3:06pm: Herrera’s third-year option is valued at $10MM with a $1MM buyout, tweets Bruce Levine of CBS Chicago / 670 The Score. That indicates that Herrera will earn $17MM between the first two seasons of the deal, with the buyout making up the remainder of that $18MM guarantee. The exact terms of the vesting option remain unclear, though Levine notes that Herrera will need to be healthy in both 2019 and 2020 for it to vest, so it’s likely a combined number of innings pitched or appearances that’ll trigger the third year. As with all vesting options, it’ll revert to a straight club option if Herrera does not meet the designated criteria.
1:45pm: The White Sox are in agreement with free-agent righty Kelvin Herrera on a two-year contract that will promise him $18MM, reports Jeff Passan of ESPN (Twitter link). The Wasserman client’s contract will also come with a vesting option for a third season. The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal tweets that the vesting option could bring the total value of the deal to $27MM.
Given the manner in which Herrera’s season ended, the righty looks to have done quite well for himself in free agency. Herrera was lights out in Kansas City top open the season and was the centerpiece of an early-June trade sending him from Kansas City to the Nationals. Herrera, though, wasn’t as effective in Washington, as the superb control he showed with the Royals regressed and he became uncharacteristically homer-prone.
Those flaws might’ve been little more than a small-sample blip, but Herrera did hit the disabled list for just under two weeks due to a shoulder impingement. More concerning, however, was the foot injury that ended Herrera’s season. The righty tore the Lisfranc ligament in his left foot in late August — an injury that comes with a lengthy rehab process and can have lingering effects down the line. Herrera was said to be jogging in early December but, at that point, had not yet progressed to throwing at full strength. Based on the size of his contract, it seems that the ChiSox are expecting him to be available for the majority, if not all of the 2019 season.
Prior to his hiccup on the mound with the Nats and his subsequent season-ending injury, Herrera looked primed for perhaps the second-biggest payday on the relief market this winter (behind Craig Kimbrel). He only just turned 29 on New Year’s Eve, placing him among the youngest free-agent relievers on the market. He was also nothing short of dominant to begin the season in K.C., pitching to a 1.05 ERA with a pristine 22-to-2 K/BB ratio in 25 2/3 innings. That level of control was likely unsustainable for Herrera, meaning the same applied to his ERA, but he nonetheless looked legitimately dominant. He was averaging better than 96 mph on his heater with a 14.4 percent swinging-strike rate and an otherworldly 40.5 percent opponents’ chase rate on pitches out of the strike zone. Simply put, he looked well on his way to proving that a down season in 2017 was a fluke.
Given his age and a generally excellent track record, we at MLBTR predicted that Herrera would sign a one-year deal with an eye toward reentering free agency in advance of his age-30 season next winter. It’s hard to blame him, though, for preferring the security of a guaranteed multi-year deal — especially considering that he could still once again return to the market before his age-32 campaign even if he maxes out the value of the contract. As pitchers such as Andrew Miller and David Robertson have already demonstrated this winter, it’s certainly plausible for pitchers to secure hefty annual values on multi-year deals even as they enter their mid-30s.
Herrera will pair with trade acquisition Alex Colome to give the ChiSox a dramatic and much-needed upgrade at the back end of the bullpen. That duo, teamed with a hopefully healthier Nate Jones, will give manager Rick Renteria a trio of high-caliber right-handers to deploy in the late innings as the Sox look to begin to emerge from a multi-year rebuilding process. Of course, Chicago still has myriad other needs to address; in addition to questionable outfield mix — Eloy Jimenez looms, but Nicky Delmonico, Adam Engel and Daniel Palka are lined up at present — the Pale Hose will likely need to add some established talent to the rotation beyond already-acquired Ivan Nova if they indeed aim to be competitive in a weak AL Central. They’ll be without top prospect Michael Kopech in 2019 due to Tommy John surgery, while former top prospect Lucas Giolito has yet to prove his mettle in the big leagues.
