October 6th: Hundley has now been interviewed by the Giants, reports Susan Slusser of The San Francisco Chronicle.
October 5th: As the Giants get their managerial search underway following Bob Melvin’s recent dismissal, Jon Heyman of the New York Post reports that catcher Nick Hundley is “strongly in the mix” for the job. It’s unclear whether Hundley has interviewed for the position at this point, but the fact that his name has come up so clearly is nonetheless notable.
Hundley, 42, was a big league catcher for parts of 12 seasons and served as the Giants’ primary backup to Buster Posey for the 2017 and ’18 seasons. After serving under Posey as part of the team’s catching tandem, it now appears Posey has interest in bringing Hundley in to serve as his manager now that he’s become San Francisco’s president of baseball operations. Hundley immediately jumped into an off-the-field role with the league upon announcing his retirement in 2020, as he became a senior director of baseball operations with the commissioner’s office.
He spent two years in that role before departing the league office to take up a job in the Rangers organization, where he serves as a special assistant to president of baseball operations Chris Young. Hundley won a World Series in the organization in 2023, and during that playoff run was actually a candidate to manage the Giants when then-president of baseball operations Farhan Zaidi was looking to replace Gabe Kapler in the dugout. At the time, it was reported that Hundley had withdrawn himself from consideration before receiving an interview due to family considerations. He had talked to both Zaidi and Posey himself about the role before making that decision, however, indicating that he had at least some level of interest.
With no interview confirmed to have taken place, it’s not necessarily a lock that Hundley would accept the opportunity to interview if offered given his past decision to decline that invitation. With that being said, it’s entirely possible that whatever concerns Hundley had about jumping back into the grind and travel involved with a managerial role have resolved themselves in the past two years, or even that the idea of reporting directly to a former teammate like Posey holds enough appeal to get him involved in the process again. It’s also worth noting that Heyman made clear Hundley has “no guarantees” of landing the position, even in the event he has changed his mind about his desire to manage.
Whatever the case may be regarding Hundley’s candidacy, he’s far from the only person the Giants will talk to about their managerial gig. Former All-Star and longtime Oakland A’s catcher Kurt Suzuki is known to have interviewed for the position. Former Giants bullpen coach Craig Albernaz, now in Cleveland as Stephen Vogt’s bench coach and associate manager, is “expected to get a look” for the job as well. It’s worth noting that all three of Hundley, Suzuki, and Albernaz have connections to the Bay Area, though that may not necessarily be something Posey is looking for specifically in his next manager. Whoever next sits in the manager’s chair for the Giants will be an external hire, as Posey is not expected to interview any members of the current coaching staff for the job.

Giants are gonna interview every backup catcher they’ve ever had, wouldn’t be surprised if Curt Casali gets an interview
He’s in the reds FO now.
Yorvit Torrealba waiting by his phone.
Bring on Bengie Molina! He can teach them young whippersnappers something about hustle dagnabbit!
Yeah! I’d be happy with Bengie.
Bengie is doing the Spanish radio broadcast for the Cardinals now. We’ll keep him thank you very much.
I can’t blame you. Bengie is a total professional.
cool cool, we’ll take yadi then
He’s currently working out a deal to join the Cardinals coaching staff next year. Maybe Jose is free?
Bill Bathe, Jeff Reed, and Steve Decker await their interviews…
Mike “The Sheik” Sadek!
Mike Sadek is deceased. Nice attempt at making a funny.
Bummer, I didn’t know that. He was so nice.I have about a dozen autographs as he was always signing. He wore a towel over his head all the time so that’s how he got his nickname.
Only if they have Bay Area connections.
Giants backup catcher for years!
My cousin knows this guy that says Chadwick Tromp is a front runner, bigly.
76-year old Dave Rader has his phone charged and is ready for a chat.
Milt May has youth on his side; he’s only 75.
Lol Milt May!
Still running to first trying to beat out a double play!
I can still remember the FOUR May Brothers:
Lee, Carlos, Milt & Rudy !!
Was Lee Maye a stepbrother?
Kurt Manwaring on line 2.
One of my favorite Chris Berman nicknames.
Kurt what is that Manwaring?
We would say ” Kurt Manwaring women’s clothes”!
”’s Kurt Manwaring women’s clothes”
Scott Servais, who was both a Giants Catcher and an MLB Manager is available. So is Mike Matheny but we may not want to say that out loud
Eli Whiteside come on downnnn
mike – They may interview Tek again, although I hope he doesn’t leave Boston.
Well, it’s not the worst plan in the world; backup catchers study their arses off.
LOL
I would honestly consider DeRosa and Pujols for the position
Nah. In general former catchers make the best managers. Not saying that’s absolute, but a few years ago I did a count and almost half the managers in MLB were former catchers.
Once a guy has shown to be a good manager it doesn’t matter what position he played, but if they’re going gamble on someone with no managerial experience I’d definitely want a former catcher.
