Major League Baseball’s imposed deadline for a collective bargaining agreement to be in place to avoid disruption to the regular season is tonight, and the league has already stated its willingness to cancel a month of regular season play. In response, a few players have taken to social media with seemingly tongue-in-cheek suggestions they could look into the possibility of playing in foreign leagues.
Reigning NL MVP Bryce Harper posted a picture of himself on Instagram donning a Yomiuri Giants uniform (h/t to Britt Ghiroli of the Athletic). The Giants, based in Tokyo, are a member of Japan’s Nippon Professional Baseball. Braves reliever Luke Jackson tagged the Mexican League’s Toros de Tijuana in a tweet implying he could be available to sign there. Yankees outfielder Joey Gallo joked about creating a self-deprecating profile on LinkedIn (on Twitter).
Pointed quips aside, it’s not out of the realm of possibility that some players could pursue opportunities in foreign leagues if the lockout lingers into the start of other countries’ seasons. As Ken Rosenthal of the Athletic points out (on Twitter), guidance provided by the MLB Players Association to players and their representatives last November stated the union would back any effort by a player who wanted to make the jump from an MLB 40-man roster to a foreign league. “The PA would challenge any attempts by MLB to interfere with Players who choose to participate in a foreign league during a lockout,” the union wrote, shortly before the league implemented the lockout. “During the 2004-05 work stoppage, a large number of NHL players chose to play internationally.”
How many players would have interest in exploring that possibility remains to be seen. It’d certainly register as a surprise if a star like Harper or Gallo — each of whom has already banked notable earnings in their careers, albeit to different extents — made that kind of move. However, players on the fringes of 40-man rosters could more earnestly pursue those opportunities if they present themselves. Even in offseasons unaffected by a work stoppage, it’s not uncommon to see players at the very back of rosters request their release to head to a foreign league like NPB or the Korea Baseball Organization. Those deals typically come with a guaranteed salary greater than what the player might’ve made shuttling between the majors and Triple-A (and sometimes even above the MLB minimum salary).
It doesn’t seem likely we’ll see an exodus of big leaguers heading to Asian leagues. NPB and Taiwan’s Chinese Professional Baseball League limit each team to carrying four foreign-born players on their active rosters at any given time. The KBO caps teams to three foreign players with salary maximums. All KBO foreign roster spots for 2022 are already accounted for, and NPB and CPBL teams would face similar challenges in accommodating multiple players.
That’s not to say players would be completely devoid of opportunities though. The Mexican League, in particular, could be a destination. While that league places a limit of seven foreign players per team, it exempts foreign-born players of Mexican descent from that list. As Joseph Bien-Kahn of GEN explored in 2019, that loophole has incentivized teams signing players born outside of the country to search for any semblance of Mexican heritage in the player’s genealogy.
Whether any players will choose that route remains to be seen. The lockout doesn’t seem to be on the verge of a resolution, and big league players are facing the possibility of lost game checks. The MLBPA has stockpiled a strike fund in recent years, from which union members will receive stipends for an indeterminate period of time if the lockout continues. (MLBTR’s Steve Adams broke down that system in greater detail this afternoon). The chance to play in a foreign league could allow some players to supplement their income, however. If MLB indeed follows through on its stated amenability to canceling games, it’s possible the union’s support for players pursuing foreign opportunities could spur some to explore that avenue.
Fred Park
Sounds like everybody is giving up.
Rats!
Al Hirschen
There’s talk that Mexico will let teams go over the limit to let MLB players play in the league during a lockout
The_Voice_Of_REASON
Keep them locked out, seal the gates, hire unhinged armed guards.
AshamedMethGoat
Sounds like you’re volunteering, as you meet the criteria of “unhinged”.
Bowadoyle
Good, I hope the greedy players sit out the season.
BirdieMan
Players have moved a lot farther off their original positions than the owners have. Remember, the owners locked the gates, then waited 43 days to make their first proposal.
Dunedin020306
BirdieMan – The players SHOULD have moved a lot farther off their original positions. Your argument reeks of relativism and assumes the players were reasonable in the first place, which they weren’t.