As for the rest of the lineup, the Sox, as everyone knows at this point, are aiming big. They’ve been prominently linked to Manny Machado and, to a somewhat lesser extent, Bryce Harper. While the addition of Herrera won’t be a tipping point in the Sox’ courtship of either star free agent, it certainly can’t hurt to show the pair that the organization is willing to add some recognizable assets in an effort to turn the tides after several seasons of playoff misses.
Nabillionaires Live for Crismania
Big good
tomsack
good start now let’s keep going..
Tim Newport
I think you mean “Don’t stop now, boys!”
Los Calcetines Rojos
Nice addition, Sox bullpen could be very surprising this year with some of these additions that adds to a nice core of Fry and Colome. Wouldn’t be shocked to see a young guy like Ian Hamilton step up big as well
SouthSideDynasty
And let’s hope Nasty Nate Jones gets and stays healthy.
Thomas Bliss
For real right. He is special when he is 100%
CluHaywood
4 straight years with an injury. You can basically pencil him in for an inflamed shoulder around May 5th…
stymeedone
I would have thought Nate Jones would have taught the White Sox how a player on the DL doesn’t help, no matter what they do when healthy. To pay Robertson money for a pitcher coming off both shoulder and foot injury (one that usually has lingering effects), just shows desperation. Even if it works out, it shows that it takes a premium to convince players to sign with them.
Priggs89
Totally man. #HotTake
MrStealYoBase
They have so many quality-stuff, suspect-control guys in the high minors. There’s a really good 7-8 man bullpen there with some permutation of those guys, plus the veterans they’ve added.
If the Royals and Orioles teams this decade have proved anything, it’s that a really good bullpen can add 10-15 wins that projection systems fail to account for.
fisk72
Nice piece for the pen, save or setup.
juicemane
He Gone!
Francys01
Good signing.
sss847
i like the move. they have a pretty expensive back end of the bullpen, that usually signals competing but the rotation and offense is full of holes. hopefully they can address those with some big moves
ChiSox_Fan
I hope he has fully recovered from ligament injury.
His stats look good.
Just turned 29. In his prime.
This looks like Plan B. Manny likely not signing with the Sox.
SouthSideDynasty
“Plan B” really? If anything that convinces him to sign there even more…
canocorn
Plan B as in Plan Bears.
Bears want Manny as their kicker.
MrStealYoBase
In what world does signing a pen arm for two years take them out of the running for a position player on a mega deal?
ChiSox_Fan
Sox know they aren’t getting Manny or Harper.
So they are gambling and spending on pitching to flip at the trade deadline.
chitown311
K.
canocorn
Sox_Fan;
Perhaps you’ve hit on the fallback plan should the season appear to be lost by the trade deadline.
ScottRolen
Has Herrera married into Machado’s family? Is he a buddy of Machado’s?
bobtillman
Herrera and Machado went to Boy Scout Camp together and got very close….in the biblical sense…..
Not that’s there anything wrong with that……
Thurman8er
I have a theology degree. I don’t think that means what you think it means.
bobtillman
You’re probably right. In high school, I thought the Periodic Table was something women used to gauge fertility……
captainsalty
It’s not?
socalsoxfan78
LOL
Thurman8er
Tillman, that’s hilarious.
canocorn
Tillman;
… Of course there’s nothing wrong with it.
People’s personal preferences are nobody’s business.
I just wonder if there’s really a Festivus for the rest of us.
wrigleywannabe
Oh ye who is bound for hell.
Aaron Sapoznik
Kelvin Herrera is Dominican. Manny Machado has a Dominican heritage and has played for that country in international competition including the WBC. The White Sox have one of his BFF’s on their roster in Wellington Castillo who is also Dominican. They also traded for Yonder Alonso who is his Cuban brother-in-law which of course means he is married to Machado’s Dominican sister. Alonso is more than just a brother-in-law. He also happens to be a great friend of Machado and is his neighbor during the offseason in Miami. Last but not least, Eloy Jimenez is also Dominican and he is expected to be a force in the batting order as well as a ROY candidate when he debuts this coming April.
