berman clarifies (on Twitter). The trade is pending medical reviews. CSNPhilly.com’s Jim Salisbury first broke news that the two sides were nearing an agreement, and he added details along with ESPN’s Jayson Stark as they emerged.

"<strong

Giles, who turned 25 in late September, took over as closer in Philadelphia following the trade of Jonathan Papelbon and continued to display the dominance he’s exhibited since breaking into the Majors upon being moved to a more prominent role. In 115 2/3 career innings, the former seventh-round pick has a masterful 1.56 ERA with 11.8 K/9, 2.8 BB/9 and a 44.6 percent ground-ball rate. Giles’ fastball has averaged just a shade under 97 mph in the Majors (96.8), so he’ll satisfy Houston GM Jeff Luhnow’s previously stated interest in adding a hard-throwing arm that the back end of the Astros’ bullpen had been missing.

By adding Giles, the Astros will deepen their bullpen considerably. Luke Gregerson, who performed well as the club’s primary closer in 2015, will return to the setup capacity in which he thrived for much of his career. He’ll be joined there by side-arming Pat Neshek, the quietly excellent Will Harris and Josh Fields in 2016. Houston will still need to address its dearth of left-handed relief options, however, as its two primary southpaws — Tony Sipp and Oliver Perez — both departed as free agents. Perez has since signed with the Nationals, though a reunion with Sipp remains a possibility, as he’s still a free agent and there has reportedly been mutual interest between the parties.

Houston will control Giles through at least the 2020 season if all goes well. With one year, 113 days of Major League service time, Giles will fall shy of Super Two designation and thus will not be arbitration eligible until the 2017-18 offseason. He’ll earn scarcely more than the league minimum in each of the next two seasons (barring an extension), providing Houston with financial flexibility to address needs elsewhere on the roster.

The centerpiece of the deal for the Astros is Velasquez — a 23-year-old righty who entered the 2015 season as a consensus Top 100 prospect and made his big league debut after performing exceptionally well at the Double-A level. Velasquez logged a 1.91 with a 45-to-13 K/BB ratio in 33 innings at Double-A in addition to posting a 4.37 ERA in 55 2/3 innings at the Major League level where he struck out 58 and walked 21. He’ll immediately be in the mix for a rotation spot with the Phillies, though it’s possible that Philadelphia may want to get Velasquez some time at Triple-A, where he has yet to throw so much as a single inning.

While Velasquez may need some additional development before slotting into the Phillies’ rotation on a full-time basis, Oberholtzer should be able to step into the starting five from day one. The 26-year-old has been up and down with the Astros over the past three seasons but has totaled 45 appearances (42 starts) and recorded a solid, if unspectacular 3.94 ERA with 5.9 K/9, 2.1 BB/9 and a 38.5 percent ground-ball rate. That ground-ball rate, though, isn’t fully representative of Oberholtzer’s new skill set, as he began using a cutter in 2015 that upped his rate to 48.8 percent in his sample of 34 2/3 big league innings. He’ll give the Phillies an option at the back of their rotation that can be controlled for up to five years — the same as Giles — if he’s able to consistently perform in the Majors.

Fisher, meanwhile, was the 37th overall pick in the 2014 Draft and rated as the No. 8 prospect in a deep Houston farm system, per MLB.com. The Virginia product, whom Baseball America ranked 13th among Houston farmhands entering the season, is said in their scouting report to be a toolsy outfielder with plus-plus raw power that has yet to fully manifest. He draws praise for his bat speed and above-average running, though BA noted that he has a below-average arm and has questionable route-running, so left field is probably his ultimate home.

Still just 21 years old, Fisher split the season between Class-A and Class-A Advanced, hitting .275/.364/.483 with 22 homers and 31 stolen bases before going on to bat .254/.397/.424 in 17 games in the Arizona Fall League. He’s at least a full season away from the Majors and possibly two, but Fisher gives the Phillies a potential everyday outfielder down the line if he can keep hitting the way he did in 2015. MLB.com calls him a potential “impact hitter,” even if he isn’t believed to have a future as a strong defender.

Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.

