The Rockies announced they’ve signed Charlie Blackmon to a one-year contract extension. He’ll return for a 14th season with the club in 2024. The ACES client receives a $13MM guarantee that offers an additional $2MM in incentives. Blackmon would receive $500K apiece for tallying 425, 450, 475 and 500 trips to the plate.
Blackmon has spent his entire career in Colorado. A second-round pick in 2009, he debuted two years later. By 2014, he’d established himself as a very good everyday center fielder. That season, Blackmon secured his first of four career All-Star nods. His best campaign came in 2017, when he finished fifth in NL MVP balloting and won the NL batting title. Colorado signed him to a $108MM extension the following April — including player options running through 2023.
The two-time Silver Slugger winner remained a well above-average hitter through 2019. He still hit above .300 during the shortened 2020 season, albeit with diminished power. Blackmon slumped to a .267/.332/.415 line between 2021-22, raising the possibility that this would be his final year in Denver. He exercised a $15MM option for this season and was set to hit the free agent market for the first time in the coming weeks.
Blackmon rebounded from his down couple seasons. Still working largely out of the leadoff spot, the 37-year-old has turned in a .283/.370/.451 slash through an even 400 plate appearances entering play Friday. He’s still not hitting for much power, but only Nolan Jones has more consistently gotten on base among Rox’s batters. Blackmon is drawing walks at a personal-best 9.8% clip while striking out just 13.5% of the time. He’s still performing well against pitchers of either handedness.
As one would expect for a player in his late-30s, Blackmon hasn’t provided much on the other side of the ball. The Rox moved him off center field after the 2018 season. Since logging 134 starts in right field two seasons ago, the veteran has seen increasing action at designated hitter. Skipper Bud Black has penciled him into the outfield on just 26 occasions while turning to him at DH 60 times.
Blackmon will presumably continue working as Colorado’s primary DH for another season. Jones has had a strong rookie year to take over left field. Kris Bryant was the primary right fielder early on, although he’s been a first baseman or DH since returning from a finger fracture. Bryant could move back to the outfield next season, which would allow the Rox to keep Blackmon out of the field on most days. If the Rockies keep their $182MM signee at first base, they could look to add a corner outfielder in free agency or trade over the winter.
It’s the second late-season extension for Colorado. The club agreed on a two-year, $20MM pact with starter Germán Márquez three weeks ago. Márquez underwent Tommy John surgery in May, so that move is primarily about 2025. This deal ensures veteran continuity for a young roster while keeping around a fan favorite who’s still a productive hitter — albeit in more of a rotational role than an everyday capacity. Reliever Brent Suter and depth starters Chris Flexen and Chase Anderson are the club’s remaining free agents.
Colorado had just over $98MM in guaranteed commitments for the ’24 campaign before re-signing Blackmon. The extension brings their commitments to around $111MM before considering arbitration-eligible players. They opened this year with a player payroll around $172MM, as calculated by Cot’s Baseball Contracts, so there should still be a decent amount of breathing room headed into the offseason.
At the same time, it’s a surprisingly strong sum for the Rox to commit. They’ll likely need to add at least three starting pitchers this offseason. Bullpen and/or center field help could be targets as well. Blackmon’s status in franchise history surely played a part in the deal, though it’s still above market expectations for a non-elite veteran hitter limited to a part-time DH/corner outfield role.
It’s a bit above the $10MM and $12MM respectively secured by J.D. Martinez and Michael Brantley last winter. Martinez indicated he took less than was available to join the Dodgers, while Brantley was coming off a season-ending shoulder procedure. Yet both players have been more productive hitters over the last few seasons than Blackmon has been. The Rockies are willing to go beyond what the veteran likely would’ve received as a free agent in order to ensure he’ll be back at Coors Field for another season.
MLBTR’s Steve Adams first reported the contract details.
Image courtesy of USA Today Sports.
oscar gamble
Good move for both player and team.
MLB Top 100 Commenter
I would suggest that you cannot really say whether or not it was a good move for the team until you know the one-year salary amount
oscar gamble
The dollars only matter if it will keep the Rockies from doing other deals.I don’t think they’ll be giving him that kind of money.
Dumpster Divin Theo
Didn’t he beat the Cubs? Or was that Bryant?
Backup Catcher to the Backup Catcher
Nice PR move by the Rox. But it doesn’t cover up just how poorly this team has been run since its inception.
Dock_Elvis
The fact the Rockies managed to make a World Series while playing at elevation is an absolute miracle.