Clearly money and opportunity will dictate Machado’s decision between the White Sox, Yankees and Phillies in the coming days and weeks. The White Sox so far are the only team who has “reportedly” offered Machado a formal contract proposal, even if it is just an opening bid and less than what he and his agent are looking for. As for opportunity, the White Sox would appear to be the one team that might offer Machado a chance to play SS in 2019. Despite having Tim Anderson at the position he has publicly stated that he would be open to a position change for the betterment of the team. This could be a move to fill their CF void if Machado is promised the SS job during contract negotiations. The Phillies prefer Machado to play 3B after recently acquiring veteran SS Jean Segura from the Mariners. The Yankees have also signed Troy Tulowitzki to be their starting SS until Didi Gregorius returns from his TJ surgery rehab in July or August. If Machado signs with the Yankees it will be to play 3B meaning a bump of stud 23-year old Miguel Andujar to 1B or as a potential trade candidate. The White Sox do have a potential opening at 3B as well although Yoan Moncada is currently considered their likely core player at the position once Nick Madrigal debuts in 2020 or 2021.
Bottom line: There are a lot moving parts at play here but the White Sox appear to be doing everything in their power to make their team as attractive as possible for Machado to join them as the face of their franchise. Signing Herrera is just one more piece that could make that outcome more likely.
ChiSox_Fan
Can’t disagree with what u said.
Sox need Garcia back cheap and hope he has a season like 2 years ago. He and Eloy need to get their bodies in playing shape.
Aaron Sapoznik
Ay caramba! Avisail Garcia is Venezuelan. I suppose he could rejoin countryman Yolmer Sanchez and Jose Rondon on their potential 2019 active roster but let’s give Bryce Harper a chance at the RF position first.
Btw- I was remiss in not noting a few more Domicans on the White Sox roster to entice Machado. That would include SP’s Reynaldo Lopez, Ivan Nova and utility INF/OF Leury Garcia. That’s in addition to aforementioned countryman Kelvin Herrera, Alex Colome, Wellington Castillo and Eloy Jimenez.
stymeedone
@AaronS
So exactly who are you calling racist?
Aaron Sapoznik
Racist? Are you implying something?
I was merely chiming in on the ScottRolen “tonge in cheek” comment with some facts regarding the heritage of many of the White Sox players and how they might possibly influence Manny Machado’s decision in joining the organization.
While I’m at it, I have another one. If Machado was to sign with the White Sox it would be his first experience playing for a manager with a hispanic heritage at the MLB level, one who is also bi-lingual. That doesn’t imply racism, be it with the White Sox, Rick Renteria or myself. It’s just a consideration to getting an edge in the Machado sweepstakes, nothing more and nothing less.
Signing Machado would also be a fine marketing strategy for the White Sox who could use a star going forward to compete in the Chicago market with their cross-town rivals. 2019 will be the last season that the White Sox will be partnering with the Cubs in their 4-team cable affiliation. The North Siders are moving on with their own exclusive network in time for the 2020 season while the White Sox will remain with their current one and continue a partnership with the Bulls and Blackhawks. Any one of those three teams would benefit from a partner who could add a superstar to their cable network. The White Sox could also turn to Bryce Harper as well this offseason. Machado is their most pressing target right now and the elite FA most likely to sign first among the two.
From what I can gather, the White Sox have also been more open about targeting the local hispanic community in Chicago than the Cubs. I live in the far NW suburbs but travel into the city regularly to visit my daughter, son-in-law and grandkids. They currently reside in the North Side of town, in the Albany Park neighborhood which has a significant hispanic population which I believe is mostly Mexican. That neighborhood is not too far from Wrigley Field and would be considered a Cubs hotbed. My son-in-law has an American/Korean heritage and grew up a couple of mile from where he currently lives, in the West Ridge area of the city, another Cubs stronghold. Every summer I see White Sox billboards in those areas, in Spanish promoting their team, ones that often include some of their latino players including Jose Abreu. I have yet to see a Cubs billboard doing likewise. Does this make either team more or less racist? Absolutely not. It’s just a marketing strategy in which the White Sox are trying to reach out to a particular ethnic group in their community in order to attract more fans.