JoeBrady
That’s what some of the union fans miss. If you off $285k for my $300k house, and I ask for $450k, me coming down $15k is NOT a concession. Same as the owners offering a 1% increase in the cap, and then increasing that 1% to 1.1%. If you don’t have a reasonable starting point, you can’t put a stake in the ground.
Halo11Fan
Go, who is stopping you? Baseball could survive just fine without Bryce Harper… or Mike Trout or anyone else.
These guys are not the players getting screwed.
I’m more on the players side than owners, but crap like that doesn’t help
YankeesBleacherCreature
Can you picture Ohtani playing in Cuba?
Geno55
I could see Ohtani pitch for Japan
Halo11Fan
I wonder if Ohtani is the highest paid player in baseball. His endorsement deals must be through the roof.
VonPurpleHayes
I mean Harper’s post was clearly in jest. Chill.
AndyMeyer
Baseball can survive without 2 of its biggest stars? Right…
osfandan
Just the headline we all came here hoping for….sigh.
I was commenting to a friend about how frustrating it is that my favorite sport also happens to be the most inept.
Captain Dunsel
Wouldn’t players under contract risk voiding it if they got seriously injured playing for another team? How different would this be from Aaron Boone’s injury while playing basketball that voided his Yankees contract?
DarkSide830
none of these leagues are adding spots because the union and teams can’t get along.
TJECK109
Let the players go. No sympathy for either side in this issue. Over glorified babies and crusty billionaires bickering about money. Meanwhile gas is $6 a gallon in some places and people struggle for necessities. These sides are so out of touch.
AlvaroEspinoza 2
That’s almost as much as pineapple juice! (in some places)
JoeBrady
ROTFLMAO! The Mexican leagues? Sure, maybe, possibly for some AAAA types. And Harper playing in Japan, and risking $300M or so getting injured? Is this supposed to be some sort of threat? Virtually no one will eave the MLB.
Next!
VonPurpleHayes
@JoeBrady Yea. Harper’s post was in jest about the current situation. He’s not seriously considering playing in Japan.
JoeBrady
Harper’s post was in jest
==============================
I assumed so. How about the Mexican Leagues? Is there a line of million $$$ contracts looking for minimum wage jobs in Mexico?
Geno55
I say poop on the whole baseball season Who gives a flying SIT Baseball should be a game Gee I’d play for free and I have in men’s fast pitch leagues 20 years
gbs42
Baseball is a game. But because our society has placed significant value on the ability to play it at the highest skill level – similar to football, basketball, movies – it has become an $11B-per-year industry. No one is willing to pay to watch you play softball, but millions of people are willing to pay to watch the best baseball players on the planet.
rolder
I’ll pay to watch MLB players play Foreign League Ball.
I’ll buy their merch too.
sdono25
They are all fools
Chasing fools gold
holycowdude
They are certainly acting like fools at the moment, greedy fools at that. But your “chasing fools gold’ comment makes no sense. They are actually all chasing REAL gold (money). That’s the issue here – it’s coming down to who can stack the most coin at the end of these negotations.
Rsox
I wonder though, if a player signs with a foreign team and plays during the lockout, what happens if he gets injured? Surely the Phillies are not going to be ok with a player like Harper (hypothetically) playing in Japan and tearing an ACL
Franco27
You are exactly correct, not going to happen with players currently under contract. A free agent could do it, but once again it’s risky if you get hurt.
VonPurpleHayes
Keep in mind this was a joke. But to your point, I’m sure an injury during those circumstances may void the contract.
JoeBrady
Basically, the entire article was a joke. It was written like it was a threat to the MLB that players will leave the MLB without a quick settlement.
gbs42
Marginal MLB talents – Quad-A players, if you will – sign with foreign leagues all the time. There could be more players choosing to do so if a major league roster spot is not an option for a while. Simple as that.
Yankee Clipper
Man, first the business owners shipped our jobs overseas, now they shipped MLB overseas! Come on owners!
dodger1958
Not much of an alternative. If the players decertify the Union the owners must start to honor the contracts. Then after the season starts they Re certify. Then if no agreement, the owners face a strike.
wileycoyote56
Too bad there isn’t another league here in the US, a little competition would be good for MLB
gbs42
The antitrust exemption gifted to MLB all but blocks that possibility.