DeRosa? Maybe Lauren Shehadi instead…
Pujols the frontrunner for Anaheim.
Managers don’t matter
Neither do you
“Managers don’t matter”…I think they “matter” way less than most people think, but a strong on-field leader can probably win 1-3 extra games a year.
A bad manager will probably cost a team a somewhat equal number of games.
The Brewers certainly did not miss Craig Counsell, the latest guy to be designated a “great” manager by the MSM.
They absolutely matter. Games are won and lost by decision making.
Strategy, fundamentals, talent, analytics, culture, chemistry all play equal roles. It doesn’t manage itself.
Head coaches and baseball managers do matter. It’s quite hard to explain but playing in organized sports would help show that.
I wouldn’t go so far as to say that they don’t matter, but these days a manager’s main job is being the implementer of the front office game plan. So they matter a lot less than they once did. Except when the front office is looking for someone to blame. Then they matter a lot.
NFL head coaches matter a ton. They design the offense and defense, choose coordinators, and literally call the plays.
Baseball managers have far less impact on the game, and the “strategy” they control, like bunting or sending the runner, is pretty marginal.
Bullpen management, while important, is overrated. Especially with the three batter minimum. Anyone can bring in the good RPs when you have a lead.
Player development and managing playing time is more important, but harder to quantify. And often is up to the GM as much as the manager.
Essential. Everybody needs a scapegoat !
I believe the correct spelling is ‘escapegoat’.
Brian Kenney’s burner account
rhndome, Mike Sadek it is, then.
Surely you can find more qualified people than that, Posey!
How are they unqualified?
“How are they unqualified” Most people and employers consider experience in the job to be fairly important.
But, I’m sure having a likable, jovial personality and being well liked by fans is also important.
So unqualified means no managerial experience? I guess Steven Vogt was unqualified. Entering the 1995 season Bruce Bochy was unqualified, as was Bob Melvin in 2003. In fact, that means every guy ever hired without experience was unqualified. That’s kind of a ridiculous position to take.
“So unqualified means..kind of a ridiculous”…No, what’s “ridiculous” is making up your own points and then arguing against them.
I was merely answering a question and said “most people”. I actually never made any of the points you argued. Not even close, buddy.
mlb fan, So you responded to a question about another person’s post, and then got all huffy about the response to the implications in yours. Your response to:
“How are they unqualified?”
was:
“Most people and employers consider experience in the job to be fairly important.”
How should that be interpreted other than lack of experience equals unqualified.
” I actually never made any of the points you argued.”
I only made one point and that was lack of experience does not equal unqualified.
You butted into a question directed to someone else, and offered zero alternatives to what makes someone unqualified, other than lack of experience. That issue of lack of experience, which you introduced, is what I addressed. I did not make up anything. Don’t blame me for your feckless, and ill-thought out response.
100% of people doing any job for the 1st time have no experience at that job. In no way does that make them unqualified.
There are plenty of people that have experience doing jobs that they are spectacularly unqualified to perform.
How do you know that lack of experience isn’t a consideration, even if hired?
Those are 2 different things. Lack of experience certainly would be a consideration for some, if not all teams. But how big a consideration would it be? The lack of experience being considered, still doesn’t mean someone is unqualified.
In fairness, a lot of first-time MLB managers come to the job with experience managing at the minors level, or in some other dugout position in the majors. Hundley has none of that. His best qualification for the job could well be that Posey knows and likes him.
Sure, some, but there are plenty of guys that did not manage in the MiLs, or as a bench coach. Aaron Boone was hired out of the broadcast booth, as was David Ross, and Bob Brenly a couple decades ago.
Stephen Vogt was a ML manager after one year of being a bullpen coach. Like Hundley, Craig Counsell took a FO job and was also hired out of the broadcast booth. Brad Ausmus was a field coordinator for 2 years and then hired as a manager.
A.J. Hinch never managed a professional team before the D’backs hired him. Dave Roberts was 1B coach, and filled in as manager for one game before the Dodgers hired him. There are more than enough examples of guys hired to manage with little to no managerial experience.
My point is, the way baseball is played today, the manager is more than ever an extension of the front office.
Well, that wasn’t your point entirely. You did mention the experience of MiL managing, and being a bench coach, and noted that Hundley lacked experience as both.
And, the topic of the thread was managerial experience, and whether the lack of meant unqualified or not, but I appreciate your diversion to a different aspect of the role.
Please don’t tell me what my point was. Thank you.
Fine. You make two points initially, Edit it to one, somewhat off topic, but then get touchy when that’s pointed out. This is a comments page. Don’t post if you can’t handle any pushback.
I can see subtlety is lost on you.
I can see logic is lost on you.
Shezzus, are you ever obsessed.
You reply to me. I reply to you. But I’m obsessed. Right.
Nah. It’s more like unqualified people commenting on who is qualified.
He finds the most qualified people he can… and stop calling him Shirley.
Still have to pay Melvin for 2026.Hundley fits the price range.