Yankeepatriot
Not a bad deal if he’s close to his prior form
gotothevideotape
Pretty sweet deal for the Sox, they are really trying, and who knows, Manny might just end up there.
I don’t even think Cashman will ever go 6 years for anyone. Well that will be 2 he lost then.
KP23
But he will sign Jacoby Ellsbury for 7
gotothevideotape
LOL, KP, So right!
O Conchobhair
Once bitten twice shy lol
Joltin Joe
Two years is a bit of a risk unless the sox feel confident that he’s recovered and will be back or at least close to previous form; I like him though, hope he ends up a bargain for the south side. Was surprised the bombers didn’t give him a look considering how many teams are competing for ottavino….
tac3
The name Herrera is the new Smith of the baseball world
Ackattack
Let me guess, the Angels were a finalist because that seems to be the trend…
Yankeepatriot
Lmao
Tom S
Nice get if healthy!
driller
Gotta have a lead to use those pen arms. Not going to have to many leads with a lousy rotation and swing and miss offense.
Idosteroids
Anthopoulos lets another bullpen arm pass right on by. List is getting smaller and smaller by the day.
Thronson5
Nice pick up for them. Hopefully this is the start to a busy week of MLB signings. My football team was garbage, my NBA team sucks so all I got to look forward to free agency finally taking off lol
basebaIl1600
They should trade for Tony Watson of the Giants. Pen would look nasty, Watson doesn’t cost that much money and would only require 1 mid level organizational prospect.
Thomas Bliss
I would trade Carson Fulmer
king joffrey
Whom do Chisox bump from filled 40 roster? Clarkin (again), Thyago, or an uninspiring outfielder like Tilson or Cordell?
MrStealYoBase
Yes to any of the above
Mr_KLC
A good bullpen could make the difference in a weak division.
shortytallz
Otto should get a similar dealio.
bravesfan
Wanted the braves to get him bad. Electric stuff
Thomas Bliss
I’m going to say Ha! because my brother is a Braves fan.
Thurman8er
To misquote Lando, This lack of a deal keeps getting worse all the time. I can’t wait for the Angels to miss out on Ottavino and Kimbrel!
Boogaloo
You should pray they miss out on those 2.
Thurman8er
I hear you…and I agree with you on Kimbrel. Obviously I don’t want the Angels to overpay (as I think the Yankees did on Britton). But our relief corps is just pathetic and the need has to be addressed.
MrStealYoBase
*Pitching corps*
Thurman8er
I wouldn’t classify the Angels starters as pathetic. How about just “below average.”?
white_sox9195
Im hoping Cordell gets removed he sucks Tilson atleast has good speed
MrStealYoBase
The next ball that Tilson hits hard will be the first
stan lee the manly
I was really hoping the Cardinals would pick this guy up to join with Miller and Hicks at the back of the pen, nice pickup for the Sox
Frisco500
RIP Stan the Man Lee
giantboy99
All for naught if no Machado or Harper…just saying
Philliesfan4life
Angels are just sitting there doing nothing.
jay13
The white sox got a damn good player. He has great stuff and is a great teammate. I really enjoyed watching him blow by hitters. He was one of my favorite players in Kansas City. Sucked to see him go
imgman09
Wow they still have a lot of work to do
Thomas Bliss
Yeah but now we got a ton a pitchers. Maybe we could move one like Carson Fulmer to fill another need.
kidaplus
Carson Fulmer isn’t a major leaguer. They’re not getting anyone capable of filling a hole for him.
If there is one thing the White Sox do well it’s develop pitchers… fail as much as they succeed, but succeed more and fail less than most on turning guys around.
If they can’t do it, most teams as a red flag. Will be released at end of deal. Someone will bring him, but only when it costs them nothing.
Priggs89
Now go sign Grandal so you have somebody that can actually help your young pitchers.
And then get Machado locked up.
ChiSoxCity
Nah, overpaying for a catcher isn’t necessary. They have catchers in the system already.