Share 290 Retweet 10 Send via email0

Houston Astros Newsstand Philadelphia Phillies Transactions Brett Oberholtzer Ken Giles Mark Appel Vincent Velasquez

Phillies Acquire Charlie Morton From Pirates
Main
Mariners, Ed Lucas Agree To Minors Deal
View Comments (104)
Post a Comment

104 Comments

  1. TheMichigan

    9 years ago

    Brett olberholtzer? The heck

    Reply
    • rob361

      9 years ago

      Hes decent, he can eat innings

      Reply
  2. jakesaub

    9 years ago

    Smart decision by the Phillies, no need to hang onto a young closer in this reliever market.

    Reply
  3. 184729

    9 years ago

    Why, blue jays need to get a pieace of all theae trades

    Reply
    • ThorsHammer34

      9 years ago

      Get used to it, Shapiro/Atkins combo love to watch from the sidelines. That’s all they did in Cleveland.

      Reply
    • JT19

      9 years ago

      What do they have to trade? They almost gutted the farm with the moves they made last year.

      Reply
      • Mark 20

        9 years ago

        Gutted the farm system? The blue jays still have Pompey (top 100 prospect), 1st round pick Harris, Reid-Foley, Pentecost (another 1st round pick) as well as young guys in Devon Travis and others.

        Reply
        • jedihoyer

          9 years ago

          yeah thats like 1 package. and they arent trading their starting 2b. so its rather underwhelming. as you can see first round picks just arent worth as much as prospects in the upper minors.

          Reply
        • mlbagent

          9 years ago

          Blue Jays farm system is depleted. Look at their rotation, they can’t afford to deal Jon Harris. And lots in baseball view him as a reliever longterm. And don’t forget the whole college fast track concept doesn’t apply with Harris who got shelled in his pro debut.

          Pentecost has value with Catching position around baseball a mess, but he missed all of 2015. Simply, Jays system is depleted & needs to be restocked.

          Reply
  4. SabermetricsForLife

    9 years ago

    Good job ‘Stros! Who is the last prospect?

    Reply
    • philtheez

      9 years ago

      Derek Fisher. Ugh

      Reply
      • degeneration nation

        9 years ago

        D Fish could turn into a stud and move through the minors quickly. Went 20-30 in A ball and played well in the AFL. Nice add for Phils

        Reply
        • A'sfaninUK

          9 years ago

          Fisher and one more prospect….wow this is just like the Kimbrel package.

          Reply
  5. tankadelphia

    9 years ago

    one station is reporting the last prospect is derek fisher

    Reply
    • tom brunanskys black sock

      9 years ago

      Solid point guard

      Reply
      • lastros

        9 years ago

        Can they turn around and trade him to the Rockets?

        Reply
    • bringoutthegimp

      9 years ago

      No Bobby Fisher! Checkmate!

      Reply
  6. Juansbz

    9 years ago

    AL west is definitely the most COMPETITIVE division of all

    Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      What about the NL Central?

      Reply
      • Overbrook

        9 years ago

        NL Central = most overrated division. 40% of that division isn’t even trying to win. That equals inflated records.

        Reply
        • Juansbz

          9 years ago

          Yes, that’s why I put COMPETITIVE and not the BEST

          Reply
        • southbeachbully

          9 years ago

          Only 5 teams in the NL Central had 90+ wins. 3 of those 5 came from the NL Central and they had the 3 best W/L records. How are they not the most competitive divisions. While we can say that the Brewers and Reds are in rebuild mode we can absolutely, without equivocation, say the same for the Rockies and Padres in the West and the Phillies and Braves in the East.

          Reply
          • southbeachbully

            9 years ago

            I meant there were 5 teams in the NL with 90+ wins…..

            Reply
  7. A'sfaninUK

    9 years ago

    An excellent, top 75 MLB SP prospect, a reclamation project SP and the Astros 1st rd draft pick from 2014. Pretty good, but after AZ’s package today almost all other packages are going to look light. I think I’d rather have Boston’s package for Kimbrel than this, but I guess both are almost equal when you take into the slight risk with Giles, who hasn’t been good as long.

    Reply
    • southbeachbully

      9 years ago

      Who’s the reclamation SP?

