For a second straight offseason, Astros owner Jim Crane is “wary” of exceeding the luxury tax threshold, Chandler Rome of The Athletic reports. Dipping under the tax line was a clear priority for Houston last offseason as well.
This year’s first-tier luxury threshold lands at $244MM. Per RosterResource, the Astros are currently about $25MM shy of that mark. Their DFA of Ramon Urias and last night’s trade of fellow utilityman Mauricio Dubón (for lower-priced utility option Nick Allen) trimmed a net $8.7MM off that payroll projection, which uses MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz’s projected arbitration salaries.
Houston’s current $218.9MM luxury tax projection could — and very likely will — dip further over the next 36 hours. The deadline to tender contracts to arbitration-eligible players is tomorrow at 5pm ET. The ’Stros have several plausible non-tender candidates, including outfielder Jesus Sanchez ($6.5MM projected salary), reliever Enyel De Los Santos ($2.1MM projection) and outfielder Taylor Trammell ($900K projection). If the Astros move on from that trio, they’d trim a net $7.15MM from the current $218.9MM projection.
The Astros are known to be in the market for rotation help — they already took a cheap one-year flier on former top prospect Nate Pearson, guaranteeing him $1.35MM — and have been working to balance out a heavily right-handed lineup for the better part of the past calendar year. Framber Valdez is a free agent, leaving Hunter Brown atop a starting staff with more question marks than reliable contributors.
Cristian Javier is a quality mid-rotation arm when healthy, but 2026 will be his first full year back from Tommy John surgery. Lance McCullers Jr. returned from a two-year injury absence in 2025 but struggled badly. Spencer Arrighetti missed most of the season with a broken thumb. Jason Alexander was a surprise contributor in 2025, but he’s a journeyman 33-year-old with no prior MLB success who’d struggled in Triple-A from 2023-24. J.P. France pitched just four MLB frames and was hit hard in Triple-A after spending the first two-thirds of the season rehabbing from shoulder surgery. Left-hander Colton Gordon was tagged for a 5.34 ERA in 19 starts as a rookie. Righty AJ Blubaugh impressed in his first 32 big league innings but was tagged for a 5.27 ERA in a much larger Triple-A sample. Each of Ronel Blanco, Hayden Wesneski and Brandon Walter underwent Tommy John surgery. Prospect Miguel Ullola could factor in, but he’s yet to pitch in the majors and has poor command.
Suffice it to say, the need for starting pitching is acute, but the means to acquire it aren’t exactly plentiful. The Astros can certainly add one free agent starter at a notable salary, but that’d eat up a good chunk of the space they have between their current standing and the first luxury tier. Adding a left-handed bat to a lineup where Yordan Alvarez and rookie outfielder Zach Cole are the only current options (assuming Sanchez is non-tendered or traded) will also cut into the gap. Houston would presumably prefer to add another catcher, too; current backup Cesar Salazar hit just .213/.353/.353 in Triple-A this past season and has just 67 career plate appearances in the majors. He’ll turn 30 in March. And of course, most teams prefer to maintain at least a little financial wiggle-room for in-season dealings.
The trade market always presents alternative options, but Houston’s farm system is in dire straits. The Astros have long shown a knack for coaxing strong performances out of pitchers who weren’t considered top-tier talent throughout the industry (though the team clearly stalled in that regard this past season). However, that doesn’t mean other clubs will be lining up to surrender established talent in exchange for minor leaguers from what’s widely regarded as a bottom-five system in the game.
It’s feasible that further trades could be engineered to create more spending power, but GM Dana Brown has downplayed the possibility of moving first baseman Christian Walker (owed $40MM through 2027) and flatly said that he has “no interest” in trading infielder Isaac Paredes ($9.3MM projected salary). As things stand, the Astros have limited spending power to address their needs and an even more limited stock of minor league talent to peddle if they try to upgrade via trade. There are never any “easy” answers when trying to assemble a competitive roster with sufficient depth to navigate a 162-game season, but Brown & Co. are staring at their most complicated puzzle in recent memory.

The Division belongs to Seattle or Hopefully Texas now. It’s the end of the cheaters time. I’m still surprised they traded for Correa if they are getting cheap now.
Big facts. The Astros and their fans don’t want to admit it, but they’re 3rd/4th place team now.
It was a nice run for them.
Lol Angels and As tho
Houston finished tied for the last wildcard spot last year despite pretty much their entire rotation going down and yordan giving them basically nothing.