Priggs89
No, they really don’t. They have a couple bat-first “catchers” that don’t offer much in the way of defense or pitch framing, which is sorely needed with their staff. Not to mention his platoon splits would setup perfectly with Castillo in the meantime (or even McCann if they move Castillo).
Grandal would be a fantastic, much needed addition.
CluHaywood
I dont understand the love affair people have with Grandal. He isnt that good. Especially not for the money.
Priggs89
Good defense. Elite pitch framing. One of the best at his position for getting on base and hitting for power. At worst, he’s a top 5 catcher in the league, and he’s significantly better than the reputation he has gotten on this site.
Aaron Sapoznik
From your mouth to god’s (RH & JR) ears. I have been stumping for Yasmani Grandal all offseason, even after the White Sox signed FA James McCann to back up starter Wellington Castillo in 2019.
The White Sox need one of MLB’s premier pitch-framer’s to aid a budding “young” staff that possess electric arms but also come with some command concerns. The fact that Grandal can also provide a power bat with a .341 career OBP would be gravy.
It’s not like there will be an abundance of elite catchers available next offseason either. This winter has two in their primes, soon to be 28-year old Marlins catcher J.T. Realmuto who would cost a small fortune in prospects and only comes with two more years of arb-control along with just turned 30-year old Grandal. It would behoove the White Sox to jump on one of these players and only Realmuto if he was amenable to a contract extension during trade discussions.
Grandal would also be another nice Cuban addition to the team, one who is friends with both Yonder Alonso and Jose Abreu, joining younger countryman Yoan Moncada as well as top CF prospect Luis Robert by 2020 or 2021.
I’m also in favor of the White Sox cornering the market on Dominicans this winter. They still seek Manny Machado who could then join countryman Kelvin Herrera, Alex Colome, Wellington Castillo and top OF prospect Eloy Jimenez as White Sox teammates in 2019. Hola and muchas gracias!
ChiSoxCity
Nice job, Hahn. The Sox will most likely flip these relievers at the trade deadline for prospects.
Thomas Bliss
Looking more like Carson Fulmer chance at any sort of job is fading quick.
Aaron Sapoznik
One of the advantages of being a former #1 pick is a longer leash with an organization. Those types of prospects also possess some extra trade value, especially those who are only 3 years removed from their draft class and have had zero health issues.
Carson Fulmer still has a world of talent and could still compete for a job as the 5th starter this spring. More likely, he would vie for a long relief job since he was switched to AAA Charlotte’s bullpen during the second half of the 2018 season. Fulmer had success as both a top of the rotation starter and closer at Vanderbilt University before becoming the White Sox first round pick in the 2015 June Draft.
I suspect that if Fulmer isn’t traded or earns a spot as the White Sox 13th pitcher this spring he will be given an opportunity to vie with another former first round pick, Zack Burdi, for the closer role at Charlotte in 2019. Burdi was selected one year after Fulmer as the White Sox second first round pick in the 2016 Draft. Burdi was on a fast track to the White Sox bullpen as another college pitcher who was viewed by the organization as their future closer coming out of the University of Louisville. Burdi was absolutely dominating and up to AAA less than one year after being drafted but suffered a torn UCL ligament that required TJ surgery later in the 2017 season. He has completed his rehab, pitched briefly in the AFL last fall in is set to report to camp in Glendale this spring. With the addition of Alex Colome and now Kelvin Herrera there is no need for the White Sox to rush Burdi to the big league roster in 2019.
Thomas Bliss
I agree. I read one time a that someone compared him to a future Andrew Miller type situation.
Priggs89
The only way Fulmer is taking the AAA closer job from Burdi next year is if Burdi gets hurt again. Fulmer is nowhere near the pitcher he was in college. His long leash is close to its end.
Aaron Sapoznik
We’ll see. The White Sox were committed to Fulmer becoming a starting pitcher despite the fact that many scouts had their reservations because of his high maintenance delivery. Perhaps Fulmer will thrive in a role that may have been more suited to him. His mechanics may still be a problem but the elimination of an extra pitch or two required of a starting pitcher could help his case as a premier back of the bullpen pitcher.