      Reply
    • southbeachbully

      9 years ago

      Oh I miss read it. Oberholtzer

      Reply
  8. Brixton

    9 years ago

    Phillies go with Nola, Velasquez, Eickoff, Hellickson and Oberholtzer as the rotation to start, along with Morgan, Thompson and Eflin by midseason.
    Bullpen should look something like Araujo, Otero, Hernandez, Russell, Gomez, Garcia and Hinojosa.

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      9 years ago

      That bullpen makes me sad.

      So very, very sad…

      Reply
      • Brixton

        9 years ago

        The upside is actually pretty good, but it could get ugly… really ugly..
        Atleast we have Jimmy Cordero to look forward too out there. He can touch 103.

        Reply
      • SabermetricsForLife

        9 years ago

        What are you expecting from your team this year? Embrace the abysmal for 2-3 years. You get great draft picks as a result.

        Reply
        • Brixton

          9 years ago

          The Phillies were really bad last year because of that rotation — headlined by Aaron Harang, Sevy Gonazalez, Jerome Williams, Kevin Corriea, Alec Asher, David Buchanan, o’Sullivan and Billingsly. That cast of charactors combined for 104 starts last year. The lowest ERA of the bunch was Harang’s 4.86. Everyone else’s was over 5.
          This year they have a full year of Nola, Eickoff, Velasquez, and top prospect Thompson should debut at some point.

          Reply
          • jedihoyer

            9 years ago

            they were really bad because of a lot more than the rotation, they are still going to be giving consistent ab’s to ryan howard, carlos ruiz, and the crap infield other than franco.

            Reply
          • R.D.

            9 years ago

            I expect better years from both the Braves and Phillies this year. More time being given to talented young mlb ready players will do both teams good.

            Reply
    • phillyphanatic819

      9 years ago

      Don’t forget about matt harrison when he gets healthy

      Reply
      • Brixton

        9 years ago

        Its very unlikely he pitches much this year. He has major injuries still.

        Reply
      • No Soup For Yu!

        9 years ago

        Not when, but if.

        Reply
    • No Soup For Yu!

      9 years ago

      I’d argue that Morgan has just as much of a chance at a rotation spot as Oberholtzer, if not more. Neither pithcer was overly impressive last year.

      Reply
      • James7430

        9 years ago

        I agree. Morgan’s wheels will eventually fall off I’m afraid. He may be better suited in the bullpen than as a SP.

        Reply
        • Brixton

          9 years ago

          I actually expect Morgan to get better. Last year was his first year off TJ. He was a former top prospect for the Phillies. I think he can be a 30 start a year, ERA under 4-type.

          Reply
          • James7430

            9 years ago

            I hope so. He could end up being the odd man out though, which would necessitate a move to the bullpen or elsewhere. That’s a good problem to have though. Better than trotting out Sean O’Sullivan, Kyle Kendrick, or the likes every fifth day.

            Reply
    • oofa

      9 years ago

      It is sad to see Giles go. Hopefully Cordero is the real deal.

      Reply
    • cxcx

      9 years ago

      I certainly hope not. Why would the Phillies burn control over Velasquez when they aren’t competitive when they could just start him at AAA? Makes zero sense.

      Reply
  9. jb19

    9 years ago

    Great trade Astros. All three were expendable… Immediate improvement to the ML roster, for both teams, plus Derek Fisher to the Phils system.

    I’m glad we held onto AJ Reed.

    Reply
  10. sflomenb

    9 years ago

    Sounds horrible for the Phillies 🙁

    Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      Its not terrible. Velasquez has pretty good potential. He definitely has more potential than Nola or Eickoff does.
      Oberholtzer… well… hes a backend starter/ LH reliever. Nothing special, but servicable.
      Fisher has a really good bat and can really run. Hes nothing special defensively (from what I read), but definitely a high-upside bat.

      Phillies are getting a 4th player though, so theres that.

      Reply
      • gibbs58

        9 years ago

        Where are the numbers that show he definitely has more potential than Nola? Plus, Nola’s upside is a 2, VV’S is a 3, and considering he hasn’t pitched 2 full season’s worth over the past 6 years, I don’t see that either. I hope I’m wrong.

        Reply
      • Matt St.

        9 years ago

        An additional bonus with Fisher is that he is a local kid. Reading is practically home for him.

        Reply
  11. dejota

    9 years ago

    Seems like a win win, especially if Velasquez or Olby do well and can be flipped.