I wouldn’t write them off just yet, they’ve created insane organizational depth and if they have better luck injury wise I would expect them to be in the mix for the division
People have been saying that for years now and they’re still the best. Astros dealt with so many injuries last year if they get back even 5% of those games missed they beat Seattle for the division easily. They’re the team to beat in al west.
I agree with you (or I hope I can), it’s going to be a tight race with Seattle and Houston, Texas is dead, A’s could come in, and Angels will have to wait for a few more years. That’s IF Houston is healthy, IF Texas is healthy, maybe?
They have attempted to stay under the luxury tax threshold the last few offseasons. The Correa deal is making it harder. So they are being just as cheap as they have been.
Having the 6th highest payroll and going over the cap 2 years in a row isn’t cheap. Wake up!
I would agree with you when it comes to Seattle. By the way, the cheaters reign ended after the 2018 season, and not the Texas Rangers. They need to make Offseason moves, we’ll see what happens later in the Offseason.
Yeah, the Rangers got a rare full healthy season from DeGrom and surprisingly good innings from Corbin to manage a .500 season. Corbin, Kelly, Mahle are FA. I don’t think they are that close to a playoff team right now.
The Rangers are likely the most overrated team in MLB. I think they will be projected .500 team unless they add some stuff.
You must think other teams don’t cheat ROTFLMAO.
You do know Beltran played on the Rangers the year before the Astros right???? So they cheated too moron.
Yes they can!
At least, they play in the same division as the Angels and A’s….
Stros should trade Walker straight up for Nimmo and non tender Sanchez.
I know some video games allow a player to force trades, but I was unaware that forcing trades was something that could work in real life.
But in that case, why don’t the Stros just trade Walker straight up for Skenes or Skubal?
Are you insane? This is something that my friend says. The answer is NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO from the Tigers/Pirates.
I think you missed his point.
I probably did.
Calm down fella. Take a little time, read the comments, ask yourself how they’re intended before leaping in. And, with respect, probably post a little less.
Why would the Mets want Walker? Oh Pete is a free agent so they will trade a useable outfielder for someone who is old expensive and declined both offensively and defensively last year. Lol. Only reason to trade Nimmo is to save money for this offseason moves. Not save money two years down the line.
They want to trade Nimmo for their upcoming young outfielders AJ Ewing and Benge. Alonso is a DH. They may still sign him for that. They will play McNeil in left field this year and then let him go if kids are ready next year. Mets have an option on him next year. Also opens up 2nd base for the more defensive young infielders Baty, Mauricio Jett to compete for 2nd base. Clifford, the former Astro prospect, should be ready for 1st base by the time Walker contract expires. I wouldn’t be surprised if they go after Bergman besides a starter like Gallen or Cease.
Mets gonna Met
Walker for McNeil could help both teams.
Duh. Does this article need to be made?
If they don’t have the prospect collateral for a big trade, and money is an issue, it means bargain hunting; a Houser, Mahle or Bassitt type, a reclamation project like Bueller or May, and some cheap wallpaper to paste over an underachieving bullpen…
I think AJ Preller proved at the trade deadline last season prospect capital is way overblown. Everyone kept saying that SD didn’t have enough to get any trades done and they went and got what they wanted.
Fans still remember the time when teams were trading top 100 prospects all the time. But moving top 100 guys is becoming more rare. You can get a lot done with a just ok farm system.
Yeah. The ones that are more likely to be dealt are the 90s and possibly the 80s. 70s have a slim chance, but 60s and under is just…
Unless if your San Diego and decided to trade de Vries.
The Astros 2025 revenue was roughly 500 million. Besides being cheap, why are they not spending? Oh I forgot, the Dodgers are ruining baseball.
It’s because MLB is a cartel. It enables owners to maximize revenue rather than incentive owners to field competitive rosters.
I’m confused. Isn’t maximising revenue the primary means to fielding a competitive roster ?
no
The just pick player salaries off the money tree growing out the back ?
No.
At Casey,
Yup. All the cheap teams can be cheap and the owners will still take in profits due to the Dodgers/Yankees/Mets. Eventually this model will fail them because fans are growing tired of the season being predictable. The Dodgers just won two straight championships with huge issues/flaws in their rosters, but enough money to buy all-star depth players. Last year the rotation was an injury mess, so they go out and sign Snell and get Sasaki and add Yates and Scott. Then this year the bullpen and offense struggled… Didn’t matter, because they had enough all-start depth to push them through. This off-season will likely be the same. If the Dodgers actually field a decent team, they will just cruise through the season. I’m curious to see if the other owners care about competition or not, and we’ll see that in the new CBA talks.
compare parity of the capless MLB to all the other cap leagues.