Degaz
I’d say it’s pretty meh and an overpay. He really hasn’t been an above average starter in the league since 2017. 6.5 bWAR in 6 years isn’t great production. and he’s not getting any younger at 37. Probably just a. way to let him retire a Rockie.
statman
Wow massive overpay for a .237 singles hitter (check the splits before anyone doubts me)
Dock_Elvis
Statman…he’s marketing gold in Colorado. Case of value off the spreadsheet.
filihok
statman
First, name doesn’t check out.
Second, using batting average as a metric for player offense is ignorant as hell.
Third, nearly every pl;ayer hits worse on the road than at home, so saying a player is only their road performance is just plain incorrect.
Fourth, Rockies hitters, especially, have bad road splits because they get used to pitches that don’t move in Coors and when they go on the road it’s like playing wiffle ball.
Fifth, Rockies’ players don’t revert to their road stats when they leave Coors field. Let’s take a recent high-profile example.
Nolan Arenado. had a 108 wRC+ on the road as a Rockie. As a Cardinal he has A 128 wRC+
Bad taek
Missippi_has_3Ks
Wow some players love being losers. Him and trout have accepted their fates. How do you work towards something your entire life only to piss the chances of winning away:
letsgopadresialsolikeoakland
When someone throws you a $100 million to live in a city for 15 years and play a kids game that’s how
miltpappas
And there are far, far worse places to live than Colorado.
Ted
Winning a ring at all cost isn’t necessarily the sole priority of all professional athletes. Even the really good ones have families, teammates, and established lives.
Missippi_has_3Ks
I get that but, really, aren’t you trying to win at least one ring before you retire?
Baseball_dude
So do you consider Ted Williams and Tony Gwynn losers because they never won a World Series? If you do, you might wanna switch sports
Missippi_has_3Ks
trout and Blackmon are both coveted by teams yet they still decide to stay with losing teams. It’s feels differently being around winners. I guess they’re just complacent, Nolan Arenado did they opposite he’s like fk that get me out of here!
hiflew
Yeah and that worked out real well for him this season.
miltpappas
Makes you wonder what the greats of the past would have done had there been free agency then. Maybe Ty Cobb would have gone to the Cardinals? Or Walter Johnson to the Cubs?
Dumpster Divin Theo
I’ll take that category Ken. Players who love being lovable losers for $500. What are….the Chicago Cubs?
Denim
The Cubs won the World Series in 2016. The Rockies came closest in 2007 against the Red Sox.
thefallensoldier
I’ll take teams that are a complete dumpster fire and need to drop ticket prices to $1 to get anyone to show up to their games for $2000 Ken. Who are the White Sux
Dock_Elvis
Accept fate? Trout was drafted by the Angels and signed an extension that NO one would have refused. Don’t act like it’s as simple as just walking away. I’m not sure what the philosophical flaw of honoring a contract is.
Ski to Coors
2024 Playoffs, HERE WE COME!!
AHH-Rox
As long as it’s for less than 10 million, I like the Rockies bringing back a veteran leader who can still contribute at a decent level.
AHH-Rox
At 13 million or more I don’t like it so much. But the Rockies aren’t going to compete next year anyway so maybe it’s OK if they spend a few million too much for Charlie instead of on some mediocre free agent (like their signing of Profar this year).
Dorothy_Mantooth
Colorado is a strange organization. They have let great players go (Arenado, Holliday etc..) for little to no return, yet they go out and sign Kris Bryant to a monster contract and pay some of their respected veterans (Bard, Blackmon, Marquez) well over market value to retain them. They need to pick a lane and stay in it. Blackmon is a franchise icon, but $13M – $15M for next season is a $5M overpay if you ask me. I love Blackmon as a player and a leader but paying him this much might prevent them from signing a good relief pitcher or adding more AAV to a free agent pitching offer.
The Rockies fans are one of the most loyal fanbases in MLB. They are always in the top 5 in attendance regardless of the product they put on the field and they have a solid TV deal in place. They have the financial resources to pay their players; the problem is they often pick the wrong players to pay and don’t draft that well either. A lot needs to be done to make the Rockies relevant again.
hiflew
Let Holliday go for little return? They got Carlos Gonzalez (arguably a better player than Holliday) and Huston Street in that deal. The Holliday is probably one of the better trades in Rockies history.
Colorado Springs
There is no TV deal in place, if you haven’t heard, RSN (ATT) is out of the business at the end of the year. The announcers are unemployed.