    Reply
    • LH

      9 years ago

      If Velasquez does well he’ll be held onto. But yeah I agree it’s a win win.

      Reply
    • koldjerky

      9 years ago

      Why would the Phillies flip these guys when they have years of control yet? Giles was a luxury, these guys will be a part of the future (hopefully).

      Reply
      • dejota

        9 years ago

        Both of their ceilings is MoR if they are pitching well I think the Phils would be wise to trade them at peak value. I’m an Astros fan and that’d what the three known pieces are in my eyes.

        Reply
  12. formerlyz

    9 years ago

    This looks like a great deal for the Phillies. Still, Houston did get 4 years of Giles, with a couple of years at the league minimum. I like what Philly has done in the last few months

    Reply
    • James7430

      9 years ago

      Actually it’s 5 years. Through 2020.

      Reply
    • rob361

      9 years ago

      Prospects man, prospects. They come they go.

      Reply
    • rob361

      9 years ago

      When luhnow gives up on prospects you know whats up! :p i like this deal! The Astros needed a closer asap.

      Reply
  13. philly435

    9 years ago

    The Phillies made out incredibly well here

    Reply
  14. Brixton

    9 years ago

    2012 the Phillies we had Victorino and Pence
    2013 we had Hamels and Lee
    2014 we had Hamels, Lee, Utley, Byrd and Papelbon
    2015 we had Byrd, Papelbon, Hamels, Utley, Rollins, Revere and Giles
    Who are Phillies fans going to make fantasy trade proposals about this year? J Hellickson? ew

    Reply
  15. stoi

    9 years ago

    Fisher being included in this trade makes this look awesome for the Phillies!

    Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      It does look awesome, plus theres a fourth guy. If hes anything of significance, that would be a huge win-win by both sides. Its a win-win either way,

      Reply
  16. swiftymcswifts20

    9 years ago

    kudos to the Phils, these are the moves you need to be making

    Reply
  17. Weighed

    9 years ago

    I would try to steal Tyler White. #30 prospect but from what I hear, he will be the gun for Houston.

    Reply
  18. Matt Galvin

    9 years ago

    Other Prosoect coming from Astros.

    Reply
  19. koldjerky

    9 years ago

    Who is the 4th!?!?

    Reply
  20. coldgoldenfalstaff

    9 years ago

    Seems a ton to give up, but a hard thrower is a need and he’s locked up for a long time. At least we didn’t give up McCullers.

    Hate to see Fisher go, Eventually he’s going to be a solid contact bat in the bigs.

    Reply
  21. bobo678

    9 years ago

    looks like a fair trade for both sides…..I hate to see 100 miles giles go he just turned 25 and is lights out with 5 years control let….looks like a fair trade for both sides though

    Reply
  22. southbeachbully

    9 years ago

    The price for a dominant closer is really, really high. I see why Cashman is at least fielding offers for Miller.

    I’m not sure if I would like this deal for the Astros. If Velasquez becomes a front of rotation SP then you’ve effectively traded 6 years of his service for 4 years of a closer. Add to the fact that last year was kind of a “flukey” year for the Astros and maybe this was a bit presumptive for them to make a move like this. Maybe they feel they have a brief window of opportunity with the Rangers and Angels not really separating themselves from the pack?

    Reply
  23. gobraves46

    9 years ago

    Wow. No offense to Giles, but the Astros majorly over paid on this one. I feel like they could have gotten Fernandez with a package centered around Velasquez, Appel, and fisher, (albeit a fair amount more would have been needed). Meanwhile the Phillies all of a sudden have one of the best farm systems in baseball now, expecting to see a rotation with Nola, Appel, Velasquez, and Jake Thompson at some point this year.

    Reply
    • dieharddodgerfan

      9 years ago

      Yeah, Nola, Appel and Velasquez could make for a very good 1-2-3 in a few years. About the time when the free agency market will be ripe for big spenders like the Phillies.

      The Phillies are doing a nice job of rebuilding.

      Reply
    • rob361

      9 years ago

      Appel was a dud. one of those picks you REGRET getting and are so ashamed of you trade him away. All astros needed was a good closer.