Cap does not increase parity or competitiveness.
I’m arguing more for a floor. Even if they install a hard cap now it won’t make much of a difference. But they should address deferred payments and how it counts towards the cap. Only the Dodgers/Mets/Yankees have the ability to do deferred payments and it’s an unfair edge.
So first focus is to put in a floor and fix current cap loopholes. Player salaries have ballooned because of the Dodgers and foreign players. 80% of the league can’t or won’t spend on any big FAs. Unless there’s a grievance filed of course.
It’s about draft penalties. Which increase significantly if you go over in consecutive years. For what it’s worth they said the same thing about staying under in the 23-24 offseason and then they signed Hader. He’ll cross it but only for the right player. Who could be Dylan Cease. But they’re not gonna let marginal players like Mauricio Dubon be the difference in staying under.
Thanks captain obvious
It’s apparently not obvious because of all the “why so cheap” people here.
I am so sick of Jim Crane being a cheap owner.
I feel like he should spend more on pitching.
He will spend, just not above the luxury tax threshold.
The problem with Crane is not spending.
The problem with Crane is when he and Bagwell cosplay as GMs.
I normally don’t care whether he spends or not. But he has to spend on starting pitching, this is the year.
He’s got to choose from this.
Here is a breakdown of the 2025-26 free-agent class.
Players are grouped by position and ranked by their FanGraphs WAR total across 2024-25. Each player’s 2026 seasonal age is included in parentheses next to his name.
^Declined QO
STARTING PITCHERS
Dylan Cease (30 years old, 8.1 WAR)^
Framber Valdez (32, 7.7)^
Ranger Suárez (30, 7.5)^
Nick Martinez (35, 5.5)
Chris Bassitt (37, 4.8)
Michael King (31, 4.7)^
Zac Gallen (30, 3.9)^
Merrill Kelly (37, 3.8)
Zack Littell (30, 3.7)
Patrick Corbin (36, 3.6)
Erick Fedde (33, 3.2)
Justin Verlander (43, 2.9)
Zach Eflin (32, 2.6)
Kyle Hendricks (36, 2.2) — retired
Miles Mikolas (37, 2.2)
Nestor Cortes (31, 2.1)
Adrian Houser (33, 2.1)
Tyler Mahle (31, 2.1)
Lucas Giolito (30, 2.0)
Andrew Heaney (35, 1.9)
Michael Lorenzen (34, 1.9)
Jose Quintana (37, 1.9)
Aaron Civale (31, 1.8)
Chris Paddack (30, 1.8)
Tyler Anderson (36, 1.6)
Michael Soroka (28, 1.5)
Jon Gray (34, 1.4)
Frankie Montas (33, 1.3)
Martín Pérez (35, 1.3)
Griffin Canning (30, 1.0)
Chris Flexen (31, 1.0)
Marcus Stroman (35, 1.0)
Max Scherzer (41, 1.0)
Austin Gomber (32, 0.9)
Cal Quantrill (31, 0.9)
Dustin May (28, 0.8)
Paul Blackburn (32, 0.6)
Jordan Montgomery (33, 0.6)
John Means (33, 0.5)
JT Brubaker (32, 0.4)
Alex Cobb (38, 0.3)
Germán Márquez (31, 0.2)
Tomoyuki Sugano (36, 0.1)
Ryan Yarbrough (34, 0.1) — reported 1-year deal with NYY
Carlos Carrasco (39, 0.0) — reported MiLB deal with ATL
José Ureña (34, 0.0)
José Urquidy (31, 0.0)
Tony Gonsolin (32, -0.1)
Kenta Maeda (38, -0.1)
Mike Clevinger (35, -0.2)
Kyle Hart (33, -0.2) — signed 1-year deal with SD (Nov. 17)
Wade Miley (39, -0.2)
Walker Buehler (31, -0.4)
Anthony DeSclafani (36, -0.7)
Drew Anderson (32, N/A)
Kohei Arihara (33, N/A)
Foster Griffin (30, N/A)
Tatsuya Imai (28, N/A) — posted by NPB club on Nov. 18
Anthony Kay (31, N/A)
Cody Ponce (32, N/A)
Kona Takahashi (29, N/A) — set to be posted by NPB club
yeah, he does, but I don’t think Crane has earned the ‘Cheap’ owner narrative. Arrogant bull in a china shop destroying the very organizational tools that allowed success. Sure, I’ll thumbs up that narrative.
Here’s how I think the Astros should play it.