We aren’t a poverty franchise.
Suzuki can take his hat and go to the house. No way that nonsense is playing in San Fran
You prefer that wing nut Gabe Kapler be asked back?
I absolutely would like to see Kapler back. Holds all-time record for wins in a season and was most recent MOY, lest we forget. Things have gone so well since he was let go……
Don’t hold your breath. Kapler alienated some players, and the clubhouse got toxic. It’s just rumor, but apparently Logan Webb was one of those guys he rubbed the wrong way. With Webb still atop the rotation, Kapler isn’t coming back soon.
“Things have to change here” was pretty definitive from Webb. Very solid supporting evidence for the rumour.
Looked like Kap got carried away with himself after 21. Yeah, I don’t think there is a coming back from that.
21 was a Unicorn season from the Giants. They got unreal production from pretty much everyone on the bench in the platoon roles, nearly 3 WAR from Darin Ruf,nearly 2 WAR from Wilmer, 1.5 from Wade, career year from Brandon Crawford, one of Posey’s best years, a great year from Belt. They also had Gausman, Webb, and DeScalfani have awesome years. A lot of things aligned from that. They tried to run it back in 22 and it resulted in an 81-81 record and the highest WAR from Yaz at 2.0.
Kapler was on fire in 21. Every move he made turned to gold and they all bought in. Something changed in ‘22. Im guessing Kaplers ego had him not taking enough responsibility. He admitted as much, but too little too late. Lost them. Gone within a week of Webbs “needs change” comment.
Unicorns are mythical. Just a reminder.
kapler had his issues but if I had to choose one or the other it would be kapler
You’re quite upset about Kurt Suzuki aren’t you, wiffle(ball)meister?
So there’s a chance that a member of MLB HoPG could get the job and a potential future member might be in that same boat.
Remember who’s reporting this about Hundley!
Heyman also reported “Arson Judge” was signing with the Giants
Until Hundley is officially announced as the new Giants manager take anything Heyman reports with a grain of salt. Heyman’s credibility is nonexistent
As a Padres fan this breaks my heart
He’s used to being Posey’s backup.
Benito Santiago, baby! A Boricua will get us back into WS!
Hundley was a gamer and great teammate. I remember what a thorn he was in the Giants’ side when he was a Padre.
Reading this article got me dimly remembering that he was indeed in the conversation for manager the last time out. I’m glad he’s back in the mix, and I hope he gets an interview and a shot at the job.
Would love to see Fasano manage the giants
Brett Phillips rumored to have inside track on Giants position?
Giants manager Matthew Lillard
How about this old Giants backup catcher John Bacabella or the other guy that’s nickname was Eye Chart. I can think of his name right now.
I’m betting he gets the job, probably no one else gets interviewed either.
I think Yadi would make a great manager. He might be the heir apparent in St Louis though.
I hope so but tbh at this point I’ll take a cardboard cut out of yadi if that means we can get rid of marmol
Craig Albernaz!
Looks like Posey is going to get his guy. Hundley was never the most talented player on the field but he stuck around for 12 years because he knew how to handle a pitching staff and his game generalship. Those skills go a long way as a manager.
Oh please. Just stop. You are
not deceiving anyone.
It’s funny how people pick their Manager projections based on popularity without any idea as to whether they can manager or not.
Yeah I remember him, he’s a good guy, that’s my pick for the next Giants Manager!
I hope Buster doesn’t hire one of his church buddies instead of the actual best candidate
Bochy.
Interview Mark DeRosa
Newsflash! He’s not a catcher anymore!
This whole thing is odd, if the Giants were going to fire Melvin why not fire him last off season? Obviously things changed with Posey coming in and to think that 2025 was win or get fired make no sense esepecially since they decided to pick up his salary for 2026. What happened in two or three months?
The team was average at best after starting the season 19-11, aside from the 14-4 run in Aug/Sep they were not a good team all year. It would have made since if they decided to bring in Bochy, but to now consider Hundley who has zero experience coaching at the MLB level is a head scratcher.
This team isn’t good enough to win in 2026 especially if they hire a manager who will need to learn on the job. If things go well this team is probably 2 years from making the playoffs, but then everyone is going to want Poser gone.
Not odd at all. Melvin wasn’t fired because they didn’t win. He was fired because the Giants were the most inconsistent team in MLB. They had big upgrades at SS and 1B and yet were no better than the season before.
What’s odd is how they’d hit the cover off the ball and win like 7 of 9 games, or 10 of 13, then lose like 8, or 9 of 10 because they weren’t able to average even 3 runs per game over that span.
IMO that’s not all on Melvin. The coaching staff bears a lot of responsibility for the erratic up’s and downs hitting. But Melvin hired the coaches and is the one responsible for the performance of the team. Had they played well, but not won, Melvin would still be the manager.
It’s complete conjecture on my part, but it’s entirely possible that Melvin refused to fire any coaches, leading to his own dismissal. It wouldn’t be the first time that’s happened.