      Reply
      • gobraves46

        9 years ago

        Yes, Appel has struggled. But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t still have value, He finished the year a lot better than he started. also, because he was a good college pitcher, he is a pretty polished prospect, and is still close to big league ready. Wait until he’s actually set foot in the big league before you call him a “dud” or a bust

        Reply
      • raykraft88

        9 years ago

        So maybe Appel isn’t Kershaw, but sometimes these guys end up way more valuable than they seem. Check out Wade Davis 3 years as a starter (never had an ERA under 4 and WHIP over 1.3) in comparison to his 3 years as a reliever (under 2.50 ERA).
        baseball-reference.com/players/d/daviswa01.shtml

        Reply
  24. MaineBaseball

    9 years ago

    Appel too?

    Reply
  25. dieharddodgerfan

    9 years ago

    So the Phillies get two possible pieces of their future rotation in Velasquez and Appel for a very good reliever? Wow, that’s a good trade for them!

    Reply
  26. DannyQ3913

    9 years ago

    The Phils robbed the Astros, this is beautiful deal for Philly!

    Reply
  27. TJECK109

    9 years ago

    The Phillies pick up 3 young SPs in this deal… Wow

    Reply
  28. flyerzfan12

    9 years ago

    Jonathan Arauz is actually a really good young SS prospect, he’s not just some throw-in. I don’t like seeing him included in the deal, but still like this deal for both sides. Astros get a young, top tier closer with 6 years of control and the Phillies continue to add pitching depth to their system.

    Reply
    • PhilliesFan012

      9 years ago

      Idk if I like arauz being part of it but I guess that tells us they are gonna be all on with Crawford, and if he doesn’t I’ll be devastated. But snagging Velasquez and Appel are great adds and if Crawford pans out then this deal is a great one for philly, even if oberholtzer and Velasquez turn in to shut down relievers.

      Reply
      • flyerzfan12

        9 years ago

        I don’t like losing Arauz either but he’s so far away anyway that they could draft another young SS or sign another young international SS that would be on the same track this summer. He’s got a ton of upside, but is far enough away that he can be replaced. I’d rather he not have been included, but I like the return.

        Reply
  29. PhilliesFan012

    9 years ago

    If he doesn’t pan out ***

    Reply
  30. A'sfaninUK

    9 years ago

    Five players traded for a relief pitcher, what a time to be alive.

    Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      9 years ago

      Oops, missed the part about Arauz – wish I could edit my posts but this new format doesn’t allow it.

      Reply
  31. rusignola

    9 years ago

    Grammar error — should be “Astros’ second best prospect” not “Astro’s second best prospect”.

    Reply
  32. R.D.

    9 years ago

    The nats and mets are in the midst of clearing out their farms with promotions and here come the braves and Phillies looking to duke it out in a few years.

    Oh yeah and the Marlins are somewhere.

    Reply
    • jabmets

      9 years ago

      Mets pitching in the minors is much thinner but a slew of position players is on the way. Amed Rosario, Dilson Herrera, Dominic smith, nimmo, bacerra. Oh and if Murphy signs elsewhere mets will get an extra pick barring them signing a big time free agent. 2 picks in first 30 not bad. Also if mets sign cespedes they don’t have to use a pick.

      Reply
    • A'sfaninUK

      9 years ago

      Its funny that in all of their title seasons the Giants were mocked because they basically only had one elite position player and one elite pitcher. The Marlins have one elite position player and one elite pitcher, they have about the same chance of winning a title as the Giants did in those previous years.

      Reply
      • greatd

        9 years ago

        The Giants are fundamentaly sound
        and have decent guys through out their line up.

        Reply
  33. raef715

    9 years ago

    would love to find out what happened with Fisher; heard great things about J. Arauz this year but oh well.
    now, do the Phils have a coach who can bring the best out of Appel?
    if not, it’s still a deal where the Phils got a lot of parts they can use, while the Astros gave up parts that werent critical to their future success to get a closer who will be.

    Reply
    • tac3

      9 years ago

      my guess is the Phillies took Goddell in the rule 5 draft, picking him over Fisher. Fisher’s numbers come out of a hitters friendly league, so the numbers are inflated by most experts opinions. I can seee that. Maybe they went back tot the table after the rule 5,. If not, ehhh phillies get a #1 draft pick for an out of nowhere closer. Appel could turn it around. I hope he’s not a headcase like Jesse Biddle is.