1 Dump as much as you can
2. Fill as many positions with pre-arb/arb players that can be productive
3. Sign Ranger Suarez for 5 years, 125 million with 3 club options for 23 million
4. Sign 2 mid rotation arm for 1 or 2 years
5. Trade for a offensive target
Any thoughts
Think they need go all in this year. potential ’27 lockout is going to eat one of the few remaining years of competitiveness the Altuve core has left.
Blow past the CBT
we already know they will be dumping as much as you can, i think they’re comfortable with rookie salaries and potential upside rather than being upside down on sanchez/dubon/mccormick/urias, as we have seen.
I don’t see the Astros signing anyone to a 9-figure deal this offseason, unless it’s a ridiculously team friendly extension for Hunter Brown.
I’d like Cortes, Mahle, Buehler, a flier on Urquidy or someone similar. I personally do not think they will sign Verlander even though MLBTR site writers projected it.
i am curious to see if walker gets traded and if there is any salary relief (doubtful)
They can go all in and blow their load unprotected for one more shot. Or they can pump and dump and try to sneak into a wildcard through the back door. Either way things don’t look good for 27.
My pick from realistic options is Merrill Kelly,
You can pretty much count on 6IP each start.
Hail Mary pick. Trade for Sandy. I have no idea how the Astros can pull it off, but maybe.
I’d be open to trading Yanier Diaz for him if we re-sign Caratini.
feel like it would selling low on Diaz
Diaz is ARB1 this year. Estimated at $3mil
Caratini signed for 6mil last year.
Trading yainer for who?
Alcantara
I’m not optimistic that either his plate discipline or defense will improve enough. And Alcantara only has one less year on his contract (which is quite team friendly) than Diaz has in team control. Alcantara’s upside is CY and with the Astros’ track record on optimizing pitchers, they’d definitely be the team to get him back to that.
Figure out of the 28 other teams, someone would beat a Diaz for Sandy offer
I don’t think so honestly.
I would like to add that in addition to Crane’s meddling the Astros are hindered by the fact that Dana Brown has no idea what he doing.
Oh 110%. Dana Brown was Crane’s selection for someone acquiescent. I miss James Click so much
Jake Meyers and Dubon were Click’s parting gifts for us.
No way the current FO would make moves for those guys
?
Oh and the franchise is worth roughly 3 billion. Crane paid 680 million in 2011. He’s made roughly 2 billion profit in appreciation but he can’t exceed the luxury tax?????
Impressive.
What a franchise is worth and profit are not the same thing,
Yeah valuation does not equal liquid cash, I don’t know why people don’t understand that.
They generate roughly 500 million a year and spend 200. They’re highly profitable excluding the 2+ BILLION he’ll make when he sells.
Well again, the CBT is not just about money. It’s about draft penalties, which increase when you go over in consecutive years.
In total, the penalties are.
1. Get taxed
2. Lose picks for signing QO
3. Lose bonus pool for signing QO
You also lose draft picks for crossing the CBT in consecutive years, not just for signing free agents with a QO.
They get delayed by 10 picks if you go through too much. not lose.
It is a big loss because it affects how much money you can spend on your draft picks.
So do you support the fact that Jim Crane isn’t spending on starting pitching
Huh? Offseason just started. They’re definitely gonna spend on a starting pitcher or two.
Most picks amount to nothing. It’s a farce. Unless you’re picking in the top 10, it’s a crap shoot every year. Pucks are overvalued because they’re cheap talent for cheap teams that might amount to something. Nothing more, nothing less. Most current MLB players were picked outside of the first 3 rounds.
85MM plus
@noquarter What about all the other expenses of running a franchise? Employees, taxes, stadium upkeep, cost of concession goods. Player salary is not the only cost.
Exactly.
Why even have a draft then?
So many off-field factors.
Player costs are roughly 85% of expenditures. They’re making a handy profit EVERY season.
exactly. outside of players there’s only a handful of team execs who “might” make more than $500K. MLB teams generally pay their staff poorly because “hey you get to work for a baseball team, free tickets, etc) so while there’s lots of employees, the great majority are making between $25K and $40K.
It’s relevant to point out that the Astros, like any business, have operational costs beyond just the major league payroll.
M’s Ushers-17 per hour
Stros Ushers-22 per hour
A 2018 report by Forbes had it as a 54% average in MLB.
Non player costs haven’t gotten cheaper.
85 percent of expenditure? that is flat absurd. So for a 150 million dollar payroll team, Marketing, travel, stadium upkeep, employee pay, taxes, donations, fees, scouting, organizational infrastructure, medical costs,, etc etc are all being done for 28 million dollars? That 85 percent number is totally made up.
