A ten-game losing streak in late June and early July seemed to close the door on Guardians' chances, but the club then won six of its last seven games to regain some momentum heading into the All-Star break. Cleveland doesn't play a single opponent with a winning record between now and July 31, so it certainly seems possible that the Guards can bank some more wins and put themselves more firmly back into the Wild Card race. The Tigers' big lead in the AL Central likely makes that Cleveland's only path to the postseason, and 4.5 games and five other teams stand between the Guardians and the Mariners for the final AL card berth.
The Guardians are one of the more on-the-fence teams in baseball at the moment, and yet regardless of what happens between now and the July 31 deadline, the most probable scenario is that Cleveland will dip a toe in both the buying and selling directions. If the club is still treading water by the deadline, some additions could still be made, even if they're perhaps more aimed towards reloading for 2026 than a significant push to contend this year.
Record: 46-49 (10.6% playoff probability, per FanGraphs)
For other entrants in this series, see this post.
Sell Mode + Potential Trade Chips
Impending free agents: Carlos Santana, Jakob Junis, Austin Hedges, Lane Thomas, Shane Bieber ($16MM player option for 2026, $4MM buyout), Paul Sewald ($10MM mutual option for 2026, $1MM buyout), John Means ($6MM club option for 2026)
Santana could be dealt whether or not the Guardians are contending, as the team would probably love to get the remainder of the veteran first baseman's $12MM salary off the books. Young Kyle Manzardo has played well enough that Cleveland might entrust him with everyday first base duties, and clearing the 1B/DH situation would also free up more at-bats for David Fry, who is a DH-only player in his first season back from offseason elbow surgery.
The catch here is that Fry hasn't been hitting at all since being activated from the 60-day injured list, and Santana's modest 98 wRC+ still makes him one of the more productive hitters in a weak lineup. Cleveland could look to play it both ways by dealing Santana, and then picking up a less-expensive, first base-capable player (probably a right-handed bat) to act as a complement to Manzardo. Prospect C.J. Kayfus is a left-handed hitter but he could also be called up to help out at first base, as Kayfus has been shredding both Double-A and Triple-A pitching this year.
Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription
- Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams, and Anthony Franco.
- Join exclusive weekly live chats with Anthony.
- Remove ads and support our writers.
- Access GM-caliber tools like our MLB Contract Tracker
Bieber or Means would be acquisitions for 2026 more than being expected to contribute this season. I could see teams having interest in Santana and Junis but i wonder if they would consider trading Kwan or Bibee if the offers were good
Bieber has a player option. The only way he stays is if he’s injured.
He hasn’t pitched at all so far in 2025. He needs to both prove hes healthy and perform and if he doesnt do those things he probably will exercise his player option.
Except for Santana you’d be lucky to get a bucket of balls for the rest of the list. Beiber is just off major surgery and Means isn’t available until September if at all. If they are truly in sell mode and want to receive any value at all they have to look at dealing Clase and Kwan
But why would Santana bring much back? Expensive contract, mediocre performance, and 39 years old. Limited to IB and DH. Maybe a contender with a sudden need, but…
Ramirez and Kwan have produced 6.4 WAR this year. The offense as a whole has produced 4.4 WAR. So the rest of the position players have produced negative 2 WAR. Thats not good.