SweetBabyRayKingsThickThighs
Does this mean the Subaru strike zone is gone as well?
hiflew
One can only hope.
astros_fan_84
It seems the Rockies are doing exactly what they want: fill the stands with an entertaining product. I don’t think winning the World Series is their priority. Extending Blackmon will sell tickets and make many in the fan base happy. So, it’s a good deal.
Dumpster Divin Theo
Yeah when that happened their little friend Madonna declared: “Holliday. Celebrate!”
Dumpster Divin Theo
There are no TVs in the Rockies? That would explain all the snow bunnies and blow.
Dumpster Divin Theo
Well played young Luke, well played!
Dock_Elvis
Meddling ownership. They had a vaunted scouting department and let it all drift away. The Braves picked up a lot of those people.
hoff38
Decades of not drafting enough or quality arms kills them. Wish they would go hire some Braves or Cardinals scouts to help them.
Dock_Elvis
They HAD a bunch of the Braves scouts.
Dock_Elvis
Being a Top 5 attendance while routinely putting out mediocre teams is Cubs fan level indifference. Denver is a football town and always has been. Baseball is something to do until it’s Broncos time. And I’ll say this as someone who LOVES Colorado.
flamingbagofpoop
I think they’d be better served throwing that money at relivers and hoping to find some that show well and can be traded at the deadline. I think they probably could have had Blackmon under $10m if they waited.
Degaz
To reward him and allow him to retire a Rockie is really the only way to justify paying that much for someone who will be 38 next year and likely at the end of his career.
Yankeesfan23
Neat!
filihok
How do you write this article (or any article about a batter in Colorado) without referencing wRC+ (or at least OPS+)
YankeesBleacherCreature
Mute Anthony?
solaris602
Because in traditional Rockies fashion, we don’t want to cloud the issue with facts. This signing is all about FEEEEELINGS.
hiflew
Your reaction is because your wittle FEEEEELINGS are hurt. So what is the difference.
Dumpster Divin Theo
You’re burying the lede: “Colorado Rocky Mountain high. I’ve seen it raining fire in the sky”
JoeBrady
hiflew14 hours ago
Your reaction is because your wittle FEEEEELINGS are hurt.
=========================
Or, maybe, just maybe, it is because he thinks this is a stupid move, and isn’t satisfied with the 100-loss season.
Maybe he thinks that this is no small-market team trying to survive. It is a mid-market team battling KC and Oakland for the #1 pick.
filihok
DDT
Most likely it’s some of both mixed with the black-and-white-hot-taek-culture where nuance doesn’t exist.
Signing Blackman isn’t going to turn the franchise around. And, it’s probably a bit of a overpay.
But, as I noted elsewhere, Blackman almost certainly has more value to the Rockies than to any other team.
This signing isn’t preventing the team from competing in 2024 or in the future.
So, calling it a “stupid move” is really just a stupid and emotional thing to say
One can disagree with the signing and use a bit more critical thinking and nuance to do so.
There are positives and negatives to this deal. A failure to consider both of those is stupider than this signing
Anthony Franco
I don’t think those park-adjusted metrics handle Colorado hitters particularly well. There’s a ton of research establishing that Rockie hitters have tougher times than players on other teams when they go on the road because they’re seeing pitches move in a different way than they do at altitude.
filihok
AF
Sure. For the first few games especially.
There’s also a heck of a lot of research that shows that hitters are added within Coors. Every single game.
It’s almost certain that the adjusted numbers are are a more accurate representation than the raw numbers. Even if they are imperfect.
Anthony Franco
Not disputing that Coors helps the raw slash line. Everyone’s already aware of that, though, and it’d be tiresome to caveat every Rockies-related post with a mention of park effects.
I understand the argument for using the indexed stats. It just seems that saying he’s nine points better than league average by wRC+ implies greater accuracy than I believe the metric has for Colorado hitters specifically.
I’d rather lay out the surface stats, note that Blackmon has the second-best offensive production on the team, and let readers determine how impressive they consider that to be given the environment and the quality of the rest of the lineup. Totally get if you disagree, but that’s my line of thinking.
filihok
AF
Thank you for sharing your thought process
It makes more sense to me now than it did
I very much doubt the average MLBTR reader can look at a raw stat line and immediately make the mental adjustments in their heads. I know that I can’t. That’s why I’m sure adding that information gives more clarity than it removes.
Anthony Franco
Of course! Happy to discuss reasonable questions/criticism on the post. Thanks for your cordiality.