It’s about draft penalties. Which increase significantly if you go over in consecutive years. For what it’s worth they said the same thing about staying under in the 23-24 offseason and then they signed Hader. He’ll cross it but only for the right player. Who could be Dylan Cease. But they’re not gonna let marginal players like Mauricio Dubon be the difference in staying under.
You do realize he gets taxed from his own wallet.
They also get taxed from their draft pool.
The international bonus pool. They lose picks.
I guess that makes it obvious why Houston traded Dubin for Allen.
It’s Mauricio Dubon, Dubin is another player.
It was just a typo. I and O are right next to each other. Fat thumbs and all. 🙂
Okay.
Crane never really spent big, but began to with Christian Walker, Josh Hader, and bringing back Carlos Correa.
Those moves felt like an attempt to hold onto that competitive window while letting franchise prospects walk. Houston had a great run of development, beneficial trades, and scandals… and won the World Series twice in that window. Sustainability has run out, and Crane may be wise to retool a depleted farm system and save for when the team is competitive again.
After talented farm systems such as the Orioles and White Sox have seemed to fail, Houston really did well over the past 10 years.
The Astros are going to have to pony up on starting pitching to compete this year.
Dude you need to chill on the posting…DAMN! Somebody needs to get a job.
They said this in the 23-24 offseason and then they signed Hader. I think they will happily cross for the right player (ie Cease).
They signed 95 million for a reliever. But only 85 million for a starter? Yes, I think they should go for a top starter.
Good. Players are far too expensive.
The Astros are going to have to go over the 85 million starting pitcher threshold. But they can stay under the threshold with enough cuts.
Translation: we will miss the playoffs again
How Nick Allen is on a MLB roster is a mystery to me. His glove isn’t worth that newspaper bat
Easy. shortstop was such an absolute train wreck for the Braves that Allen got a bunch of playing time just for his glove alone.
Allen’s ’25 OPS was .535. For his career its .536.
Unless he can routinely cover from the foul line to the second base bag, that is not a tenable number
Dbacks trade proposal with the Astros. Walker and one of Arreghetti, Gordon or Alexander for Eduardo Rodriguez and Pavin Smith.
Eduardo Rodriguez’s contract is even further underwater than Walker’s.
I think you can get Walker for a prospect if Dana Brown is smart.
True, But…neither team wants another $20M/yr player. Astros want left handed starters, Dbacks want a 1b. So trade a 1b and pitcher, for 1b and pitcher. Win. Win.
Rodriguez has had off years. The Dbacks are going to have to eat some of that.
5+ ERA. You could say Walker does too, but Walker is more valuable than Rodriguez at the moment.
I was going to say the opposite! Goldie is in decline, Astros kick in $5M
Are you Dbacks fan
There are similarly priced bad contract swap candidates on 1B-needy teams with a lot more upside than E-Rod. Kodai Senga, Sean Manaea, Jordan Hicks, etc. I don’t hate the basis of this trade but the DBacks would be the team that needs to kick in additional players/cash. Walker for E-Rod, Jake McCarthy and $5M cash per year and you’ve got a deal.
It will be tight financially, but there is definitely a path to contending. They have to get a decent starter (a #2 or 3 in rotayion) and and useful but relatively cheap outfielder . Might have to trim some payroll fat like they did with dubon, but it can be done. My preference would be to move Hader for someone pitching and prospects, but it would be selling low with his health. If they wanted to be really bold, alleviate the crowded infield by trading Pena for someone like Schlittler.
They’re going to restart again. Lose 100+ games again and reset. Thats who the real Astros are. They’re not serious contenders in the long run.
I don’t think you follow the Astros closely. The Astros made apperances from 6 consecutive (and I excluded the cheating seasons), not many teams make 6 consecutive appearances. They are going to have to get back up next year. But they have to cut a lot of their arbitration players and make more sucessfuly salary dumps.
Astros won’t trade with the Yankees (at least they try not to)
I don’t think there is anything wrong with deciding not to exceed the luxury tax threshold. Most teams don’t. But if you’re not gonna spend you have to build your team differently.
You can’t sign Abreu, Walker, Hader, and trade for Correa, and then refuse to spend. Not compatible strategies.
Here is hoping the new CBA lowers the luxury threshold a whole lot!
As Hell, just sell off all your players, you gave away Dubon for nothing. Sell the rest off, then you can be the cheapest team in MLB! You won’t win anything but thatll be ok with you cheapskate. Why dont you sell to someone who can spend money like Dodgers and Yankees to field a competitive team!
Why are there so many Jim Crane haters? I don’t like how he doesn’t spend in some areas, but why so many haters.