      Reply
  34. bobbycurls

    9 years ago

    like the trade for both teams. Appel looks like a bust so keeping Fisher and getting Arauz is a big coup for the ‘Stros. But regardless, Phillies should feel good.

    Reply
  35. scottaz

    9 years ago

    This is the second trade in a week involving a No. 1 – 1 Draft Pick.. The D’backs took major heat and ridicule for including Dansby Swanson in the trade for Shelby Miller. This trade sheds some light on the value placed on prospects, and particularly on No. 1 – 1 Draft Pick prospects. Everybody assumes that 1 – 1 prospects are future superstars. But this trade of Appel once again proves that assumption is flawed. A 1 – 1 is not a 1 – 1 is not a 1 – 1, they are not all the same. Different drafts are rated good, bad, deep, top heavy, etc. in defense of the D’backs, the 2015 draft was considered a weak one, with no superstar at the top. Maybe the Braves didn’t totally fleece the D’backs after all?

    Reply
    • Brixton

      9 years ago

      D’Backs got fleeced because Inciarate might have more value than Miller alone.
      Appel hasn’t produced and he could really benefit from a change of team.

      Reply
    • dylanp5030

      9 years ago

      While you have a point there, I think the argument is more that they could’ve got a much better player than Shelby Miller for that package. Two years ago if the Astros traded Appel, they would’ve been crucified.

      Maybe Swanson doesn’t pan out and the trade looks Okay for Arizonr then. But as of right now, it looks like a steal for Braves.

      Reply
      • greatd

        9 years ago

        Appel’s numbers in the minors don’t impress.
        Although he could drastically change.
        Not a control guy or a high strike out guy.
        He seems to be a 3-4 starter at best.
        They probably saw him enough to give him up.

        Swanson on the other hand hasn’t seen any pro action yet.
        The fans probably wanted to see him play a bit.

        Can’t blame the Arizona fans for being upset as well.
        Towers traded away Upton / Cook / Parker / Bauer for nothing
        They traded away 32 war to get 13 back during his reign.

        Reply
        • firstbleed

          9 years ago

          Don’t forget Adam Eaton.

          Reply
    • Ray Ray

      9 years ago

      Why is everyone convinced that Appel is a bust? He hasn’t even had a chance to prove himself in the majors and everyone is already writing him off. He is still a top 100 prospect. There have been guys in the past that outperformed their minor league numbers once they reached the big leagues. Getting a guy with the talent of Appel along with everything else for nothing but a reliever is just silly good.

      Reply
      • phillysports215

        9 years ago

        I know right. They should go on baseball reference and see Ken Giles minor league numbers lmao not as bad as Appels but they aren’t good either.

        Reply
      • AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres

        9 years ago

        Because he has done NOTHING since getting drafted first overall

        Reply
        • Ray Ray

          9 years ago

          He was drafted first overall 2 years ago not 6 years ago. This is not the NBA, 1st overall picks are not going to help you immediately.

          Reply
          • J32

            9 years ago

            That wasn’t the point, he’s hardly impressed in the minors also. Stuff is reportedly still pretty good, but mediocre results thus far, I know he’s in the PCL, but even the K/BB numbers don’t point to anything special

            Reply
          • AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres

            9 years ago

            I never said they would. But Mark Appel has done nothing in the minors since being drafted. If some guy drafted in the 10th round were to post the exact same results as Appel over the last 2 and a half years they would be seen as a non-prospect.

            Reply
          • Ray Ray

            9 years ago

            Well obviously people in the know disagree with you because he is still the #43 prospect in the entire minor leagues. And a guy in the 10th round wouldn’t be rushed like Appel was either.

            Reply
          • AndThisGameBelongsToMySanDiegoPadres

            9 years ago

            He is only ranked that high because he was drafted first overall. It takes a while to slide down the prospect boards after being taken that high.

            Reply
  36. dswaim

    9 years ago

    I wonder what Jeurys Familia’s return would be in this market?

    Reply
  37. gooberz

    9 years ago

    I still can’t believe even before the accusations, why the bumbling reds couldn’t get more for aroldis Chapman.