Dumpster Divin Theo
Not sure about the impact of Coors on the raw slash line but the impact of Coors on the raw sushi line is immeasurable.
gbs42
DDT is here for the jokes, and only the jokes.
hiflew
Not to mention that Rockies players are the only players in the league that don’t get to add Coors Field stats to their road averages. The Rockies road numbers will always be lower than everyone else because they are missing the #1 hitters park from the road average. Every team is missing one park from their road stats and it hurts some teams more than others.
solaris602
$13M for a sentimental extension is a huge overpay especially when you build in escalators of $2M.
Fraham_
HOLY OVERPAY LOL ROCKIES
baseballteam
Overpay to someone who looks like he lives in a dumpster.
Kc smoke
He’s a hof rockies player for their team so it’s nice he’s going to only play for them.
nosake
Blackmon will probably be swinging the bat when he’s 50. Got to admire his tenacity.
andym-2
Would have liked to see Chuck Nasty on a contender but whatevs…
hiflew
You have seen him on a contender.
Ski to Coors
112 OPS+ and 1.5 WAR in 93 games. 13-15M is not an overpay. He’s also a mentor for their young core.
hiflew
You aren’t going to convince anyone here about that. Some of the people around here have a hanging effigy ready anytime the Rockies make any type of move.
flamingbagofpoop
$13-$15m for a 109 wRC+ defensive liability is an over pay.
Degaz
It is…
Colorado Springs
Most of the naysayers also sight “alternative facts.” Where you guys from? Not Denver.
filihok
Overpay?
Not sure any other team would give him that. Maybe?
He probably also has more value to the Rockies than to any other team
It also doesn’t really matter. The Rockies make a boat load of money and a few million between friends isn’t a big deal and that’s not the difference between the Rockies being good next year or not.
StreakingBlue
Bad contract for an aging player
mostlytoasty
aging player that has an .821 OPS right now, which would put him ahead of guys like Schwarbo, Gunnar, Goldy, and plenty of other bigger names
unless he regresses badly, which doesn’t seem to be happening as he’s been great since returning from injury a month or so ago, then the Rox are fine overpaying a bit to bring bat a career org player that can help out be a mentor on a very young squad. Rox have a lot of key future players that have either debuted or will be next year
and if folks want to stick with wRC+, he’d have ranked around 70th amongst qualified batters, which places him ahead of Yoshida, Trea Turner, Drury, and Arenado…
Dock_Elvis
Dude it’s a one year deal. This time next year he’s going to only be a year older.
colton
Terrible terrible news
Luke Strong
The Rockies are committed to losing.
top jimmy
$13-15M for a 37 year old DH that only hit 8 HR playing half his games at Coors Field?! LMAO. Are the Rockies even trying to win anymore???
Buzz Killington
The Rockies are masochlsts. Gotta change their name to it.
disadvantage
$13mm+ is definitely an overpay, but 8 homeruns (in fewer than 400 ABs) is plenty for a leadoff hitter with a .370 OBP, Coors or not.
JoeBrady
It is 2 road HRs. I understand the argument about the Rox road adjustments, but that’s weak.
4thefences
He missed 2 months with a fractured hand. He leads all active players in career doubles and can still hit .280ish. Good move by the Rockies.
King Floch
The Rockies’ organizational philosophy remains a mystery wrapped in a riddle ensconced in an enigma.
astros_fan_84
It seems pretty obvious: they want to sell tickets, which they do quite well. They have a high payroll, so it’s not like they’re cheap.
good vibes only
It seems like an overpay on its face but the money is irrelevant. They aren’t gonna win anything and he’s gonna retire in that jersey after whats been a pretty nice career. DH isn’t going to block any of the prospects so why not? This org makes some truly baffling moves but this isn’t really one of them IMO.
Wren
as a Dodger fan he’s been a thorn in the side for a decade. would always want a guy like him on your team. good on both sides for figuring out a way for him to finish his career in CO. never saw him take a pitch off.
Dumpster Divin Theo
The great thing about a Rockies chat group is you can respond incredulously by slamming your shoe like Nikita and exclaiming “are you High?” And you wouldn’t be wrong
HatlessPete
Well, that’s what happens when you bid against yourself i guess. The rockies clown car keeps on rolling.
DarkSide830
Team slightly overpays franchise icon who is one of their best players. Story at 11.
douglasb
Rockies that desperate for 1 WAR?
GarryHarris
Would’ve any other team signed Charlie Blackmon? The owner’s baseball priorities seem misplaced.