No one has ever questioned Fulmer’s competitiveness on the mound. This bulldog mentality could have hindered him with a stubborn refusal to accept change as a starter but may be less a concern in the bullpen with a two pitch arsenal. Perhaps he could become a right-handed version of Al (The Mad Hungarian) Hrabosky on the mound!
Maybe a change of scenery is in Fulmer’s future but I’d just assume the White Sox give him one more opportunity to show his meddle as an elite bullpen arm before they pursue that course. They would be selling somewhat low on him at this point anyway, no?
Priggs89
It certainly could be selling low, but he has shown me literally no signs of promise at any level since his draft year, so I’m not all that concerned. At this point, I think they’d be making a gigantic mistake if they tried him as a starter again, and if they do the right thing, I’m 100% fine with moving on if he doesn’t show any promise in the pen this season. And if they could use him as a legitimate piece in a trade (not likely), I’d be perfectly fine with moving on before the season.
stymeedone
Maybe Fulmer for Blake Swihart? Bust for bust.
CluHaywood
That was because Fulmer was ranked as the number 2 prospect in the system before the sell off. When the dust settled, he wasnt even top 10. He he has continued to fall.
eric9690
I highly doubt Carson will be up on the 25 man this year for more than 3 appearances at a time. If anything he will be a spot starter or in the bullpen for a couple days and be back on the redeye to charlotte. Far too many other good options in Charlotte and Birmingham to give fulmer a spot on this roster
kidaplus
he walked 5.5 p9 in AAA… with a 5.32 era… 1.6 whip and 15 wild pitches in 67 ip…
anyone who expects anything from this guy is nuts… he shown zero reasons to suggest he has a future as MLB pitcher.
It’s not like he’s got great stuff that no one can handle when he finds the zone and he could really be something if he finds control… when he does manage to find the plate he gets hit.
There’s nothing there. I wrote him off before last season, you’d be wise to the same.
If you’re looking for someone who could really be something if he gets right, invest your wishes in Alec Hansen.
Aaron Sapoznik
I like this signing by the White Sox better than the potential rumored one involving Adam Ottavino. Kelvin Herrera has a much better track record of success and is also 4 year’s younger at 29.
This now makes the Yankees a likely favorite to land the Brooklyn born Ottavino as a replacement for FA David Robertson in the Yankees pen. Good luck to them and good for the White Sox in stepping up to address a clear weakness on their active roster entering the offseason. Hopefully the Yankees luck in signing competing FA’s this offseason ends with Ottavino and not Manny Machado!
I would expect the White Sox to be on the lookout for one more veteran pen piece who throws from the left side, perhaps a remaining FA like Justin Wilson, Tony Sipp or even former South Side southpaw Zach Duke. They might also pursue a trade for a higher leverage arm like the Giants Will Smith or Tony Watson.
Grebek7
Will Smith or Tony Watson please. Those other 3 names listed don’t get my marbles hot at all. Rick Hahn, No more Manny friends & family additions or ex-Cubbies please (that thought process is northside cute ). Manny will sign here because he likes what their building not b/c you signed all his buddies. I’d sure like to have seen Cruz or E.E. hitting bombs out of Comiskey instead we have Alonso. Once Manny chooses NYY or another unnamed team who is letting CWS & PHI set the price, let Alonso go.
driftcat28 2
Good move, is he the closer?
hyraxwithaflamethrower
I love this move. In 2020 or 2021, they can flip him for near MLB-ready prospects and improve their window of contention further. For now, they make the starters’ jobs easier. Even if he bombs, it’s not like they can’t afford him. Hard to find a real downside.
jonesadoug
as a Royals fan I say you got a great player. hope he does well except when we face him
Grebek7
Great pickup one of the big 3 in K.C. with Holland & Davis. Dominant reliever to pair with Colome. LisFranc injuries are tricky hopefully he’ll be healthy. Impact starter would be my 1st priority now. Reynaldo Lopez is the only legit starter Sox have at the moment. Gotta go for it in 2019 this division is WEAK.
canocorn
Grebek;
Grebek was our answer to Jeter. As it looks right now, CWS starting 5 are our Grebek.