    I guess When the rest of the national league thinks you’re a bunch of bumbling idiots, you get the middle finger. Why the reds won’t get a fresh body to gm, is beyond me. This Dick Williams guy is nothing but a pawn.

    Chapman would bring a kings ransom if he was with any other team.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Please login to leave a reply.

Log in Register

ad: 300x250_1_MLB

  • Top Stories
  • Recent

Cubs To Promote Moises Ballesteros

Evan Longoria To Sign One-Day Contract, Retire As Member Of Rays

Diamondbacks To Promote Jordan Lawlar

Rockies Fire Bud Black

Cubs Promote Cade Horton

Rafael Devers Unwilling To Play First Base

Pirates Fire Manager Derek Shelton

Mariners Claim Leody Taveras

Rangers Hire Bret Boone As Hitting Coach

A.J. Minter To Undergo Season-Ending Lat Surgery

Blue Jays Sign Spencer Turnbull

Blue Jays Sign José Ureña

Ross Stripling Retires

Rangers Place Leody Taveras On Outright Waivers

Triston Casas Likely To Miss Entire 2025 Season Due To Knee Surgery

Orioles Recall Coby Mayo

Dodgers Recall Hyeseong Kim

Triston Casas Suffers “Significant Knee Injury”

Angels Place Mike Trout On 10-Day Injured List

Rangers Option Jake Burger

Cubs To Promote Moises Ballesteros

Padres’ Jhony Brito Underwent UCL Surgery

A’s Return Rule 5 Pick Noah Murdock To Royals

Yankees Notes: LeMahieu, Infield, Gil

White Sox Outright Nick Maton

Brandon Bielak Undergoes Season-Ending Shoulder Surgery

Brandon Woodruff Pulled Off Rehab Assignment Due To Ankle Injury

Blue Jays Outright Dillon Tate

Ronald Acuña Jr. To Begin Rehab Assignment

Dodgers Acquire Steward Berroa

ad: 300x250_5_side_mlb

MLBTR Newsletter - Hot stove highlights in your inbox, five days a week

Latest Rumors & News

Latest Rumors & News

  • 2024-25 Top 50 MLB Free Agents With Predictions
  • Nolan Arenado Rumors
  • Dylan Cease Rumors
  • Luis Robert Rumors
  • Marcus Stroman Rumors

 

Trade Rumors App for iOS and Android

MLBTR Features

MLBTR Features

  • Remove Ads, Support Our Writers
  • Front Office Originals
  • Front Office Fantasy Baseball
  • MLBTR Podcast
  • 2024-25 Offseason Outlook Series
  • 2025 Arbitration Projections
  • 2024-25 MLB Free Agent List
  • 2025-26 MLB Free Agent List
  • Contract Tracker
  • Transaction Tracker
  • Extension Tracker
  • Agency Database
  • MLBTR On Twitter
  • MLBTR On Facebook
  • Team Facebook Pages
  • How To Set Up Notifications For Breaking News
  • Hoops Rumors
  • Pro Football Rumors
  • Pro Hockey Rumors

Rumors By Team

  • Angels Rumors
  • Astros Rumors
  • Athletics Rumors
  • Blue Jays Rumors
  • Braves Rumors
  • Brewers Rumors
  • Cardinals Rumors
  • Cubs Rumors
  • Diamondbacks Rumors
  • Dodgers Rumors
  • Giants Rumors
  • Guardians Rumors
  • Mariners Rumors
  • Marlins Rumors
  • Mets Rumors
  • Nationals Rumors
  • Orioles Rumors
  • Padres Rumors
  • Phillies Rumors
  • Pirates Rumors
  • Rangers Rumors
  • Rays Rumors
  • Red Sox Rumors
  • Reds Rumors
  • Rockies Rumors
  • Royals Rumors
  • Tigers Rumors
  • Twins Rumors
  • White Sox Rumors
  • Yankees Rumors

ad: 160x600_MLB

Navigation

  • Sitemap
  • Archives
  • RSS/Twitter Feeds By Team

MLBTR INFO

  • Advertise
  • About
  • Commenting Policy
  • Privacy Policy

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • RSS Feed

MLB Trade Rumors is not affiliated with Major League Baseball, MLB or MLB.com

hide arrows scroll to top

Register

Desktop Version | Switch To Mobile Version